On my first day of using CMB I was curious about what potential matches I would be presented with and anxious about whether or not anyone would like me back. My first bagel, S, was totally my type.
Average height, lanky, dark-haired, and self-depreciating sense of humor. In his bio he apologized for not being Ben Affleck and stated that although he wasn’t a good cook he knew all the good restaurants in Boston, and ended with his height in heels (6′5″) and his credit score. I didn’t think it was possible, but I was smitten with a profile and immediately pressed “connect”.
To my surprise, we matched and for the next hour I was giggly like an idiot, butterflies were in my stomach and I was completely over the moon. Too shy and nervous, I refrained from messaging first but was delighted when after my evening SoulCycle class, I received a notification of a CMB message.
“Does this mean I get to take you out to dinner?” I squealed and embarrassingly jumped up and down on the sidewalk. My smile widened and I panicked, asking my friends what I should say. I definitely wanted to meet up but wasn’t sure if I was ready for a full on dinner so after consulting my friends E and J I decided to write, “You’re going to have to impress me with your wit and charm first” which was a perfectly flirty response and a perfect start to a conversation until against my better judgement I decided to ignore his next message.
I still can’t explain why I did it, but I ignored his message that night until the next afternoon. It read, “What? My profile wasn’t captivating enough for you.” Not at all skilled in text flirting I consulted E and J again and wrote as a response, “Still not sure I can justify going out to dinner with someone who’s a bigger Justin Timberlake fan than I am” (referencing a blurb in his bio about listening to the Sexy Back song for all four years of high school).
This was quite possibly the worst thing I could have said and the worst course of action that I could have taken. I was expecting a response later that day but got nothing and then another day had passed and nothing. He had ghosted me.
I dissected our very brief conversation and realized that:
1. My delayed responses probably came off as me being uninterested in him.
2. What I said, and my lack of emojis or lols in my comment to him about the JT thing made me come off as a bitch strong.
How could I not see it?! It looked like I was making fun of him instead of being flirty. I was so embarrassed that a deleted our conversation from the chat room and ignored CMB. I vowed not to go on CMB which was one of the more “serious” dating apps and told myself that I needed to practice text flirting before going back on CMB.
My next, potentially poor decision?
To create a Tinder that night.