GHOSTFACE ââ paige bueckers x reader
â â summary: after a kill, paige decides she needs to fuck you senseless.
â â warnings: sexual content (absolute pure filth, dom!paige, kinda bratty!reader, choking, blood kink, knifeplay, oral, fingering), oh yeah also murder
â â links: my masterlist
â â authorâs note: my halloween treat for you đŹđ on a serious note tho this is actually the freakiest nastiest shit iâve ever written idk wtf i was on
THE CAR idles in the dark, the soft hum of the engine barely cutting through the late-night quiet of Storrs. You sit in the driverâs seat, the burner phone in your lap, your fingers drumming against the wheel as you steal a glance at the clock. Itâs past midnight, the world outside wrapped in a blanket of stillness, but your heart is anything but calm. The recent killings on campus have the entire student body on edge, but no one would ever guess that the two of youâthe schoolâs sweetheart basketball star and her quiet, unsuspecting girlfriendâare the ones behind it all.
Tonight, though, has a different kind of energy. Itâs not just about the kill. Itâs about what came before. Paige is sitting next to you in the passenger seat, her Ghostface costume on, the long black cloak pooling around her legs. Her game-day braids are still tied back into a ponytail, her skin still glowing with the leftover adrenaline from the UConn game earlier tonight. Sheâd killed it on the courtâled the team to another win, the crowd chanting her name as she drained shot after shot.
Now, sheâs about to kill in a very different way.
You feel a surge of excitement just thinking about itâabout how she can seamlessly transition from the basketball star everyone worships to this⊠to your partner in something darker, something the two of you have created and mastered together. Youâve always been the one with the words, the voice on the phone that lures them in, taunting them, teasing them, until Paige steps in and finishes the job. Sheâs the executioner, but you set the stage.
âStill riding that high, huh?â you tease, your voice soft but playful as you glance over at her. You can see it in the way her leg bounces slightly, the leftover buzz of the game still coursing through her.
Paige turns to you, a smirk playing on her lips. âCanât help it. We crushed âem tonight.â She adjusts the mask in her lap, her eyes flickering with excitement thatâs just as much about whatâs to come as it is about the win sheâs still basking in. âYou saw that last block, right? Perfect.â
You chuckle, nodding. âYeah, it was good.â
She grins, her confidence practically radiating off her. Itâs the same look she wears after every gameâthis electric mix of pride and hunger for more. But tonight, thereâs a sharper edge to it, a different kind of hunger simmering beneath the surface. One that only you know about.
Paige leans over suddenly, her hand grabbing your jaw, pulling you into her, her lips crashing against yours in a kiss thatâs rough, heated. You kiss her back, matching her intensity, the burner phone nearly slipping from your lap as your hand grips the back of her neck. The adrenaline from the night, from her win, from the secret you both shareâit all mixes into a heady, intoxicating rush.
She pulls back just enough to whisper against your lips, her voice low and teasing. âWish me luck, baby.â
Her smirk is wicked as she slips the Ghostface mask over her head, the familiar face now staring back at you. Itâs eerie, unnervingâeverything itâs supposed to beâbut you know whoâs behind it. Paige.
The sound of the car door opening is the only thing that breaks the silence as Paige steps out, her black cloak trailing behind her as she disappears into the night.
You wait a few moments, scrolling through your phone before deciding to get out. The door slams shut behind you with a sharp, metallic thud that echoes through the quiet night. The cold Connecticut wind bites at your face as you step away from the car, pulling your jacket tighter around yourself. Itâs freezing tonight, the kind of chill that seeps into your bones and lingers, but the thrill, the adrenaline of whatâs about to happen, keeps you warm enough.
You shove your hands into your pockets, walking slowly toward the edge of the building. The apartment complex looms ahead, its brick exterior cold and silent, with only a few lights flickering from various windows. Your breath fogs up in the night air as you circle around, your shoes scraping against the asphalt, the distant sounds of traffic muffled by the wind.
You reach the back of the building, your body finding refuge against the brick wall. The rough texture scratches through your jacket as you lean against it, glancing around to make sure no oneâs nearby. Youâre careful, always careful. This isnât your first time doing this, after all.
Paige is inside, probably already climbing the stairs, making her way to the bartenderâs apartment. You can imagine her slipping through the shadows, as quiet and deadly as she is on the court, that same fierce determination in her eyes.
You pull a cigarette from your pocket, slipping it between your lips before lighting it, the flame briefly illuminating your face before you inhale deeply. The smoke curls in the cold air, the familiar burn in your lungs settling you, grounding you. This part of the night is always the sameâthe waiting. But itâs also the part youâve come to appreciate. The anticipation, the patience it takes. You wait for Paigeâs text, the one thatâll let you know sheâs in position, ready for you to make the call.
The call thatâll lure tonightâs target straight into her arms.
The bartender. You think back to that night, just a few days ago, when you and Paige were out with her team. It was supposed to be a fun night, just you, Paige, and the rest of the girls, celebrating another win. Paige had been in her usual formâconfident, charismatic, drawing everyoneâs attention like she always does. But then she came into the picture. The fucking bartender.
The girl had been pouring drinks all night, flirting shamelessly with Paige, making little comments, smiling at her in a way that made your blood boil. Paige had stayed cool, giving her those polite but dismissive smiles, her arm draped around your waist as if to make it clear. But the bartender either didnât care or didnât notice, and it had pissed you off. You could tell Paige had noticed too, the way she tightened her grip on you, the way her eyes flicked to yours whenever the girl leaned in too close.
And, later that night, after a few drinks, the two of you had ended up in the bathroom, making out against the sink. Paige had been rougher than usual, her hands gripping your hips, her lips almost bruising yours, and in the heat of it, sheâd pulled back, breathless, and whispered, âYou wanna kill her?â
You hadnât hesitated. Of course you wanted to kill her.
So, tonight, here you are. The plan is simpleâPaige gets in, finds her, and you make the call. Then, Paige does what she does best. Only tonight, thereâs something different. Paige had promised that youâd get the final stab. The last touch, the one that seals the deal, making it yours too.
You take another drag from the cigarette, exhaling slowly, your eyes scanning the street. Everything is still, nothing but the occasional flicker of movement behind closed windows. The night is quiet, like itâs holding its breath, waiting for whatâs about to unfold.
Your phone buzzes in your pocket, and you feel a thrill shoot up your spine. You pull it out and glance at the screen.
Your heart skips a beat, the cigarette forgotten as you flick it away, crushing it under your heel. Showtime. You slide the phone back into your hand, dialing the bartenderâs number. It rings once, twice, before the click of the line picking up fills your ear. For a moment, all you can hear is the faint sound of background noiseâsome low music, maybe the TVâand then her voice comes through, light and unexpectedly cheery for how late it is.
âHello?â The bartenderâs tone is casual, friendly, like sheâs used to people calling her at odd hours. Itâs clear sheâs not expecting anything out of the ordinary.
You suppress a grin, knowing exactly where this is headed. You always start the same wayâlight, teasing, pretending to be someone she might actually want to talk to. And as always, you speak through the voice changer, your voice distorted into something deeper, something unrecognizable.
âHey,â you say, the voice changer making you sound almost playful. âYou still up?â
Thereâs a pause on the other end, like sheâs trying to place your voice. âUh, yeah, I guess. Whoâs this?â
You lean back against the wall, settling into your role. âJust someone who noticed you the other night. Thought Iâd give you a call. You just started bartending, right? At Tedâs?â
Another pause, and you can almost hear the gears turning in her head. âOh,â she says after a moment, her tone picking up with a hint of amusement. âYeah, thatâs me. Howâd you get my number?â
You chuckle, low and smooth, keeping your tone flirtatious. âGot my ways.â
She laughs softly, clearly entertained. âWell, I guess youâre resourceful, huh? Whatâs your name?â
You sidestep the question, keeping her engaged, knowing that sheâll follow along if you give her just enough. âWhatâs yours?â you ask instead, turning it around on her.
She laughs again, a little softer this time, and you can picture her sitting up, maybe twirling her hair or playing with her phone. âKelsey,â she offers.
âKelsey,â you repeat, letting her name roll off your tongue, the voice changer making it sound almost sinister, but not enough for her to noticeâyet. âPretty name. Youâre pretty good at pouring drinks too.â
She snorts. âWell, thanks. I do my best. You one of my regulars or something?â
You let the silence hang for a beat, then reply, âYou could say that. I saw you with your hands all over that blonde girl the other night. What was her name? Paige?â
Thereâs a shift in her tone now, a slight hesitation. âOh⊠yeah, I remember her,â she says, her voice a bit more careful, like sheâs suddenly unsure of where this conversation is going. âYou friends with her or something?â
You can feel her starting to get a little uneasy, and it makes you smile, the thrill of it building in your chest. You lean forward slightly, taking a deep breath before speaking again.
âSomething like that,â you say, your voice low now, more serious. âYou were really bold, flirting with her like that, Kelsey. I gotta say, I donât think she appreciated it. And I definitely didnât.â
Thereâs a beat of silence. A longer one this time. And when she speaks again, thereâs a trace of nervous laughter in her voice. âOkay, uh⊠who the hell is this?â
You can hear her trying to play it off, but thereâs a flicker of panic underneath. Sheâs starting to realize this isnât a joke. This isnât some casual late-night flirtation.
âYou donât remember me?â you ask, sounding almost innocent. âI was there that whole night.â
Her breath catches, and then she laughs again, this time more forced, trying to regain control. âAlright, this is getting weird,â she says. âIâm gonna hang up nowââ
âDonât.â Your voice cuts through sharply, commanding, and you hear the soft gasp she makes on the other end. âDonât you fucking dare hang up.â
For a moment, thereâs nothing but the sound of her breathing, shaky now, uneven. You can almost see her, sitting in her apartment, probably looking around, trying to figure out if this is a prank, if someoneâs watching her. You know the thoughts running through her head. Youâve seen it all before.
âLook, I donât know who you are or what you want, butââ
âI want you to stay on the phone,â you interrupt, your voice laced with cold amusement. âYouâve been real fun to talk to so far, Kelsey. Donât ruin it now.â
You hear her exhale sharply, the panic setting in for real now. âThis isnât funny, okay? Justâjust leave me alone, or Iâm calling the cops.â
âGo ahead,â you say casually, starting to grin. âCall them. Tell them someoneâs watching you.â
Her breath hitches again, and you can hear the unmistakable tremor in her voice. âWatching me? What the fuck are you talking about?â
Your smile widens. âSweetheart,â you say softly, almost kindly, âI can see you.â
A small, broken gasp escapes her, and you hear her scramble, probably getting off the couch, rushing to lock her door or check her windows. The desperation in her voice is thick now. âWhere are you? Where the fuck are you?â
You pause for just a second, letting the tension build, before finally answering, âRight behind you.â
Thereâs a crash on the other end of the line, followed immediately by a scream thatâs cut short. You hear the sound of a body hitting the floor, the unmistakable sound of the phone dropping, and thenâ
âPlease, noânoââ Kelseyâs voice is choked, panicked, and you can hear her gasping for air, her words coming out in sobs now. You can picture it perfectlyâPaige towering over her, the blade glinting in the dim light of the apartment. The sound of a struggle follows, Kelseyâs voice growing more desperate, more terrified. âPlease! Iââ
Itâs a wet, sickening sound, the blade sinking into flesh. Kelseyâs scream is sharp, but it quickly turns into a gargle as blood fills her throat. You hear her choking, trying to speak, to beg. Thereâs more stabbing, more squelching, before it stops, and all you can hear are weak, broken sobs.
For a few more seconds, thereâs nothing but shuffling, the sound of Paige moving around, and thenâquiet.
You wait, holding your breath, the anticipation still thrumming through you, until finally, you hear her voice. Paigeâs voice, smooth, confident, and a little out of breath.
âBaby,â she says, and you can practically hear her smile through the phone, âyou can come on up here now. Sheâs ready for you.â
You hang up before beginning to walk, keeping your pace quick as you stride into the apartment building. Youâre trying to be fastâyou donât want her to fucking bleed out and die before you can finish her off.
The elevator ride up to her floor feels agonizingly slow, your foot tapping impatiently against the metal floor. When you finally reach her door, you stop for a second, taking a breath, checking the number to make sure itâs the right one. Your fist raises, knocking onceâsharp and deliberate.
The door swings open almost immediately, and there she isâPaige, standing in the doorway, her figure backlit by the dim apartment lights. Sheâs still wearing the Ghostface costume, though the mask dangles casually from her hand now. Her braids, still in that game-day ponytail, are a little mussed, strands sticking out here and there, but it only adds to the chaotic allure of her right now. Thereâs blood splattered across her face, stark against her skin, and across her clothes too. She hasnât even bothered to clean it up yet, and God, you canât help but think she looks so fucking hot.
Her eyes are gleaming, and thereâs that familiar smirk on her lips, a wild energy simmering underneath her calm exterior. She steps aside, motioning you inside with an almost nonchalant flick of her hand, like sheâs inviting you into some casual dinner party, not a murder scene.
âCome on in,â Paige murmurs, her voice low, still tinged with excitement.
You step inside, your shoes making soft thuds against the hardwood floor. As you move past her, you catch the faintest whiff of bloodâcoppery, metallicâand it sends a rush through you, like a shot of adrenaline straight to your veins. Paige closes the door behind you, and you take in the scene in front of you.
Kelsey is on the floor, twitching in agony, her body twisted at an unnatural angle. Sheâs choking on her own blood, gasping and gargling as it pools in her mouth, her eyes wide with terror and pain. Itâs clear sheâs still alive, but just barely. Paige has done her job, but sheâs left enough for you to finish.
Paige steps up behind you, her breath warm against your neck as she leans in close, her lips brushing against your ear. âSheâs all yours,â she whispers, pressing the bloody knife into your hand. The blade is still warm, slick with Kelseyâs blood, and the weight of it in your hand sends a thrill through you.
You take the knife, your fingers tightening around the hilt as you approach Kelseyâs broken, twitching form. Her eyes, glazed over with fear and pain, manage to lock onto yours as you kneel beside her. The sound of her labored breathing is all you can hear, the wet gurgle of blood in her throat. You smile down at her, a sweet, almost tender expression crossing your face.
âHi, Kelsey,â you say softly, your voice gentle, as if youâre greeting an old friend.
You think you hear her try to form the word please, but itâs lost in the thick, choking blood that fills her throat. Her body jerks slightly, like sheâs trying to move, trying to plead, but itâs useless now.
You bring the knife to her face, the tip of the blade tracing lightly along her cheek, not even hard enough to cut. Itâs almost affectionate, the way you drag the metal across her skin. But then, with a quick, practiced motion, you bring the knife down to her throat, slitting it cleanly, efficiently. Thereâs a brief spray of bloodâsplashing up onto your faceâas her body convulses once, twice, and then slumps against the floor, lifeless.
âFucking bitch,â you mutter under your breath, watching the last bit of life drain from her body. You stay there for a moment, just staring at her, taking in the sceneâthe blood, the broken, twisted limbs, the silence that settles over the room now that sheâs dead.
Youâre still staring when you feel Paige behind you again, pulling you up to stand. Her hands slide around your waist, her front pressing against your back. One of her big hands splays across your stomach, holding you close, while her other finds your wrist, gently taking the knife from your hold.
âThat was so hot, baby,â she murmurs, her voice dripping with admiration and lust, her breath right against your ear.
You lean back into her touch, your body relaxing against hers as she starts to pepper soft kisses along your neck, her lips trailing up your jawline. The tension in the room shifts from the violence of the kill to something more intimate, more charged. You close your eyes, letting the sensation of her mouth on your skin, her hands on your body, wash over you.
Paigeâs teeth graze against a particularly sensitive spot on your neck before she begins to suck, hard enough to leave a mark. You gasp softly, the sensation heightened as her hands slowly slide up your arms, fingers brushing the fabric of your zip-up hoodie. In one smooth motion, she tugs it down, letting it fall to the floor, leaving you in nothing but your red, lacy tank top. Ironically, the color is a perfect match for the blood spattered across the room, across both of you.
Her hands move to your shoulders first, but then one of them drifts lower, grabbing at your chest, squeezing your tit through the thin lace, pulling your back tighter against her front. You feel caged in her hold, a gasp escaping your lips as her grip grows firmer. But the real shock comes when you feel the teasing touch of the knife, the cold metal ghosting along the skin of your arm. Paige trails it down, tracing the sliver of bare skin just below where your tank top ends and just above where your sweatpants begin.
And then, with deliberate precision, Paige slashes the knife upward, cutting clean through the middle of your tank top. The fabric falls open, revealing your skin to the cool air and the warmth of her breath on your neck. You whine softly, âP, that was expensive.â
Paige just chuckles darkly, her fingers tightening around your breast, thumb brushing over your ïżŒnow pert nipple, as she whispers, âIâll buy you another one.â With that, she pulls the torn fabric off you, letting it drop to the ground, leaving you completely topless. You werenât wearing a bra beneath the tank, and the sudden exposure makes you shiver, but Paigeâs body pressed against yours keeps you warm.
In one swift motion, sheâs spinning you around, pressing her lips against yours, kissing you with a rough intensity. You can taste the blood on her lips, probably a mixture of the blood spatters on both of your faces. Her hand grips the side of your neck, holding you firmly in place, while her other arm wraps around your waist, pulling you impossibly closer. Her palm presses into your lower back, and the cold handle of the knife digs into your skin, a reminder of everything youâve just done together.
Your hands move instinctively to her ponytail, fingers threading through her braids before you give a slight tug. The moan that escapes from your lips is muffled by her kiss, but itâs enough to make Paige groan against your mouth, the sound vibrating through you. You pulling her hair seems to set something off in her, fueling that dark intensity behind her eyes. She bites at your bottom lip, tugging lightly as she starts to push you back, guiding you towards the couch.
When the back of your legs hit the edge, you lose your balance and fall back onto the cushions, and Paige doesnât waste a second. Sheâs immediately on top of you, her knee slipping between your legs, nudging against your clothed core with a teasing pressure. Her hand is already at your chest, kneading your breast while her other hand wraps around your throat, squeezing just enough to make you winceâbut in the way you like. You can feel the heat building inside you as her fingers press into the sides of your neck, right where your pulse pounds beneath your skin.
Paigeâs mouth meets yours again, more demanding this time, her tongue pushing past your lips, exploring your mouth with a hunger that matches your own. The pressure of her thumb on your pulse point makes your head swim, the sensation mixing pleasure with just the right hint of pain. You moan again, this time louder, your hips instinctively shifting under her as you crave more of that pressure between your legs.
She pulls away for a moment, just enough to trail her tongue along the edge of your lips, teasing and slow. Her tongue slides down to your chin, licking away the last remnants of the bartenderâs blood from earlier, and it sends a shiver down your spine. The metallic tang still lingers as she leans back in to kiss you again, the taste of blood filling both of your mouths, and it only makes you want more.
And then you begin to feel something cold and sharp press against your skin. It takes you a second to realize what it isâsheâs taken the knife again, and now the cold, wet metal is sliding over the valley between your breasts. The feeling sends a shiver through your body, and you gasp into her mouth as she presses the blade against your skin, wiping the blood from earlier onto you.
She pulls back slightly, her darkened eyes focused on the trail of blood sheâs smearing onto your chest. The sight alone makes your breath catch. Paigeâs lips curve into a smirk as she watches your reaction, clearly enjoying the way your body tenses beneath her. She doesnât say anything at first, just lets her mouth move downward, trailing kisses along your collarbones, lingering there as her hot breath mingles with the coolness of the blood.
âGod, you look so fucking good like this,â Paige murmurs against your skin, her voice low and gravelly. Her lips are teasing, pressing soft, feather-light kisses that make your heart pound harder.
Then she lowers her head further, until her mouth is right between your breasts, where the blood is smeared in a messy line. You feel her tongue dart out, licking a slow, deliberate stripe across your skin, cleaning the blood off in one long motion. The sensation makes you arch your back, a soft moan slipping from your lips as her tongue glides over your skin.
Her knee presses harder between your legs, creating a delicious friction that has you biting your lip, trying to stifle another moan. But itâs impossible to keep quiet when Paige is so close, her body practically overwhelming yours with heat and pressure. You grip her back, nails digging into her shirt as she keeps licking the blood off your chest, the knife still cold in her hand as it brushes against your skin.
Paige chuckles darkly, the sound vibrating through you as she moves her lips to one of your breasts, taking your nipple into her mouth. Her tongue swirls around the sensitive peak, teasing, sucking lightly at first. Your whole body reacts, your breath catching in your throat, and a gasp escapes you as she bites down gently, enough to send a shock of pleasure through you.
âFuck, you taste so sweet,â she murmurs, her voice muffled against your skin as she switches to your other breast, her mouth relentless. âSo perfect and pretty for me, baby.â
Her words send another wave of heat through you, and you canât help but moan again, louder this time, your body arching into hers. The pressure of her knee between your legs intensifies, and you grind down instinctively, craving more of that contact.
Paigeâs mouth leaves your breast, trailing wet kisses down your abdomen. Her tongue flicks out, teasing along your ribs, before she starts sucking at your skin hard enough that you know sheâs leaving marksâevidence of where sheâs claimed you, the sensation sending sharp tingles through you.
Her hands move with purpose, finding the waistband of your sweatpants. You donât even realize what sheâs doing until you feel her fingers digging into your pocket, pulling something out before she slides your pants down your legs, leaving you in nothing but the lacy red thong that matches the blood-smeared mess around you and that did match your now-ruined tank top.
Paige takes her time, her gaze dark and heated as she admires the way the lace clings to your skin. She reaches out, hooking her finger under the waistband of the thong, pulling it back teasingly. The pressure is light, but itâs enough to make you shiver as she flicks it back against your skin with a soft snap. Paige hums, clearly pleased by your reaction, her smirk growing as her eyes meet yours.
Youâre about to say something, maybe tease her back, when you notice whatâs in her hand. It takes a second for it to register, but then you realize itâs the voice changer. The same one you use to make all your taunting phone calls.
Paige brings it up to her lips, turning it on with a flick of her thumb. âDo you wanna play a game?â Her voice comes out distorted, deep and twisted in that familiar way, making your heart race with a mix of excitement and surprise.
Immediately, you reach for the voice changer, shaking your head. âBabe, thatâs my thingââ you protest, because it is. Youâre the one who always calls the shots. Youâre the one who makes the phone calls, who controls the game. Not her.
But Paige is quicker. She pulls back just enough to keep it out of your reach, sitting up on her knees and holding the voice changer above her head, far enough that youâd have to try harder to grab it. She cocks her head, a playful yet dangerous glint in her eyes. âAh-ah,â she clicks her tongue, the sound sharp and commanding. Her expression makes it clearâif you try to take it again, youâre not going to like what happens next.
You lower your hand, your heart pounding in anticipation, your body already responding to the shift in control. Paigeâs eyes stay locked on yours, her smile widening as she brings the voice changer back to her lips.
âI said,â she repeats, her voice low and sultry before flicking it back on, âdo you wanna play a game?â
You roll your eyes, but thereâs no real defiance behind it, just attitudeâthe kind Paige loves and hates equally. âWhat kinda game?â you ask, the challenge evident in your tone.
Paigeâs grin grows, dark and wicked. Sheâs clearly enjoying this. âOh, itâs simple,â she begins, her voice turning to a dangerous purr. âYouâre gonna follow my rules. You do exactly what I say, and maybe Iâll let you finish.â
You scoff a little at that, trying to keep up the act of being unimpressed, but thereâs no denying the way her words send a surge of heat straight through you. âAnd what if I donât?â you counter, testing her.
Paigeâs eyes flash, her smirk growing more predatory, the same look she gets before she kills. She leans in close, the voice changer still in hand as she trails the back of the knife down your stomach, teasingly slow. âThen Iâll make sure you beg for it,â she whispers, her breath hot against your skin.
You feel your throat go dry at the sensation of the knife, her breath, the words she says. You swallow, staying quiet.
âYou like that, yeah?â Paige says, her voice dropping lower as she presses the flat of the knife against your stomach, the cool metal sending shivers down your spine. âWhen Iâm the one tellinâ you what to do, when I make you all desperate and shi.â
Paige continues to move the knife down, grazing along the edge of your thong, the metal tracing the fabric lightly as she keeps talking through the voice changer. âHereâs what weâre gonâ do,â she starts, giving you a pointed look. âYouâre gonna keep your hands right here,â she instructs, using her own hand to bring your wrists together and pulling them over your head, resting behind you against the armrest of the couch. âAnd youâre not gonâ move them. If you do⊠Iâll make sure itâs not pretty, âkay?â The implication is enough to make your breath hitch.
You stare up at her, heart racing, but you donât argue. The way sheâs looking at youâhungry and in controlâmakes you want to give in. To let her push you to the edge.
âAnd youâre gonna beg,â Paige adds, her voice husky, the grin on her face positively wicked. âBeg me to fuck you. Beg me to let you cum. Youâre gonna tell me how much you need it.â
Your lips part, but before you can respond, Paige presses the knife lightly against your skin again, the threat clear but enticing.
âDo you wanna play?â she asks once more, using the voice changer. But this time, itâs not really a question. Itâs more of a demand.
You donât say anything for a long moment, staying silent. But Paige wonât have that. She takes the handle of the knife, lightly stroking your clothed clit with it, keeping her eyes on your face. Your hips buck up involuntarily at the feeling, and your gaze lands on hers, catching sight of her waiting expression. You sigh in discomfort, wanting more, shifting your hips a little. However, you know she wonât give you any more of what you need if you donât agree to play her stupid fucking game. So, you kiss your teeth and mutter, âFine. Letâs play.â
Paige immediately grins at your response, clearly eager for some more excitement (as if her night hasnât been filled with enough of that already), tossing the voice changer across the room. She leans down, pressing her lips against your hipbone as she twists the knife back around to the sharp end, trailing the tip along your thong teasingly. You feel yourself shudder a little bit at the feeling, glancing down, chin pressing into your chest as you try to get a better look.
And then Paige is effectively ruining more of your clothing, tearing the fabric of your thong apart with the knife. It splits open, revealing your glistening cunt to the blonde.
âPaigeââ you begin to protest annoyedly, irritated with her affinity of slashing your clothes apart tonight.
However, her head snaps up to look at you at the sound of your attitude leaking back into your voice. She glares, eyes narrowing as she tells you, âShut the fuck up. Ion wanna hear none of your attitude bullshit tonight.â
You fight the urge to scoff at her, instead opting to stay quiet. You watch as she hooks her fingers around the flimsy fabric of whatâs left of your thong before tossing them to the side, leaving you completely naked before her. Before you can even really process whatâs going to happen next, sheâs leaning in, her hot breath landing between your legs. But instead of her tongue or her lips making contact with your folds, itâs Paigeâs teethâbiting at your clit. You gasp at the sensation, a little taken aback at the mixture of sting and serenity, and you canât help but let your hand fall to her head to hold her there.
She wonât have that, though.
The feeling of your hand in her hair makes her pull back immediately, making you lose any feeling between your legs. You whimper a little at the loss, but she doesnât care, slapping your hand away from her head. She grabs at the wrist of the same hand sheâs just hit, eyes flashing at you as she pulls your arm back above your head, locking your wrists together with her fingers.
âThe fuck did I tell you?â she snaps, glaring pointedly, irritation clearly seeping into her. âKeep your hands up there. Donât fuckinâ move âem unless I say so.â
You glare back at her, equally annoyed and turned on by her demands. Sheâs staring expectantly at you, waiting for a response, her nails digging into your wrists slightly. Eventually, you roll your eyes and cave, muttering, âFine, Jesus.â
You watch as her eyes narrow at the bratty tone of your voice, thoughâsurprisinglyâshe doesnât say anything, doesnât snap at you again to behave yourself. But she also doesnât do anything. She removes her hands from your wrists, making sure you keep them up there, but, after that, she doesnât make herself useful in any way. Instead, she leans back a little, her body still between your parted legs, just staring. She keeps her lips pursed as her eyes flick between your face and your glistening cunt thatâs on full display before her, just inches away. You shift your hips a little, hoping sheâll get the message and do something for you, but she doesnât. She just keeps watching you, eyes tracking the movement of your hips, keeping herself still.
You whine a little, nails digging into the couch armrest above you. âWhatâre you waiting for?â you finally retort, very annoyed by this point.
However, that annoyance seems to seep out of you pretty quickly as you feel the tip of the knife blade dig into your hip bone, just enough that if Paige pushed it any harder, it would certainly draw blood. You swallow a little, looking up at the blonde, trying to hold your ground.
âEnough with the fuckinâ attitude, ma,â she says firmly, clearly as tired of your shit as you are of here. You feel her begin to trail the blade along your skin slightly, before sheâs adding, âAnd whatâyou already forgot one of my rules?â
You furrow you eyebrows at the question, not sure what sheâs referring to. All you can really feel is the heat between your legs, and the stark cold metal of the knife against your skin.
She clicks her tongue at your obvious confusion, tipping the knife against you, breaking the skin ever so slightly. It doesnât really hurt, just stings some, and you look down to see the tiniest bit of blood surrounding the cut sheâs made, a hint of crimson tainting the silver of the knife. And then Paige is crawling a little forward, so that sheâs hovering over you, and you feel yourself shiver beneath her.
She leans closer, her breath hot against your cheek, the cold metal of the knife now grazing along the curve of your jaw, before slowly, deliberately, moving toward your lips. She traces the blade across your lower lip, and you feel the wetness of your own blood against it.
âOpen,â she orders, her tone firm, eyes alight with a mixture of control and something more primal.
Your heart races, but you do as she says, parting your lips slightly. The flat of the blade presses against your tongue, leaving the metallic taste of your blood in your mouth. Sheâs watching you do it intensely, pupils blown and eyes focused. And then sheâs pulling it back, teasing you, leaving your body tense and wanting. Her lips quirk into a smirk, clearly pleased with the way your body reacts beneath hers, the power she holds over you.
Then she straightens, pulling the knife away, her expression both playful and commanding as she watches you intently. Her voice is soft, but dripping with authority, âYou gotta beg for it, baby.â
You bite your lip, staring defiantly up at Paige, refusing to give her the satisfaction of seeing you beg. You can see the flicker of frustration in her eyes as her grip on the knife tightens. She leans in, her breath fanning across your skin, but you hold firm, a smirk playing on your lips despite the tension crackling between you. Youâre playing with fire, and you know it.
Itâs right then where Paigeâs patience snaps. Her hand shoots up to grab your jaw, her fingers pressing into your skin, hard enough to hurt some. âYouâre being a real bitch tonight,â she husks, eyes narrowing as her thumb brushes over your lower lip. âI think I might just have to punish you for it.â
You can feel your heart race at her words, but you refuse to back down, a flicker of defiance still lingering in your expression, a slight smirk still pulling up your lips.
Paige tilts her head, her grip tightening slightly. âOh, you think this is funny? You think you can just act like this and get away with it?â she continues, her voice low and controlled, though you can feel the anger bubbling underneath. âFine. If you wonât beg, then you donât get to make a single sound.â
You feel your eyes widen without thinking about it, realizing what sheâs getting at, but she only smirks at your reaction.
âIf you make any noise,â Paige says, leaning in close, her lips brushing the shell of your ear, âthen I wonât let you finish. Not tonight. Not tomorrow night. Not until you learn how to fucking behave.â Her voice is dripping with authority, every word hanging between you like a challenge.
You swallow hard, trying to steel yourself, but the way sheâs looking at youâlike sheâs already won this roundâmakes it difficult. You know sheâs pushing your limits, testing just how far she can take this.
She doesnât wait for you to answer, instead crawling back down your body, keeping your thighs spread open, resting herself between them. Immediately getting to work, probably impatient herself, her mouth attaches to the skin of your inner thigh, sucking harshly, certainly enough to leave a mark for tomorrow. And then sheâs kissing her way up to the cut sheâs imprinted on your hip, ghosting her tongue along the small sliver of slashed skin and the blood that rests with it. It stings, and you hear yourself gasp, whimpering at the feeling. Sheâs not fond of that, though, wanting you to stay quiet as sheâs told you, so she pinches your thigh hard. You fight to not let the noise thatâs burrowed itself in your throat get through, swallowing it down. If you behave, youâll get what you wantâso you might as well just let her have her fun.
Sheâs getting closer to where you need her, her nose brushing against your clit as she ghosts her lips along the side of your pussy, teasing you. You shift your hips slightly, desperate for the friction youâve been needing, but her hands grab at each hip bone, holding you down so you stay still.
And then sheâs diving in, pressing her tongue to your aching cunt, licking a long stripe right up between your folds. Your eyes roll into the back of your head at the long awaited pleasure, keeping silent just as she told you to. She presses her mouth against you completely, enough to feel her every breath on you, rolling her tongue right against your clit.
Paige moans a little against you, sending vibrations through you that have your legs shaking. As she continues rolling her tongue in that famous, miraculous rhythm of hers against your bundle of nerves, one of her hands reaches up to your tit, thumb brushing along the nipple and pinching it.
You bite your lip, finally being a good girl and listening to Paigeâs demands like sheâs wanted this whole time. You stay silent, though your breaths come quicker, faster, your chest rising and falling rapidly beneath Paigeâs hand.
She glances up at you, smirking against you as she catches sight of the beads of sweat forming along your skin, your flushed face, the way youâre fighting to stay quiet. Her tongue slides along the expanse of your slit before slipping inside of you, making your thighs quiver and a tiny gasp to escape your lips. Paige glares up at you warningly at that, making sure you remember well that if youâre not quiet, youâre not cumming.
And then sheâs returning her focus back to your pussy, sliding her tongue in and out of you a couple times in a slow rhythm. You can tell sheâs enjoying this by the way her eyes slip shut, brows furrowing in concentration. She then brings her mouth back up to your clit, flicking her tongue up and down, up and down, up and down, in a way that makes you see stars. You dig your nails into your palms, squeezing your eyes shut at the euphoric feeling.
âShit,â Paige mumbles as she pulls away, staring at your soaking cunt before adding to the wetness, spitting on you. She watches her saliva slide between your folds and then leans in to lap it up with her tongue. She moans against you, probably at the taste, saying, âYouâre gonna kill me with this pussy, baby. Could eat you forever.â
You let out a long, shaky breath at the words, scrunching your face up a little she sucks on your clit. Hard. You feel her teeth scrape against it, too, and you swear your nails are going to draw blood if you dig them any deeper into your skin.
Breathing heavily, she suddenly pulls up and sits on her knees between your legs, letting go of your hips and pushing your legs further apart. Looking down between them, Paige is suddenly thrusting three of her fingers into you without any warning. You canât help itâit makes you shudder out something between a moan and a gasp, exclaiming, âFuck!â
Paige wonât have that for a second, immediately pulling her fingers out of you to slap your pussy. âShut the fuck up,â she tells you, biting along your skin as she slowly crawls up to your face again. âCanât ever fuckinâ listen to me, can you?â she asks, her fingers trailing to your clit, circling it harshly. It makes your legs shudder and shake and you feel your eyes roll into the back of your head.
âCouldnât help it,â you murmur, gasping as you feel the heat in your stomach begin to rise, the coil getting ready to snap.
Paigeâs fingers find their way back inside you, all three of them pumping. Your pussy squelches with her relentless pace, the sounds beyond filthy. Her other hand has found itâs way back to your throat, fingers wrapping around your neck, your pulse racing against her hand. âDonât lie,â she snaps, eyes flitting between your face and the way her fingers are thrusting into you with absolutely no mercy. âYouâre not a bitch, Iâve seen you take worse.â
You whimper a little at her words and it only makes her fingers speed up, sliding in and out and then curling in a come hither motion, making you see stars. âYâknow, Kelsey wanted to fuck me,â Paige taunts. Your eyes flash open at the words, the same flare of jealousy and anger rushing into you as remember the night at the bar. Realistically, you know you shouldnât still care, especially as your gaze darts to see a quick glance of Kelseyâs dead body across the room. But, still, Paigeâs words send a rush of irritation through you. She can tell, and she smirks, her thumb now abusing your clit as her fingers continue their pace. âYou think she coulda kept quiet? Think she woulda been a good girl for me? She seemed very sweet.â
âSheâs dead,â you grunt out, trying not to let Paigeâs words get in the way of the feeling of her fingers in you, on you. âSo I guess youâll never know.â
That makes Paigeâs hand squeeze your neck a little, enough for you to cry out at the dual sensation of that and her thrusting fingers. Itâs all getting too much, the heat building as Paigeâs pace keeps steady, your hips rising to meet her digits as they pump in and out. âFuck, you make me crazy,â the blonde says, her lips trailing to your neck to suck a mark against your skin. âSuch a brat, baby.â
The sensation between your legs has you forgetting Paigeâs rules, and you think that at this point, sheâs forgotten them, too, because your hands are moving from above your head to tangle in her ponytail, tugging as her fingers curl inside you. She doesnât do anything to stop you, instead humming against your neck.
âP,â you manage to gasp out, voice shaking. Youâre faintly aware that youâre sweating, your hair sticking sticking to your damp forehead and neck, your whole body pulsing with heat. âPaige, âm gonna cum.â
Paige nods against you, her tongue swiping against the hollow of your throat, her fingers thrusting and thrusting and thrusting. Vaguely, you wonder if her hand is cramping yet. âI know, baby,â she says a little breathlessly, against your skin. âCome on, ma, give it to me. Wanna feel it bad.â
You let out a shaky cry, hands finding their way beneath Paigeâs shirt, nails digging into her back, certainly leaving scratch marks. Every thrust, every breath that Paige takes against your skinâitâs all too much, and you can feel herself teetering on the edge of your orgasm, the pleasure building with every second.
And then youâre moaning out, âOh my Godâfuck!â as the coil within you snaps, your back arching against Paigeâs hand, your heart racing. âFuck,â you say again, quieter this time, trying to blink away the stars in your vision.
Your breath comes in quick bursts as you slowly come down from your high, feeling a euphoric mixture of adrenaline and warmth coursing through your veins. You lean back against the couch cushions, now damp with blood and your own arousal, your skin glistening with a light sheen of sweat. Paige presses further into you, her breath hot and feverish against your neck, and you feel her say your name against your skin. And then sheâs slowly pulling her fingers out of your soaking cunt, trailing them up to your mouth as she draws back slightly.
She slips them past your lips and you let her, mouth sucking her fingers clean, tongue gliding along her digits. The way her eyes glaze over watching you do it, lust filling her pupils, makes you think that youâre about to get fucked into oblivion for a round two. But then her gaze trails somewhere behind your headâprobably to Kelseyâs dead body, if you had to guessâand sheâs sighing, resigned, as she pulls her fingers from your mouth, tangling them in your hair. She presses her lips against yours firmly for just a moment, before sheâs pulling away, saying, a smirk pulling the corners of her lips up, âWe gotta go before they catch us.â
You frown a little, pouting as you say, âFunâs over.â
She shakes her head slightly at you, still smirking as she responds, âNah, when we get home, we can have all the fun you want.â And then sheâs reaching down onto the floor, grabbing the ghostface mask and slipping it over your head, covering your face. âCâmon, letâs go.â
You slip into your clothes quickly, watching as Paige grabs the knife and checks around the room to see if either of you have forgotten anything. Once youâre ready, the two of you open the apartment door, leaving your mess for someone to find later. However, you and Paige leave, she of course does not forget to call out into the empty apartment, âBye, Kelsey!â
The door slams shut behind you, and, obviously, there is no response back.