Last Vows Before the Altar [I'm Your Man]
Characters/Pairings: soft!dark mafia Andy Barber x curvy Millennial female!reader Word Count: 7.5k Summary: You make a discovery you never anticipated during the rehearsal dinner - a dinner Andy disappears from with no explanation.
Content/Warnings: forced engagement; use of pet name (sweetheart); smut (brief mutual masturbation, unprotected vaginal intercourse); mafia themes
Author Note: I've been working on this chapter for a long time and thinking about it for even longer. I think there will be moments you love and hate, but it's certainly full of elements that are moving us into the next phase of their story.
Previous Part | Full Collection
There are eighty-six people in attendance at the rooftop restaurant, and you are only sure you know the names of maybe a third. The rest are here because of Andyâto witness or test alliances, play in the ongoing power games, weigh old debts or new risks. Itâs the rehearsal dinner for one of Boston Mafiaâs elite, so the guest list was meticulously refined for Andyâs part. Yours as well, but not with the same intent or stakes to be considered.
Andy doesnât own Contessaâthe restaurant atop The Newbury Hotelâbut he does own the hotel, so it was seamless for your team to arrange this part of the wedding nuptials there. While you and Andy arenât having a full society affair wedding with all the bells and whistles and three or four days of events and traditions, you do have few significant event pieces woven into the wedding weekend, this being one of them. No one had asked you what to include, but you were part of the overall conversations, and if there had been anything you truly wanted to refuse, you think you might have been able to say so. But your team knows you well enough to create elements you appreciate.
And, annoyingly, so does Andy.
The room is a riot of velvet and silk and black wool, the exact social armor you expect at a pre-wedding gathering of this sort. And yet you can tell this doesnât scream mafia to the people who donât know the predators theyâre intermingling with. Itâs all too reminiscent of how you dismissed the barely-hushed rumors of Andy Barberâs potential connections before he revealed he was one of the kings of organized crime in the city. And for the sake of your parents, your friends, your family, youâre relieved and hope they remain ignorant.
Tonight will be a monumental tell for the future and whether or not you can pass, or rather, who you have to be while passing. You scan the clusters of guests and realize you should have always been able to spot true mafia at ten paces, even when theyâre disguised as board members and development officers and venture capitalists. Thereâs a particular gravity, neither ostentatious nor shy. Men in Brioni suits who know how to vanish into the background, women with hair so immaculate it could have been sculpted from silk.
Andyâs hand has been heavy at the small of your back most of the evening, and itâs somehow almost comforting, an anchor. Occasionally you feel his thumb graze the bare inch of spine between velvet and skin, a touch so subtle itâs only for you.
You look across the room and spot your parents lingering near a tray of passed champagne, your mother straightening the lapels of your fatherâs jacket with the hopeless affection of people who have been married long enough to know that preening is just another form of devotion. Your motherâs dress is a shade of navy so dark it reads black, and your father looks as if he was born inside a suit, so naturally does this one fit him.
Suddenly Thea is in front of you, plucking a glass of champagne off a passing tray and handing it over, flanked by your other two other bridesmaids. Thea gives you a once-over, and says, âYou look like a goddess, a terrifyingly pretty one.â You mutter a thank you, and Thea rolls her eyes. âPlease pretend you believe it, just a little bit. Youâre a gorgeous bride-to-be whether you want to be or not.â
Sheâs the only one who knows about your hesitations, and even then youâve only indulged a fraction.
She winks at Andy, linking her arm through yours. âIâm stealing your fiancĂ©.â
He smirks. âAt least you're conceding sheâs mine.â
âYou wish,â Thea replies, and with a toss of her hair of her shoulder, she leads you away.
The entire evening is a kind of lucid dream. Greetings, handshakes, hugs, careful double-cheek kisses dispensed by those in attendance as you circulate the room. In reality there was no rehearsal for tomorrowâs ceremony, tonight it is merely a small gathering staged for ⊠well, from what you gather, for the sake of it. For those closest to you, itâs to keep up the illusion that this is a wedding you want. For Andyâs world, it seems to be a necessary ritual to confirm the ranks of his orderâhis trusted soldiers and a handful of his choice allies.
You donât register that your uncle Rob isnât there until suddenly he is, and by then, the room has already begun the low-pressure phase transition from cocktails to dinner. The movement is organicâsomeone dims the lights, the waiters begin the subtle herding, and you are being gently, almost imperceptibly, shepherded toward the long, low banquet table at the far end of the room.
You are halfway to your seat, with Thea close behind and Andy once again at your side, when the double glass doors at the restaurantâs entrance hiss open and Rob strides in, in a full three-piece suit and with the off-kilter swagger of someone who seems to have truly rushed directly from the airport. He gives you a nod and a warm smile, though even at this distance you note it doesnât quite reach his eyes.
You wave him over, ignoring the subtle tightening of Andyâs hand on your hip. Rob moves quickly across the room to you, and immediately drops a palm on your shoulder, squeezingâwarmth, family, genuine affection. âAm I horrifically late or just fashionably disruptive?â he asks, and before you answer, heâs already deflecting. âYou look tired but good. He treating you right?â
Your uncleâs gaze bores into yours for a half-second, searching for something reassuring. You nod and give him a smile. He softens, but only infinitesimally.
âUncle Rob, this isââ
âAndy Barber,â he supplies, and his gaze flicks to your fiancĂ©, settling there a half-beat too long, cataloging him. You donât know whatâs transpired between them, but you sense something clearly has as thereâs a palpable undercurrent, like two strong magnets meeting, neither yielding.
Uncle Rob gives Andy a stiff nod, but Andy merely meets the moment with an open hand. You sense the silent exchangeâneutral ground, white flag for tonight, or maybe just a kind of mutual agreement not to detonate inside a room full of witnesses.
It feels strange, but itâs only another line on the list of things that arenât normal for this entire affair. The exchange goes unnoticed by nearly everyone else since all in attendance are finding their seats, and Uncle Rob falls in among them and takes his assigned seat by your parents.
The food is dazzling, course after course in small, perfect compositions. You try to taste things, to remember flavors, but you are more conscious of the shifting dynamics around you. You are aware of Andyâs hand ever presentâon your knee, tracing patterns on your arm, once just lightly gripping your wrist as if keeping you tethered to the table, to himself. You wonder if itâs meant to keep you under control, but the gesture genuinely feels more like reassurance than possession tonight.
Flanked by Andy on your left and Thea on your right, both seem engaged in a subtle contest to out-maneuver each other in their attempts to manage you. Sometimes itâs by steering the conversation, sometimes by way of silently passing you the better part of a shared dish, with Thea by gambling how much she can make you laugh given the current company and whether the moment is suitable for choking on your wine. Youâre not sure if you resent this orchestration or if itâs a balm. Maybe both.
At intervals, you glance over at Uncle Rob. The smile he flashes the room is the same as ever, but his eyes seem to rove the room, always taking stock, never fully at rest. He watches Andy most of all, the way a hunter watches a rival predatorâadmiring and calculating, never blinking outright. At one point, your eyes meet and Rob lifts his glass in a toast, not quite a salute, but you feel the force of the message: heâs here, for you, and heâs not leaving until heâs sure youâre safe. Heâs always been more protective of you than anyone else in the family, but this seems more intense, even for him.
Halfway through the meal, Andy excuses himself to confer with two men in dark suits who materialize at the edge of the room, and you find yourself, for the first time all evening, feeling alone at the lack of him. Thea leans in. âYou doing okay?â she whispers, but with a smile on her face so it reads as idle gossip.
âIt feels like someone elseâs wedding,â you mutter back. âIâm just glad youâre here.â
She gives you a look that is both knowing and impossibly gentle. âIf you want to run, just say the word. I have five hundred dollars in cash and a getaway Prius, and thatâs enough to get us at least to New Hampshire before anyone notices.â
You snort-laugh, a little louder than you meant to, and feel lightheaded for an instant. There is some relief in naming it, even as a joke, even though you donât question sheâs serious about the Prius and the cash.
There is a moment, a half-second, a single synaptic twitch, in which you consider the offer or vanishing into an Uber for Logan Airport. But the urge passes. You already jetted away once and came back.
And that coming back was your choice.
It doesnât make sense to escape again now.
The rest of dinner passes in a spiral of rich food and laughter that from most people seems to be unforced. Andy returns, all courteous apologies, and places his warm palm on your back again as if plugging back into a vital organ. He leans in and presses a kiss to your temple, his voice pitched only for you. âIâll need to disappear for a bit after dessert. Business.â He says it lightly, but the tension is a wire behind each syllable. You nod, and at the same moment he gives your leg a squeeze under the table, as if to say: Donât worry, Iâll be back. For you. Always that emphasis.
When the meal ends, the room doesnât thin so much as it condenses. People abandon their seats in favor of looser, more volatile clusterings near the bar or moving out onto the balcony. You sense the shape of the next hoursâa kind of shadow afterparty, drinks and ritual toasts and the swerve toward dysfunction that all close social gatherings eventually take. Andy fields a last volley of congratulations, then gives you a look that says thirty seconds, and moves toward a private door near the kitchen, shadowed by his men. You watch him go, feeling again the negative space at your side.
Itâs at this point that your uncle finds you again.
âYou sure about this?â he murmurs, like youâre trading nuclear secrets instead of making polite familial small talk at your rehearsal dinner. âNot too late to call it off.â
You set your jaw, then, because the answer is yes. Or as close to yes as youâll ever have. If thereâs a question curled up in the base of your spine, itâs quieter nowânot gone, but quelled by Robâs questioning.
You find yourself saying, âIâve made my decision.â
Uncle Robâs expression is unreadable, then softens just enough to let a sliver of affection through. âYour folks are damn proud. Just so you know. You do know that, right?â
You give half a shrug and a nod.
âAnd you know that you can always come to me, for anything.â
âEven ashes and body disposal?â you ask, letting a smirk break through the anxiety. He huffs a laugh, but you can see heâs not disarmed by it, not really.
âEspecially that,â he says. But then, gentler, yet more serious, he says, âYou ever want out, you just say so. Donât matter what anyone else wants, least of all him. You come to me. You hear?â
You nod, only then realizing, âYou know who he is.â
He nods and knocks his glass lightly against yours. âIâm only a phone call away. Fuck the protocols.â
You donât know exactly what his ties to Andyâs underworld are, or how long he and Andy may have known each other, but some unexplained parts of Uncle Robâs past make a whole lot more sense if heâs involved with the mafia. You imagine the more you trace back, the more certain absences and behaviors could ultimately be explained.
You donât allow yourself to ask the next rush questions assembling in your mind. Instead, you clink glasses with Rob again, and when Thea reappears at your side, he makes an excuse and fades back into the crowd. You watch him go, feeling heavier and lighter at once.
âYou want air?â Thea asks, as if the answer could ever be no.
Out on the balcony, you stand at the stone parapet for a while, each of your with a glass in hand, the city shining beneath you. Over the railing, half the Back Bay looks like a jewelry case, all neat squares and gold filigree light.
Thea tips her chin out into the dark. âSo whatâs it like standing up here, knowing youâre about to be a married woman?â
You roll your eyes, but thereâs a nervous tickle in your chest. âAbout the same as it is being an unmarried one, only with more witnesses.â
You expect her to laugh, but instead she fixes you with a sly, assessing stare. âHe scares me a little, you know,â she says, so matter-of-fact it undercuts any drama. âNot for anything heâs said or done. More in the way those security guys all treat him like heâs royalty. Which, I guess, he basically is, right? Mafia royalty?â
You hesitate, glass at your lips. Did you ever say it to her? You donât think you did, because you went to Stockholm on the heels of signing the pre-nup which included the NDA elements⊠You race back through every conversation, every running-on-fumes phone call, and thereâs nothing you can recall that would have spelled it out. But your silence lingers half a second too long.
Theaâs face splits in a grin thatâs bright and wolfish at the edges. âI KNEW it,â she crows, as if youâve just confirmed a conspiracy theory about the moon landing. âOh my god. I knew it. I KNEW IT! Donât even try to deny it.â
You gawk. âWhat areâhow didââ
You try to look innocent, but Thea is already cackling, delighted with herself, her elbows resting on the parapet like a triumphant detective. âPlease,â she says, waving her hand at the party inside, âHeâs waaaaaaaaay too rich, Iâve read way too many mafia romance novels, and you had a security detail when you visited me in Stockholm using his private jet. I was 99% sure, and your hesitation there hesitation gave me the last percent.â
You consider protesting, but technically youâve broken nothing in the contract, and the fact that your best friend knowsâthat anyone knowsâfeels like an instant balm.
You clamp a hand on Theaâs wrist. âPromise me you wonât say a word. Seriously. Not to a soul. I mean it. Not a joke, not even a whisper or a meme reference.â Thereâs an urgency in your voice, and Thea, reading the shift instantly, sobers.
The brightness in her eyes dims by an iota, the seriousness of your tone cutting through the fizz of her delight. She nods, solemnly, and you know that as cavalier as she can sometimes be, she doesnât question the gravity of your insistence. âI wonât,â she vows, putting her hand over yours.
In the shared silence, you feel her searching your face for something she doesnât want to say. You let the air prickle between you, each steadying the other just by being present, until Thea finally asks, âDoes he make you happy?â
You donât answer, not at first. You stare into the bright helix of city lights and let the question slide down your spine and settle into your gut. You want to say yes, or even no, anything definitive, but instead you just tell her, âHe makes me feel alive,â and hope she hears the ambiguity for what it is.
She nods, lips pressed together. âIâm still not sure why youâre doing this, but I will admit that even though I still have questions, one of those questions is not how much that man cares for you.â
Thea fixes you with a look so curious and gentle it makes you want to squirm out of your skin. âIt doesnât look like any love story Iâd picture for you,â she says. âItâs not the type people write poems about or that you see on Pinterest boards. I donât even know that itâs love, but itâs definitely fierce, and runs deep.â
âThea,â your voice is a little choked.
âHe looks at you like youâre the last thing on earth he thinks is worth burning for.â She shrugs and takes another sip of her champagne. âI donât know if thatâs good or bad, but itâs true.â
Youâre grateful, even if you canât manage the words to say so outright. Thea is one of the few souls you trust without hesitation in this world. You study her face in the city-dark, finding closeness there that reminds you, with a pang, of who you were before all this.
âIâm glad youâre here,â you say. You mean it harder than it sounds.
Thea bumps shoulders with you. âIâd literally stand in front of a bullet for you.â She glances toward a distant rooftop bar, probably scouting for snipers. âMetaphorically, but also probably literally.â
You stay there together a little longer, the gentle thrum of summer and the humid glow from the party behind you, breathing easier for the reminder that not all loves are fairy tales, that some are knife-edges, and open secrets, and best friendships.
Shep slides out the glass door with the hush of someone practiced in not disturbing an armed perimeter. He doesnât interrupt, just drifts into the range of your awareness and waits. When you finally realize on a conscious level that heâs there, turning your head and giving him a small, tight-lipped smile, he says, âTime to make our exit, if youâre ready.â
Thereâs a quiet emphasis on the word âour,â and you realize how long you mustâve been out here.
âWhereâs Andy?â You look over his shoulder, expecting to see him somewhere in the glow and tangle of the party, looming, waiting for you expectantly, but heâs not there. Youâre surprised at how keenly you feel his absence. Then you ask Shep, âHeâs not coming back tonight, is he?â
Shep shakes his head, a single, precise movement. âHe wanted me to see you home. Markâs already downstairs.â He hesitates, then softens with a half-smile, reading some of your reluctance to leave. âYou can have ten more minutes if you want them.â
You take the ten.
Itâs enough time for Thea to finish her glass and for you to make the rounds of the party, saying goodnight to your circles of friends and family who were invited to be part of tonight.
Your mother is waiting for you near the coat check, her dark eyes shining, twin tears perilously close to the edge. She pulls you in for a fierce, almost painful hug, her perfume sealing around you like a memory from childhood. âYouâre my treasure,â she says into your ear so hard you forget to breathe for a second. She pulls away, fixing your hair with a trembling hand. âJust tell me heâs as good as he looks. Thatâs all I ask.â Her voice breaks on the last word, and you bob your head, not trusting yourself to say anything more.
Outside, the night air is a slab of heat. Shep guides you to the waiting Range Rover with a balanced mix of deference and Iâm still your bodyguard. Mark already has the curbside door open, and you buckle yourself in, feeling the exhaustion of the night releasing through your limbs. You lean your head back against the headrest and close your eyes. As complicated as your feelings are around Andy, his absence gnaws at you in a way you didnât expect. Especially tonight.
When you walk into the mansion, the silence is as sharp as a slap. You expected it, or something like it, and yet standing in the cavernous hush of the marble entry, clutching your tiny evening bag, youâre overtaken by an urge to slam the door hard enough to wake the dead. You donât, though. You click it shut, toe off your heels and hook them on your fingers, and walk barefoot through the dark to your rooms upstairs.
Andyâs absence is complete and totalâno jacket left half-flung on the banister, no ghost of movement or glass of half-drunk bourbon left somewhere. You resist the urge to immediately check your phone, because you want to feel the ache fully, let it sharpen until it outcompetes the dull, unanswerable questions that have circled every day since you said yes, but especially tonight.
You go to the bathroom and take a long, methodical shower. You take your time as you finish getting ready for bed, drifting through the mechanical rituals of skincare and pajamas and teeth-brushing, but you take no comfort in the delicate, orchid-scented candle you light, or the feel of the silk on your skin.
You check your phone, eventually. Thereâs a text from him, timestamped an hour ago.
ANDY: Iâll be late, donât wait up.
You want to scream. You want to hurl the phone at the wall or at least send an angry string of messages to force some reaction from him, but you donât. You sit at the end of the bed with your phone in your palm, glaring at the glow as if it can blink first. Donât wait up, as if this is remotely normal. You know heâs got business, but heâs never missed an evening with you, never let you go to sleep without him there, touching you, fucking you, just being with you. And now heâs gone the night before your wedding?
You thumb your phone off, toss it face-down onto the bed, and stand for a moment in the hush. You are lit by moonlight coming by moonlight coming in a narrow spill through the vast window, alone with the hum and pop of baseboard heat, a ghost in your own life. You want to be sated by this, to have the sudden expanse and absence feel like relief, but instead it gathers pressure inside your chest. Under the thin silk of your robe, your skin feels hypersensitive, almost electrical, and the wet ends of your hair drip cold water down your spine.
You donât want to admit how badly you want him hereâhow quickly your anger at his text has curdled into a more woeful, sticky missing. It chafes to need him.
You try to zone out streaming something on TV, but nothing cuts through to capture enough of your attention in the absence. Youâre so used to the energy of Andyâs presenceâthe kinetic hum of him near you, whether heâs angry or amused or simply radiating power from the next roomâthat the void he leaves behind is almost audible.
Eventually you are able to at least focus on reading, legs tucked up under you on the settee.
You must have fallen asleep, because the next sensation is not the passage of time but abrupt displacement.
Youâre in mid-dream when you sense the shift, the weightless suck of gravity before the realization: someone is lifting you. You twist, half-awake, to find Andyâs arms locked under your knees and back, carrying you with the unthinking efficiency of someone who has probably hauled bodies at some point. You mutter something into his shirt, a syllable heavy with sleep and protest, and he just keeps moving, your head lolling against his chest, too groggy to fight him off at first.
Then you thrash, not gently. You elbow at his chest, catch his ribs with a knee, and hiss, âPut me down.â You mean it. Youâre not just startledâyouâre still feeling that lingering angerâand Andy, to his credit, sets you down with more care than you expected. You sway and nearly lose your balance, but he catches your wrist, keeping you upright.
âEasy,â he murmurs, voice absurdly gentle, and that somehow pricks worse for all its reasonableness.
You rip your hand away. âDonât do that. Donât justâpick me up.â
He studies you, searching your face with an unreadable patience. âYou were sleeping,â he says.
You steady yourself and glare up at him, refusing to let your fatigue soften the edge of your voice. âYou missed the whole rest of the night, Andy. Where were you?â
Although his expression remains the same, the tension around his eyes tightens. âYou know Iâm not going to tell you that.â
You scoff. âHow do I know that?â
Maybe itâs the sleep, maybe itâs the hunger youâve been stifling, but it lands with a new kind of sharpness, how Andy answers a question only by hollowing out the possibility youâll ever ask again. But you refuse to fold into that silence tonight.
âI want you to tell me,â you say.
Andy closes the gap between you with a slow step, his gaze not leaving your face. âTomorrowâs our wedding,â he says, low and thick in his throat, a softness that isnât practice so much as exhaustion. His hand goes to your shoulder, thumb pressing the knot between bone and tendon, and you flinch at the intimacy of it, at how easily he can make you want to forgive him. You step back, and he lets you, his arms falling to his sides in a slow, theatrical surrender.
âDonât do that,â you say again, voice thin this time. You hate the tremor more than you hated his absence.
He tilts his head, studying you in the low light. âYouâre angry.â
He smiles, weary but pleased. âYouâre angry because you missed me.â He says it not as an accusation, but a simple, delighted observation, like heâs just solved a riddle in your presence. âYou care.â
You make a sound, a cross between a snort and a huff, and turn your head before he can get a better look at your face. âIâm angry because youâve insisted on all of thisâme, the wedding, pulling me into your lifeâand then you desert me the night before weâre supposed to get married? Leave me during the rehearsal dinner? And all I get is a âdonât wait upâ text?â
You hate that your voice rises, hate the heat behind your eyes. Andy comes closer, and you want to slap him and also want him to hold you. You flex your jaw, force your gaze to stay away.
He listens. He lets you say it all, and when itâs out of your mouth, tumbling and ugly, he says, âI know. But there are things I canât and wonât tell you. I canât ever expose you to certain things. I wonât allow them near you.â His voice is all iron and velvet. âIâm protecting you, even if it doesnât look or feel like it.â
He lets the pause hang, then takes a slight step closerâclose enough that you nearly shiver at the radius of his heat.
There are things I wonât shield you from, either. You told me to never lie, so I wonât pretend Iâm made another way. But I will always come back.â He says it softly, neither a threat nor a comfort.
After a lengthy moment of silence, you tell him, âI donât want another night like this. I donât want to ever be stranded in the dark.â
He considers it. Not with a smirk or a challenge, but real intent, a resolution hardening. âIâll do my best.â
âThatâs not good enough.â
âIâm not good enough,â he says, and it is the flattest, most relentless admission. âBut I am what youâre marrying.â
You should laugh. You almost do, at the incredulity, the audacity, the unfairness of his answer, of this entire situation, but then he reaches out, just a single knuckle under your chin, and youâre suddenly taking in a shaky breath.
You hold his eyes for a full count, your body picking up the stutter of your pulse, anger and want running convergent through your system. You want to turn away, to break the connection, but you canât.
âThen show me. Make it better,â you say, and your voice is a command, not a plea.
You let him guide your face up. His thumb travels a gentle path down your jaw. He leans in, pressing his words, and his mouth, against your skin. âYou want more than this? I will never give you less.â The last of it is a murmur, not a vow, but it lives in the hollow between you, nudging the edge of promise.
He kisses you behind the ear, slow and intentional, and your whole body contracts around the point of contact. You hate how even this controlled display of contrition draws you in. Were you less tired, were it not the night before your wedding, you may have pushed him away. But he knows exactly how to pull on the string that unravels you, and you canât leave it at that, so you cup his face and press your mouth against his, not sweet or apologetic but with a frustrated need to bite, to mark. He lets you, opens willingly, tongue flicking yours, and the pressure he uses to guide you toward the bed is insistent. You pull him with you, backwards, the two of you bumping knees, bumping hips, his hands already finding the tie at your robe and making short work of it.
He pulls it from your shoulders, lets it float to the carpet with exaggerated gentleness thatâs belied by the urgency of his mouth and hands. You take brief satisfaction in yanking at his shirt buttons, two of them tumbling somewhere onto the bedding, but Andy just shrugs out of the rest and lets it fall to the floor.
He is, as youâve come to expect, taller and heavier than you in the moments that matter. He pins you beneath him, stretching your arms above your head, taking his time as if you both arenât aching with a violent need. He kisses you with a patience that does not match the tension in his body, hands working down your ribs, touching and teasing the places heâs learned draw your responses.
You let him press you down, let him grind against you, clothed below the waist but with a bare chest and a punishing grip as he presses one of your thighs up and open for him. Your silk nightgown is tangled above your hips, ruined for decency, and the sheets under you bunch as you wrap your leg around him.
You are not even sure when you stop resistingâthe anger, the lonelinessâmaybe when he murmurs, âIâm here,â into the shell of your ear, or maybe itâs before that, at the familiar drag of his teeth across your shoulder. You want to snarl at him, but you can only gasp and tear one of your hands away so you can grab for his waistband, the zipper, too impatient for finesse.
The button resists for half a second before you hear the pop. Andyâs hips cant, the gesture half involuntary. He is, unlike you, a master at not showing his hungerâunless he wants you to see it, and tonight he must, because the restraint rubs your skin raw in a way thatâs almost a dare. You dig your heel into the mattress, lift your pelvis to grind into the urgency thatâs thickening between your bodies. He lets you, but barely; his hand catches your thigh, squeezes, and you wonder if there will be marks tomorrow. You hope so.
He pulls back, and you make a desperate, wordless noiseâappalled at the empty space, the abrupt loss of him. Andy grins, a glint of teeth in the dark, and then heâs dropping to his knees at the edge of the bed, eyes black and bottomless. âPatience,â he says, voice low and hoarse. âI want you naked for me. Completely.â
Youâre tempted to resist him, to force him to earn the reveal, but you want the heat and the gaze andâmore than anythingâthe feeling of him unraveling for you. So you tug the nightgown up and off, shimmying as best you can.
Andy reaches out to assist, dragging your panties off in a single, practiced movement, leaving you splayed open and vulnerable in the spill of moonlight, the air cold and sharp against your skin.
He stands, shucking his pants and boxers with ease. His cock is already hard, and he takes himself in hand, stroking slow, almost lazy, but you can see the tension in his jaw, the way his forearm tightens, every line of his body at the edge of restraint. He stands there for a moment, head tipped, just watching you with that focus, just this side of feral. It should alarm you. It should, maybe, make you recoil, the ferocity in him, so unlike the men youâve known before. Itâs a look that should have scared you from the beginningâbut no one has wanted you the way he wants you, and youâve grown addicted to how Andyâs hunger works.
You want to wipe that look of composure from his face, and you know exactly how to do it. You arch your back, knees falling apart, and bring your fingers to your cuntâslow, deliberate. Andyâs mouth parts the barest inch, but he doesnât move to stop you. You circle your clit with two fingers, the slide easy and slick, and moan just loud enough that you know heâll hear it for days. He watches, lips parted, and the tension in his neck sings.
âIs this what you want?â you ask.
You donât wait for an answer. You drag a slick, purposeful circle with your fingertip, then roll your hips up again, forcing his attention onto the precise spot you want it. Your other hand moves to your breast, pinching a nipple until the ache flashes through your belly. You moan again, longer, keeping your eyes pinned to his as though you can draw out his release through sheer insistence.
Andy comes closer, his hand sliding up your calf, kneading the inside of your knee with enough pressure to make you gasp and lose the rhythm of your own touch. He takes your wrist in his, slows your movements, and brings your fingers to his mouth. He licks them, savoring your taste, then sucks the tips into the heat of him, eyes trained on yours the whole time. âYou want to make me lose control?â he murmurs. âYouâre close, sweetheart.â
You shudder, half from his voice and half from the pleasure needling up your legs. âThen what are you waiting for?â
âFlip over,â he says, and you obey. Not because you care to perform for him, but because this is the only language you speak fluently with each other.
You turn, face pillowed in moonlight, the curve of your ass arched and on display. The sheets are cool under your cheek. Andyâs hands find your hips, not rough but absolute, his palms broad and braced. He kneads you for a long moment, a brief, silent exhibition of ownership, before running his thumb down the seam of you, spreading you open with the same clinical certainty he uses to carve out secrets.
He fucks you in one smooth, relentless motion, every inch filling you until your body feels engineered for the shape of him. You groan from the fullness, and he groans being sheathed inside your cunt. He leans forward, curling over you, and presses a kiss into your neck.
He holds you there, pressed hard against the mattress, your knees bracing apart as his cock drives into you with a steadiness thatâs almost brutal but never crosses over into pain. You have only ever known men in this position to get greedy, to lose their pacing almost immediately, but Andyâs rhythm is a ruthless metronome, each thrust a little deeper, a little harder, calibrated to keep you right at the edge.
His weight is a gravity you loathe and crave; you let him press you into the bed and hold you there. Youâre still angry, still trembling, but everything is blurred with your arousal, your hunger, the lines so tangled you can barely see the difference.
You try to deny him your pleasure out of spite, but itâs a losing propositionâAndy finds the angle he wants, rocks into you so that you choke on a half-sob, and holds there until you scratch at the sheets, half-crazed. The sound you make is ugly and desperate, and the only thing worse is how much you want him to hear it, to be stoked by it, to see what he does to you. He seems to sense this, his voice a gravel scrape against your shoulder blade. âTake it, sweetheart. Let me hear how much you want it.â
His thumb finds your clit, presses in tight, and for a few strokes you somehow resist, but then your hips buck and your vision splotches out, and you do let him hear how much you want him. Itâs exquisite. He continues to fuck into you, working your clit, every nerve burning, every muscle tightening in a white, brutal wave. He fucks you through it, groaning, not letting up until a second, sharper quake rips through your body. Then and only then does Andy let himself goâslamming into you, his hand a vise around your hip as he spends himself, jaw pressed to your spine. The shudder of him fully inside you is shocking, almost convulsive, and he bucks in you until the last aftershocks fade and the only sound in the room is two desperate people fighting for air.
He doesnât pull out right away. He just stays there, draped over your body, letting you catch your breath, his weight an absolute. When he does finally move, heâs slow and careful, laying beside you and rolling you into his arms, not a word spoken. Youâre still too fogged by want and exhaustion to move, content to let him hold you close, the press of his cheek against your hair. Neither of you speak for a very long time.
But there are thoughts you still need him to hear.
You find your voice in the hush, not loud or demanding but plain, with the rough edge of sleep and aftershock. âI donât want more nights like this,â you say, and you can feel the way Andyâs chest stills under your hand. âI didnât want to be coerced into your bed, I didnât want to be forced into an engagement, I didnât want to get married like this. You exploited the attraction, youâve made me weak for you, but please,â your voice breaks, âplease donât make me the wife who has to wait up alone for you.â
Andy doesnât speak, not at first, and the silence unsettles you, but you make yourself hold itâmake yourself show that it matters. You refuse to shrink or swallow the need. If heâs going to be the kind of man who pulls you into his orbit, heâs damn well going to know he canât just leave you in the dark. Not without a fight. Heâs made slow but small shifts in some areas youâve pressed with him. Maybe you can have resonance here, too.
He smooths a hand from your shoulder, down your back, each pass gentler than the last. Heâs thinking, you know. Not just brushing off what you said, but actually holding it up to the light, inspecting the seams. When he finally speaks, his voice is low and soft, but firm.
âI meant it when I said Iâd do my best,â he says. âI donât want you to be herâthe wife who waits at the window. But I also canât give up what I am.â His hand lingers at your waist, a heavy presence.
You sigh, too thoroughly boneless to summon the right words, so you simply roll over, and itâs too natural how your body melds against him as he curls his arm around you and pulls your back flush against his chest. All you can do now is hope your sentiments will start to seep into him through osmosis.
You let the silence ride a little longer, curled together as if this is some and listen to the slowing cadence of his breath, to the metallic taste of words you didnât say, and you wonder if this is what love might beâthe willingness to be furious and still stay.
And you wonder if this is loveânot because itâs gentle or clean or what you imagined, but because it has weight, because it has teeth, because it sits in your chest like a stone you keep reaching for. Because you are angry and ruined and held, and somehow all three of those things are the same thing. Because no one has seen you the way he does. Because no one has made you feel so wanted, even if itâs infused with possession. But even through the moments you know there are things he isnât telling you, you know heâs never lied to you. Even when he says things you donât want to hear, he speaks to you openly. Even when his actions are incendiary and disagreeable, theyâre still somehow for you now.
He says your name. Itâs a quiet thing, a soft push through the dark, but it lands with a rattle in your chest.
âI want to tell you something,â Andy says. âNot because you asked, but because if youâre going to be my wife, you will need to know.â
You swallow, knowing instinctively that to interrupt is to lose the tiny, trembling momentum inside him. He never initiates these confessions. Heâs all action, never exposition. You hold your body still, afraid any breath will snap the thread.
âThey brought me in tonight to consult on a sit-down. Not a war, but something close. One of the families in JerseyâLupoâs peopleâmade a move on Levinsonâs propertiesâof one of our alliesâalong the North River. Not a huge play, but enough to draw blood. No one got shot. But next time, someone will.â Andyâs hand flexes at your hip, tightening like a vise. âIf that happens, everything changes. This life, the way we can have it, ends. The only thing that keeps usâkeeps youâsafe, is the order.â He breathes out, a single tight exhale. âIf the peace goes, I canât guarantee anything. Not for you, not for me. And thatâs not something Iâm willing to risk.â
You lie there, staring at the ceiling, sheets cooling under your legs, and you realize what heâs giving you is not reassurance, but the truth of his world, knife-sharp and blood-warm. It should terrify you. It does, to a degree, but youâve had a security detail, you know there are six loaded guns hidden here in the master suite. There is nothing normal about any of this, but the fact of Andyâs world is that it remains obsessively ordered only so long as no one has reason to start a war.
âWhen I have to go, I have to go, and Iâll never apologize for that,â he adds when you donât say anything more.
Thea joked about reading mafia romance novels, but this is not a genre, this is your life now. When you let the reality land, it isnât just gravity, but something like inheritance: no matter what you wanted or didnât, youâre marrying into all of this.
And yet, as you lie there, taken apart and held tightly yet again, you find a calm in yourself you didnât realize you could access. Maybe itâs the spill of adrenaline draining away, or the simple fact that Andyâyour future husband, in a matter of hoursâhas finally handed you the truest thing heâs ever said. Everything is always at risk.
But if the world really is this dangerous, youâve no doubt youâre held by the most powerful man youâve ever met, and since he stopped at nothing to secure you, he will stop at nothing to keep you secure.
Uncle Rob! Thea! Andy! A Levinson name drop?!
There are so many things here that I've been plotting for ages, and so I think it's half the reason it took me so long to finish this chapter. Back in May I had written what I thought was about 3k to make up the first half of the chapter, but something about it just wasn't working, so I pulled it apart, kept a few of the scraps, and went back to the drawin board. I'm pleased where it finally ended up, and even though I know parts of this story are frustrating (coughSOMEOFANDY'SBEHAVIORcough), I do hope you all like the chapter.
And I know this is at the verrrrrry tail end of Monday for the first of what I'm hoping will be I'm Your Man Monday, but we made it! So we'll see if I can make this happen and get you another update next week!
â Main Masterlist | Aspen's Ask Box | Field Guide to the Forest
I do not do tag lists, but FOLLOW @buckets-and-stories and TURN ON NOTIFICATIONS to be updated any time I publish a new work!









