frat boy! natalie scatorccio x fem! reader x frat boy! lottie matthews . . .
synopsis : they always say that two will always be better than one.
— tags & warnings : nsfw content. minors do not interact. threesome, double penetration, gp! natalie, gp! lottie , rough sex, p in v sex, unprotected sex, implied breeding, blowjobs, oral (lottie! receiving), college! au, contains cursing, dirty talk, overstimulation, lottie accidentally walks in lmao, contains heavy cursing, porn w plot, NOT PROOFREAD.
— read the request from here . . 💌
Attending a party with midterms right around the corner was a risk you didn't even know you'd take this Friday night.
You had promised yourself you'd bury your nose on the mountain of textbooks slowly piling up on the hardwood of your desk, try to atleast give yourself a chance — yet just hours ago, an unexpected argument with one of your professors that was definitely being a dickhead again had left you sour.
That's how you ended up here, cramped against the fraternity house that had suddenly thrown an unexpected party, restricted under the stairs with people snogging each other left and right as blinding lights filled the place, blaring music drowning the shout and excitement the other people had been showing.
The unexpected party was already loud when you got there along with your friend that was missing by now, music blaring left and right as a haze of cigarettes and vapes lingered thickly through the air. The house smelled like cheap liquor from the dollar store along with half-burnt weed, and from where you stood - you can see a line forming by the hallway, leading to the small, cramped bathroom.
You stood there, clutching a red plastic cup against your hand as you leaned on the wall just beside the stairs, looking over at the sea of people forming by the basement of the house, sweat starting to linger through the walls. You had been wondering at the last five minutes as you stood there where the fuck was your friend, and how your recent life choices would definitely fuck up your college life.
You tried your best to squeeze through the wooden staircase, leading up to the house itself as you heard the loud cheers at the entrance of the fraternity house, with people cheering as your eyes caught up to the familiar piercing green eyes that had been haunting you for the past three goddamn days of your life.
"Fuck," you mumbled under your own breath, before speeding up to refill your cup on the kitchen, fingers slightly trembling.
But it was already too late, a hand you can recognize from anywhere had already wrapped around your waist, pinning you on the marble countertops as you were forced to turn around.
"What the fuck do you want?" you hissed, looking up to see the person no other than Natalie Scatorccio, the girl whom you hooked up with last week and had the fucking audacity to leave her number like some kind of stupid hotline.
Natalie lazily smirked — the smirk she'd known that was so goddamn attractive, her fangs peeking up as her mouth curled at you.
"Chill, sweetheart." she murmured, her voice sounding like gravel. "What's gotten into you? You're uptight already." she chuckled.
"Leave me alone, Natalie." you said, trying to desperately get out of her grip as you clenched your jaw, "The hell do you want from me?" you said, looking up at her.
"You." Natalie murmured, her free hand tracing the outline of your hips through the dress you wore, her green, sharp eyes already scrutinizing your gaze as the minutes dragged on between the two of you. "Thought that was already obvious?" she added.
"Oh fuck you," you spat, trying to break free from her grip as she held up that shit-eating grin you had always loved and hated at the same time.
"Yeah? Sure I can, babe." she murmured, "What's gotten you so uptight, hm?" she said, suddenly hoisting you up at the countertop, with you instinctively placing your hands on her shoulders as she caged you with her two hands.
"Fucking... professor humiliated me in front of the whole class," you scoffed, chugging the drink you placed onto the countertop not so far, "Pissed me off, and midterms are next week." you added.
Natalie's hands that were previously pressed against the surface had now snaked themselves onto your waist, looking at you as she smirked at that, thumb rubbing small circles around your hips, listening to what you were saying.
"Then let's fix it?" her voice that was raspy, yet gentle had asked you, before you smashed your lips against her, wrapping your arms around her neck, pulling her closer to your body.
That was how you and Natalie had stumbled upon her room upstairs, the skimpy dress you've been wearing all evening had been abandoned in the carpets of her floor along with your bra and underwear.
Fingers gripping against the sheets of her bed, trying to contain your moans as your back arched, Natalie's lips swirling around your hardened nipple as her palm squeezed your other one, before switching to the other nipple as your legs spread further, inviting her.
"Fuck, Nat..." you spoke, your eyes closing as you only heard the raspy chuckle escape from your lips, with her peppering your stomach with kisses as her hand had finally swept over your folds, groaning from how wet you were already for her.
"Christ," she murmured, her voice already jagged and raspy as she looked at you. "I haven't touched you for days, and you're already this dripping for me?" she mumbled, dragging her fingers over your wet folds just to emphasize her point.
A sob escaped your lips from that, bucking your hips impatiently to atleast find some sort of friction, your actions already driven from pure want and need.
"Nat— fuck— please!" you said, before her lips crashed against yours, your tongues fighting for dominance.
Her fingers were rubbing slow, tortuous circles against your clit— massaging the small bundle of nerves that had you moaning against her mouth, before she swallowed up all the noises you were making as you both continued to kiss.
Finally, with the slow drag of her fingers against your folds — two fingers pushed themselves inside your gummy walls, your mouth falling open as your hips were impatiently bucking against Natalie's long, thick fingers that seemed to stuff you so full.
"That's it," she whispered, pressing a soft kiss to your forehead as her fingers curled just right, uncurling themselves as she started to thrust them in a fast pace, your back arching painfully against the bed.
"God," you choked up, eyes rolling back at your head as she scissored them just right, a tight knot already forming at the pits of your stomach, your grip on her arm that was between your legs tightening.
"I'm gonna cum! — I'm gonna—" you whined out, before she pressed her lips against yours, pulling away.
"Yeah? Come." she rasped out, her thumb continuing to rub small circles against your lips as you cried at the stimulation, tears stinging your eyes before falling into the sheets as the knot untangled— your orgasm rippling through your brains as you came in her fingers.
Natalie's fingers were a relentless rhythm inside you, her pace slowing down as you rode your orgasm, yet still deep and persistent as you finished from your high, slumping down the familiar sheets as she pulled her fingers out, licking them off clean before releasing them with a pop.
She unbuckled her belt, leaning against the headboard as her length sprung free from her boxers, already half-hard and leaking with pre-cum as she groaned, making you sit up and straddle her lap, her hardened cock pressing against your thigh as you whined.
"Nat... I can't." you mumbled against her shoulder as she kisses your forehead, tucking the loose strand behind your ear.
"You definitely can," she murmured, looking at you as she lined up against your entrance.
"We can take it slow, hm?" she added as she started to push inside just slowly, her walls already swallowing her length as you both groaned, hands pushing against her shoulder to make you sit properly, hands resting on her stomach as you whimpered.
All seemed fine between the two of you before the door of Natalie's bedroom suddenly opened, with you immediately pressing yourself against her as she chuckled lazily, not even minding that the two of you were practically naked underneath a blanket that you had lazily thrown last minute.
"Are you seriously fucking each other in a room with walls that are paperly thin?" a voice had asked, slightly unimpressed that belonged to no other than Lottie Matthews, a cigarette pressed between her fingers as she slowly exhaled the smoke out from her mouth, looking at Natalie.
Natalie smirked lazily, "What're you here for, moron?" she asked, "You jealous?" she added with a chuckle as Lottie slightly laughed at that, her gaze still unimpressed, though it shined with want.
It should've pissed you off, given that Natalie was still very inside you— and the fact that the two of them, probably the two most popular girls around your college was in one room with you, the other one with her dick still buried inside you, yet they were talking like they discussed shit about weather.
"Jackie's waiting downstairs, said we have some shit to discuss after the party." Lottie murmured, leaning against the door as she stepped inside, before closing it as she inhaled the smoke from her cigarette.
Natalie only groaned at that, the coldness of her metal rings pressing against your waist as her fingers only tightened, before looking at Lottie again. "What the fuck does she need from me now," she grumbled under her breath, now slightly annoyed from what you could make out from her face.
"She's pretty, Nat." Lottie murmured as her gaze now fell over you, wetting her lower lips as she smirked.
"Yeah, she is." Natalie smirked, pressing a kiss against your jaw as her hips subtly started to move again, her eyes remaining on Lottie's the whole time as an idea popped through the blonde's mind.
"Wanna join us?" Nat offered as Lottie's smirk widened at that, her gaze falling over you once again as if to silently ask for permission. "That okay, pretty?"
But your eyes were already closed, raspy moans escaping your lips as Natalie started to thrust her hips deeper and faster, all coherent thoughts flushing down the rain as you buried your head against her neck, muffling your moans.
"She asked you a question, baby." Natalie murmured, her grip against your waist squeezing impossibly tight as she looked up at you through her half-lidded eyes, "Don't tell me you're that fucked out to answer?" she murmured, gripping you tightly.
Your eyes opened, vision blurry as you nodded, "Y-Yeah." you said, making yourself sit against her lap again, hands resting on her stomach as you bounced off her dick shamelessly, before you felt your head getting tilted, Lottie's lips crashing against yours.
Unlike Natalie, Lottie's lips tasted like smoke and something sweet at the same time her kiss gentle yet rough as she swiped her tongue over your bottom lip, opening your mouth as she deepened the kiss, hands caressing down your neck and down to your chest, cupping your chest while her lips moved down your neck.
You closed your eyes, letting her take whatever she could as Natalie's thrusts were unforgiving beneath you, her pace turning to brutal and deep. The brunette pulled away, unbuckling her pants with trembling hands down to her ankles along with her boxers as her cock sprung free in her hands.
Lottie's was much more bigger than Natalie, given that the Gods had blessed her with her height, but hers looked much angrier, already fully hard and pre-cum sliding off her length as she pumped herself a few times, before pressing them against your lips as you greedily took her inside yours.
You bobbed your head, maintaining eye contact with her as she groaned, fisting your head as she looked down on you with a lazy smirk. "Fuck yeah," she murmured, her grip on your hair tightening as you struggled to take her deeper, given her size.
"Fuck— fuck, choke on it." she mumbled, hazy from the pleasure as she gripped your head, the head of her length already hitting the back of your throat.
Lottie's thrusts were brutal, head tilted up to the ceiling as you choked down her cock, tears springing from your eyes as she repeatedly hit your throat with her sharpened thrusts.
Underneath you, Natalie was busy chasing her high, thrusts that were borderline hitting your cervix as her eyes were closed, groaning from the pleasure as your folds squeezed her tightly.
"I'm close," she rasped out, her hands resting on your waist squeezing you impossibly hard. "You wouldn't mind if I don't pull out, won't you baby?" she rasped out, "Fuck, I don't think I can pull out—" she said, chuckling as she groaned.
But you were too busy choking from Lottie's cock, shaking your head as your clammy hands gripped Lottie's hips, eyes rolling back as her thrusts were all uncoordinated now, her thighs trembling.
Before you can comprehend what was happening, Lottie was pulling away — fisting her cock that was now covered in your spit, pulling you closer as she fisted, groaning as thick ropes of cum splattered against your breasts, spilling all over your stomach and the sides of your jaw.
She was breathing heavily as you kissed her deeply, your palm cradling her nape. Natalie also came shortly after, hips snapping roughly against yours as you felt the warm liquid fill you, painting your walls white as her rough hands pulled your face from Lottie, crashing her lips against yours as she came down from her high.
The room reeked of smoke, sweat, and sex— the sheets ruined as you rested against them, watching the two of them dress up as you covered yourself in Natalie's sheets, completely exhausted to the bone as you lit a cigarette, holding them between your fingers.
As you laid there, you could only think of two things — one that this was definitely the craziest shit you pulled all throughout your college life— and two? you'd definitely do it again.
all rights reserved. user a7domeda.
yellowjackets / masterlist / natalie / lottie