Are we overreacting?
This is the culmination of many a conversation between me and the husband after attending the same church for the past five years and serving consistently for the past four.
I remember feeling called to serve in 2022 around Easter? I had taken a long hiatus from serving after moving here and leaving my childhood home and church. Many events played into that, and attending this church has really helped heal a lot of those harmful perspectives and habits that I picked up from my previous church.
At the same time, I have had lots of time to reflect on my experience at my home church and the lovely things I learned while attending. I was explicitly taught how to do devotions (they don't call it devotions here), how to set up a Bible reading schedule and how to talk about the Bible and lead Bible studies. I was taught the importance of memorizing scripture and reflecting on how it applies to your own life. And lots of these habits have fed into my current practices today. I (try to) do devotions in the morning while eating breakfast, reading the Bible, journaling, and writing down my prayers (a habit I picked up shortly after moving). My husband has also picked up Bible reading in the morning and sometimes we read together in silence across the dining room table. We often discuss afterwards or after work.
While my childhood experience was more... academic? That's not the right word, but more... explicitly encouraging (and teaching) of Bible reading practices and Sunday sermon practices (this isn't a big deal, but I don't see anybody taking notes at my church right now, and that was something I was encouraged to do back home). And I don't mean to compare, as no church is perfect, and each church has different focuses and methods, but I think I miss the more in-depth, academic, meticulous study of the Bible.
We're thinking of shifting gears to do that for our community group, but I am also... feeling stuck. I don't know if I want to lead a community group, but that's also tied to our group members and attendance issues and whether or not they actually care about showing up. The husband has brought this up as well, and he would like to lead community group again next year, but I know that it would add more to his already very full plate. I worry that it will be too much for him.
Anyways, this conversation has led us into discussions about whether the church focuses on the Bible enough on Sundays, if community groups (as a concept at our church) are established with Biblical intentions and if that EVEN MATTERS??? The husband brought up good points, that community group is a spiritual, God-led group of people "walking through life together" (as the saying goes), and that it HAS to be more than just a social group. At the same time, there is a social aspect to it, so there needs to be a mix, but what is the right mix? What's the right thing to do?
And then this feeds into other parts of ministry and church operations that we really don't know how to feel about. Like, how soon should someone be allowed to serve in church after they've started attending? Can non-Christians serve in church? Should non-Christians be encouraged to serve? Should membership be more strongly encouraged than it currently is (husband and I are not members and I like it that way, but that doesn't make it right)? Should kids church has a focus of being fun? What are the behavioural expectations around kids church? What are the expectations of those who serve in the church and how highly are they held to that standard? Should a person's faith be taken into consideration when they volunteer to serve? We have so many questions! And it preoccupies my mind when I'm there. Is this right? Is this wrong? Does it matter?
All things considered, this church has been really good to me, to us, and I really appreciate all that it has done and that I've been able to contribute to. But at the same time, what are we to do, as people who attend and are finding that we have these questions? Do we do nothing? Do we do something? Do we leave? There's just a lot of question marks and not a lot of clear answers.














