TRACKING MY ATTRACTION: AN ABSURDLY CONFESSIONAL POST
The course of my future has dramatically shifted in the weeks since my last post, to the extent that that post is completely irrelevant to me at this point in time. Right now, I feel completely invincible to any and all embarrassment (though I’m sure that I will snap out of this glorious haze within the next two to three months). This current high is probably why I feel comfortable writing about the men I’m attracted to in the first place, let alone posting about them. But what sort of twenty-something would I be if I didn’t take advantage of my current mania by typing my thoughts out for the world to see and judge me by?
I’ve understood that I’ll die alone for a long time now, I’m just hoping I don’t die lonely. In my pursuit of not dying lonely, I’ve come to the conclusion that it is incredibly important for me to understand what my “type” is, once and for all. I don’t expect to actually learn much from this process–I don’t think I’ll behave any differently after this personal investigation as I’m sure all of the thoughts I’m about to write out are constantly bubbling within me and that I already subconsciously act accordingly–but I think it could be neat to see the inner workings of my brain laid out in a nice, easy-to-read roadmap of the men I am, or have been, attracted to. I think that’s enough preamble. This post has taken me over two months to actually finish due to the aforementioned dramatic life changes, so let’s just get into it.
________________________________________________________________
SHOHEI OHTANI
Starting with a softball, no pun intended.
Having a crush on Shohei Ohtani is probably the most like a normal woman I’ve ever felt. He is immensely talented, internationally famous, and an incredibly handsome once-in-a-generation baseball legend. He’s 6’4”, crazy rich, and serious about his sport. Complete jock, complete hunk.
I can’t pinpoint it for sure, but thinking back, my crush on him started sometime around the 2023 WBC. Certainly during the time he played for the Angels. It makes sense; that era of his career was probably one of the most publicized times in his life. I probably got suggested some tweet about him on my For You page and quickly fell down the rabbit hole from there.
Picking my brain more and getting to the root of my attraction to Shohei Ohtani, yeah, it’s the arms. Imagining him without the massive biceps and general hugeness, I’m not confident that I’d still be into him. So what if my attraction to him is purely superficial? He’s an athlete and I like that he looks the part. Sue me!
Let’s get this chart started with our first entry:
________________________________________________________________
ADAM SCOTT
Harsh pivot!
The humor of shifting focus from one of the greatest athletes of all time to a man typecast as "weak adult dork" in every film or television series he’s ever been in is not lost on me. I’m open to all sorts, I suppose.
Really, though, Adam Scott is more in line with my general understanding of my own type than Shohei Ohtani. Ohtani is an outlier, whereas Scott is foundational. This will become more apparent as the list goes on.
Anyways, Adam Scott.
This is a Parks and Recreation-based crush. Now, I have not seen a single full episode of Parks and Recreation in my life, but I am a dedicated viewer of the Parks and Recreation YouTube channel which posts compilations of Ben and Leslie being crazy in love every three weeks or so. From my frequent viewing of these various “Ben and Leslie being enemies-to-lovers for 14 minutes straight” compilations, I have fallen deeply in love with Adam Scott’s Ben and am experiencing emotional transference, directing these emotions onto Mr. Scott himself. Ben is employed and falls head-over-heels for Leslie, and my stupid brain is convincing me that this is real and I need to care at all about the actor these lines are coming from.
I don’t want to discount Adam Scott’s attractiveness though, he is very handsome. He seems quite dorky in real life too, which is probably why I don’t consider my crush on him to be strictly a crush on Ben from Parks. Dorky in a different way, though. I tried listening to his U2 podcast, but I just felt like I was eavesdropping in on the most boring conversation of all time.
So yeah, the looks and the personality do count, but they’re not turning me blind. Like, am I looking up scenes from movies where I know he has kiss and/or sex scenes? Yes! Am I enjoying them just because he’s there? No. I tried to watch Little Evil a few years ago and my takeaway at the time (courtesy of my Letterboxd review) was: “⭐⭐my lame crush on Adam Scott is not enough to make me like this movie.”
I haven’t seen Severance yet even though I know I’ll enjoy it because I don't have AppleTV and I left a hard drive that a boy gave me after an awkward half-date containing (I think) both pirated seasons of the show on it back home. (I never actually opened up the hard drive. There could literally be anything on there). I bring up my lack of Severance watching both as another funny “I haven’t seen this man’s most famous work” digression, and as a transition into the story of how I knew I had a crush on Adam Scott for real. It was in the spring of my freshman year of college. I saw a poster for the first season of Severance, this one, specifically:
I saw it and I thought to myself, “He literally looks ugly and I still think he’s hot.” And that’s when I knew I was done for.
Chart:
________________________________________________________________
NOAH WYLE
Now we’re entering the shame zone.
I can feel readers slipping away from me. And honestly, I don’t blame them.
Let me make one thing clear, I don’t think I would get along with Noah Wyle AT ALL. Of everyone on this list, he is the one person that I am convinced would have a downright sinister energy if I interacted with him in person. I would never want to meet him and I think we would have terrible conversation.
That being said, I like him as Dr. Robby. Dr. Michael Robinavitch is smart and capable and holds his dark feelings inside him and canonically fucks. He is also yaoi-fiable, though Hucklerobby does less than nothing for me, personally. He’s old-man hot, which is part of Noah Wyle’s charm.
Despite my spiritual aversion to him, I will say, I do find Noah Wyle’s passion for television as a medium to be very attractive. I know a lot of people online give him shit because he comes off as a crotchety old grump who’s pessimistic about the industry, and they don’t like the things he has to say about The Pitt and about its cast members leaving the show, but I think that he’s mostly correct. He clearly cares a lot about acting and about creating good TV, and being known for one role he did in the 90’s for the past thirty years of his career probably informs a lot of his less-than-completely-agreeable statements.
I don’t want to be too nice to him, though. Like I said, he is actually probably evil and I am convinced that he and I would not get along because he would secretly have awful things to say about me behind my back. Our personalities would not mix well and we would have nothing to talk about. I know this because my mom Hates him. I just figured I'd throw the old dog a bone.
Add the oldie to the chart and let’s move on:
________________________________________________________________
HENRY FROM UGLY BETTY
Alright, time to round out this inadvertent “TV crush” section. And what a man to go out on!
Now why is this entry “Henry from Ugly Betty” and not “Christopher Gorham,” you might ask. That’s because I’m not attracted to the actor Christopher Gorham in any other context. Thank you for asking, I’m glad I could clarify that for you.
Henry from Ugly Betty, what a man. He loves Betty, he has a stable job, he’s nerdy and wears cute glasses and has a great smile. Phew! I’m getting jittery just thinking about him.
I know that I could spend these lines waxing poetic about how cute and dorky he is, and how that is actually the basis of my attraction to him, but I don’t think that would capture why I like him enough to include him in this list.
Henry represents an entirely new, adult world to Betty. He works in the same building as her new job at Mode, he isn’t her super lame first boyfriend, and he is serious about her and the life they could have together.
More than anything else, Henry opens up Betty's world. When she realizes she likes him, it pushes her to recognize her own desires as valid and gives her the strength and self-respect she needs to leave her cheating boyfriend. She can want better things for herself and get them. I guess I just hope the same is true for me. I want to want things and I want the strength to accept the things I want. Maybe this crush is a bit more projection-based than I initially thought, but what are crushes if not projections of insecure longing?
Adding this lovely young man to my diagram, Adam Scott finally has a friend:
________________________________________________________________
HANK GREEN
See what I meant in the Adam Scott section about my “type” becoming clearer as the list goes on. Ohtani’s looking like a real curveball now, huh? (Haha).
This crush is super recent, and likely not super legitimate. If I’m being completely honest, I don’t get any fuzzy feelings in my chest when I interact with any Hank Green content anymore, but there was a cute three week period where that was the case. A fleeting attraction, but an attraction all the same. One significant enough that I’d feel like a liar if I didn’t include him in this post.
I think the meat of this crush is based on Hank Green being such a practiced educator. Nothing he taught me through the Crash Course episodes I watched in high school stuck, but he’s such a great communicator and seemingly an even better listener. His new series Ask Hank Anything is better evidence of those qualities than I could ever hope to provide with mere written description. It helps that he seems to be one of the most passionate and sincere men on planet Earth.
Am I specifically interested in teachers who care deeply about their job and the effects they can have on people, or am I just generally interested in people who care about things, no matter what they are? This is a very real question and I'm inviting anyone reading this who knows me in real life to excuse themselves from voicing their opinion on the matter to me in any capacity.
Have any of these crushes been weird? Me being attracted to Hank Green certainly isn’t odd by any means, but I’ve always had this understanding of myself as being someone who experiences attractions that others would deem strange. Maybe my final entry will get me back on track in that regard.
Anyways, it's chart time!:
________________________________________________________________
MATT JOHNSON
See, now this is the one that’s actually a bit serious and for that reason is also a bit concerning to me. You’re going to see in the chart that Matt Johnson is the man closest to being the full package of my intersecting attraction elements. A terrifying concept.
These past two entries stand out to me for reasons that are probably not immediately honest to any normal reader. The truth of the matter is that I am actually sexually prejudiced against blonde men, but these particular blonde men have somehow made it past my mental firewalls. I suppose I like listening to them both talk at length about their respective interests with unrivaled intensity enough that they are able to bypass my defenses.
I mentioned that I find my attraction to Matt Johnson concerning and I feel the need to expand on that. Part of me thinks that I find my crush on him concerning because it’s current; I’m writing all this while currently crushing on Matt Johnson and am desperately praying for the day when that is no longer the case. Another reason I’m not all too chuffed about this one is that I see it as an ugly manifestation of jealousy more than anything else. Never have I understood the question “do you want to be him, or do you want to be with him?” more than I have at this point in my life. It’s a novel experience and I’m not all too happy about it.
Liking Matt Johnson makes me feel bad about myself. Maybe that’s just how having crushes works sometimes. I don’t enjoy the idea that this crush feeling worse means that it’s somehow “realer” than other celebrity crushes I’ve had (ones listed above or otherwise)--they are all equally fake. I don’t actually care about any of the people on this list, including Matt Johnson, in any particularly intense or even interesting way. Clearly, I feel comfortable expressing some level of affection for them, but all in all, this rambling post has more so been an exercise in dissecting my own mind and how I perceive others than it has been an investigation into these individuals’ personas.
So, yes, liking Matt Johnson makes me feel bad about myself. But that has nothing to do with him and everything to do with me. I don’t like that I’m not as motivated as him. I don’t like that I don’t feel smart or passionate or confident enough to dedicate myself to film like he has. Blah, blah, blah, pity party for me. It’s a comparison game I’m playing with myself, which is an awful game to play, but I’ve somehow internalized the idea that continuing to allow Matt Johnson on my social media feed is healthy because I like looking at his biceps and listening to him talk about homoeroticism and the Epic of Gilgamesh. Basically, I wish I was an effective storyteller with a demonstrable understanding of the world around me and I’ve made Matt Johnson the victim of my envy.
I will say, it doesn’t help my mental health that Matt Johnson is also probably the nearest approximation of a man I could find in real life. The prospect of that does make me feel a bit parasocial and ill. My only comfort is found in the mental image of any man with Matt Johnson’s energy/demeanor approaching me and knowing that this would likely immediately ick me out. Boisterous confidence (a sign of immaturity) is, for whatever reason, only attractive to me when held by older men. Do any therapists reading feel like telling me why that is?
Get him in the chart:
________________________________________________________________
CONCLUSION (?)
I don’t believe in hell but sometimes I do wonder if I’m going to end up there.
Here are my final attraction categories:
TV dork
Adam Scott + Henry from Ugly Betty
Glasses
Henry from Ugly Betty + Matt Johnson + Hank Green
Big arms
Matt Johnson +Shohei Ohtani
Very passionate
Matt Johnson + Noah Wyle + Hank Green
What does this tell me about myself? I appreciate vulnerability–I think that’s what the “TV dork” and “very passionate” categories indicate. You can’t be a dork without being honest about your interests and you can’t be recognizably passionate about a topic without offering a part of your soul up to the public, risking judgement.
“Glasses”–I’m into guys who look plausibly, stereotypically smart. That paired with “big arms,” I guess I just want the classic “buff nerd” archetype. Is that seriously what all this writing was for? To discover that I’m attracted to jacked poindexters?
I don’t know if any of this was helpful. It was fun to write, don’t get me wrong. I like my cute little venn diagrams, but yeah, I think I was right to assume that writing this post wouldn’t lead to much other than the creation of my cute little venn diagrams. That’s alright with me, though. Writing this was pretty therapeutic and it made me excited about writing again. So I’ll chalk it up to a win in my book!














