ok iâm having some #thoughts⊠what if fbi!dex and reader were dating before the whole fisk bullshit and when he went to the mental hospital, reader never visited him. he was so confused and hurt bc u told him youâd never leave him, so when he escapes prison, the first thing he looks for is u. he shows up to your apartment and sees a kid standing behind u, the right age for dex to be the fatherâŠ
Benjamin Poindexter x fem! Reader
warning: hurt/comfort, angst, depression during the pregnancy, your daughter being a little possessive over you
A/N: WAIT I LOVE THIS IDEA SO MUCH OMG???? Thank you so much for the request, I hope you like this <333
Dex remembered promises with terrifying precision.
Most people forgot small details over time. Words blurred together. Memories softened around the edges until they became easier to live with. But Dexâs mind didnât work like that. Every important moments burned itself deep beneath his skin like shrapnel he could never fully remove.
Especially when it came to you. Especially that night.
You had been laying half on top of him on the couch, wrapped in one of his shirts while some terrible late night cooking show played quietly in the background. Dex barely remembered the show itself. What he remembered was your heartbeat against his chest. The warmth of your fingers lazily tracing the scars on body. The way you looked at him like he was still human even after learning all the ugly parts of him.
âWhat if I get bad again?â he asked quietly. You lifted your head almost immediately after that. Confusion crossed your face first before sadness slowly replaced it. Like the question itself hurt you more than him.
âWhat do you mean?â Dex shrugged slightly beneath you, eyes fixed on the ceiling instead of your face.
âPeople leave eventually.â His voice stayed flat when he said it, almost detached. âUsually after they realize Iâm too much work.â
Your expression tightened instantly. You shifted upward until he had no choice but to look at you. Your hands cupped his face carefully, thumbs brushing lightly against his jaw.
âIâm not people.â you whispered softly. Dex stared at you for several seconds without speaking.
Your forehead rested against his.
âI promise.â That promise became the thing that haunted him most after Fisk destroyed everything.
Because you disappeared. Completely.
No visits during recovery. No calls to the hospital. No messages. Nothing.
At first Dex thought maybe you were hurt. He asked about you constantly during the first few weeks until doctors started exchanging uncomfortable looks every time he brought up your name. Eventually one nurse admitted nobody matching your description had visited him once.
That answer hollowed something inside him immediately. Still, he made excuses for you.
Maybe Fisk threatened you. Maybe the FBI forced you away. Maybe you thought he hated you now after everything that happened.
But as weeks turned into months, the silence became impossible to explain away. Dex sat alone in sterile hospital rooms replaying every conversation you ever had together until it drove him half insane. Every memory became evidence against himself.
Maybe he scared you too much. Maybe you saw what he really was. Maybe loving him finally became exhausting.
Eventually the worst possibility settled heavily into his chest and refused to leave. You abandoned him.
Just like everyone else always did.
The realization destroyed him more thoroughly than Fisk ever could. Because Dex loved catastrophically. His body craved you like oxygen. He was utterly miserable and obsessed with you. Once someone mattered to him, they became stitched directly into his nervous system. Losing them didnât feel emotional.
It felt physical. Like skin being ripped apart. Like he was told to stab himself over, over and over again.
So when Dex finally escaped months later, bruised and angry and barely holding himself together beneath layers of violence and betrayal, there was only one thing he needed before anything else. You.
He found your apartment just after midnight.
The building sat in a quieter neighborhood than your old place. Smaller too. Safer. Warm yellow light glowed faintly through the curtains while flower pots rested carefully beside neighboring doors.
Dex hated how normal it looked.
You used to talk about wanting normal someday. Somewhere peaceful. Somewhere without constant sirens and blood and fear clinging to every street corner.
Apparently you built that life without him. The thought twisted sharply in his chest. Dex stood outside your apartment door listening carefully before moving closer.
Two heartbeats. His expression darkened instantly.
His jaw tightened hard enough to ache before he reached for the lock. The mechanism clicked softly beneath practiced fingers. The door opened silently.
The apartment smelled exactly like you. Vanilla candles. Laundry detergent. Coffee. And your parfum in the air made it worse.
For one dangerous second, Dex nearly forgot why he was angry.
His eyes moved carefully across the room. A blanket tossed over the couch. Crayons scattered across the coffee table. Tiny shoes abandoned near the kitchen.
Tiny shoes? Dex frowned slightly.
Then he heard your voice somewhere deeper inside the apartment.
âLily, if youâre still awake, I swear to god-â Small footsteps thundered instantly through the hallway. A childâs laugh followed.
You appeared seconds later wearing oversized sleep clothes, hair messy like youâd been trying unsuccessfully to get someone into bed for the last hour. The second your eyes landed on him, every bit of color drained from your face instantly.
The air left your lungs so sharply he heard it.
âDex.â His name sounded fragile coming from you. Emotional enough to make something ugly twist inside him all over again. You stared at him like youâd seen a ghost. Dex stared back just as hard.
You looked tired. Not physically exhausted exactly.
Just worn down around the edges in ways he didnât remember. Softer somehow too. There were faint shadows beneath your eyes, old stress lines near your mouth, and despite everything crashing violently inside him, Dex still thought you were the most beautiful thing he had ever seen.
Then anger surged back hard enough to choke him.
âYou left.â The words came out rougher than intended. Your expression cracked immediately after hearing them.
Before you could answer, another figure peeked around the hallway corner behind you.
A tiny human, a little girl. Maybe five years old.
Dark curls slightly messy from sleep. Big eyes narrowed suspiciously at the stranger standing inside her apartment.
Dexâs breathing stopped instantly.
Because she looked like him.
The eyebrows. The cheekbones. The expression.
Even the way she tilted her head while assessing him looked painfully familiar. The little girl blinked once before gasping dramatically.
âMOMMY!!!!!!â Dex barely had time to process what was happening before the child suddenly shoved herself directly in front of you with shocking determination.
âMOMMY GET BEHIND ME!!!!!â she yelled loudly. âTHERE IS A MAN HERE.â
Dex stared blankly. The tiny girl spread both arms protectively in front of you like she genuinely planned on fighting him herself if necessary.
You looked one stress induced headache away from collapsing entirely.
âNo!â she shouted. âI saw this happen on the big screen.â
Dex blinked slowly. The child pointed accusingly toward him.
âYou cannot break into our house.â
Dex frowned slightly. âTechnically I already did.â
âTHATâS WORSE.â You made a strangled noise beside her that sounded suspiciously like suppressed laughter.
Dex looked deeply offended instead. The little girl squinted harder at him.
âYou look sus⊠uh⊠susbizi- Mommy what was the word for weird dangerous looking people.â
âSuspicious, baby. Suspicious.â
âYOU LOOK SUSPICIOUS!!â
âYes.â She narrowed her eyes critically. âAnd your face is weird.â
Dex actually looked wounded by that statement.
âNo itâs not,â she argued immediately. âYou look like a sad potato.â
You physically turned away to hide your laughter. Dex stared at the child in complete disbelief. Then suddenly her expression changed. Her eyes narrowed further.
âOh my god.â Your face lost every remaining trace of color.
âYou have my eyebrows.â Silence filled the apartment instantly. The little girl looked between both of you several times before gasping loudly enough to wake the entire building.
âMOMMY.â You covered your face with both hands immediately.
âIS THIS THE GUY YOU SAID WENT ON VACATION WITH PEPPA?â
âYes, Lily. Thatâs him.â honestly? what were you supposed to tell her when she asked you where her dad is. So you came up with the excuse that her father is on vacation with⊠peppa the pig.
âSo⊠thatâs your secret husband?â she asks innocently.
Dex looked equally alarmed. âAbsolutely not.â
The little girl pointed directly at him again.
âYouâre the daddy my mommy told me about.â Dex forgot how breathing worked. You looked ready to die on the spot.
Lily marched directly toward Dex after that with terrifying confidence before stopping directly in front of him. She planted both tiny hands on her hips while staring up at him with the exact same intense focus heâd seen in mirrors his entire life.
âOkay,â she announced seriously. âHere are the rules.â
Dex blinked once. âRules.â
âYes.â She pointed between herself and you. âMommy is mine first.â
You made another choking noise somewhere behind her.
âIâm not sharing,â Lily continued firmly. âEven if you are my dad.â
Dex stared at the tiny child standing in front of him issuing territorial warnings like a mob boss. Then very seriously:
âYou donât wanna share your mother.â
âNo.â She crossed her arms harder. âSheâs my favorite person.â
Something inside Dex cracked slightly hearing that. Because he understood immediately. Because youâre his favorite person, too.
Unfortunately for him, Lily apparently inherited every protective instinct he ever possessed. It was as if your genes didnât even try other than her getting your eyes.
âYou can stay!â she decided after several seconds. âBut if you make mommy cry, I bite.â
Dex nodded solemnly. âUnderstood.â
âShe actually bit a pre school teacher once.â you admitted weakly.
âHe was rude to you!â Lily defended instantly. Dex nodded again like this was perfectly rational behavior. Honestly, the fact that he seemed proud shouldâve concerned you more than it did.
The next hour passed in complete emotional chaos.
Lily interrogated Dex like an FBI agent while simultaneously climbing all over you possessively anytime he sat too close. She demanded answers to increasingly bizarre questions while Dex answered every single one with complete seriousness.
âDo you know dinosaurs?â
âWhatâs your favorite?â
Lily gasped dramatically. âThatâs mine too.â
Dex looked absurdly pleased by this information.
Meanwhile you sat frozen on the couch trying unsuccessfully not to emotionally collapse watching them interact.
Dex looked at her like she hung the moon itself.
Eventually Lily began falling asleep curled against your side while still glaring suspiciously toward Dex anytime he moved too suddenly.
Her tiny hand clutched your shirt tightly even half asleep. Dex watched her carefully from the opposite side of the couch.
Memorizing every detail about her. About his daughter.
Then Lilyâs sleepy eyes slowly lifted toward him one final time.
âYou better not go on vacation again.â she mumbled quietly. The room fell completely silent. Dex froze instantly. Lily yawned softly before curling closer against you.
âMommy gets sad sometimes.â she whispered sleepily. âShe cries when she thinks Iâm sleeping.â
Dex looked at you immediately. And the pain on his face nearly destroyed you. After carrying Lily carefully into bed together, the apartment finally fell quiet.
The second her bedroom door clicked shut, all the tension both of you had been avoiding rushed back violently.
Dex stood near the kitchen counter while you lingered several feet away uncertainly. Neither of you knew how to begin unraveling five years of grief.
âSheâs five.â you said softly. Dex nodded once.
âShe likes dinosaurs. Hates cherries. Talks a lot about wanting to build an animal farm. Thinks every stray cat belongs to her.â His expression softened briefly before tightening again.
âWhy didnât you tell me?â There it was. The question he keeps asking himself the whole time.
You looked down immediately because suddenly meeting his eyes felt impossible.
âBecause I was terrified.â you admitted quietly. Dex stayed completely still.
âAfter Fisk.â you continued shakily, âpeople watched everything connected to you. Hospitals. FBI contacts. Your apartment.â Your throat tightened painfully. âThen I found out I was pregnant.â
Dex looked physically unable to breathe.
âI kept thinking if anyone found out about herâŠâ Your voice cracked slightly. âTheyâd use her against you. Against me.â
Tears blurred your vision.
âSo I disappeared.â Dexâs jaw clenched hard enough to ache.
âI wanted to visit you,â you whispered. âGod, Dex, I wanted to so badly.â
His breathing became uneven instantly.
âBut every time I thought about bringing her near any of thatâŠâ You shook your head weakly. âI couldnât do it.â
The apartment suddenly felt too quiet. Too small for all the pain sitting between both of you.
âThe pregnancy was horrible without you.â you admitted softly after a moment. Dex closed his eyes briefly.
âNot because of her,â you said quickly. âShe was an angel. Felt like she knew I wasnât doing well and tried to not give me a even harder time.â A weak laugh escaped you through tears. âBut because every scary part of it made me want you.â
His face crumpled slightly.
âI wanted your arms around me when I got sick.â Your voice shook harder now. âWanted to tell you when she kicked for the first time. Wanted you there during ultrasounds.â Tears slipped freely down your cheeks now. âI wanted to lay against your chest and hear you tell me everything would be okay.â
Dex physically flinched. Like every word hurt him. Like you just stabbed him in his heart.
âI needed you,â you whispered brokenly. âAnd I couldnât have you.â
For several seconds, Dex said absolutely nothing. Then suddenly he crossed the room. His hands cupped your face carefully. Like he needed physical proof you were still real.
âYou protected our daughter.â he said fiercely. You cried harder instantly.
âYou should hate me.â
âNo.â The answer came immediately.
âI thought you abandoned me,â Dex admitted quietly, eyes burning into yours. âBut you were protecting her.â
Your chest hurt painfully.
âI waited for you every day,â he confessed. âEvery single day.â
Something shattered inside you hearing that. You wrapped your arms around him instantly.
Dex made a quiet sound against your shoulder that almost didnât sound human at all. Relief hit him so hard it physically shook through his body. His arms locked tightly around your waist while his face buried against your neck like he still couldnât believe this was real.
âI will never leave you again.â he whispers loud enough for you to hear.