WE FIXED IT: The Police - Every Breath You Take: The Classics
Author’s note: Yes, there has been an eight month gap between “A Man, a Plan, a Van, Refugee” and this post. No, we haven’t given up, nor have we been thinking of packing it in. What happened is that we are both dads now, as of roughly around the time Kyle, the newest member of the Dad Club, wrote “…Refugee”.
It is not our intention going forward to only write something every time Venus completes an orbit around the sun, even if that would give our site a kind of cool symbolism. We just got a little distracted by babies and winter and such. Still, timeliness has never guided Dear Jerks. We’re not here to break the latest bands about which you’ll need to say “I only like their early stuff”, trends you need to be over before anyone else cares, or twitter feuds you need to pick sides on.
Without further ado, and to prove our indifference to being relevant…
When I was a young lad beginning to accumulate awareness of pop culture, the Police were about to go out on top as one of the biggest rock bands on the planet. All of their CDs were in our house, and their music is forever tied to casual but somehow memorable experiences such as going with my dad up to Capitol Hill to see his hair guy Phil at the Supercuts on E. Olive Way, even if the Police weren’t playing in the car or at Supercuts at the time. We probably had The Dream of the Blue Turtles in the house by then, too, but I don’t think I noticed it on the shelf until the early ‘90s after it was sitting next to The Soul Cages and Ten Summoner’s Tales.
For years now, there has been a lot of 1980s love going around indie rock and pop music. What first felt like a predictable 20-year-cycle revival seems to have lodged itself into the contemporary framework as its own kind of genre. I’m not really sure how much of this love gets spread to the Police. The only band I’ve ever personally spoken with that alluded to the Police being an influence on their music was instrumental rock lords Maserati. These days, the Cure probably gets mentioned at a rate of at least 100:1 compared to the Police when it comes to millennial band interviews; back in the day the Cure were just beginning to climb out of their goth phase when the power trio of Sting, Andy Summers and Stuart Copeland were selling out Shea Stadium.
If the kids really don’t care, that’s a damn shame. The Police had some freakin’ tunes. Plus, unless you are looking to go all in, you really only need to own one of their records: Every Breath You Take, which first came as ‘The Singles’ in 1986, and then later in slightly different form as ‘The Classics’ in 2005. The Police were concise, minimal composers who didn’t waste a note or drum whack. That sense of economy extends to the number of perfect songs they wrote: enough to fill a single best-of collection. Sure, there are plenty of good and worthy album tracks, but there really aren’t too many deep cuts spread across their five studio albums that fair-weather fans truly need to concern themselves with. They struck fields of gold two to three times per album, and after that they were free to mess around.
A while back, my eighteen-month-old son began demanding that I put a CD on the stereo every day when we got home from work/daycare. Most of my CDs are in a big CD shelf, which this past winter I had to tape garbage bags around to keep said son from pulling all the CDs off the shelf and manhandling the discs and booklets. I’ll see you again someday, my plastic friends. Thus, the evening selection has been limited to what’s in the handful of folders and wallets we didn’t have to seal off. Every Breath You Take: The Classics turned up in one of them a couple weeks ago. No time like the present to bring the next generation into the fold.
Kiddo does enjoy listening to Every Breath You Take (or at least toddling around the apartment while it plays in the background), but it takes him a bit of time to work into it. After giving it some thought, it seems clear that it would benefit from a couple of minor adjustments, including one that might come across as sacrilege to fans.
“Roxanne” has got to go. Hear me out.
Yes, “Roxanne” is one of the band’s most easily identifiable hits. It was the song that first endeared them to a wider audience. It was even inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 2008. Who knew individual songs could be inducted into halls of fame?
But it is a little too slow for my son to dance to, so off it goes.
You might also be thinking that a song from 1978 about a man telling a woman “you don’t have to sell your body to the night” is preachy and condescending in 2016. I don’t want to do the Internet’s job for it, but, yes, Roxanne’s profession might be her choice and something she enjoys. I will say in Sting’s defense, however, that his lyrics often came from the point of view of a flawed narrator (the stalker of “Every Breath You Take”, the lecherous professor of “Don’t Stand So Close to Me”), so it is easy enough to read “Roxanne” as making light of the narrator who thinks he’s a hero trying to save the prostitute he is in love with. Remember, Sting notoriously bragged about being able to bone tantric-style for four hours at a time. He’s nothing if not sex-positive.
(Side note: what was the fascination with the name Roxanne in the ‘80s all about, anyway?)
Still, any such needless debate can be avoided by simply taking the song off the album. Then my son can immediately start rocking back and forth on his feet to “Can’t Stand Losing You” (another song with a flawed narrator) without me having to press the skip button.
Better yet, “Roxanne” can be replaced by the slightly more upbeat “So Lonely”, which in fact was on the 1986 version of Every Breath You Take: The Singles, though for some stupid reason it only graced the UK and European editions. It may not be as nuanced or titillating as “Roxanne”, but it is another nice dual-speed hybrid of reggae and punk, an “A + B = C” blueprint for the sound the Police were working to establish. Plus, my boy is guaranteed to have more fun stomping around to it.
The 2005 re-boot of Every Breath You Take as ‘The Classics’ was the perfect opportunity to put “So Lonely” right where it should be, between “Can’t Stand Losing You” and “Message in a Bottle”, but somehow the people in charge of such decisions failed audiences yet again. Space could not have been an issue, because the whole disc only runs an hour long, and CDs had long held over 70 minutes of music by that point. Those goons did manage to put the original version of “Don’t Stand So Close To Me” in the line-up (The Singles featured only the not-as-good “Don’t Stand So Close To Me ‘86” take), but they still tacked on to the end that lesser ’86 re-working, along with a pointless ‘new classic rock mix’ of “Message in a Bottle”. “Wrapped Around Your Finger” is the ideal closer, and those two bonus tracks also need to be tossed overboard.
Here, then, is what Every Breath You Take: The Classics, should look like. You know what? Since we’re cutting those bonus tracks, let’s slap “Synchronicity II” on there. That back end could use some pep…
1. “Can't Stand Losing You”
2. “So Lonely”
3. “Message in a Bottle”
4. “Walking on the Moon”
5. “Don't Stand So Close to Me”
6. “De Do Do Do, De Da Da Da”
7. “Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic”
8. “Invisible Sun”
9. “Spirits in the Material World”
10. “Every Breath You Take”
11. “King of Pain”
12. “Synchronicity II”
13. “Wrapped Around Your Finger”
Belll Boyyy!!!
-Ian
















