꒰ა 𝒩𝑒𝓌 𝑔𝒾𝓇𝓁 𝒾𝓃 𝓈𝒾𝑔𝒽𝓉 !! ໒꒱
A Jeff the killer x reader short story
TW: Sex mentioned heavily. Heavy cussing.
This was made inspired by a troop that has been in the creepypasta fandom for a while. I wanted to make my own version LOL! Sorry if writing was kinda trash. I wanted to make it like how they did back in the 2010’s but in my own style. I really enjoyed writing this at 3:30 in the fucking morning.
You and Jeff had been sleeping with each other for a while now and it was no surprise you caught major feelings for him. He didn’t push you away like how you thought he would and honestly… he didn’t seem too bothered with your clinginess after the sex you guys shared.
Currently you two were laying in his bed naked and sweaty after the most intense rounds of sex you’ve ever had. Jeffery was falling asleep next to you as your head was against his chest. Until you whispered to him. “Jeffery…?” Jeff responded with a sleepy hum that sounded slightly irritated. “Was it good?… The sex I mean… its been a while since we’ve done something like that … I mean. I dunno… are we really dating..?” you mumbled sleepily against his chest. He held you tighter. “Jeez.. half of the mansion consider us as a couple. And yeah.. it was okay I guess…”. He said slightly softer. It was the best you’ve got out of him and you knew he fucking loved it more than he’d like to admit.
Until you both were interrupted with a knock on the door. You heard a voice that sounded like toby’s… “hey you guys!! Slender man wants us to go to the living room!! Its important!!!”. You both let out an audible Groan of frustration. jeff gently rubbed your bare back subconsciously. “Get off me princess… you can cling onto me after I get dressed…” you were annoyed but obliged.
After you both two were dressed and more composed. You two went downstairs while you chatted to him a bit. “Do you know what’s so important? He never makes us gather up like this…” you said to Jeff while trying to hold his hand lightly. “No. I don’t know. I fucking hate that cunt for making me do useless shit. I’m fucking exhausted.” jeffery said very annoyed. “Hey… its okay. Maybe we’ll just sit together on the couch okay? It’ll be fine.”. You were still all sleepy and in a daze from post sex and he could tell. He laughed and nudged you.
Once you both were settled down on the couch next together. Everyone was crowding around you. Every single proxy you could name was around you guys. Sally came out with slenderman holding a doll in her hand. Looking happy as ever.
“Hello guys! As you may know everyone was gathered here!! And that’s because we have a new proxy!! Someone was really determined to work for slenderman!” Sally said happily before looking up with a huge grin on her face to slenderman. You couldn’t help but think how slender man and sally looked like such a dad and daughter duo. you gently snuggled closer to Jeff and he didn’t mind. He was falling asleep anyways
Sally looked back into the crowd. “Her name is moxie!!”
Suddenly a girl came out. Like she was waiting for an intro. She looked somewhat like Nina. With all the pink. Only thing that was different was her awfully bleached hair. It looked hella patchy. At least to you. She was talking but your ears didn’t seem to process it. Like it was in the background. All you could focus on was how her eyes didn’t seem to leave Jeff. The man you were pretty close to sitting to. It was pretty fucking well known that you and Jeff were together.
You already started scowling In anger. Jeff noticed you got tense and he just poked your side. Which seemed to make moxie pause.
After her whole bullshit speech. A lot of proxies left. But you and Jeff stayed on the couch since he was falling asleep by the second.
It boosted your ego he always got sleepy after sex with you.
But it pissed you off the moment she sat next to Jeff opposite of you. She gently tapped his chest and he scowled. pushing her arm away. “Don’t fucking touch me, cunt.”. She apologized. “Sorry… I just think you are really adorable. What’s your name?”.
Ugh. She spoke in such a forced baby voice. It made you sick to your stomach.
“Do I have to spell it out for you, dumbass? Obviously I’m not telling you. Get out my face before I make you.”
Jeff’s threat made her freeze and stutter.
“Alright.. okay I’m sorry. My names moxie.” She said nervously. “Are you deaf? I’m in a relationship with the person that’s been sitting next to me the entire time. “Are you fucking blind? Back the fuck off. I’m trying to nap.”.
Moxie left fast. You could hear her heels colliding against the wooden floors with every fast step she took.
“You didn’t have to do that… but thanks anyway.” You mumbled to Jeff. “Gosh, I’m not shitty all the time.” Jeff teased. He stood up quite fast and lead you upstairs back to your shared bedroom. He got undressed to his black boxer briefs and laid back on the bed, grabbing your waist and laid you down on his side. You clinged to his side. Legs intertwining under the comforter. It was almost cringe how well you knew each other to be like this.
Your hand came up to his cheek and traced his face scars with your fingertips. The moonlight covered his face. Jeez he really was so fucking handsome.
“Jeffery… I love you. Are you really falling asleep…?”
“Yeah… just shut up and keeping doing what your doing.”
You kept touching his face and soon began kissing him softly. He reciprocated lazily.
You pulled away eventually to let him sleep.
“Don’t ever stop loving me, ‘kay?” Jeff mumbled.
“I could never… just sleep okay…? We can hang out all day tomorrow.”
“Alright.. I’m not a fucking toddler.. and just to let you know.. we’re officially dating. Too late for take backs.” He said half jokingly.
You couldn’t help but let out a quiet laugh. “Alright, boyfriend.”
He smirked proudly to himself. What a way to boost this man’s ego.
You and jeffery fell asleep in each other’s arms. For once, life didn’t seem so bad as a serial killer in the slendermanison.
A/n: sorry for anyone named moxie LOL. U guys are amazing <3