source: vikingrune.com
As I’ve been doing quite a bit of musing about the Nene River Ring and its two contrasting bezels lately, I’ve been asked about different variations of the valknut symbol, and whether or not it was adopted and adapted by Christianity. I’ve come across a few sources that state that the valknut comes in various different forms, including one with rounded edges (aka. triqueta) frequently seen in Celtic cultural contexts. Whilst these ‘variations’ may hold similar meanings, I’m not convinced that they are closely related. I am no expert on Viking/Celtic/Christian symbolism, but I am keen to argue against lumping the valknut and triqueta forms together as one.
In recent papers I’ve presented to conferences I’ve briefly mentioned the valknut symbol and its presence on stone monuments in the British Isles. This blog post was inspired after seeing a picture one of these monuments, regrettably after the fact, and going on to hunt down these supposed valknutted artefacts to see for myself. The first object that inspired this investigation is the hogback stone from Brompton, Yorkshire, that has been described as having the valknut symbol carved onto its side. This particular stone is Brompton 4 (Lang 1984), or Brompton 19 (Lang 2001). Upon viewing the picture, I was pretty disappointed. The supposed valknut is in the Celtic triqueta form, which, I agree, is loosely visually similar to the valknut (primarily its unicursal style), and similar in cultural affiliation, but is inherently different in terms of ideology and use. The valknut and triquetra are frequently mentioned as one in the same, but I would really argue against this.
Brompton hogback stone. Photo: Jamie Barnes
Unicursal
I must say first that the term ‘valknut’ is a relatively modern Norwegian word. It was not called this during the Viking age. Therefore we lack any substantial written evidence as to what this symbol actually means. The term itself means ‘knot of the slain.’ The most we can say, based on its artistic context, is that it is somehow connected to the ideas of death, sacrifice, burial, or the underworld. It is also frequently linked to the god Odin (See Nene River Ring and Valknut), and his ability to ‘bind and unbind’ the minds of people, and has thus been called ‘Odin’s knot’. It may also refer to the web of life, and the weaving of the strands of destiny. There are two types of the original valknut: the unicursal and the tricursal. The unicursal is the earliest form, made of a single line that creates the design. It is seen twice on a 7th century rune stone from Tängelgårda, Lärbro parish, Gotland, Sweden, underneath the legs of horse in a warrior scene. The tricursal form is visible in the Viking Age, and has three triangles that are linked together. In both cases the lines/triangles can either be snuggly fit together or loosely, so that blank space can be seen.
The triquetra, also called the trinity knot or a trifold knot, is typically described as a symbol of the Holy Trinity. Its original form is a singular ribbon that loops around three times to create a threefold, triangular shape. It can also be depicted within a circle, supposedly to represent spiritual unity. The exact origin for the symbol is generally unknown. Some claim that it can be traced back to Neolithic times representing the trinity of sky, earth, and the sea. It may also refer to the connection of the mind, body, and the soul. The triquetra is mostly known as a Celtic symbol, predominantly within Christian contexts. Within the 9th century ‘Book of Kells,’ the triquetra can be seen within the many patterns of interlace. It is also known in Scandinavia, as it is found on a few runestones, like rune stone G181 from Gotland, Sweden, seen below, which is dated to the Viking-Age (AD 800-1100). (1)
Runestone G181 from Gotland, Sweden.
This runestone was originally found at a church. On this stone, the triquetra can be seen to the right of the three figures at top. The runic inscription states, ‘Hróðvisl and Farbjôrn and Gunnbjôrn’, in short-twig, younger futhark runes. There are arguments on whether or not these three names relate to the first three figures in the top panel, or the three in the main panel below them. The runestone has also been interpreted to represent the trinity of Odin, Thor, and Freyr, who may actually be the three figures at the top, associated with the triquetra (1). The three in the lower register therefore may be the three mentioned in the inscription, and considering the objects they hold (spear, mace, and sickle, objects representing authority, justice, and fertility), they may be the three priests of Odin, Thor, and Freyer, or they may be three men holding offices within the Swedish state. Furthermore, the triquetra seen here could actually BE a valknut, just a stylised unicursal version, considering its context associated with the Norse gods.
Strap-Ends from Flixborough, with the triquetra visible near the bottom of each. Source: Thomas 2000, cat. nos. 325 and 326.
Triquetra symbols are found significantly more on insular art (created in Britain and Ireland) than valknuts are. In the late Anglo-Saxon world, they are present on two strap-ends from Flixborough, North Lincolnshire (2), which was an important Anglo-Saxon settlement site, possibly the site of a monastery. The triquetra is also seen as a shoddy drawing on a piece of leather, possibly a sword scabbard, from Coppergate, York (3), dated to the 10th and 11th centuries (Viking Age). The triquetra is also visible on the impressive Gosforth Cross, in Gosforth Village, Cumbria (4). Standing 14 feet 5 inches, the cross dates to AD 950-1000 and depicts scenes of Old Norse myth and Christian belief. Present are the Norse Gods of Thor, Odin, Loki, Mimir, and Heimdallr, as well as Christ crucified. At the very top of the cross on either side are 4 triquetras forming the cross shape. The scenes on the cross are believed to represent the conquering of Christianity over the old pagan beliefs. Or rather, “the fall of the old gods and the establishment of the Church,” through scenes from the Norse Ragnarok, in which a series of events leads to the death of the old world and rebirth of a new one (4). Triquetras quite frequently are placed on the outer arms of crosses, either individually or as parts of continuous interlacing lines. Here on the Gosforth cross they carry a very strong Christian significance.
The Gosforth Cross. Source: Burg 1958
The triquetra is also visible on many cross slabs on the Isle of Man. They appear on cross slabs of Scandinavian and pre-Scandinavian artistry, including some with Anglo-Saxon decoration (and one with Anglo-Saxon runes). Their frequency and often graffiti-like appearance on the monuments on the Isle of Man may suggest that they were seen more as decorative than symbolic motifs, but their presence nevertheless represents the influence of Celtic illuminated manuscripts, particularly on the cross slabs with purely Scandinavian artistic display (5, pg 60). On the stone slab 101 from Kirk Michael Church, the triquetra is seen next to symbols of the resurrection (a cockerel) and of the Holy Ghost, with a possible representation of the Holy Trinity. Another monument, Kirk Bride 97 (seen below), popularly called Thor’s Stone, also has the triquetra beside a cockerel, suggesting that the symbol might represent Christ’s resurrection (5, Plate XLVII). Being located between Ireland and Britain, the Isle of Man is a melting pot of Irish, Scottish, and English contacts, and this is well represented on the numerous stone monuments on the island. There are many different variations of the triquetra found on these monuments, but none of them resemble the original valknut. They are all clearly the Celtic trinity knot, contained within completely Christian contexts, and possibly symbolising resurrection, rebirth, and the dominion of Christianity over the old world.
Triquetra Designs on Scandinavian Crosses on the Isle of Man. 1) Bride 97; 2,6) Michael 101; 3,4) Michael 105; 5) Michael 104; 7) Braddan 109; 8) Andreas 103. Source: Kermode 1994
Bride 97 (Kermode 1994), ‘Thor’s Stone.’ The triquetra can be seen faintly on side A (right) at the very top to the right of the cockerel. Source: A Manx Notebook
From my research, the valknut on the River Nene finger-ring is the only one of its kind in Britain or Ireland. Apparently there are symbols ‘resembling’ the valknut found on ‘certain cremation urns’ from early Anglo-Saxon burials in East Anglia alongside images of wolves and horses, according to Hilda Roderick Ellis Davidson (5), but she fails to give any further information about these supposed urns. I am leaning towards the assumption that these ‘similar symbols’ are either the swastikas that are verified within the archaeological record to be on Anglo-Saxon cremation urns, or variations of the triskele (seen below), another Germanic symbol of trinity. Seen on artwork from the Neolithic to the Anglo-Saxon period and beyond, the triskele is often in the form of three animal heads in Anglo-Saxon art. Like the triquetra, it has its foundations in Pre-Celtic and Celtic artwork, and was adopted as a symbol of the Holy trinity in Christianity.
Faversham Brooch, Anglo-Saxon, c. AD 600-650. Garnet cloisonne bird’s heads in the form of a triskele (Source: The British Museum)
The triskele symbol has also been described as a triquetra in some instances. Like on a 5th-6th century picture stone from Gotland, Sweden, in which an image more closely resembling a triskele than a triquetra is represented by three snakes. This stone may symbolize the three institutions of the Swedish state (1), similar to runestone G181 from Gotland, that has been previously discussed.
I was asked at a recent conference whether the valknut has Christian versions. There seems to be a universal religious, spiritual, or secular importance to the number 3, and the idea of a supreme or divine trinity. Whether this reigning trinity refers to the father, son, and the Holy Ghost, the mind, body, and soul, the earth, sky, or sea, the past, present, and future, or any spiritual trio, symbols of three are visible in basically every culture in history. Because the term ‘valknut’ is a relatively new term, we could, in theory, use it to describe any symbol that is a triangular shape made up of three smaller triangular shapes. The same goes for the term ‘triquetra,’ of which any 3-armed symbol could qualify. Valknuts are traditionally only associated with Scandinavia (with the exception of the River Nene ring) and Old Norse mythology, whereas the triquetra is seen in various cultures and contexts, predominantly within Christian settings. They may both hold similar connotations of the Gods and death, but the triquetra has been taken an adapted by many people, oftentimes to symbolise something a bit more personal. Nowadays it seems more like an ethereal symbol of Celtic mysticism found on jewellery and other ‘Celtic’ trinkets.
It is difficult to find valid sources on the history and meaning of Celtic symbols. Most are described using fanciful and ethereal language that brings to mind fairies and druids. Basically, there are various meanings and interpretations behind Celtic symbolism, and most scholars and experts tend to avoid giving a concrete definition. It is my belief that the Valknut was created separately from the triquetra, most definitely in Scandinavia, and faded out of use upon the spread of Christianity, when it either evolved into the triquetra or was completely abandoned in favor of the trinity knot. The triquetra, regardless of its origin, evolved from a purely pagan symbol and took on a new significance within Celtic Christianity. It was then adopted throughout cultures in the British Isles to represent their conversion to the Church, and seems to have been overused to the point where it was no longer a special isolated symbol but rather an almost meaningless Christian motif. It is my belief, therefore, that the valknut and the triquetra should be visually, literally, and theoretically distinct from each other.
References:
de Vries, H. 2015. Sverige. <http://www.hubert-herald.nl/Sverige3.htm>
Thomas, G. 2000. A Survery of Late Anglo-Saxon and Viking-Age Strap-Ends from Britain. PhD Dissertation, University College London.
Mould, Q. Carlisle, I. and Cameron, E. 2003. Craft, Industry and Everyday Life: Leather and Leatherworking in Anglo-Scandinavian and Medieval York. The Archaeology of York: The Small Finds. Vol. 17
Burg, K. 1958. The Gosforth Cross. Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, Vol. 21, No. 1/2 (Jan. – Jun., 1958)
Kermode, P.M.C. 1994. Manx Crosses. Balgavies, Angus: The Pinkfoot Press.
Davidson, H.R.E. 1964. Gods and Myths of Northern Europe.
Valknut or ValkNOT? As I've been doing quite a bit of musing about the Nene River Ring and its two









