I have to say I support pulling ting2 out of AA (there are conflicting rumors between coaches making the decision vs. the 2nd fall on ub aggravating her back injury, and I really have no inside information to confirm either), it doesn’t matter who made the decision, the objective fact is ting2, with her current issues, is unusable for tokyo, so it is better for tang to get some more experience.
My issue is, ting2′s issue are not new. Even her mental issues are not new. She’s always had the exact same problems (block on dty, 540 on ub, going over time on bb etc) for two years. It’s not like she fell on a random turn on beam or suddenly landed on her head in a tumbling pass and everyone was like “how did she manage to do that?!”. No, people literally knew the exact skills she struggles with, have been begging for her coaches to reconstruct her routine to one she can do consistently, and those issues were never dealt with or her routine wasn’t modified in the span of two years.
There are people watching training sessions in Stuttgart saying both Ting2 and Lsj struggled with UB, so I’m not making the argument that lsj should have went up on ub. I’m just questioning that given this information, should they not have had a plan B for ting2?
Again, as much as I love ting2, she’s just not a mentally tough gymnast, nor one that can think quickly on her feet in high-stress situations. I don’t want to make excuses for her, because she lost a world medal for her younger teammates who all performed their best and might not get another chance, that will likely end up affects their futures like school placements.
But here’s the thing, not everyone can be Aliya or Huang huidan, but imagine if a gymnast is already not mentally tough, struggles in training with a particular set, and then is told you are the captain of the team, you gotta go do that same set in tf since you managed to hit in quals by some stroke of luck.
You would think if you don’t have a lot of options (the ones in the running with better ub than ting2 has worse bb or fx, better fx has less good ub/bb etc), you would create an environment to best succeed for your headcase of a gymnast.
I just feel like this house of cards was two years in the making, even if ting2 has her own issues, she will likely shoulder all of the blame.