Cat stayed silent as he explained the moment. It was partly to let him speak. Ellis was somebody who had a lot to say about most things, and some of the time, she enjoyed letting him ramble. Even when he was talking about things she had less then no interest in, he looked cute when he was being a complete dork, so she didn't always mind. It wasn't that which kept her quiet this time, though. Most of it was the fact that she was completely taken aback by his answer. If hers had taken them on a journey back to a time neither of them particularly wanted to relive, his made her feel a weird sense of guilt and shame. Not for the first time, Cat cringed at the realisation that her way of thinking in their first attempt at a relationship was completely off the mark.
"They were plaid," she pointed out. "Your boxers, I mean. They weren't cartoon. They were plaid." It was a seemingly trivial detail to correct, but there was a method to her madness. She wanted him to know that she remembered the moment clearly, that it mattered to her as much as it did to him. It might not have been her lightbulb moment, but it was still a special one to her nonetheless. "I had no idea that it was like that for you so early on, though. I wish I'd known." It was a bit hypocritical, given not five minutes ago she had been talking about how they shouldn't have regrets, but Cat had never claimed to be fair. "I never thought moving in with you would lead to all this. Getting engaged. God, I didn't even think I was the type of person who'd ever get married to anybody. Being with you has changed my life for the better. I don't even know where to start with thanking you for that."
It took all of Ellis's might to not respond with a dopey 'huh?' when she mentioned the plaid. Once she clarified, though, it was hard to drive his attention anywhere but towards her and her words. "They were? Interesting. Didn't know you were checking me out that hard, Cat," he flashed her a tiny smirk, letting it fade once she realized the moment wasn't fully over. He couldn't help but shrug as a response. "You know now. Plus, I think if you did know then, things might've been a lot different. Like, would I have been proposing to you in some icy puddle? Maybe, but also maybe not. It was a different version of us back then. Even with all the fucked up shit, I don't know we'd be here without it. I mean, I feel like I'd still want all of this to be with you, but I don't know if the road would've taken us where we needed to go, if that makes sense and isn't too cheesy."
Ellis found himself chuckling at the revelation that they did, in fact, start as just roommates. He pressed his lips together, fighting his inner intrusive thoughts from letting him quote 'oh my God, they were roommates' out loud. The last thing on his mind that first day was some form of romance with Catalina Silva, the girl who managed to get him kicked out of class on the regular in high school. It was funny how things like that just worked out on their own. The laughter settled into something else as he listened further. "Thank me?" he asked, as if the idea was beyond him. "You're the one who said yes to this goof, I think I should be the one thanking you. Like..." he trailed off, not wanting to get too sentimental but knowing if there was an appropriate time for it, it was now. "I had a very weird idea of what it meant to love someone before you came along. You weren't what I expected, but you were and are exactly what I needed." He paused on the sidewalk, arms winding around her waist to bring her in closer. "I wouldn't have it any other way. You changed my life, too. I'm still a big old doofus, but I'm now one with an incredible fiancée. Pretty lucky, if I do say so myself."













