Every damn phrase coming out of his mouth, every single second that passed with Gabriel so much as breathed beside him, made James want to stop the car and punch some sense to him. Right there, in the middle of a mission. His knuckles turned white from how hard he was grabbing the steering wheel and his nostrils flared with anger. He knew very well what would happen if he interfered with the mission just to fight.
Ι wanted to love her the same way you did.
“Well you fucking couldn’t!” The words lashed out, hitting the other like a whip. The way he tried to describe what he did as some romantic act of despair made his gut turn and twist with disgust. “You should’ve known. You fucking should’ve.” What did he think was going to happen? That he’d get to have an affair with his girlfriend without him ever finding out? And if he did, how he could live with himself at the thought was beyond him. “Oh you didn’t, huh? So you rathered fuck her in my house instead. For two, fucking, years.” He spat every word out. Whenever he stopped and tried to even conceive a reason good enough for them to do what they did, his excuses were coming short. They were in love, was the one fact he’d pretty much assumed from the get go. Still, it didn’t cut it. When you feel this way for someone you’re not supposed to, you either hold back or man up and tell the truth instead of fucking up the way the both of them did. “The worst part is, you two still would’ve kept it on if I hadn’t caught you.”
You are so damn lucky and you don’t even realize it.
As if on its own accord, his foot hit the brake and he pulled over, roughly parking the car at the edge of the road. The glare he threw his way was filled with disbelief and disgust. “Lucky?! You of all people have the balls to call me that. I looked up to you,” he scoffed. “You’re the only person I trusted with all the shit I’ve been through! But you went ahead and ruined the one thing I had that made me happy anyway.” Gabriel was the only person besides Eleanor who knew exactly what had happened to him. He knew how he grew up in a house of abuse, how he lost his childhood way too soon. He knew how his mother’s addiction led him to foster care, and that he worked his ass off to finish school while being a goddamn adult, surrounded by kids who pointed their finger at the dumb kid who couldn’t finish in time. And he damn well had witnessed the other guys at the police academy go on with this act after they saw someone join at the age others were graduating, for he was the one to tell them off back in the day. It was how James took a liking in him. Every day of his life, every good thing he had, he’d spit blood and sweat to achieve it. Opening himself up to love was no exception. Letting someone in when he’d witnessed first hand how love can blind and destroy a person, had been one of the hardest things he ever had to do. He’d done it twice in his whole life. After Eleanor left him, it took James six years to pick up the pieces and move on. With Isabelle. There Gabriel was, claiming he’d loved…both of them? Claiming he was the sad kid whose heart broke.
“Whatever the fuck you’re talking about, I don’t care to hear it. But don’t you try and blame me for the mess you two caused. If you wanted to screw one another you should’ve told me and I would’ve stepped aside.” James shook his head slowly. For the first time, a hint of sorrow glinted in his eyes. “‘Cause I’m the fucking idiot who thought of you as my brother and her as someone worth loving. I would’ve let you be happy.”
With that, he turned his eyes straight ahead and turned on the engine, hitting the streets before he did something that would get him suspended.
For a brief moment, as the car returned its movement, Gabriel felt a tinge of guilt pass through him. He allowed silence to fill the vehicle as he thought of something to say. There was this notion of unease settling in him.
“Why’d you look up to me?” He asks, genuinely curious. “Because if anything, I looked up to you.” Gabriel thought back to everything he did and this much was true.
“But I don’t see how you could’ve looked up to me when I saw you as the most admirable thing around, Blackwell. You were the one who worked so god damn hard for everything. You had the girl, both girls, mind you. You had everything that I didn’t. So the fact for a second you’d look up to me, I don’t get it.”
“I shouldn’t have. I couldn’t. I wouldn’t. I’m sorry.” He apologized, knowing it didn’t mean much now. “Screwing around behind your back was awful. We were going to tell you. I swear. But it was Isabelle’s idea to keep everything so secretive. Every time I asked her to come clean, she wouldn’t. She said just a little bit longer. I believed her. I wanted to so badly believe her. I should’ve known that no woman was worth our friendship and for that, I’m truly sorry.”
“I didn’t just lose the love of my life, I lost my brother. my best friend. if I could take it back, I would.”