This week, I will be learning…
Method:
Piped: Spritz Cookies Dropped: Chocolate Chip Rolled/Cut out: Alfajores (dulce de leche)Molded: Polvorones (Swedish Yule Logs) Stencil: Tuile Batter Sheet: Whole Wheat & Oatmeal Crumble Bar Bar: Biscotti Ice Box: Checkerboard Cookies
Menu: Spritz, Alfajores, Checkerboard, Biscotti
Vocabulary: tuile, icebox
I have made many bad cookies in my time. It is astounding how much difficulty I have had with plain old chocolate chip. I think my main issue is that I do not like to adhere to the recipe or measure or wait at any point. I also tend to make these cookies at night and I am mostly interested in eating the dough.
In uplifting news, I have made biscotti before. The recipe I used involved vanilla and almond extract. It also said nothing about hazelnut flour. I am curious to see how the results are different between the recipes. I feel like the extract will be missed in the cookies even though it may not be as traditional.
I make Christmas cookies every year using the rolled/cut-out method.
My learning objectives are to prepare a variety of cookie doughs and batters, use a variety of make-up methods for cookies, and bake, cool, and store cookies properly and to use a variety of make-up methods for brownies, and bake, cool, and store brownies correctly.
Soft cookies are made from dough with a high moisture content and a lower proportion of fat and sugar. Eggs contribute to making a chewier cookie.
The proteins in the eggs bind and firm during baking. The moisture in the eggs helps develop gluten in the flour.
Formulas that use granulated sugar, not powdered sugar, usually bake into a chewier cookie. For even softer, chewier cookies, 10-15 percent of the sugar may be replaced with invert sugar, glucose, honey or corn syrup. Invert sugars act as humectants. Humectants absorb moisture and contribute to a softer baked cookie.
Because ovens vary, baking cookies at slightly higher temperatures than specified in a formula and underbaking the cookies slightly will help ensure a chewy texture.
Wrap baked cookies, or the entire sheet pan, with plastic wrap while the cookies are still warm. This helps them retain moisture and stay soft.
Spreading has a large effect on softness or chewiness; cookies that spread are usually crisp and crunchy, not soft or chewy(1).
Italian in origin, biscotti are twice-baked cookies served with coffee or sweet dessert wine. The dough is mixed and shaped into a log. The log of dough is baked, then cut on a diagonal into individual cookies, which are returned to the oven to bake further. This twice-baked process ensures that the cookies will have a long-lasting, firm, crisp texture.
Alfajores are a classic Argentinian cookie filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut.
“As far back as the eighth century, an early form of the alfajor existed in the Middle East. It was referred to as “alajú,”which is the Arabic word meaning “stuffed” or “filled”. It’s believed that this cookie consisted of dried fruit preserves that were rolled in dough before getting rolled in sugar or nuts. When the Moors traveled from the Middle East to occupy Spain, they brought this cookie with them and soon Spaniards started making their own version: a cylindrical cookie covered in almonds or powdered sugar that they called an “alfajor”.
When Spaniards began migrating to South America in the sixteenth century, they entered through the Rio de la Plata, which flows between Argentina and Uruguay. As they launched their conquests into the New World, they brought their traditional foods to the river banks, including their alfajores.
Soon, people groups around South America were creating their own versions, each region developing an adaptation of its own. This involved replacing the nuts and fruit of the Spanish version with fillings like dulce de leche and marmalade. They also thickened the dough to make shortbread-style cookies and started dipping the sandwich cookies in chocolate.”
Citrus Spritz Cookies- Add 0.21 ounces (1 tablespoon/6 grams/2%) grated lemon zest to the butter in Step 1.
Cinnamon Spritz Cookies -Add 0.04 ounces (½ teaspoon/1.2 grams/0.4%) ground cinnamon with the flour in Step 2. Sprinkle the piped cookies with cocoa nibs before baking in Step 3, if desired.
Chocolate Spritz Cookies- Substitute unsweetened cocoa powder for 1 ounce (30 grams/10%) of the flour.
1)Labensky. On Baking, Fourth Edition
2)https://www.alfajoresbakery.com/blog/2020/2/22/a-brief-history-of-alfajoresnbsp
(click for better image quality)
830 mis for checkerboard, mis for other 3 cookies
9 Mix checkerboard cookie dough. refigerate
930roll checkerboard, chill
mix alfajores, mix spritz
10pull out biscotti, cool
10pipe spritz, chill, roll alfajores, bake
1020layer checkerboard, chill. bake spritz
layer alfajores, dip biscotti. cool all cookies on wire rack asap
Method: The biscotti method worked well. I think the almond flour worked well and added flavor.
The rolled out cookies, alfajores, were way too crumbly. The disintegrated like an ancient mummy being dragged into the sunlight.
Taste: The spritz cookies were sweet. I would like them to be less sweet. The jam center added some tartness to the cookie. The butter in the cookie tasted rich.
Flavor: The biscotti had a nice flavor, it was nutty and strong. There was not too big of a flour flavor; I think it would have had a better flavor with vanilla and almond extract and less almond flour.
The checkerboard cookies had the most interesting flavor. The chocolate side and the vanilla side were distinct but went well together, of course.
Texture: The biscotti was a bit too hard. The spritz cookies were a good texture. They retained their shape when resting and baking. The checkerboard cookies had a very fine texture; the crumbs were small and the bites were crunchy but dissolved in your mouth.
The texture of the alfajores was despicable, as I have stated. I actually think someone in my group used almond flour rather than pastry flour. The cookies were greasy and shattered into dust with even slight movement.
Discuss the techniques that did work well.
Piping the spritz cookies worked very well. It took some effort to get the desired shape at first, but once I started to do them it became easier to get a consistent result.
The three different flavors of jam on the spritz cookies made them more visually interesting. We used blueberry filling, marmalade and chopped cranberries, and pomegranate filling.
Discuss the techniques that did not work well.
The checkerboard cookies did not turn out well. We did not have cold enough dough for one. They were still interesting to look at with the alternating colors, but they were not “checkerboard”.
The learning objectives were somewhat met. We prepared cookies, but we did not get to brownies. I think I have a better understanding of cookies upon completing this lab.
In the future, I will not use these recipes. The alfajores were too crumbly and tasted too sweet. The biscotti were too hard, dense and not crumbly enough. I will definitely use this spritz cookie recipe again.
I will also use the checkerboard cookie recipe again. I would like to try again to make the correct pattern in the cookies and I would also like to make these cookies over a longer period of time so that the dough is properly frozen and thus more cooperative.