you’re lying — you’re lying to me, again! melody’s words cut straight to her hearts, and her body is frozen as it repeats in her mind. melody has never looked at her like that, afraid and distrustful. anger - at herself, the doctor, the universe, everything that brought them to such a terrible point - burns in her eyes, muted only by the tears that promptly follow the emotion.
“i would never lie to you.” it’s a hoarse, nearly broken declaration, but all the more honest for it. melody continues talking, accent fluctuating as her anger boils over like donna has never seen before. she stays quiet for the rest of melody’s release, her empty hand curling back to her chest during it. she sees how her eyes move, like an animal trapped and she seems too old, too much like river. tears escape, not crying, not yet and not now, as the dots connect and her jaw clenches. her mind wails, this is too soon! this isn’t fair!, but she keeps that quiet, nails digging into her palm as she breathes.
it does little to steady her voice. “listen to yourself. i’ve never lied about anything to you, not now and not before — i was keeping you safe! the silence were a problem,” she had to clear that up. to let that lay would mean she’d lose her right here, and it was a miracle on its own that melody was still here as it was. donna was only a hybrid, a disaster of a metacrisis, she had no way of knowing if that misunderstanding would be the nail in the coffin. she refused to let it. for the girl she’d watched grow up, who’s tears she’d wiped with hushed words of reassurance, tickled laughter out until neither could breathe, to think that she had anything to do with those monsters might just kill her. “i was getting rid of them, if i’d—-”
her grip on her anger is slipping, too fast for her to catch it. her voice is a steady rage, a rage normally private, both hers and borrowed with the surety of a timelord’s right. where melody is shaking, donna’s anger makes her stone, cheeks blossoming as her lungs rush to keep up. “everything was in place for you to never come across them. this is my responsibility, to keep you and your parents safe.” melody’s words echo, they’ve done something to me, and she throws out a hand, voice raising just as her emotions. “would you rather i throw them in the middle of the danger? i couldn’t risk them, not when that meant you could lose them.”
a silence wraps between them. faintly, she thinks that the night is far too peaceful for this to happen. the moon is clear, bright as it hangs without a cloud nearby, and its an otherwise beautiful sight. their anger, this break in their relationship - for as frantic as donna might be working and will keep working to fix it, the fact stands that it’s been broken - is closed off to just this pathway. elsewhere, there are search parties futilely trying to find a girl that knows too well how to make sure she’s untraceable. donna can now see that she’d come to her hoping for her to bring clarity.
and oh god, what if she’d just lied? what if she’d pulled her in, lied through her teeth and said this was the first time she heard of them? how much might that have helped - or would melody have been too hurt by then to trust anything at all? she itches to travel back, a human need to get it right, to get another chance, even as she knows no amount of time travel can grant a redo. so she does the next best thing, what she’s always done, and keeps herself open to melody.
“i thought you would never have to come across them.” her voice is breathless, but there’s still an anger - more muted, more bittersweet - in the tension of her shoulders. she doesn’t reach out the same as before, merely drops her arms to her sides and looks at the girl plainly. there are no secrets in her face, tears trailing as she inhales deeply. “and——”
“i’m sorry i didn’t notice sooner. i’m sorry.”
she wants to believe her. god, does melody want to believe donna : but too much has come to light, too much has happened, and melody’s never been more confused than she is right now. nothing about what she thought about her life was right : and now that she knows the truth, pieces are coming to her. what she thought were nightmares were memories - a house, empty and dark and ruined, with writing on the wall in paint or blood : she never could tell the difference. a voice she knew but couldn’t place, that made her tense in her sleep, made her nauseous whenever it whispered in her ear. a suit : big and white and empty, trying to swallow her whole. none of it made any sense to her until today and now she can’t help but wonder what else was kept from her. for her protection. again, she listens but she doesn’t hear donna : she doesn’t hear the desperation in her voice or the truth she wholeheartedly believes. melody’s eyes close as her hands rise and she’s had enough. ❝ stop ! just - just stop, donna. ❞
melody’s jaw clenches tight : teeth grit together, and she crosses her arms yet again. at least her hands have loosened, and though there’s an ache in her palms, melody doesn’t notice. gaze fixated on donna, she tries to force herself to calm down but the attempt is futile. especially when it comes to her parents. melody scoffed, breath exhaling sharply as her glare became all the more pronounced : if looks could kill . . . she’s not far from that point, right now. she can feel it - something that stirs deep within her, that voice in her head telling her that this was all wrong, wrong, wrong - and it was all the doctor’s fault. the doctor, who held her at arms length, who kept his distance more often than not : and wasn’t the doctor a part of donna, too ?
is she really that surprised that donna knew ? all this time, she had kept this from her. from her parents. and that thought alone is enough to prompt the anger to rise in her blood, a resurgence of betrayal and distrust that she can’t control. melody bit through her teeth with a scathing tone. ❝ you’re just like him. ❞ she doesn’t realise it, but she’s reverting. the training she had undergone as a child has started to kick back in and she doesn’t remember exactly what they taught her, but she knows that sometimes words are a weapon, and melody knew how to wield them. she always has, but this time it’s different. this time, the silence were in her head and had been for a while. ❝ you pick and choose what you think is best for everyone else and you don’t care what they want, or need - you should have told them ! my parents. they deserved to know-they should have known but you decided otherwise : you are just like him ! ❞
and then she breaks. everything she’s been holding in spills out on a vicious tongue as melody loses control of what composure she had. she takes one step forward but her body is wrought with tension : fight or flight mode at it’s finest, and she’s so angry that she doesn’t think about what she’s saying. she doesn’t want to hurt donna but she can’t stop herself now that she’s started. melody pond escaped the silence once : but did she really ?
❝ you. were. wrong ! ❞ she hissed through her teeth, each word punctuated and emphasised as she thinks about all the time she’s missing, all the headaches she’s endured for weeks. melody knows it’s partly her fault : she should have told someone that she felt . . . different, lately. but she also didn’t think there was a reason to err on the side of caution. if she had, maybe this wouldn’t be happening. maybe they wouldn’t have gotten so close. maybe she wouldn’t feel so hurt, or confused, or angry.
all the fight bleeds from her, she is suddenly drained of all the adrenaline that had kept her going since she fled her home hours ago, and melody is exhausted. she immediately backs away, slow steps putting distance between them again as melody wraps her arms around her waist and the angry tears are gone : she feels, and probably looks, small. and scared. and still so very confused. her eyes dart down the street, she can feel the chill of the day on her skin and she has never been this vulnerable before : that she can remember, at least. she licked her lips lightly, lower lip catching between her teeth and she shook her head. donna said she was sorry . . . but, ❝ that’s not enough. ❞ it’s the first thing she’s said that isn’t riddled with accusation, rage or hurt. even to melody, she sounds defeated, or resigned. she shifts her field of vision back to donna, and it’s obvious to anyone who knows her : of which donna certainly does, that she’s seconds away from running. quietly, she repeats herself. but this time it doesn’t sound like an insult. it sounds like a revelation. ❝ you’re just like him. ❞