The Parable of Ristorante Cattolico
John was a progressive man. A brilliant lawyer who graduated at the top of his class, he could have made millions practicing law but chose instead to use his degree to fight for women’s rights, civil rights and labour unions. His vote always went to the left, and his favourite quote was from Dr. King. “No one is free until we are all free.” He was married to an equally remarkable woman, a surgeon named Sophia who dedicated her career to saving the lives of others, and who annually traveled to highly dangerous countries as a volunteer with Doctors Without Borders. They had two children, ten year old twins named Mary and Mark. They taught them that all people were equal regardless of gender, faith or race and that they could achieve anything they put their minds to.
Every Sunday John and Sophia would bring the children to their favourite restaurant, the Ristorante Cattolico. On a sunny afternoon in December the family arrived at the restaurant, where they were well known. The Maître d' welcomed them warmly. “John, such a beautiful family, how are you all?” John began telling the Maître d', whose name was Jude, about some brilliant surgery that Sophia had performed that week, saving a life that many had thought was beyond saving. “Such a remarkable woman,“ said Jude, “such a credit to our community!”
The twins had been standing silently with their parents, but now Mary spoke up. “Dad, do me and Mom have to sit at the back of the restaurant again? Can’t we sit up front with you guys? Do we have to help with the cleanup again?” Jude chimed in. “Such a precocious child! So spirited.” John explained to her that this was the seating arrangement for this restaurant, that it had always been so. “But why? Mommy is smart and nice and so am I. Why can’t we sit up by the windows with you and Mark?”
Jude replied for John. “It is tradition, my child. Women have always been seated at the back. The founder of our restaurant was a man, and we feel that women are not well suited for the front of the restaurant. The manager said just last week that he would rather that the restaurant burn to the ground than change this arrangement. And there is so much ladies like you can do in the back! When you and your mommy help with the cleanup, you are performing a wonderful service for the restaurant, one that our founder would be very pleased with. And you know, when you grow up and get married, as you must, you will have lots and lots of babies, and then they will come to the restaurant too! It’s what our founder wants for you girls.”
“You listen to Jude,” said John, “And yes, some day you will have lots of babies to make sure that this restaurant is always full of people. It’s your duty.” The Maître d' lead John and Mark to a table by the window in the full light of the winter sun, and then took Mary and Sophia to the back of the restaurant to a table next to the restrooms. Sophia smiled at Jude and thanked him for his kindness. “Not at all my child,” he said, “I will let you know when we are ready for you to help with the cleanup. You are such a credit to the Ristorante Cattolica.’ When dinner was finished, John and Mark relaxed with desert while Sophia and Mary cleaned their tables and took the dishes back to the kitchen.
The next day at work, John met a colleague at the water cooler. “How are you, Peter?” he asked. “To be honest, John, I’m not great. We recently found out that our son was raped by a waiter at Ristorante Cattolico, and our neighbour told us that his daughter was raped by Jude in the kitchen. Apparently this has been going on for years, many children raped and then warned not to tell their parents. We complained to the restaurant management, but you know how rich they are, and how powerful. They said they would transfer the waiter who raped our son to another restaurant, and that they would speak to Jude in private about the other allegation.” John was shocked. “My God, Peter, that is terrible. Are you still going to the restaurant for the Christmas party in two weeks?” Peter did not hesitate. “Yes, of course. We will see you there.”
The following week, John decided to bring his 83-year-old mother along. She had been patronizing the restaurant for her entire life. ‘Won’t it be nice today Mary?” said John. “Nanny will be at the back with you and Mommy and cleanup will go so much more quickly with the extra pair of hands!”














