Acquired Skill or Talent?
One idea that sometimes floats around is whether artistic talent, or any talent for that matter, is something you have at birth or if it's something you can pick up from hard work.
Not too long ago I picked up ''Outliers'' by Malcolm Gladwell. This book popularized the idea of the 10 000 hour rule. Whereby expert level skill is obtained through 10 000 hours of practice, and that some individuals that we consider ''talented'' merely found themselves in circumstances that allowed them to get those hours at earlier point than most in their lives.
With a little bit more searching, I found that this idea was based in part on a study called ''The role of deliberate practice in the Acquisition of expert performance''. This study followed groups of violinist and pianist. There were three groups studied. Best, Good and ''music teachers''. They compared the time the dedicated to ''deliberate practice''. An activity that requires some effort, is not necessarily enjoyable but is done with the specific objective of improving performance.
The study revealed that what differentiated the 3 groups was the hours spent on deliberate practice. The ''best'' practiced the most and the ''music teachers'' the least.
A similar study on chess players seemed to draw similar conclusions, in this case, study being the form of ''deliberate practice''. After 10 years of intense training and study, a level of expert performance was reached.
All this seems a little academic, but I guess in the end it offers a little inspiration to all of us by saying that if you're willing to put in the hard work, you can reach those goals you set your aims on.
The more batting practice, the better you'll be at hitting the ball, the more at bats you'll get. It's a snowball effect that works in your favour.
I'm still not going to write off the existence of talent all together, but it certainly gives you something to think about.
I do have one idea to leave off with on this whole issue. A philharmonic level expert violinist plays on a level very few reach. Great technique and artistry. Yet, what most of us like to listen to is stuff like the Beatles and Stones. 3 chord rock, technically much less sophisticated than what the violinist is doing. These bandscreate something unique that speaks to a lot of us. Practice is a big part of the equation, but I think creativity and unique artistic expression isn't found through the violionist's type practice alone.
Ok, enough rambling, time to practice ;)