The Skyliners’ “It Happened Today”
For the first time I went through the database looking for versions of a specific song, so that I could compare and decide on the best source.
Since Skyliners will be our first releases I looked for all the master sources I have for “It Happened Today.”
Originally released on Original Sound in 1963
Written by: James Beaumont, Walter Lester, Joseph Rock, John Taylor, Joseph Verscharen, Janet Vogel
Arlovol Music, Administered by Southern Music Pub. Co., Inc. (ASCAP)
mp4 given to us from OSE pursuant to the terms of the sale
wav file ripped from the commercially available Skyliners’ CD on Ace CDCH 78
¼” tape BMC-2109 acquired by Art Laboe when he bought Calico Records out of receivership.
The wav file is indeed clearer than the mp4. My suspicions that these files are sourced from the same place. The ¼” version has 5 takes of the song on it, indicating it as a session tape, either 1, 2 or 3 track master. We could not determine how many tracks were on the tape at the digitization session.
The first two takes are false starts, the first not slated, the second slated as take 01.
Three full takes exist, slated as take 2, 4 and 5, indicating that take 3 was removed or erased from the reel.
An examination of the tape 2109 might show a leaderless splice (hard to see during digitization) where take 3 was removed. If no splice was observed then we might draw two conclusions:
This is a safety copy of the session tape, made after removal
Or, take three was erased
Or, the session engineer miscounted
On Take 5, I noticed a slight vocal drop the lead vocal enters on first verse at around 11 seconds on sources 1 and 2. Turns out to be a fidelity drop, affecting both channels of the mono track—meaning there was an irregularity in the transfer for sources 1 and 2. This problem did not exist in the digitized transfer we made with Brian Kehew in 2012, source 3.
What this proves is that sources 1 and 2 are almost certainly copied from the same place, further indicating that source 1 was simply ripped off a retail CD, probably the Ace CD mentioned above.
Other non-digitized sources for this song exist in what appears to be ¼” safety transfer or album master from the ‘80s, another from the 90’s, and an 8-track cassette master (with “four programs”) from the 70’s. DAT and U-Matic sources also exist from the 80’s and 90’s––I assume these are early digitizations of the original tapes acquired from Calico Records, and may have been made when the tapes were in 20 years earlier condition.
Test transferring one of these, may be wise, if only to use as a measure of how tape has degraded over the years. However, transfers have many variables, tape condition being only one, and a transfer made today on an older tape, may render a better quality “tape performance” than a flawed transfer made twenty years ago on the younger version of the same tape.
On source 3, Take 2 is groovier than take 4, but 5 is very much the best, mostly because the drummer widened the swing a bit and found the groove. However, there’s a piano improvising over this track and it id distracting and only appears on the final take, yet not on any of the previous commercial releases. Probably best to use a version without the piano––which is take 2.
However, take 5 is indicated as the master by an inserted stretch of leader tape.
On Take 5, I noticed a slight vocal drop the lead vocal enters on first verse at around 11 seconds. Turns out to be a fidelity drop, affecting both channels of the mono track—meaning there was an irregularity in the transfer for sources 1 and 2. This problem did not exist in the digitized transfer we made with Brian Kehew in 2012, source 3.
What this proves is that sources 1 and 2 are almost certainly copied from the same place, further indicating that source 1 was simply ripped off a retail CD, probably the Ace CD mentioned above.
Other non-digitized sources for this song exist in what appears to be ¼” safety transfer or album master from the ‘80s, another from the 90’s, and an 8-track cassette master (with “four programs”) from the 70’s. DAT and U-Matic sources also exist from the 80’s and 90’s––I assume these are early digitizations of the original tapes acquired from Calico Records, and may have been made when the tapes were in 20 years earlier condition.
Test transferring one of these, may be wise, if only to use as a measure of how tape has degraded over the years. However, transfers have many variables, tape condition being only one, and a transfer made today on an older tape, may render a better quality “tape performance” than a flawed transfer made twenty years ago on the younger version of the same tape.
At least for tape 2109, the Skyliners seem low on between song banter. The pianist and tympani player keep busy noodling around quietly. Otherwise slates and count offs and a bit of hearty laughter from a vocalist are the only points of interest.
Vocal takes appear on every take, indicating these sessions were live, direct to tape with no overdubs.
Because my very first inquiry into the Skyliners’ catalog revealed a transfer flaw for the 1991 Ace CD version, my temptation is to return to the studio to digitize more of the original Calico Records tapes.