ok so this was becoming stafford-lore heavy enough, and my own thoughts were long and detailed enough, that i thought i should pop it into its own post <3 i apologize in advance for how long this is laksdjfkjdsf but its stafford lore and i can never resist jumping into that head first akldsjafkjlsdfklj
quillington
11h
Marian firing that shot abt guin being a mom! Roderick: Le gasp! Sfhjkljfdg ooooh ~do you think Marian knows where lena was from? 👀
forgottenmarian
10h
SO i was thinking abt that more honestly, haha, and I wonder... do you think Poppa Sun was like 'hey the late queen of astaira was from Orinthian and GUESS WHAT DRAMA HAPPENED!' meaning everything w/ Lena & Rian's Dad & Dom... which idk if this was just my HC or something we decided but i'd kind of thought aria & eilia didn't have much of a relationship w/ their mom's side bc her family was rather offended/embarrassed by everything that went down! BUT maybe she's thinking that the ~bad blood between that family and the staffords (plus we know they didn't come to help astaira during the invasion!) would mean they might be good allies for the varmonts--specifically arthur ig? (marian's out here wanting to get her bb boy a naval fleet too, ig!) PLUS wouldn't it be kinda embarrassing to bring up all of that ~drama w/ Lena & the stafford brothers-- another way to sort of emphasize that bastard rumor w/ the stafford sisters AND maybe make @forgottenrian seem like a less desirable option as a potential husband for cassandra? Also Marian thinking 'hey arthur seems to like aria and she looks like her mom-- maybe one of her cousins would be a perfect stand-in!' jkjkjk XD
also YES sorry @forgottenguinevere , marian will now be trying to solidify in roderick's mind that there is nothing BETTER for a lady than being a wife and mother! and definitely to do that well you CANT be the heir to an empire!
quillington
10h
Oooooh ~interesting and now that you say this I feel like riacan probs was continuously spouting off a la mr whickham abt his many grievances and misfortunes at the varmont court, most def including the tragic take of his stolen bride! and, while Marian herself may have been a touch young to be at court then given her timeline? Certainly her relations would’ve heard and I’m sure all that ugly talk abt the Astairan king made the rounds in the ovn! So (while v skewed in riacan’s direction!) no doubt she’s heard rumors! Tho they might be dramatic enough, and we’re doubtless harped upon enough, that some ppl (ngl I’m thinking of @forgottenarthur even pre meeting aria 😂) might be just as likely to roll their eyes like ‘not this again’ now re that? But anyway!! I hadn’t considered that her fam might be put out by the whole thing but I think that’s quite interesting! In my mind it was her fam that was pushing ahead for the alliance since it went forward but it might easily have just have been whoever was the king at the time and the rest of the fam was horrified, or if they have say a parliament or smth that might’ve insisted the marriage treaty go forward or even a bad strategic situation they were in that prevented them from withdrawing, etc, even if they are strictly monarchical! I like the depth the ~slight living on in Orinthia’s memory brings to the whole bf there — that there ~are multiple sides etc. Like dom did try his best but we already know he wasn’t perfect, and he ~did marry his brother’s love in front of his ~own love (potentially was even married to Lena ~by aine depending ig💀) but yeah a scandal ~plus an ocean between them would all make sense re the sort of estrangement there! Esp given how family-oriented Astairan culture is it makes sense that there’s multiple factors coming between them there! I also like that Marian not only knows abt that drama but is actively working to weaponize tgat! YAS QUEEN!!! This reminds me! TBC
@forgottenmarian I was thinking abt it and I thought that maybe Aine ~was the woman that roderick claims dom was already married to when lena came along — and maybe that’s why arthur has ger letters w him? Where our girls might someday get their haves on them? Bc he was asked to bring such things by roderick w him? Arthur didn’t know it was research to be put towards bastardizing @forgottenarias @forgotteneilionora or anything but yeah! Twas a thought! Love that Marian’s getting a lil dig in at rian! Roderick’s gonna be STRESSING! If Rian ain’t gonna be contributing to the royal line if varmont, then he can’t go reproducing! But how’s roderick meant ti reasonable prevent that now??? Sgjkhfdgh arthur like ‘CANT stop staring at my future wife so that’s a plus! Ofc it’s bc I can’t stop thinking abt her cousin but…’ 🤦♀️💀😂
@forgottenmarian Roderick: some v solid points! Everyone knows that’s true! Eilia: ~does everyone know that? ~is that something that ~everyone ~knows…? Roderick: obviously 🙄 *Eilia looks directly into the camera*
forgottenmarian
9h
@quillington Ooooo I love that idea honestly!! Do you think maybe Roderick has had this idea the girls are bastards in his mind for years thanks to Rian’s dad maybe? Like we know he lost the throne AND lost Lena before he went back to the OVN… could Dom’s brother maybe have mentioned to people that Dom had been in love with Aine? And that rattled around in everyone’s brains for awhile? (Did
@quillington Ugh hit send too soon but could maybe lord sun have kept that lil tidbit floating around since we know he and Rian’s dad were rivals??? Still obsessed with Arthur having things in his possession that could help heal some of Aria and Eilia’s long standing generational trauma 😅 but if Roderick had thought Aine might be Dom’s actual wife it totally makes sense he would want Arthur to bring everything he could find! Side note— do you think Rian actually believes the girls are bastards????? Marian re: Rian not having his own kids: oh that’s so sad…. Anyway! 😅 I want to say jk but it’s actually so real… Honestly Aria has been through a lot what she needs is her not!bf to become engaged to her cousin! (Who in my mind could be arias twin but like an upgraded version of her 🤣 )
ok so imma divvy this up into a couple sections just bc my brain is pinging around in my skull on this lakjsdkfajsd so:
STAFFORD GIRLS' BASTARDY IN PAST OVN
ok so, i def have it in my head that @forgottenroderick , lord sun, and rian all have rather different notions on this whole ~bastardy situation and how long its been a thing, but im thinking that maybe lord sun has the biggest ~outlying position from the other two given the whole ~rivalry situation that went on -- ill get into that later
so this whole situation is also ~further complicated by the fact that, while at first they just had riacan's voice on all this, ~later they also had ~realta's who was speaking for herself, for dom, and for all astaira, and eventually presumed a future ovn queen, herself...but was also a woman (and later presumed witch)...but also i def feel like riacan was the kind of guy who beat that dead horse of all his injustices so long that after awhile everyone was kinda sick of hearing of them so like??? probs lowkey hurting his own position that way plus just like...dom ~is the king and for some time astaira was the larger/more powerful country till roderick really went hog wild w his whole conquests situation so like...dom and his ambassador's words def carried hella weight, and then later there was just the reality that @forgotteneilionora just ~was queen and there wasn't anything they could do abt that till they overthrew astaira (and roderick had heard so much from riacan that he was genuinely confused abt how inheritance works in astaira, and thought that meant they ~had to be considered legit by astaira etc)
ok so!! roderick's mind is extremely malleable to himself. what i mean by that is that the dude is a world class self-deceiver. if it suits him to believe x in opposition to y one moment? ok he does! next moment the opposite suits him? immediately he's on the y train against x and what do ou meaN he once said the opposite??? stop LYING he's always believed y!!!!!! and so forth
so, do i think he always believed that eilia and her sisters were bastards? frankly, no, bc -- and this is what matters -- i don't think he really cared???? if anything, i think he was at one time probs pr pro-dom and all his kiddos bc he was their ally, and actively looking to marry into that fam re realta, etc, but like?? more than that, i also think at one time he was hella ~against war w astaira bc he knew his dad ~wanted it, wanted astaira through roderick's marriage and kids, and that was a whollllle thing...
now his dad is dead, tho, he wants to retroactively please him/prove smth to him but like??? when he was alive??? roderick was out here to oppose him (tho from the shadows ofc). bc of this, he did NOT want to marry realta when athaulf wanted that. but, as we know, he wanted her v much ~after athaulf kicked the bucket *facepalm* anyway, as a result of all this, i do think roderick was, at one point, in support of dom, and therefore in support of dom's marriage's and his childrens' legitimacy, until some time after roderick's father was dead
i don't think roderick really ~started to care whether or not eilia and co were bastards until realta's witch-gate situation, but then he started to VERY much care. to justify himself in almost burning a woman he had loved, he wanted to villify everything abt her, including her fam. at first, he probs tried to emotionally brush the whole thing under the rug to assuage his guilt ~that way, might've tried to ask dom to send him a new bride -- which as we know may have resulted (indirectly) in @forgottenbartholomew wedding a calleary when roderick decided he wanted @forgottenmarian instead but ANYWAY point is that dom was NOT going to send one of his kid daughters there to be a child bride (tbf roderick def would've waited till the kid was grown before the marriage etc but stiLL) and/or get burned alive like his sister almost was ARE YOU CRAZY RODERICK (me: he def aint well adjusted, dom, let me tell you that!) but had to find political reasons to delay a war (which probs wasn't hard bc astaira doesn't recognize polygamous marriages and roderick obv already had his elaine and amira atp and possibly even marian too) etc
also incoming sidebar thought -- maybe roderick pursuing his daughters (even potentially @forgottenarias herself at the time since she wasn't the heir and therefore was potentially available to be a queen elsewhere) might've been a factor in dom's growing fear for aria's life? and might be part of ~why a marriage pact just ~never seems to have been discussed between dom and his daughters? he was worried abt dudes like roderick?
ANYWHO i do think when dom was like DUDE UR ALREADY MARRIED and also you tried to burn my only sister alive and provided an environment for her in which she died in a jail cell roderick was ~highly offended and then when riacan starts saying dom and lena aren't truly married he was probs like *interestinggggg* and as dom persisted in his stubbornness -- which only made roderick want astaira ~more bc that man wants what he can't have (had he half-convinced himself he was in love w eilia only to immediately lose 90% of ~his romantic interest -- still v much wants to marry her for the bloodline/to stick it to his doubters and detracters/retroactively impress his father tho! -- when she finally agreed to marry him? yeah, probably laksjdfkjsdf)
anyway, now he's killed realta and dom is rejecting him!!! and roderick has GOT to retalliate!! he starts to despise dom, starts to make ~him the villain so roderick can continue feeling justified!!!!!! and this is where he really starts to ramp up for war and part of why he went so ho wild esp ~w burning witches, when he hit astaira. it was justifying almost burning to death a woman he'd once loved (the same sort of overkill reaction ive talked abt him having if he ver learns that marian betrayed him, etc). marrying eilia is ~also abt putting that to rights -- see! i married her! its fine that she died in a cold jail cell, abt to be burned alive by her fiance, bc she didn't! she's right here beside me as my bride...
roderick def convinced himself that dom and eilia's ~reigns were invalid, and that they came from a misguided, backwards, even borderline evil country (or being led ~into evil by its unjust rule!!!!!! dom was evil!!!!!! he led his daughters astray too but by his glory, roderick can still save them if they just listen to him....) that worshipped demons and needed the clearsing light of his one true god to save them from the darkness of sin and ignorance, so really it was not only just, but actually ~righteous, of him to invade, and eilia being a bastard was probs just icing on the cake
HOWEVER, i DONT think he outwardly embraced the illegitimacy (tho he may have lowkey ~suspected it was true, and discussed it privately amongst his family!) until AFTER the conquest bc he def wanted to make it clear that he was NOT conquering astaira ~for rian!!!! this is for roderick!!!! hence the whole song and dance at the ice ball abt the great and terrible ~shocking discovery of their bastardy two full years in to the conquest (mostly hoping to take the wind out of shiv's sails at least until such time as he could recover her)
while he was arranging this convenient discovery, i think he had a fairly neutral belief abt whether it was true bc he ~also knew he was gonna reverse it to marry eilia, BUT now that he's announced it??? i think he fully does believe it!!! now, tho, the fact that eilia has accepted him, however...weirdly jdksjfkasjld...he's starting to waffle on those opions again, and is planning to reconsult those things. but yeah if/when he overturns it he'll believe that he was willfully deceived by bad acters and then he'll execute them, and then just conveniently forget the matter entirely as eilia starts popping out kids -- or that's the plan anyway (tho he doesn't fully acknoqledge to himself that there ~is such a plan bc...lying to himself...that's the source of all his continuoous hypocriacy tbqh) lkadsjfkljdsjf
ok so my thought is that...i don't think riacan started coming out w all those LENA'S MARRIAGE IS INVALID complaints until ~after his ~own wife had died?
so, my thoughts re the timeline...as we've duscussed before, i think that maybe dom and lena took some time to conceive and/or have a surviving child -- they may have frankly taken their time consummating their marriage, just to get to know eo etc? idk (i DONT think tho, if they did have other kids before her, that eilia ever knew any of them -- she's so firstborn coded re how she perceives the world etc that i dont see her as having ever been a younger child within her own knowledge) bc we've talked abt how riacan tried to carry lena off on her way to wed his bro, so i think he was still unmarried at ~that time, esp bc we've ~also discussed how there was a whole love triangle situation and yeah i do think riacan would've waited for her till she wasn't an opion anymore
so, given that rian is 9 years older than eilia, i ~do think that the minute that dom and lena were wed, riacan, feeling heartbroken and betrayed, hastily got hitched himself and quickly popped out a couple of heirs
i ~do think that rian knew his mother (which is probs where his more ~reasonable side comes from ;D) but yeah i do think she still died when he was younger? but anyway!! as soon as riacan was free again, i think he was thinking abt lena again bc i ~do think she ws the love of his life, but also atp, that she was probs symbolic to him of all that he thought he ~should have had but was ~denied by the caprice of the ppl and the adversity of his traitorous brother, etc., basically all of his own father's and grandfather's worst fears realized!!!! but he could still rescue lena and make things right and be in love and!!!!! HER MARIAGE IS INVALID!!!!!! SHE CAN AND SHOULD MARRY ~ME NOW INSTEAD!!!!!
but yeah i feel like, for rian, like...he loves his dad, he's never once questioned him etc...but also like his mom JUST died, riacan made her miserable and humiliated her by constantly talking abt how lena ~shouldve been his~ if there were any justice in the world, but he never said THIS??? and now??? before she's even cold in the ground???? he's saying THIS?????? honestly i think it was the first chink he really saw in his dad's armor esp bc, i think it ~immediately gave rise to rumors abt rian's ~own legitimacy bc of lord sun...i'll get into that below laksdjfjdsf but i think that lit a fire under rian to prove that he's EVERYTHING a stafford should be all the more and just!!! yeah!!! even now he's lowkey still fighting that fight!!!!
i do think that, even now, rian's v uncomfortable w the bastardy thing, even re his cousins. he wanted to beat eilia fair and square!! he wanted to beat her on his own merit after going toe to toe w her at the trials when she was 14 and getting beaten!!! but now his house's honor is under fire by this assertion???? and like!!!! i do not think he likes these claims!!!! it was supposed to be bc he was a man and a conqueror and eilia was supposed to surrender to that and accep it, it wasn't supposed to be a stain on his house and he shunted off to lorcan??? no this is all wrong where's all the honor he so craves and the justification he's ~always wanted for everything that was taken from him?????? why're ~more things being taken from him, instead??? this is wrong and its worse bc he can't gainsay it, since the emperor backs it! he def came into all of this w rose colored lenses on but none of it is, in any way, turning out the way he always imagined! klsdfjsdajf he's got more ~cassandra varmont~ similarities than you'd think...asldkjfskjdf though he'd HATE me saying so BAHAHAHAH
plus, there's always the threat of roderick turning these rumors against ~him...more on that later
LORD SUN VS LORD RIACAN ON BASTARDY
looove your idea that lord sun wanted to do smth w these rumors, and ive got an idea on what he might've done!!!!
so, riacan has this long standing rivalry w lord sun, as we know, and then when riacan's wife kicks the bucket, he's suddenly got a new grievance (everyone groans). he starts talking to anyone who'll listen abt how dom had this old flame and loves like that, well...
the ovn, themselves, know that these handfasting marriages can be done quickly and secretly even by the most highly observed members of society: the royal family -- roderick, himself, married secretly that way. and riacan says he knows first hand that passions like that, well, surely aine and dom were wed!!!! and lord sun smiles to himself and says 'not unlike your own first passion, lord stafford, don't you think? even after all these years, you still cannot seem to give lena of orinthia up. how binding your own first love appears to be...'
and now there're whispers, whispers that riacan, himself, undertook a secret first marriage -- to lena, all those years ago when he was ambassador to orinthia! was ~his marriage invalid? h is own assumptions abt dom seem to confirm it! are not rian and garbhan perhaps secretly bastards, themselves?
anyway, my point is, your mentioning of lord sun hanging onto these made me think...maybe he found a way to turn riacan's own stories against him? maybe he thinks (or at least whispers! idk that he truly believes it? or even necessarily actually ~cares whether its true? the suns seem like true opportunistis, ready to bend whatever way at a moment's notice when the wind blows in a way that'll suit them...) that ~rian and ~garbhan are bastards bc lena and riacan were secretly married well before lena ever even ~met dom?
RODERICK ON LORD SUN'S BELIEFS
idk if he knows ~lord sun~ is the one who forwarded this notion of riacan's invalid marriage/bastard sons, or not, but rn it suits him v much to be against this one, big time! v soon it may suit him to think differently, however. even now, deep down, he knows that when he weds eilia, it won't really suit him to have stafford heirs that ~aren't varmonts, which is part of why he's pushing rian and @forgottencassandra together, however w marian set firmly against that, well...
and, should rian ever turn against him, this is VERY handy ammo in his back pocket. he likes that rian knows this, and doesn't refrain from reminding him in little hints esp when rian was head of an army and expressing concerns re how roderick was behaving esp re astaira and astairans, a subtle little 'ive given you all that you have -- and just as easily, i can take it all away again!'
atm i don't think roderick has any thoughts that rian would DARE move against him frankly, but rian ~is in fact moving that direction tbqh ~and roderick is growing in his paranoia, and esp if he's convinced that things won't work out re cassandra, well, bastardizing rian and garbhan might come to suit him, after all...and, of course, if it ever does, roderick will grow to believe its true, anyway, bc that's just what he does laksjdfkjldsfkj
so, yes, i do def think that roderick ordered arthur to bring everything that he could ~from aine without reading it himself, for roderick to go through, etc. anything that ~dispels the idea of them having been secretly married i think is now conveniently hidden away in a private cache that'll magically be found should the eilia wedding go forward! everything, however, that seems to suggest that they ~were (i mean, i can def see where aine and dom probs at one point ~did talk abt getting married! but just...decided not to go through w it, etc, as we know), and roderick probs has those in his keeping but copies on display to be freely read etc. i don't think he's ~published them bc he lowkey knows he'll just have to hunt them down and destroy them later, but yeah, there're probs readable within the palace.
i think that anything that wasn't directly relevant to whether or not aine and dom were ever wed was probs just handed back to arthur for safe keeping as lord of kil-kennar, and there may be more ~at kil-kennar which aine had hidden so they have yet to be discovered, etc, but yeah letters that don't have any particular ~political meaning might still have intense personal meaning to the staffords...