What Do You Know About Yearning?
Cait was never allowed to want things like that.
“God created man for a woman, and God created woman for a man.”
The sunlight on her face. The mischief in her eyes. The euphoria in her voice. The electricity in her touch. Her calloused, soft hands on mine.
“Cait! It’s so nice to see you again.” But somehow, it kept on spiraling back to her brown eyes all over again.
Vi, short for Violet. Auburn-haired, hard-headed, and reckless. She stood in front of Cait, almost unfamiliar, with her hair cropped short and arms vandalized with tattoos. Yet, Cait still saw them running around empty corridors and sharing endless stories after class. Vi was gentle touches and secret hand-holding, with that look in her eyes that Cait never looked for any boy in her life.
“In the Sacrament of Matrimony, only a man and a woman are united into one flesh under a sacred covenant with God.”
Vi was a reminder of what she had lost and what she’d continue to lose.
“You know, it’s funny how we only ran into each other now after so long. I was actually hoping to see you when I moved back here. We didn’t exactly have a proper goodbye.” God, it was almost like the universe was pulling a cosmic joke on her.
How could Cait ever admit that she was the reason why their friendship fell apart?
Cait remembered it all too well; how they lost contact after middle school, how she ignored Vi’s stares and attempts at small talk before graduation, and how their falling out was her entire fault.
Vi, who liked to punch the boys in their class but was always tender with Cait. Vi, who always listened to her stories and showed her the best spots around their school. Vi, who held her hand when she was nervous and gave her the biggest hug when she got her first big school award. Vi, who only put her arm around Cait’s shoulder, not knowing that her wood sage scent and her electrifying touch sent Cait on an emotional breakdown of conflicting feelings and beliefs.
Vi, who Cait had and then lost because she concluded that she wasn’t allowed to want things like that.
She wasn’t allowed to want her like that.
How could she ever tell Vi that that one moment of intimacy between the two of them sent her heart spiraling to the skies until it fell down into dread?
What are you so afraid of, Cait?
“Though we support our homosexual brothers and sisters, we have to remember that homosexual acts are still against the teachings in the Bible.”
“This might sound weird, but you were my first love.” But Vi, who was now sitting across from her with a hot cup of coffee in her hands, still looked at her with the same wonder and awe in her eyes as when they were twelve and sharing stories.
She felt it again, the electricity in her veins and her heart soaring inside her chest. But she also felt the same fear pooling in her mind, telling her, “No. No. No. Don’t give in.”
“First love? Me? But… I’m a girl.” So, the rehearsed script came out of her mouth.
Vi’s face fell, but she still put on a small smile that didn’t quite reach her eyes. “Well, you don’t force yourself to fall in love, Cait. It’s supposed to come to you naturally. You just look at that person, and it instantly clicks in your head. Girl or not. And for me, it was you.”
What did Cait know about yearning, anyway? She could recognize the look of love or admiration from all the boys she’d dated before, but it never made her feel anything as strong as this.
Vi’s eyes looking at her made Cait want to claw herself out of her own body. If she could put a name on that look in those familiar brown eyes, she knew it could only mean one thing.
And it scared her.
Vi softly laughed. “Don’t worry, I’m not going to try anything. I know you’re straight and all that.”
“I also have homosexual friends, but they’re good because they don’t give in to the sinful temptation of homosexual activity.”
Why was it so terrifying to go against everything you’ve been conditioned to believe in?
But why should she be scared of the good things?
Cait was never as courageous as Vi. She was afraid of the possibility, afraid of the truth, and afraid of the only real thing she’s ever felt. She had severed her connection with Vi before, buried herself in denial, and held other boys’ hands, wishing they were hers instead. She had read romance novels, fantasized about a husband, and obsessed over cute guys like other girls. Still, in the depths of her mind, she dreamed of Vi’s crooked teeth, messy hair, soft smile, playful smirk, and gentle touch that were always reserved for her. In denial, nonetheless.
“You will find love when you find him.”
But Vi was here now. Right in front of her with crooked teeth, soft smiles, and everything she ever wanted.
If Cait could ever begin to think about wanting something more than what she was supposed to want from Vi, from a girl, would it be alright? Would God still love her? Would she still go to heaven? Would all her Sunday masses and nightly prayers go to waste if she chooses to follow love?
“How about you, Cait? Do you have a first love?” Wanting. Yearning. Loving.
What was so wrong with loving her?
Vi stared at her so intensely with an unreadable look on her face. Cait received it. “Maybe.”
If it was wrong, why did it feel right?
“Being gay is a sin. You will go to hell for liking a girl.”
Then, it clicked.
Cait only realized one thing at that moment: If loving Vi would make her a sinner, she’d gladly go to hell.















