10 points to Gryffindor
What is a social credit system? according to an article, social credit system is a set of databases and initiatives that monitor and assess the trustworthiness of individuals, companies and government entities. In China, It is where a good rating could offer priority health care or deposit-free renting of public housing, while a negative rating could see individuals banned from flights and trains. The real question leads to, does this only applies in China or that this system has far existed beforehand?
I remember growing up as a Malaysian in high school that credit system are also implemented. Where good behavior are credited with positive point while bad behavior are credited with negative points. This points leads up to what marks your behavior performance and are given in a certificate after graduation. This system is known as Merit/Demerit system and it is commonly use nationally in educational sphere. The purpose behind this system is that student will maintain a high level of discipline and that they will comply to the rules and regulations of the schools. We can also notice this in movies like Harry Potter where the principle would reward points to group of students. In the end, some student were able to maintain a high level of merits and some fail to do so.
Does social credit system ever had a way to instill good behavior and provide safety to citizen? I think social credit system can be viewed as a law system. Having an offence against the law leads to punishment. The only difference is that the credit system goes into two ways, credited for good and punish for bad. On the other hand, does this system provide safety for the citizen? Just as how that laws are there to protect our general safety, and ensure our rights as citizens against abuses by other people, organizations and even by the government itself, so it is with this system. The system is not bias but applies to all individual including bodies of the government. The system may somehow also look scary especially of how that the data collected can lead to governmental control such as to determine a person outcome. Still, does control ever stop a person to do what they wish? In the end, I believe a person behavior is not determine upon the system but to what they choose to act.














