Carnival Chaos! But The Good Kind.
Jessica Jones x male reader
The neon lights of the Brooklyn Carnival blinked like they were trying too hard to be cool. Ferris wheel turning slow against the night sky, the smell of fried dough and popcorn thick in the air, and the distant screams of people on the Tilt-A-Whirl mixing with carnival barkers yelling about giant stuffed animals no one really needed. It was loud, chaotic, and exactly the kind of place Jessica Jones usually avoided like the plague.
But tonight was different.
Y/N had spent three weeks planning this. Three weeks of overthinking, second-guessing, and scribbling notes on napkins at 2 a.m. while Jessica was passed out on his couch after a long day of PI work and too much whiskey. He wanted to impress her. Not with some fancy restaurant where she’d feel out of place in her leather jacket and perpetual scowl. No, he wanted something fun. Something that said “I know you’re tough as nails, but I also know you secretly like stupid shit that makes you smile even if you pretend you don’t.”
So he picked the carnival.
He stood at the entrance now, shifting from foot to foot, hands shoved deep in his pockets. His button-down shirt was a little wrinkled (he’d ironed it twice), and he kept checking his phone like the time would magically change. Jessica was ten minutes late, which for her was basically on time.
When she finally appeared, cutting through the crowd like she owned the place, Y/N’s heart did that stupid flip it always did. Leather jacket, dark jeans, boots that could probably kick through a wall, and that signature resting “fuck off” face that somehow made his knees weak.
“Hey,” he said, voice cracking just a little. He cleared his throat. “You look… great. I mean, you always look great, but tonight especially. Not that you need to try or anything. Shit, I’m rambling.”
Jessica raised an eyebrow, lips twitching like she was fighting a smirk. “You’re nervous. Cute. What’s with the shirt? You trying to look like a guy who sells insurance?”
Y/N glanced down at his slightly too-formal button-down. “I thought… carnival… maybe a little nice? But not too nice. I didn’t want to look like I was trying too hard.”
“You’re wearing a shirt with actual buttons. You’re trying too hard.”
He rubbed the back of his neck, cheeks heating up. “Yeah, well… I planned this whole thing. Games, rides, the works. I even made a list. Timed it out and everything. Thought it’d be… impressive.”
Jessica looked at him for a long second, then shrugged. “Lead the way, Romeo. But if there’s a cotton candy stand that doesn’t taste like regret, I’m in.”
Y/N’s face lit up like she’d just agreed to marry him. “Okay. First stop — ring toss. I practiced. Kind of. In my apartment. With bottles.”
He led her toward the game booths, already mentally rehearsing his moves. This is gonna work. She’s gonna be amazed. I’m gonna win her the biggest stuffed animal here and she’ll think I’m cool and competent.
The ring toss booth was run by a guy who looked like he’d been smoking since birth. Bright lights, cheap plastic rings, and bottles stacked in precarious pyramids.
Y/N paid for a set of rings, rolling his shoulders like he was about to throw a perfect game. “Watch this. I’ve got a technique.”
He threw the first ring. It bounced off the bottle and landed in the dirt.
Second ring — hit the rim and spun away like it personally hated him.
Third ring — somehow went backward and almost hit Jessica in the shin.
Jessica crossed her arms, clearly trying not to laugh. “Wow. Olympic level right there.”
Y/N’s face burned. “Okay, that was… warmup. The next ones are gonna be better. Physics was never my strong suit.”
He threw the last three rings in quick succession. One landed on a bottle but immediately slid off. The other two missed entirely.
The carnie gave him a pitying look and handed him a tiny plastic keychain as a “consolation prize.”
Y/N stared at the keychain like it had betrayed him. “This is not how I pictured this going.”
Jessica finally let the laugh out — short, genuine, and surprisingly warm. “You practiced in your apartment?”
“With empty beer bottles,” he admitted, rubbing the back of his neck again. “I thought it’d be impressive. Like, ‘Look at me, I can win you giant bears.’”
She took the pathetic keychain from his hand and hooked it onto her jacket zipper. “It’s ugly as hell, but I like it. Come on, loser. Let’s try something I’m actually good at.”
She dragged him toward the strongman game — the one with the giant mallet and the bell at the top. Y/N tried to protest. “Wait, this one’s rigged. The guy told me last year—”
“Watch and learn, Romeo.”
Jessica grabbed the mallet like it weighed nothing (because to her, it basically didn’t), swung it in one smooth, terrifying motion, and slammed it down. The puck shot up the tower, dinged the bell so hard the whole thing shook, and the carnie nearly dropped his cigar.
The crowd around them cheered. Jessica turned to Y/N with the smuggest look he’d ever seen on her face and pointed at the wall of giant stuffed animals.
Y/N blinked. “You… just destroyed that game.”
“Yeah. Now pick the biggest, ugliest one so I can carry it around and embarrass you all night.”
He ended up choosing a massive, bright purple elephant that was almost as tall as Jessica. She slung it over her shoulder like it was a purse, completely unbothered.
The squad — well, the imaginary squad in Y/N’s head — would have been dying laughing. In reality, a group of teenagers nearby were staring openly.
One of them whispered loudly, “Dude, that lady just murdered the strongman game. And her boyfriend looks like he’s about to propose.”
Y/N turned bright red. “I’m not— we’re not— it’s our first real date night, okay?”
Jessica snorted. “Relax. They’re just jealous I can swing a mallet better than their dads.”
Next came the shooting gallery. Y/N thought this would be his redemption arc. He’d played enough video games. How hard could it be?
His first shot missed the target by a mile and hit the back wall. The second shot pinged off the side of the booth. The third somehow ricocheted and knocked over a stack of cans that weren’t even part of the game.
The carnie stared at him. “Kid, you sure you’re allowed to handle firearms?”
Jessica stepped up beside him, took the toy rifle, and fired six shots in rapid succession without even aiming properly. Every single target went down.
She turned to Y/N, deadpan. “You were saying?”
Y/N threw his hands up. “I give up. You win at everything. I’m just here for moral support and emotional stability.”
“That’s why I keep you around,” she said, voice softer than usual. She picked another giant stuffed animal — this time a neon green dragon — and added it to her growing collection. “You’re good at the parts I suck at. Like not scaring small children.”
They moved on to the Ferris wheel. Y/N had planned this as the romantic climax. Soft lights, nice view of the city, maybe a quiet moment where he could tell her how much he actually liked her without sounding like an idiot.
The carnie locked them into the seat. As it started moving, Y/N cleared his throat.
“So… this is nice, right? I mean, not too crowded, good weather, no one trying to kill us for once. I thought it’d be a good way to… you know… show you I can do normal stuff. Not just sit on your couch while you drink and stare at case files.”
Jessica looked out at the glowing carnival below them. The wind tugged at her hair. “It’s not terrible.”
High praise from Jessica Jones.
Y/N took a breath. “I overthought this whole night. Like, a lot. Made lists. Timed everything. Practiced ring toss in my living room like a loser. I wanted to impress you. Make you think ‘wow, this guy’s got his shit together.’ But I’m realizing I’m mostly just… me. Awkward, shy, and really bad at carnival games.”
Jessica turned to look at him. The colorful lights reflected in her eyes, making her look softer than usual. “You think I wanted some smooth operator who wins every game? I like that you tried. Even if it was embarrassing as hell. It’s… sweet. In a pathetic kind of way.”
Y/N laughed, the sound shy and relieved. “Pathetic sweet. That’s my brand.”
The Ferris wheel stopped at the top for a moment, giving them a perfect view of the carnival spread out below like a messy, glowing painting. Jessica shifted closer, her shoulder pressing against his.
“You know what I like about you?” she said quietly. “You don’t try to fix me. You don’t flinch when I’m in a mood. You just… sit there. Listen. Bring me shitty coffee when I’ve been up for thirty hours. That’s better than winning some stupid giant bear.”
Y/N’s heart did another flip. “Yeah?”
“Yeah.” She bumped his knee with hers. “Don’t let it go to your head.”
They rode the rest of the wheel in comfortable silence, the earlier embarrassment fading into something warmer.
Afterward, they hit the fun house. Y/N thought it’d be harmless. Mirrors, silly slides, maybe a few laughs.
The first mirror made his head look enormous. Jessica pointed and laughed — actually laughed, loud and unrestrained. “You look like a bobblehead.”
Y/N groaned. “This is my nightmare.”
The next room had a tilted floor. Y/N immediately lost his balance and slid straight into Jessica, nearly knocking both of them over. She caught him easily, one arm around his waist.
“Steady there, Romeo. Can’t have you breaking something before I get my cotton candy.”
They stumbled through the rest of the fun house, bumping into walls, making ridiculous faces in the distorting mirrors, and laughing harder than either of them had in months. At one point Y/N got stuck in a spinning barrel and had to be pulled out by Jessica, who was wheezing with laughter.
By the time they emerged, both were flushed and grinning like idiots.
“Okay,” Y/N admitted, “that was fun. Even if I looked like a distorted potato in every mirror.”
“You looked cute,” Jessica said, surprising both of them. She quickly added, “Don’t make it weird.”
They spent the next hour wandering from booth to booth. Jessica dominated the basketball toss (sinking every shot with bored precision), the balloon dart game (popping them so fast the carnie looked scared), and even the duck pond (somehow winning a goldfish she immediately named “Kilgrave” just to watch Y/N’s horrified face).
Y/N tried the milk bottle pyramid game three separate times. He knocked over exactly zero bottles.
On the third attempt, Jessica stepped up beside him, took the ball from his hand, and gently tossed it underhand. The entire pyramid collapsed like it had been waiting for her.
She handed him the giant stuffed tiger the carnie reluctantly gave her. “Here. For all your hard work and zero results.”
Y/N hugged the tiger to his chest like it was precious. “This is the best worst date ever.”
“It’s not the worst,” Jessica said, bumping his shoulder again. “It’s actually… nice. Really nice.”
They ended the night on the benches near the exit, sharing a massive bag of cotton candy and watching the carnival lights flicker. Y/N’s arm was around her shoulders — shy at first, then more confident when she didn’t shrug him off.
“I had all these plans,” he confessed, popping a piece of cotton candy into his mouth. “Timed everything. Thought if I won enough prizes and did everything right, you’d be impressed. Turns out I’m terrible at carnival games and you’re terrifyingly good at all of them.”
Jessica leaned her head against his shoulder, the giant purple elephant and neon dragon sitting beside them like ridiculous bodyguards.
“I don’t need you to impress me with games,” she said quietly. “I like that you tried. Even when it was embarrassing. Especially when it was embarrassing. Makes me feel like… I don’t have to be the tough one all the time.”
Y/N turned his head to look at her. The colorful lights reflected in her eyes, and for once she didn’t look like the unbreakable Jessica Jones. She just looked like a woman enjoying a date.
“I really like you, Jess,” he said softly, the shyness creeping back in. “Like, a stupid amount. Even when you’re grumpy and drink too much and threaten to throw me out the window.”
She snorted. “Good. Because I like you too. Even when you overthink everything and wear button-downs to carnivals.”
They sat there for a long time, sharing cotton candy, laughing about the ring toss disaster and the fun house barrel incident, trading quiet stories about nothing important. No cases. No demons. No bruises.
Just two people who somehow fit — the private investigator who carried the weight of the world and the nerd guy who carried her stuffed animals without complaint.
When the carnival started closing down, Y/N stood and offered her his hand.
Jessica took it, lacing their fingers together. “Yeah. But next time, I’m picking the date. And there better be whiskey involved.”
They walked out of the carnival together, arms full of ridiculous prizes, shoulders bumping, laughing about nothing and everything at once.
It wasn’t a perfect night.
@6rookie-writer0110 @fandomnerd9602 @marveldcfandom @multi-fandom-enjoyer @viilovers @herioclizard @superflash2255 @tenaciousnymphinsight