Long rant about Black media and the lack of positive stories and also about people's attitudes towards that.
So, I periodically go on the look out for cozy, comforting books about Black people. Because I like those books and I think Black people should have those just like anyone else. Inevitably, I come across someone on Reddit asking for similar books. Usually, they ask for books that aren't about pain and suffering. And, EVERY time, you get some of the same responses. First, multiple people will haul out books that are filled with pain and suffering. That are about pain and suffering. But, they are about Black people. They bring up all the classics whether they fit the request or not. Imagine if someone just said they wanted a feel good book without specifying race. If they said they wanted something without tragedy. No one would suggest something Anna Karenina and then say it's the opposite of what was asked for, but it's such a good book they had to recommend it. So, why do they do that for books about Black people? Is it to prove that they have read books by Black people? Kindred was an amazing book. I sped through it because I couldn't wait to see what happened next. I would totally recommend it. Unless someone specifically asked for a book that wasn't about Black trauma. Then, I would never recommend it.
Second, someone will say that stories need conflict. As if asking for a book without Black trauma means you don't understand how stories work. Yes, fiction does need conflict. Conflict does not equal trauma. Or, it's not the only definition. Anne of Green Gables is full of conflicts. Anne is not 100% happy through the entire book and everything doesn't go right on every page. But, it's a feel good book. She's not happy all of the time, but she's happy throughout the book. There's moments of joy sprinkled throughout the difficult moments. And while a tragedy does happen, it's not about the tragedy. You don't come away from the book thinking the primary story is about loss and pain. Conflict can be funny. Or, even a book with a serious subject can be about someone overcoming troubles and finding joy. And, again, if you ask just for a general feel good or comforting book, you will get a bunch of suggestions without someone arguing that books need conflict.
Third, people will argue that books about Black pain and suffering are realistic. And some will get sarcastic and angry that you don't want to deal with it. Except, it's not the only reality. I don't wake up every day in a cloud of misery bombarded by suffering and trauma whenever I step out of my house. People need to listen to Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's TED talk about the danger of a single story. Pain and suffering and racism is not the only story for Black people and to say that people who want one of the other stories of Black people is not wanting reality is annoying.
It's like some people feel we don't have the right to light hearted stories. That we have a duty to immerse ourselves in suffering. Look at Abbott Elementary. A really good comedy show set in a struggling, primarily Black school. It has serious subjects presented in a funny way. It's a feel good show. People started to suggest that the show should do a school shooting episode. You can find the humor in difficulty of getting school supplies. You can focus on the ways teachers make do. You can't make school shooting funny. Remember, Abbott Elementary is a comedy. And no one was hoping for some kind of dark humor twisted comedy. They wanted a hard hitting somber episode. Even though it's not the style of the show at all.
And, I'm not saying on these threads people never try to actually answer the question (although it seems like it's only a handful of stories), but the things I mention inevitably come up that don't come up when someone doesn't specify that they are focusing on Black people.