Months later and I was still thinking about him. I felt anger, disappointment, void, sorrow and, most importantly, pain. How could he betray us like this? Betray me? I was so foolish to believe that he actually had good intentions. That he loved me.
I should have listened to Stiles. Theo wouldn’t have been able to come this close if we all just listened to Stiles. Scott wouldn’t have been in such danger and I wouldn’t be as heartbroken as I am right now. I tried to remind myself that he killed Scott. The bond me and Scott had could not be described in words. We were inseparable. Like siblings.
And the worst thing is that I could have prevented it. I could have talked to Theo but instead I was at the hospital that day helping Melissa. Once we heard that Hayden didn’t make it and that Liam almost killed his own Alpha, I run as fast as I could to the library to get Scott out of there. I’m glad I didn’t cross paths with Liam, otherwise I would have killed him on the spot. I understand that he was hurt and angry but how can he hurt Scott, who treated him like his son this whole time.
Once I arrived I did not expect, my now ex boyfriend, to be there as well. He had locked the door so I couldn’t interfere and stop him. I had to watch him kill my best friend. I screamed, I cried for help, I tried to break the door down. Nothing helped. He ignored me like I was nothing. Like he couldn’t hear my screams and pleas to let Scott go.
That’s when I realized how little I meant to him. All the kisses we shared, all the late night talks we had, all the amazing and unforgettable memories we created. It was all a lie.
I was at the library during a free period doing my homework when my phone rang. I chose to ignore it and concentrate on my paper for latin instead. It’s not like it’s important anyway. It was probably just Mom texting me about the groceries.
A few minutes later and my phone ringed again but this time it didn’t stop ringing.
People around me gave me dirty looks as they tried to study. I smiled quietly. “Sorry.“
I took my phone out of my bag and saw Liam calling me. I quickly accepted and pressed my phone against my ear. “What?” I hissed quietly. This better be good.
“Why weren’t you answering?” Liam said, sounding a bit in a rush. “Never mind, just come to Scott’s as fast as possible.“
"What do you mean? Where are you? You’re supposed to be in class, Liam.” I said, sounding like a big sister. Scott wasn’t here either which made me even more concerned.
“That doesn’t matter now! We’ll meet at Scott’s.” He hung up.
I quickly stood up packing my stuff and left.
I knocked on the door already anxious. What if he was hurt? Does Scott know? Where was he anyway?
Hayden opened the door looking just as worried as me. “What happened?” I asked in hurry.
She shook her head. “Liam’s fine if that’s what you’re worried about.” I let out a breath that I hold in this whole time. Thank God.
I walked inside and put my bag on the kitchen counter.
“What is it then that I had to leave school and miss my classes? You all know we missed way too many classes these past months and-“ That’s when I got interrupted.
"Hey, babygirl.” I turned around and immediately couldn’t believe who was standing in front of me. Theo.
"Liam brought me back.” He smiled at me with a light twinkle in his eyes that made me go weak.
He started walking closer to me ready to embrace me but I stepped back with my hand in front of me. As a sort of protection.
Theo stopped in his tracks and furrowed his eyebrows. “I would never hurt you, Y/N. You know that, right?”
“Why did you bring him back?” I completely ignored him along with the pain inside my chest as I turned to Liam who stood behind Theo.
“We needed someone with the ability to absorb electricity. He was the only one who we came up with.” Liam sound frustrated.
“Does Scott know?” I was furious by now. I scoffed and turned away from both of them. I couldn’t look at him. He looked just like my Theo. The one I loved with all my heart. But I knew better. He and his manipulative ass can crawl back into the hole that he came out of.
“No, he doesn’t know but that’s beside the point. We only brought you here because Theo wanted to talk to you.” Liam said.
“Maybe we should leave them alone before Scott comes back.” Hayden said softly behind me. “So that he can kill me too?” I asked furiously.
“You know I would never hurt you!” Theo said, just as mad as me. I looked him deep in the eye before saying.
“Oh really? Just like you promised that we could trust you.” tears started to form in my eyes and my voice cracked a bit.
“That was different! Everything I’ve ever said to you was nothing but the truth!” He came closer till we were face to face. Both our breathing irregular.
“How could you?” I cried out and started hitting his chest. He didn’t bother to fight back. And even though I knew it didn’t hurt him I still wanted to make him feel the same pain as I did when he left me.
“Did you even mean it when you said you cared for me? Why would you kill the one person that meant the world to me? To see me suffer?” I kept hitting him. But I did not dare to look in his eyes because, I knew the minute I would look at his face I would give in.
“I never knew that he meant this much to you, Y/N! All I ever wanted was a pack!” His tone was harsh. He grabbed my wrists to prevent me hitting him. “I love you.” He said softly.
He’s lying. I closed my eyes and tried to stop myself from crying. “Look at me, Y/N.” one hand let go of my wrist as he slowly brought it up to my face to wipe my tears away. “Why would I lie to you, babygirl?”
“Open your eyes.” He said and cupped my chin. I did as I was told and looked him deep in the eyes. God, how much I missed them. They were the same green shade, just how I remembered.
He looked at me and smiled at me with such adoration that I couldn’t bring myself to hate him. "The whole time that I was down there I tried to think of you. I had to go through much worse than you could possibly imagine. You were my anchor that kept me sane this whole time.“
“I don’t need the pack’s forgiveness. All I need is for you to forgive me. That’s all that matters to me.” He sounded almost pleading as he caressed my cheek.
I let out a deep breath and said. “I will always love you, Theo. But you can’t expect me to forgive you.” He shook his head not believing what I was saying. “No, no, no. Don’t say that.” His face twisted up in pain.
I took a step back already missing his warm touch on my face. “If Scott or Liam decide to bring you back… I won’t try to stop them.” Was the last thing I said to him before turning around and walking out the house.
First imagine! I plan on making a second part to this but it depends on how well this does. Hope you liked it!
Also, I do not own any of these amazing gif’s! Credit goes to the owner who posted them!!!!
gummygunk
kianamaiart
blakekathryn
gracieabrams
2087
turnnoffyourmind
