Gravesend Chronicles #4: Youth, the ‘hood and Metaphysics
Gravesend Brooklyn in the nineteen-seventies was a tough place to grow up, but not an unpleasant one. Unlike the more popular Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst or Coney Island, all of which were right next door, Gravesend was less glamorous, less well known, and less important. It was -- and remains -- a working-or middle-class neighborhood, made up of immigrants from all over the map: Russian and Ukrainian expats, Chinese, Orthodox Jews, and today Latinos as well. When I was growing up there, it was mostly Italians, and Jews from eastern Europe who had escaped the Nazis. Most of my friends during junior-high and high school were one or the other: Italian-American or Jewish. We got along well, and the two cultures mixed and interacted in interesting ways, influencing one another: I learned Jewish and Yiddish insults and slang phrases from the Jewish kids (schmuck and putz were favorites), while they picked up lots of Italian street lingo and that very unique accent that places one in Brooklyn -- Aye!, how you doin'!, etc., along with plenty of cursing).
I've been revisiting the 'hood lately and there are lots of great remnants of the past, alongside recent changes like the many chain stores that have moved in, and the dwindling number of old-school specialty shops that used to line every block from Stillwell Avenue to Ocean Parkway, along Kings Highway and Avenue U. Unlike when I was growing up in this neighborhood, when at that time, as I’ve already mentioned above, Gravesend was almost entirely Italian and European Jews, today there are people from all different cultures. Even so, it has largely retained its working-class roots, and in that sense, is much the same as it was then.
Walking these streets made me rethink my own background: We were immigrants, we were working class. Both my parents worked. My mother was a seamstress in a sewing factory: it was hard work, low pay, and at the end of the day she'd come home and make dinner for my father, my sister and me.
My father worked in construction. He'd been a bricklayer and stone mason in Italy and later in Argentina. He built monuments and houses mostly -- hard, physical labor. I remember he worked six, sometimes seven days a week, but he was good at his craft and managed to save enough money to buy a house for us. It was actually possible in the seventies to be working class and still buy a house in Brooklyn. As I walked around the neighborhood, I could see the same faces, the same hard lives, the struggles the Moms and Dads have to go through every day.
I had a bunch friends on the street we lived on — Dahill Road. A few of them were very close friends, others more casual. For whatever reason, my immediate close friends were mostly Jews. This would make a major difference in my life well into the future. However, I also had a very few close Italian friends. The Italian kids were all from blue-collar backgrounds. Most of the families came from one or two generations back when the parents or grandparents came over post-war to try and make a decent life for themselves and their families.
Italy was a poor country all the way up until the 1960s when things began to change economically. Many of these kids had a lot of problems at home: abusive or absent Dads, Moms who had to work and weren't around much to give guidance or even basic sustenance to their kids, weak or non-existent parental guidance.
This would lead to difficulty in school, psychological and behavioral problems, and for many Italian kids, dropping out of school. Some got into crime, some of them died young, others eventually would straighten up. It's an old story that repeats over and over regardless of the culture. For me, this period was a sort of trial, if you will, because as a teen I was easily swayed, and often misguided.
Frankie (not his real name) was this hyper dude, a big guy with a generally sweet disposition -- if he liked you, that is, and if he wasn't having a meltdown. Frankie was a gifted mechanic, he could fix up or soup up a car like a pro. He couldn't have been more than seventeen at the time.
Frankie had a job working with a slightly older guy (we'll call him Max) who came from a wealthy family and did high-end work on expensive sports cars which he would then flip for a handsome profit. The thing was, Frankie did the actual work, but was paid peanuts, while Max
was making out like a bandit off the deals. Eventually this work arrangement ended -- Frankie was too volatile to work with, and he realized he was getting screwed.
So, one afternoon around 1975 or '76, my friend Stan (not his real name) and I were on the street chatting about movies or books or whatever, when Frankie came along. Frankie immediately started chattering about a bunch of things at once, sort of all jumbled together. Who knows what drugs he was on at the time, but this wasn't unusual behavior for him.
Stan and I knew it was often tricky to navigate with Frankie and we would generally defer to whatever he wanted or wherever his mind was going. Frankie would bring up a subject that he heard on TV or a movie that he knew absolutely nothing about, but wanted to get his head around. On this particular afternoon Frankie was quite exercised about *metaphysics*.
How he'd latched onto metaphysics, we didn't know, but Frankie had a strong need to pose a particular question to Stan, who was a few years older, very smart, very savvy, and would more or less thoughtfully answer any question anyone might have for him -- Stan was a sort of genuine street intellectual and philosopher.
Frankie's question went something like this: "Stan, I heard about this metaphysics stuff, do you know about this? You know, I want to get into this, like how can I use this on someone?" How can we use it against somebody we don't like? Clearly Frankie thought that metaphysics was some sort of sorcery or witchcraft or a spell that could be cast on someone. To say that he was a little off would be an understatement -- Frankie was off by a lot.
Stan, in his own inimitable way, moved to deflect Frankie's concerns and steer him in a different direction. Almost anything, after all, could trigger Frankie into a violent tirade.
Shortly after Stan worked his calming effect, however, Frankie started his nervous jumping around again. Suddenly, he wanted to have us over to his house for treats and sodas.
So we trekked on up to the tenement apartment where Frankie lived with his folks above a cheap jewelry store. We were a little uneasy about how all this would take shape. Frankie was in fact what we'd later call a borderline psychotic. As soon as we got into Frankie's apartment he began to yell at his mother to come greet us, then barks at her to get us sodas and, oh, did we want anything to eat? "Mom could also fetch some treats too, pastries, ice cream, whatever
you want!"
Frankie's family came over in the post-war wave of Italian immigrants that had to leave their home because of poverty, and you could see and hear that old world mentality in their eyes, their voices, their gestures, their ability to be generous even though they had next-to-nothing. Frankie's Mom obliged him and served us potato chips and cokes. This was all very awkward and I felt bad for her. She looked like she'd seen and had enough.
Frankie meanwhile plied Stan with more questions: religion, politics, philosophy and, of course, metaphysics. Stan handled himself adroitly in the face of this and deftly presented Frankie with more questions than answers, which distracted Frankie and kept him calm.
But that couldn't last: What about the people Frankie wanted to get even with? "Hey, let me show you my guns!" He runs to his bedroom and pulls out from under his bed a box with a couple of handguns, a rifle, boxes of ammo, a serious collection of knives, a black jack, brass knuckles.
Frankie hands me a pistol, and a thought came to me: Is this gun loaded? I didn't want to ask, I examined the thing and quickly handed it back to Frankie. I never did find out if his guns were loaded. Stan wouldn't touch Frankie's guns. He was, as mentioned above, the smart one in the bunch. Frankie asked us if we wanted to get a gun for ourselves and that he could help with that. He knew people. During this exchange, Stan and I kept a close eye on Frankie and we would look at each other with every word or bizarre action from Frankie with a mix of horror and amazement. We couldn't wait to get our skinny asses out of there.
AT this point Frankie could see that we weren't totally on board with his train of thought and his mood changed quickly. He threw his guns back in the box and shoved it under the bed. He said he needed to take care of some business and had to get going. He wanted us to come back soon for more chats and hanging out. "Oh and Stan, I want to talk to you some more about metaphysics man, maybe you know some books I could get about that?" Sure Frankie, let's talk tomorrow, or whenever you're free.
Out the door and down the stairs we went, and as we did we could hear Frankie yelling at his poor mother "Why didn't you bring some nice pastries or cake!?" We could hear him all the way out on the street, yelling obscenities and demands and cries of injustice: crazy talk. Again, I felt bad for his parents, who were not equipped to handle the blustering gale of mental illness screaming in their faces.
So where did Frankie end up? That's right: in prison. He inevitably pushed past legal boundaries. It was a matter of when-not-if he'd get caught. His crimes were often violent, though I don't think Frankie ever killed anyone. Over time his mental state had deteriorated. Prison, psych wards, prison again, and then Frankie died.
I think about Frankie now and then, how his family wasn't all that different from mine, how with one wrong move here, another wrong person there, I might have turned out like Frankie.
Maybe not an early death, but somehow in terrible shape. So many of the kids I knew became junkies, got into serious crime or ended up in prison. Only a precious few straightened themselves out. I like to think I managed to do that, maybe by the skin of my teeth.