Rafayel & Sylus | Caleb | Xavier & Rafayel | Zayne & Sylus | Xavier & Zayne (this part)
It turns out that Mistakes Were Made but you Faced the Consequences. You're in For it Now that all your men know about each other. Their relationships develop alongside yours, and you end up stuck in the middle, not that you're complaining.
CONTENT NOTES FOR ALL PARTS: 18+ MDNI. LaDs men x MC (you). Smut & Angst. Smut with Feelings. No use of Y/N. Possibly ooc bc I'm still getting back into fanfic. Oral f&m receiving, p in v, p in a, dp, tp, unprotected sex bc its fiction, creampies, softdom!Xavier, brattamer!Zayne, brattyswitch!Rafayel, switch!Sylus, dom!Caleb, brattyswitch!MC, but it's all fluid imo. light bond*ge, sp*nking, size difference, overstimulation, improper use of evol, semi-public sex. Nicknames used in all parts: canon nicknames as well as bunny, princess, love, & darling. F reader. MC is described as being curvy and strong with some fuller titties bc I love titties. MMF+ in almost every part. Unedited. You get this raw (just like our Lads!)
The past few weeks were busy for everyone. An uptick in anomalous energy readings surged through Linkon, keeping you working at all hours of the day and night. Your stress levels hadn't been this high in ages, but with everything going on, you barely had time to breathe, much less engage in stress-relief with your lovers.
Zayne did endless research in his library on the events popping up all over the place. Caleb got called on a surprise mission into the Deepspace Tunnel. Rafayel and Sylus had teamed up on the house hunt, and some other hunting. Ever had been behind so much, and they each had suspicions about this, too. Xavier worked at your side every day, but you'd both spent the last several weeks sleeping at the Association, on call, should anything happen.
And aside from all of that, you couldn't help but feel like someone was watching you.
After nearly a full month of endlessly being on-call, you and Xavier were sent on a forced vacation. Two weeks of nothing but rest. Yet what should have been a lighthearted, relieved walk home with takeout held weight and tension that you hadn't seen in Xavier in months.
The last fight went sideways. Xavier pulled a daring move to get the wanderer low enough for you to trap it, but the damn thing opened its maw and headed straight for him. Instinct took over, and you dove in front of him, unleashing a flurry of attacks. The wanderer nearly snapped the top half of your body off. A burst of Xavier's evol pushed it back just enough to miss you. In the end you succeeded and gathered the protocore, stabilized the area, and cleared it, but your partner had seethed ever since. He barely responded when you asked about food.
Yet, his grip on your waist wasn't angry. It reminded you of the way Sylus held you to his chest after that injection. Desperation. He didn't let go of you, and his eyes scanned the horizon for threats, watching. waiting, like he expected something to come out of the darkness and hurt you.
He only relaxed, just a touch, when you entered your apartment building. The elevator slowly moved up to your floor, and his head finally settled on your shoulder. Just for a moment. When the doors opened, he returned to his vigilance, a Knight protecting his Princess. You opened the door, slipping inside with him. Only then did he let you go, and it was only so he could quickly check your apartment. The past few weeks had made both of you paranoid.
You dropped your bag by the door, slipped off your shoes, and set everything on the table. The corset of your uniform slipped off, and you took the first full breath you'd taken in weeks. Your weapons needed maintenance. Sylus would scold you if he saw the condition your guns were in right now, but that needed to wait for tomorrow. Tonight? Tonight you needed to fuck Xavier until he forgave you and fall asleep on his chest without an alarm waking you up in the morning.
You removed the weapon holsters from your body and set them down, verifying everything was unloaded and offline. Xavier silently did the same behind you, his coat and gloves coming off in quiet rustles of fabric and clinks of metal.
"I was fine. Why did you put yourself in danger?" Xavier asked, his voice low and restrained.
"You were not fine, Xav! It was going to take a chunk out of you, I had to do something!" You turned to face him, your brows drawn together.
"And it almost killed you."
"We both know I'm harder than that to take out," you said.
"I'm not going to apologize for loving you, Xavier!" The words hung in the air between you both, heavy in the humid night. You'd danced around the L-word for a long time now, afraid to call all of this what it was because putting the words to the feelings felt like a bad omen. But you had finally said it, and he caught it, the hard look on his face softening in the darkness of your apartment.
He closed the distance, wrapping you up in his arms, so tight it made it hard to breathe but you returned the embrace, savoring the warm, firm strength of his chest against your cheek. "I'm not asking you to. Please, never run into danger on my behalf again. Trust that I have a plan. If anything happened to you, I..."
"Where you go, I follow. We're a team," you murmured. "I need you safe, Xavier."
"I need the same from you. I know you're strong. You might be the strongest person I know. But when you do dangerous things I..." Flickers of old memories dance in his eyes, maybe a pain a past version of yourself put there. You cupped his face, and he leaned into your palm. When he spoke next, his words were a quiet, whispered confession. "I won't survive losing you again."
"You won't," you promised. "I'm not going anywhere."
He kissed you then, lifting you into his arms and pushing you against the wall. Like he needed to feel you, to taste you, to know that you were here, safe, and his. You returned the kiss, and the last month's worth of repressed desire came surging forth as you dug into his shoulders and rocked your hips into his.
You peeled his undershirt off his body, moaning at the heat of his skin under your palms. You broke away from his lips to kiss down his neck, choosing to leave a mark right where his collarbone and neck met. He groaned, rocking into you, his fat cock throbbing against your core.
A knock sounded against your door. The pattern familiar enough you knew without having to see the person. Zayne? What was he doing here? He usually texted before he came over. Did he find something urgent?
"I gotta get that, Xavie," you said.
"No you don't. Whoever it is, they can wait. They can listen to the way you scream my name when I make you come for me if they want to stick around, but I need you right now, starlight."
"You'll have me," you promised. "I know that knock, though. Zayne wouldn't show up unannounced unless something important came up."
Xavier's brows drew together. "Doctor Zayne, right? One of your other lovers?"
Xavier visibly trembled. "Is he as aggravating as Rafayel?"
A bright giggle burst from your lips. "All of you have your own unique way of pissing me off, but I wouldn't have it any other way."
Xavier blinked, and his grip loosened, and you slipped out of his hold, darting to the door. You opened it, and Zayne rushed in, sweeping you into his arms. You laughed a little, holding onto him as you breathed him in. The smell of baked goods filled your apartment, and you smiled as you looked up at your beloved Doctor.
"Hello, darling. I'm sorry it's late. I discovered something and I know your vacation starts tomorrow and I --" he trailed off as his eyes landed on Xavier. He cleared his throat, a faint pink blush dancing across his cheeks. "Didn't want to interrupt you and your partner's vacation. Though, it seems I have. Apologies, Xavier."
"You remember my name?" Xavier asked.
"Of course. She talks about you often."
Xavier hummed, the sound somewhat pleased as you pulled Zayne further into the apartment then closed the door. "I know you wouldn't come out of the blue unless it was urgent. What's wrong?"
"That injection the assassin put in you, I found out who made it. It took weeks to assess the specific chemical compounds, but it seems that whoever sent those assassins after you didn't want you dead, only unconscious with your evol activated. I brought the file with the information, and you can go over it once you've had some time to rest."
"Does Sylus know about this?" you asked.
You sighed. Sylus and Rafayel were already likely on the trail, then. You pressed a soft kiss to Zayne's lips. "Thank you, Zaynie."
He hummed and gently kissed your forehead. "Anything for you, darling. I brought dessert."
"She hasn't earned those," Xavier said. He crossed the room and took the box from Zayne, then set it on the counter. "Our sweet little Princess was reckless today. Nearly got herself killed."
Zayne looked down at you, his gaze sharpening. "Is that true?"
"I was trying to to help Xavier--"
"And she put herself in danger, even though I had a plan. We're all lucky I reacted in time to block the wanderer."
Zayne pinched the bridge of his knows. "She often does that, doesn't she? Putting herself directly into harm's way."
"Excuse me? She is right here, and she will kick both of your asses!" You crossed your arms. "I'm a Hunter. My entire life is danger."
"That may be so, but you know what happens when you're reckless, darling." Zayne cupped your face in his hand and took a step closer to you.
You backed up two steps, then your back hit Xavier's bare chest. "Maybe it's a good thing you showed up after all, Doctor. I was just thinking that she needed to be punished for her behavior."
"I think you're right. Danger is a part of the job, but recklessness serves no one. Maybe you'll learn to be more careful if we deliver the right consequences to your actions." Zayne's hazel eyes met yours, that stern, dominant look in them that made your knees buckle. Your head fell back against Xavier's chest, and you looked up at him, finding his chin tilted up, eyes downcast. You bit your lip.
Fuck, you were really in for it now. You gulped. "I doubt it, but you two can try, anyway."
Xavier's hands on your hips pulled you flush against his body. Zayne pressed his chest to yours, his firm grip settling around your waist. Xavier kissed your neck, grinding his hips against yours, and your eyes fluttered closed. Zayne made quick work of your shirt, and he tossed it to the side, exposing your chest to the still-dark apartment.
With your shirt out of the way, Xavier undid your bra, and Zayne pulled that off you, too. The moment your chest was exposed to the room he leaned down, pressing soft kisses against your chest before pinching both of your nipples.
Your hands tugged at his black shirt, undoing all the buttons before pushing it off him. Pressed between your lovers, both their bare chests against yours, your mind stuttered, almost entirely forgetting about the punishment that awaited you.
Xavier turned you around, bending you over the counter. A flicker of his evol danced from his fingers, then slipped around your wrists, pulling them behind your back and binding them together. He circled the counter and slipped his hand into your hair, tilting your head back to look up at him.
Zayne pulled your pants down and off your hips, leaving you only in your panties. His large, slightly cool hand grazed your ass. He kneaded the soft, plush expanse of your ass in his hands, and goosebumps rose all across your skin.
"I'm going to spank you, and you will keep count for us. You were there, Xavier. How many has she earned?"
"We will start there, then. Keep your eyes on Xavier, and don't lose count, Princess."
Zayne landed the first spank on your ass, and unlike his usual love-taps, this one stung. You wheezed as the hit worked through you, your hands clenching uselessly against Xavier's evol.
"One!" you counted, looking up at Xavier.
The second came quickly, just as firm as the first. The clap echoed through your apartment, the sting burning deeper into your skin.
Zayne continued, his next spanks landing in the exact same spot. The skin there warmed, each successive spank made the next all the more sensitive. You blinked up at Xavier, keeping your eyes open despite the urge to close them. He looked down at you, his head tilted to the side, with that dangerous look on his face. Your stomach fluttered, a new surge of heat pooling low in your belly. Your eyes stung with unshed tears, blurring your vision as the warmth and need spread all through your body.
"Ten!" you cried, the tears finally falling down your face as the clap landed across your ass.
"You're taking your punishment so well, Princess," Xavier cooed. He leaned down, capturing your lips in a hungry kiss. You moaned into his mouth, and his tongue tangled with yours, swallowing the noises you made as Zayne's cool hands soothed the heat his spanks caused.
"What do you have to say for yourself, darling?"
Xavier broke the kiss, his tongue lapping up the tears on your cheeks.
Your mind was fuzzy, the haze of subspace wrapped around you, making it hard for your brain to piece words together. You swallowed. "I was just trying to--"
Zayne's hand came down hard on the other cheek, and you squeaked your chest arching off the counter. "Fuck! Eleven!"
"Fuck isn't a number, Princess. Do we need to start over?" Xavier asked, roughly tugging your hair up to meet his gaze.
"N-no, 'm sorry!" you gasped, blinking up at him.
"You're so fucking beautiful when you cry for us," Xavier praised. "Keep counting as you were, but don't hold back those pretty cries."
Zayne landed spank after spank on the plush cushion of your ass, hitting the same spot with perfect accuracy, giving both cheeks the same treatment. Tears flowed freely down your cheeks, and your panties were so wet they clung to your pussy, soaked entirely through.
"T-twenty!" you sobbed as the last spank echoed through your apartment. Your legs trembled, though you were bent over. A layer of sweat soaked your bare skin, and your breathing ran ragged. Yet, you still stared up at Xavier, your tears flowing down your cheeks, and he moaned.
"You did so good, starlight. You took your punishment so well." Xavier pressed a kiss to your damp forehead, and you nuzzled into his touch, feeling floaty and untethered.
"Amazing. You really did so well, darling. I'm so proud of you. What a good girl." Zayne rubbed his cool hands over your bright-red behind, soothing the burn with his touch.
"But it's not over yet," Xavier said. "I still don't think you've quite learned your lesson."
Xavier went behind you and muttered something to Zayne that you couldn't quite make out. Gods, when you told all your lovers about each other, you never believed it would lead to them working together like this, but you loved it. Being at their mercy was the only place you wanted to be.
Xavier pulled your soaked panties off, helping you step out of them but not otherwise allowing you to move. Kneeling behind you, he spread you open and spit on your already soaked pussy. His face then dove between your thighs, his tongue delving deep into your pussy. You moaned his name, shuddering against your counter as he ate you out. Your eyes fell closed as Xavier pleasured you.
His licks were ravenous, messy things as he slurped down your juices. Long curls of his tongue hit your inner walls, gathering your wetness as he drank you in. He left your hole to lap down to your clit, sucking it into his mouth. He hummed against you, and your hips jolted, grinding against his face. Xavier grunted against your pussy, his grip stilling your movements, keeping you pinned while he ate.
His hand left your ass, choosing instead to curl inside you. He hit that spot that made your knees tremble and paired it with firm, powerful sucks on your clit. Already sensitive and pulsing from the spanking, your moans pitched higher as the pleasure built.
Zayne's hand spread your ass apart and a dribble of cool liquid spilled over your tightest hole. "We're both going to take you tonight, darling. While you will be punished, we won't have you unprepared."
"Yes, Sir. Thank you, Sir," you whimpered.
"Now you behave," Zayne chuckled. "Good. Maybe we will reward you."
Content with how much lube covered your skin, Zayne slipped one slick finger into your asshole, slowly stretching you around the digit. You'd taken most of your lovers in your ass by this point, but the first stretch in a while always had you forgetting how to breathe. Yet, you followed Zayne's steady breaths as he slowly worked you open.
Sharp cries of Xavier's name left your lips as he sucked harder, pressing firmly against that textured spot in your depths, and you arched off the counter as you came, soaking his fingers in your release. Xavier didn't stop. He fingered you through it, but if anything, the pulse of his fingers seemed to get faster, his sucks more punishing. The burn of overstimulation tugged at your senses, but the discomfort quickly gave way to sharp, unyielding pleasure.
Zayne slipped a second finger into your ass, slowly working it past the tight ring. Nearly unable to breathe from the pleasure and the fullness, everything within you stalled. Waited. Paused. When you finally remembered to breathe, it came with a sob that sounded somewhat like Zayne's name.
Under the skilled hands of both your lovers, the pressure built, their fingers pressing against one another with each, powerful press. Your legs trembled around Xavier's head, but he paid you no mind. The man was far too focused on his feast. The slick sounds of your lover's fingers slipping in and out of your greedy holes filled the room.
"Listen to that," Zayne hummed. "She's about to come for us again. So soon after the first time, too."
"Feels s'good!" you whimpered against the cool countertop. "Gonna come!"
"Go ahead, darling. Come for us," Zayne said.
You couldn't resist Zayne's gentle encouragement. You came with a sharp, loud curse. Your juices soaked Xavier's hand, the sounds so wet, but yet again, neither of your lovers stopped. Xavier sucked your clit with more fervor, and this time, the burn of overstimulation sharpened into pain before it melted into blinding pleasure.
A third finger slipped into your ass and you were lost. At the tail end of your second orgasm came your third. Hot and sharp, it cut through you, melting you from the inside out.
"Xavier please, s'too much! Please!"
Your cries didn't move him. Xavier and Zayne pulled two more out of you just like that, your sobs losing more and more coherence the further into pleasure you descended. A loud sob punctuated your last release, and only then did Xavier release your throbbing, too-sensitive clit.
You trembled against the counter, legs shaking and mind hazy. Xavier slowly slipped his fingers out of you, then Zayne did, too. Xavier's evol released your wrists, then Zayne -- who had stripped of all his clothes at some point -- lifted you into his arms and carried you into your bedroom.
Zayne lay flat on his back, and he pulled you down into bed with him. You straddled his lap, and his long, thick cock pulsed hard and heavy against your thigh.
"I'm going to fill this pretty little pussy and Xavier is going to stuff your ass. Is that alright with you, Princess?" Zayne cupped your face, pushing the fallen strands of hair back behind your ear.
"What's your color?" Zayne asked.
"Green," you said, verifying you were okay to continue.
"Good girl," Xavier said. The bed dipped as he climbed in behind you. The heat of his body hovered behind you, and he pressed a soft kiss to your neck. "You're always so good for us."
More lube covered your ass, then Zayne lifted your hips, and you slowly inched down on his big cock. Soft, whimpering noises escaped you as your still-sensitive insides accommodated his girth and length, stuffing you to the brim.
"Come here." Zayne held you against his chest as Xavier lined himself up with your other hole. You shuddered as the fat head of Xavier's cock pushed against your ass.
"You can do this, starlight. Let me in." Xavier moaned as the head of his cock slipped past the right ring. "Fuck yes, just like that."
Slowly, so slowly, Xavier sank all the way inside your ass, stretching you out around his immense girth. With both cocks fully inside you, your entire body vibrated with deep pleasure. Everything felt so good, so much. With Zayne in front of you and Xavier behind you, you floated in the bliss they gave you, your mind empty.
Zayne thrust in as Xavier pulled out, the friction of their thrusts sending powerful waves of deep pleasure jolting through you. Your holes clenched and pulsed around their cocks, entirely lost to the pleasure.
Both your lovers stopped, immediately, Zayne pulling back far enough that only the head of his cock remained inside you. You whined, a feral, frustrated sound, and both men laughed.
"Poor little Princess," Xavier cooed.
"Only good girls get to come on their Sir's cocks. Have you really been a good girl, darling?" Zayne asked.
The whimper that left you may have been a beg, or a wheeze, or a gag. Perhaps all three. You tried to rock your hips back and forth, but your men held you steady, refusing to give you what you want.
"I've been so good, pleasepleasepleasepleaseplease let me come!"
"Weren't you just saying you couldn't take anymore? Think of this as us doing you a favor," Xavier said.
You sobbed, but didn't protest further, too foggy brained to form the needed words under the weight of sensation. They both thrust in at the same time, bottoming out inside you, and you screamed, shaking over them. The pace they set after that was brutal, the rough sound of skin-against-skin filling your bedroom. Their hands and mouths were everywhere. Your hips, your waist, your chest. Your neck. Not a single inch of your body was unmarked or untouched by your lovers as you got fucked back and forth between them.
The second orgasm built quickly, but before you could as much as beg, both men stopped, pulling out again. Your insides pulsed and clenched with a fury, desperate to come, but yet again, they refused you.
"If you want to come, earn it. Beg. Beg us to let you come," Xavier ordered.
"Zayne, Xavier, please let me come I promise I'm such a good girl, I'll be good I promise just please, please, please!!! I need it, I need to come, please! Please!" you begged, every word more of a slurred babble than anything.
"Will you keep putting yourself in danger, starlight?" Xavier asked.
"No!!! I'll be so good, I promise, I Promise just please, Xavier, please!"
"Are you convinced?" Zayne asked.
"I think she's convinced herself" Xavier laughed breathlessly. "Fuck she feels so good."
Zayne moaned, the sound affirmative. He grabbed your throat, ot squeezing, just holding and turned your head so you looked at him. "Go ahead and come for us, Princess. You've earned it."
"Thank you Sirs,, thank you, oh thank you ---!" You screamed as you came around them, your body convulsing from the intensity. Light burst behind your eyes as you gushed all over Zayne's cock, and he groaned as he pulled you all the way down his length. Hot ropes of come shot up inside you, filling you, and your eyes rolled into the back of your head.
Xavier followed a few thrusts behind, moaning your name as he thrust in as far as he could go before coming. Every heavy pulse of his cock spilled so much inside you, deepening the sensation of just being so full.
The three of you caught your breath in the aftermath for several minutes before Xavier slowly pulled out and gathered a warm washcloth to clean you up with and a cool glass of water. Zayne helped you drink up while Xavier cleaned up, and when Xavier returned to bed, Zayne passed you to him, then took care of wiping the come from your thighs and himself.
He settled back in bed, curling up behind you as you lay across Xavier's chest. Surrounded by your lovers, you slowly came down from the bliss, though you still floated in the aftermath.
"'m sorry I scared you Xavie," you murmured.
"I forgive you, just trust me next time, okay? Let me protect you." Xavier ran his hand through your hair.
"You need to be careful, too," you whined.
His face softened, tenderness taking over his expression as he leaned in and kissed you. "Alright. I'll be careful."
You hummed as you nuzzled into him, then looked over your shoulder. "That goes for you too, Zaynie. Be careful."
Nestled in between your lovers, you hummed, content. You'd come a long way from all the mistakes you made and the consequences you had to face, and while you'd been in for it several times, it all worked out in the end, didn't it?
AND THATS A WRAP ON THIS PART!!!!!! AYOOOO!!!! There's still one more part to this story, though, so I hope you all are ready for a big, fun polycule house moment!!!!! WITH Valko!!!! Idk when it will come, but it will show up eventually, I promise!
Also I have nothing to say for myself. This was written by the ovulation demons in one sitting.
series taglist: @maraveree, @boom-boom-back, @teriyaki-calm, @yuurisfavblog @plzdonutpercieveme @blorbohunter @babyx91 @mcdepressed290 @letig0 @wonhalo @k2bfree @wynxoxo @beaconsxd @anxiety-thyme @hilliserose @vxsire @fairestofnrc @duckybarnes1917 @pretty8domino @jsitmfgoesnsfw @thatweirdomidas @wackyquacky @stardustsylus @ahandacrossspace