okay i wish i could write a better more coherent meta right now but all i have is my emotions and they are Big right now so uh hereās some thoughts about Utena
I think the moment Utena actually realizes that sheās in love with Anthy is theĀ āi put poison in your teaā scene.Ā Sheās been playing with the idea in her head consciously and subconsciously to varying degrees throughout the entire episode, and perhaps throughout a large part of the series, but this is the first time she goes wait, no but for real.Ā I love you.Ā Not like a friend, but like the way I felt towards my prince and the other guys that Iāve fallen for this year.Ā Thatās the moment she knows and accepts that she loves her and like okay i might be super emotional right now but bear with me because like this is currently the most important thing in my head now
because on the other side of this I think Anthy loved Utena from basically the moment she met/saw Utena.Ā And she knew.Ā She knew she loved Utena.Ā But she forced herself to ignore it.Ā She pushed it away, she sealed it up, she pretended she didnāt know because for her love is pain and love is suffering but being with Utena isnāt suffering for once so it canāt be love.Ā accepting that itās love would be paramount to accepting that it will end up in a fiery ball of torment like it always has for her so she doesnāt accept that she loves Utena and manages to make herself believe she doesnāt
but Utena is a disastrous bisexual and didnāt know she could love girls until like, recently, honestly in my mind it was probably around her second duel with Juri that she subconsciously started to realize that her feelings towards Anthy werenāt just friendship and a desire to be a prince, because Juri proved to Utena that a girl could fall in love with another girl and before Utena probably hadnāt even considered that was a possibility.Ā Ā
And then she falls for Akio, and things get hazy, and she sort of starts to lose herself somewhere in there because Akio is a master manipulator and thatās exactly what he wants her to do.Ā Except she sees Anthy while sheās with Akio that night.
And thatās the trigger.Ā Thatās the moment.Ā Because I never got the sense from Utena after that that she felt likeā¦betrayed, or anything.Ā She was shocked, for sure, and after all of her emotions getting tangled up by Akio Iām sure she didnāt sleep well that night, trying to deal with all of the conflicting emotions but likeā¦.that moment focuses on Anthyās eyes.Ā On how empty and broken she looks.Ā And I think thatās the first time Utena realizes that she has never seen Anthy for who she is all this time, and she starts to reevaluate every interaction sheās ever had with Anthy and realize just how much Anthy has been hurting all this time.
That next day she asks Akio out on a date, but something feels so different now.Ā Is she still in love with him?Ā I think so, because feelings donāt dissipate that quickly, but thereās confusion now.Ā I think she asks him out because sheās confused.Ā Sheās confused by everything sheās feeling about Anthy and Akio and the two of them together and she thinks, okay.Ā Iāll spend time with Akio again.Ā Iāll see if it feels the same.Ā Maybe this is how I figure things out.
And it doesnāt.Ā It doesnāt feel the same anymore.Ā Itās not about feeling cheated on.Ā Itās about the fact that Utenaās been shown how hurt Anthy is, and she canāt divorce her growing realization of her feelings for Anthy with how hurt she is, even though she still loves Akio, because itās pretty damn obvious that Akio is why Anthy is hurting.Ā So she goes on another date with him, and it feels wrong.Ā Suddenly this romance feels wrong.Ā She doesnāt feel like herself and she recognizes that in herself now.Ā And throughout the entire episode, I think rather than thinking about Akio, like she has been for the past few episodes, sheās thinking solely about Anthy.Ā She canāt get Anthy out of her head.Ā All this time sheās been distracted and now she thinks oh god i havenāt even really seen her all this time and now Anthy is all she can think about as though in compensation, as though to make up for how awful she feels at having never truly seen her and yet having the gall to fall in love with her anyway.
Because then she meets with Miki and Juri, and that whole conversation, including with Nanami, feels like the time where sheās thinking about what she wants to do about her feelings for Anthy.Ā How much she wants to accept.Ā How much she wants to explore and confirm them.Ā Nanami tells her to stay away from Akioāand Anthy.Ā And Utena can only smile and sayĀ āthanks for the adviceā but sheās thought of nothing but Anthy all day and she knows now that come fire or ice sheās not leaving that girlās side.
And then we come back to the poison scene.Ā Which I heard some beautiful meta about that Iām going to absolutely reference shamelessly here because it makes me cry every time.Ā Because Anthy knows that Utena saw her, and I think Anthyās hoping to have a final relief.Ā All this time sheās loved Utena and the longer this goes on the harder it is to pretend she doesnāt know she loves her.Ā But if Utena finally hates her, abandons her, like all of the people before her, sheāll be relieved of that weight.Ā Sheāll never have to acknowledge that love again because it wonāt matter.Ā If Utena hates her, thatās finally the end of the pain that Anthy knows love is.
And so she speaks of canterella.Ā Reminding Utena that though sheās pretended like everything is normal all day, what she saw last night happened.Ā Anthy is telling herĀ āthat wasnāt a dream.Ā I really did that.Ā I actually am awful and horrible, and Iām poisoning you with my existence.Ā Iām not going to let you forget.Ā You should run and stop eating my poisoned cookies while you can.ā For a moment, Utena hesitates.Ā Then she finishes the cookie.Ā Ā āWhat a surprise.Ā I put poison in your tea, too.ā
āYeah, I know you did that, and that I saw it, and that it happened.Ā But letās not forget that Iāve hurt you too.Ā I havenāt even looked at you like a real person this whole time and yet I have the gall to love you.Ā So Iām a poisoner too.ā
Utena doesnāt hate her.Ā She canāt.Ā This is the moment where Utena sees, clearly, that Anthy has been hurting her. Purposefully, directly, indirectly, in all sorts of ways.Ā And that sheās been hurting Anthy in turn.Ā But she says yeah, I know.Ā But Iām not leaving you unless you tell me.Ā Because that, that is the moment that Tenjo Utena recognizes, and accepts, that she is in love with Himemiya Anthy.
So Anthy hesitates.Ā And she drinks theĀ āpoisonā tea.Ā āItās delicious.āĀ Ā āSoās this cookie.ā