Beyond The Beauty of Carmen Berzatto
The fact that you're all trying to guess the feelings of a grown man who literally asked his colleague, "WHAT IS A GIRLFRIEND?"(208)Â is beyond me.
You're so blinded by the main character's sex appeal that you forget that Carmen has been an awkward/nerdy/neurodivergent man all his life who never made decisions for himself except when he decided to hire Sydney and keep her without anyone's influence.
Carmen's lack of experience means he probably doesn't know the difference between a platonic relationship versus a romantic relationship with a woman.
That's why he was baffled when Sydney tried to introduce Claire as his girlfriend.
That's why Claire pursued him, not the other way around.
That's why, at this stage, he can't even describe the nature of his feelings for Sydney.
It's also why, the day after his panic attack, he hasn't said a word to his sister, even though he's been confiding in her since season one.Â
Because he's confused himself, and doesn't understand why Sydney's vision reassured him more than Claire's did. It's also interesting that he chose not to remember when she called him a piece of shit.
Everything happens on an UNCONSCIOUS level for him, which explains all these confusing montages showing Claire and Sydney at the same time.
That's also why he made his declaration to Sydney UNDER the table where CLAIRE ATE. Because everything HIDDEN is unconscious.












