I don’t know if anyone asks you this yet but have you done an art review on Chiko yet?
So far they’ve drawn Galzus, Kinshi Hinoka, Ballroom!Ishtar, Malice, Micaiah's base alt, Festival Dancer Olivia, Panne and her NY alt, Resplendent Rhajat, Plegian Tharja, Flame Tribe Rinkah, F!Grima (refuse to acknowledge it as a Robin alt) and Silvia.
A huge list of character so far but they’ve drawn mostly women and only one rugged guy.
Fun fact, I tried answering this ask TWICE while I was on my phone yesterday.
And twice Tumblr wiped my in-progress post simply because I switched to a different window while I was trying to get the images.
I like Chiko's artwork overall, but I have some issues with individual pieces rather than an overall issue. It's a weird inconsistency sometimes.
But going over the positives first, I think they're great at drawing poses, or using clothing to flow. And their expressions are pretty good too:
They seem to be able to draw a diverse set of body types. And I appreciate that they kept Rinkah's muscles. (also shown with Rinkah I think their crit effects are pretty cool too).
Also I appreciate that Malice kept her muscles:
They've got good colorwork going too, and most of the time their lighting and shading is good.
But again, I have a few issues with individual characters, rather than an arcing overall problem.
First one I'll address is Panne. Here's base Panne:
And here's New Year's Panne:
New Year's Panne has this very weird lighting on the bridge of her face. It's distracting to me and it looks like she was drawn by a totally different artist. I really wish they didn't put the lighting there, because this otherwise would have been a perfect piece. It's still good though, just distracting.
The second is Silvia's left hand in her attack portrait:
Why is her palm facing outward like that? It's not an implausible pose, but it looks off for some reason. Seems like it looks uncomfortable.
And finally, Malice's other art portraits. I like her neutral portrait and I know I said I appreciate the muscle addition, but she gets really weird torpedo tits in her other portraits. Look:
(Whyyyyy do they look so stiff)
This one is weird because I can't remember if Malice came before or after Plegian Festival Tharja, but they seem to fix that chest issue with Tharja and Rhajat at least.
Still though, Chiko's not a bad artist at all; far from it. I think I can put them at an 8/10, I just wish their work was a little more consistent sometimes. But they're growing, as all artists do, and I appreciate that.