I think it does look like Eddie, nobody else has their hair like this in Mafia 2.
If it's the Joe's adventures ending, the guy can't be Carlo (since he was injured). Who could it be? Nobody really makes sense in that scenario, and why would Henry be there with the briefcase.
I have 2 explanations of what this scene could be, so:
It's an alternate ending of Sea Gift. Why? Because Henry has got that briefcase (like the one with heroin they get from Mr. Wong), and it seems to be taking place in Millville - like a bit of the cutscene was, where Joe and Vito seem to threaten some guys elc. So, what if this is that? It seems like Henry's trying to hide from Eddie and Someone - presumably so that they don't see him with the drugs there. Obviously, Eddie (and Carlo and nobody else in the family) was supposed to know that the guys were selling drugs around the city. So I assume maybe something happened in Millville during the selling of drugs between Henry, Joe and Vito, and the local guys - hence why one of them lies dead in the pic? And maybe Eddie and Falcone (if it is Falcone) were supposed to also come there that day to do their own drug deal (which would confirm to the audience that Carlo lied about not being into drug business), but once they arrive, they see the mess there, things have gone wrong - and Carlo could get mad at Eddie for not being able to actually work the deal out before, or directly assume that it's some sort of trap by Eddie to kill him (and pretend it was a shootout between them and the local gangsters). The problem is - why would Falcone bother coming to do some drug dealing lmao, he barely really does anything - and yeah, the pic doesn't look like him.
2. Maybe it's a pic that's somehow supposed to show Henry was a rat? Maybe he was having a Secret Meeting with his FBI contant and was (almost) busted? I wonder if Henry was there with the dead guy, the hat guy, or with Eddie - and what's in both of the briefcases? Secret documents? Drugs? Money? Did Henry set Eddie up to be shot/arrested? I know that Henry wasn't supposed to be a rat in the original version of the game, so this theory is weird, but... I just don't know what the guys would be doing in Millville (apart from drug dealing).
I wonder if the guy with the hat is Clemente? since apparently this
from the opening sequence is also him - the hat would work. But I don't know what time this would be in the game then.
One wild theory that occurred to me. Apparently, in the brothel mission (Chapter 7), in the original files, you can hear some dialogues that didn't make it to the final game - one of them is about "Mr. Clemente's unfortunate death" - which is all nice, but that is not supposed to happen until Chapter 11. Unless.... he was originally supposed to die before that. Maybe he should have died before the brothel/Frankie Potts mission - as you can see, in the "cut content" video about the mission, the brothel contains all four of our guys - Joe, Vito, Eddie & Henry - and it only makes sense if they all work together at the time. Which only makes sense if Clemente is dead. And maybe Henry played some part in Clemente's death? Lets not forget the original posters showed 4 characters, and yet we never got to see the 4 guys working together!
So yeah, if we get the four of them together in a brothel, I suppose that means they work together now... How? Maybe Henry had to earn his way into the family by getting rid of Clemente. For whatever reasons. Idk. I just wish we had all four of them working together!
jimmyeatworldofficial
kianamaiart
origamiaround
blakekathryn
