the blonde nods at finn’s comments, wondering if local hero turned primary suspect jerry juke would make his presence known anytime soon. the way that finn knows her coffee order is a small reminder of how easy things so often felt around him, the way spending time together was almost second nature. sure, things had changed as they’d gotten older, especially after the accident, but as her coffee is placed right in front of her exactly as it would have had she been the one to order it, a miniscule smile tugs at her lips. annie’s nodding along to finn’s words, enthusiastic in her performance, but she chose the wrong moment to take a sip of her drink, finn’s comment about the church causing her to almost involuntarily laugh. which, of course, while trying to drink coffee, didn’t go well. coughing a bit, she places the coffee down, one hand covering her mouth and the grin that’s fighting to break through, the other waving off the couple’s slight concern.
“so sorry about that, i was a bit too eager with the hot coffee.” of course that was it, not that the thought of her and finn bringing their imaginary gaggle of children to any sort of church was too funny not to laugh about. annie listens as the couple begin to talk about their experience living in the town, raising their children there. they were sure to talk about the athletics programs offered at the high school, about their local church (which was, rather unfortunately, not one mentioned in any of their case notes or research), about the community as a whole. the blonde sips her coffee, trying to decide when would be the best time to interject. as there’s a slight lull in the conversation, she smiles. “i’m so happy to hear that you and your family have had such a lovely experience here. we’ve heard so many good things, it’s just that…well, maybe i’m a bit of a worrier, but some of the things that popped up when we were looking at articles about the town,” annie trails off, leaning in slightly, voice lowered as concern spreads across her face. she shifts her gaze to finn, eyes widening slightly, trying to hint that now would be a good time for him to ask those questions he’d been hoping to ask the locals.
it is of no surprise to finn that annie is beginning to lose her cool. really, he should’ve known that the church comment would be the thing to send her, but he just had to add it in there. finn and annie had never been church people, and anyone else who knew them would’ve chuckled at the thought as well. finn’s parents had done their best, tried to raise him in the church, but he hated it from the first moment he stepped foot inside one. he’s sure that if he tried now, he would simply burst into flames. the man stifles his own laugh, quickly molding his face to look like an expression of concern instead. he clears his throat, ridding himself of the urge to chuckle. “you do always try to sip your coffee too soon,” he replies smoothly, a small smile playing at his lips.
finn takes annie’s words for what they are: a cue to start asking what he wants to know. he wraps soft hands around his coffee cup, the warmth spreading through his fingers. “right, like she said, some of the things we’ve found are a bit concerning. maybe not for two adults living on their own, but as the two of us want children, well...” he trails off, glancing out the window for a moment. “we read some things about some children going missing suddenly. not just a few, either. i’m sure you can understand our concern about that in particular. not that i expect the two of you to know what happened, but maybe you have some insight on the safety of children around here.” he meets the eyes of the couple across from them. he feels slightly guilty, as he’s always been a journalist who prides himself in honesty and transparency, but he’s not ready to tell them why he’s asking. there are worse things he could do for his stories, and he vows to never go further. a small fib about his identity can be the worst for now if it helps them in any way.