Hi! It’s my birthday on Saturday and I was wondering if you can do one where everyone realizes they forgot Tim’s birthday but rogues remembered.
hello anon!! AND—happy birthday !!! I hope today is full of love, sweets, and the exact level of chaos you prefer !!
I made sure to get this ask done in time to post today so hopefully you like it !! <3
Tim doesn’t expect much from birthdays anymore.
Or maybe that’s the lie he tells himself to keep the ache manageable.
He doesn’t need cake. Doesn’t need gifts—just… a text, maybe. Someone remembering. A vague, “Hey, isn’t today…?” would’ve been enough.
But the morning passes in silence.
Then the afternoon.
Night falls, and still—nothing.
He's in Red Robin gear by the time it finally hits him. It’s been a full 24 hours, and no one in the family has said a word. Not Bruce, not Dick, not even Alfred. Damian certainly hasn’t—though that’s a little less surprising. Jason? Quiet. Cass? She’d probably just forgotten in the shuffle of patrol schedules and training runs.
It’s not malicious. It’s never malicious.
That somehow makes it worse.
He keeps busy. Patrols. Reports. Maintenance.
Anything to fill the space.
But loneliness is patient. It settles in the spaces between heartbeat—in the static of his comms, in the stretch of rooftops with no voices on the other end.
There’s a cup of hot coffee waiting for him at one of his usual stakeout spots, lid marked in bright red sharpie:
“Hope today doesn’t suck. – H.Q.”
He looks around. She’s long gone, obviously.
At first, he thinks it’s a coincidence. Just Harley being… Harley. But the night keeps going.
In an alley between two abandoned tenements, tucked behind a rusted dumpster and wrapped in a soft green ribbon, he finds a cloth bundle.
It’s a cloak—dark, heavy, almost leathery to the touch. Lined with deep green ivy that seems to pulse ever so faintly, breathing with the night. The vines curl and uncurl gently, like it’s alive but sleeping.
Inside, there’s a note written in neat, looping script on recycled paper:
“Don’t act like you don’t need comfort.
Let it wrap around you when no one else will.
– P.I.”
He doesn’t know how she got it to him. Doesn’t ask.
Just presses the cloak to his chest for a second before tucking it away.
On the roof above the GCPD, he finds a small box. Inside: a limited-edition puzzle he mentioned once—once—in passing, during a sting operation where he and the Riddler were forced to work together. There’s a tag.
“Happy Birthday, Boy Genius. Don’t insult me by pretending you’re surprised I remembered. – E.N.”
It’s starting to feel like a bit.
Tim stashes the puzzle. Patrols another hour.
She doesn’t say anything at first. Just walks beside him on the rooftops, silent and unbothered, like it’s a shared habit. After a while, she passes him a wrapped package and says, “I remembered the hoodie you lost. The one with the thumb holes. Happy birthday, kid.”
Looks at the package in his hands.
For a long time, he doesn’t move.
It’s not the gift that gets him. It’s not even what it is—it’s that it is. That someone noticed. Remembered. Cared enough to do something.
Tim sinks down onto the edge of the clocktower, the package resting in his lap. Below him, Gotham hums with life—sirens in the distance, headlights flashing, a city that never pauses for anything, least of all birthdays.
The lights blur a little.
They look like candles, maybe. Ones no one lit.
He thought he’d stopped hoping for this. Thought he’d built enough layers around it, packed it away under the rest of the things he’s used to not getting. But hope’s a quiet thing. It waits. It lingers in the background, stubborn and unreasonable.
And maybe he did hope someone would remember.
But maybe it’s fitting, in some backwards way, that it was them. Harley, Ivy, Nygma, Selina. Gotham’s worst, depending on who you ask. But tonight… they remembered something the rest of his world forgot.
And somehow, that makes it worse.
Tim presses the heel of his hand to one eye and laughs once, soft and tired.
It’s not everything. It’s not what he wanted.