Quasi-two-way (AL/NL) Players Since 1900
I'm using "quasi-two-way" as a category to include players who either had meaningful time as both pitcher and hitter, or were close enough to the two-way line to be worth mentioning. This excludes Shohei Ohtani, a true two-way player, and Babe Ruth who was a true two-way player for two seasons.
Joe Wood Stellar pitcher from 1908-1915, including a 23-win season in 1911 and 34-win season in 1912 that earned some MVP consideration. A high-strikeout pitcher for his day, hence the nickname "Smoky" and a shoulder injury that ended his pitching career. Also a decent batter, he switched to the OF and returned in 1918 and hit .298/.376/.433 from 1918-1922, bolstered by a stellar 1921 performance of .368/.432/.568 in half a season's worth of games. Faced with an OF platoon and citing family obligations, he did not return in 1923.
Reb Russell Very good pitcher for the White Sox from 1913-1918, launched to stardom as a rookie with 22 wins and 316 innings in 52 games (36 starts). Barely made the team in 1919 and was cut midseason to avoid being a member of the Black Sox scandal. Transitioned to OF in the minors from 1919-1921, and came back to the majors with the Pirates in 1922-1923. Batted .368 in 1922 alone, and in 154 (or a full season's worth of) games for those two seasons, he batted .323/.377/.568 with 32 2B, 15 3B, 21 HR, 100 R, 133 RBI. He continued to hit very well in the minors before calling it quits in 1930 at age 41.
Rube Bressler 1.77 ERA as a 19-year-old pitcher in 1914, but shifted to OF by the end of the decade, where he played from 1921-1932. Batted .350 (!) for a 3-year stretch from 1924-1926, and .301 for his career.
Johnny Cooney One of the few on this list who genuinely did both at the same time. Mostly a pitcher but also played primarily either OF or 1B for a season or two from 1921-1930. Toiled in the minors from 1931-1934 before returning to the majors as an OF from 1935-1944. Career .286 hitter but only 2 HR in 3675 PA. Played in parts of 20 MLB seasons and 5 more in the minors.
Bucky Walters Primarily 3B from 1931-1934, became the premier pitcher of the National League for the next decade. Philadelphia's hitter-friendly Baker Bowl inflated numbers from 1935-1937, though he claims those were his best years and the league recognized his talent and named him an All-Star in 1937. Upon being traded to the Reds midseason in 1938, the numbers revealed what opposing batters already knew. He was NL MVP the following season, and an All-Star in 5 of 6 years from 1939-1944, including two more top-5 MVP finishes. He had 121 wins during that 6-year stretch and finished his career with 198 wins
Johnny Lindell Came up as a pitcher in 1942 but quickly shifted to OF from 1943-1950. All-Star in 1943, led the league in triples in 1943 and 1944, led the league in total bases and received down-ballot MVP votes in 1944. Probably would have been 1947 World Series MVP if the award existed at the time: .500/.625/.778, 9-for-18, 3 2B, 1 3B, 3 R, 7 RBI in 6 games. Bad slump in 1950 led to trade and demotion to minors in 1951, where he transition to pitcher and developed a successful knuckleball by 1952. Returned to majors for one year in 1953, led the league in walks and wild pitches, and called it a career.
Hal Jeffcoat Primarily a CF from 1948-1953 known for hustling, speed, and a good arm, his lack of prowess at the plate reduced him to defensive utility by 1953, and led to his conversion to pitcher in 1954. He had a shaky first season on the mound, but was solid as a swing man and starter from 1955-1957, before ending his career as a reliever by the end if 1959. Also notable: He and Madison Bumgarner are also the only two pitchers to allow a grand slam in the top of an inning, then hit a go-ahead home run in the bottom of the inning.
Dick Hall Came up as a CF in 1952-1954 (tried at 2B in 1953) before converting quite successfully to pitching. He lasted 17 years on the mound, with a solid career as a relief pitcher from 1955-1971. Known for excellent control, in his final 500 innings of his career, he issued only 26 unintentional walks (!), to go with 40 of the intentional variety. He also has the distinction of earning the first win in LCS history: Game 1 of the 1969 ALCS concluded as the NLCS was just getting underway, with Hall on the mound for the Orioles' walk-off win in the 12th.
Rick Ankiel ROY runner-up in 2000 as a pitcher (11-7, 3.50 ERA, 10.0 K/9), his only full year pitching. Returned as OF from 2007-2013, including a 25 HR season in his first full year back in 2008.
George Sisler (honorable mention) Actually a two-way player for his half-season in 1915, it was clear that he was too good of a hitter to stay on the mound. He's a HOF first baseman and one of only 14 hitters with a .340+ career BA in 5000+ PA. He hit .400 twice in 1920 and 1922, and set the single-season hits record in 1920 (257!) that stood for 84 years. Still, his 2.83 ERA in 70 innings in the second half of 1915 and 1.54 ERA in 41 innings scattered across the remainder of his career prove that the two-way talent was there.
Micah Owings (honorable mention) In MLB only from 2007-2012 primarily as a pitcher, but notable because he also frequently pinch-hit. He has a career batting line of .283/.310/.502 with 9 HR in 219 PA even with his latter-years slide. Multiply his batting stats by 3 for full-season approximation of 7.8 bWAR, 42 2B, 6 3B, 27 HR, 81 R, 105 RBI.
















