How we choose our opinions
I’m pretty left-leaning, but there are certainly times in my life when I have supported the conservative side of an issue. Here are some examples of opinions I’ve held at different points in my life:
1. DEI shouldn’t exist. People should be getting jobs strictly based on merit, not just because they’re of a certain group. Favoring one group artificially is racism. Plus, DEI isn’t even being done out of the kindness of our hearts. It’s being done because corporations want to look sensitive and caring for the public eye
2. Non-white Santa dolls shouldn’t exist. Santa was a real historical figure who did actually exist, and he was white
3. Gay marriage shouldn’t be legal. The mother and father are naturally different in temperament, so they naturally balance eachother out and cover eachother’s weaknesses. I worry that children growing up in gay households may experience more unhealthy family dynamics
4. Trans athletes shouldn’t compete with cis athletes because weight class, muscle mass, body profile, bone density, and lung capacity, among other things, would certainly give one an unfair advantage over another
However, the instant I learn more about any issue, I always switch to the left side
1. Hiring purely based on skill and merit seems ideal, but it is actually unfair as well because many races and ethnicities in America still face discrimination. This discrimination makes it hard for them to get good education and good opportunities, which is 100% not their fault nor their choice. This is a circular problem: people are in poverty, so they can’t afford a good education, so they can’t get opportunities, so they stay in poverty, so their children can’t get opportunities, and it just keeps going like that forever. This is not fair. If the only way to break the cycle is to reserve opportunities for people who could be just as skilled but never even had a chance, then so be it
2. Santa today isn’t anything like the real historical Santa. Santa today is a figure of generosity, mercy, and joy, and while that is true of the real Santa too, the real one didn’t fly around on a sleigh pulled by magic reindeer delivering presents to the entire world in one night. Santa today is a mythical figure, not a real one, and children of all races deserve to have such a wonderful and generous figure to look up to, and more importantly, one they can identify with. If it makes a child happy to think that Santa, one of the most universally beloved characters, is the same as them, then why on earth shouldn’t we let them think that and be happy?
3. Homosexuality has been observed in over 1500 animal species. The question people always ask is, if gay people can’t reproduce, then why hasn’t homosexuality evolved away yet? The answer is that homosexuality serves a very important function in the animal kingdom. If a female penguin finds a suitable mate, she’ll lay an egg with him. If she finds a better mate, she’ll abandon the egg. This happens literally all the time. This behavior of acting against their species’ own best interest would’ve made penguins extinct by now, were it not for the gay penguins, who swoop in to take care of the abandoned egg. This is what gays do in the animal kingdom: they exist to take care of those who got left behind, the orphans. The foster system is overloaded as it is, and every child deserves a loving home. Who are we to decide that absolutely none of the millions of same-sex couple on earth could be suitable for that?
4. People say “oh couldn’t Mike Tyson just claim to be a woman?” The answer is no, and there are two reasons: one for the right, and one for the left. For the right, neither Mike Tyson nor any self-respecting athlete would even consider doing that. Imagine being a man who’s too cowardly to take on other men. Society would hate you, and the industry would ostracize you. For the left, people have been cut out of their families for coming out as trans. Trans people face all kinds of discrimination and systemic issues every single day. You think saying you’re only pretending to be trans would make that all go away? No! It would make the world hate you even more, because people see that as making fun of a very serious issue. Pretending to be trans to beat up cis women is never under any circumstances worth it. It’s like spending a million dollars to earn a hundred
I draw two conclusions from this
First, there is a term called the “Diploma Divide”: people with a college education are more likely to vote left on any given political issue, while people who didn’t go to college or didn’t finish highschool are more likely to vote right. There is a stark, noticeable, and consistent contrast between the two demographics and how they vote. We’re seeing this in action with me: when I was 15 or younger, I was uninformed, so I supported the side that made sense to my simple brain, for the one and only reason that I didn’t have a good perspective on the issue, because I was missing a ton of crucial information. Trump still won twice, so it’s not like the Diploma Divide is making any meaningful difference in society, but it’s still a moral victory: it shows that the left is the side of reason and intelligence, while the right is the side of rage and misunderstanding
Second, changing your opinion when you get new information is 100% okay, and is actually the correct and necessary thing to do. What kind of egotistical donkey is too stubborn to change their opinion in the face of literal indisputable facts? Society portrays someone who changes their opinion as a traitor, because we’ve developed such a stigma around doing anything that even comes close to admitting that you were wrong. But how can you expect everyone’s first impressions to be correct 100% of the time? Changing your opinion doesn’t make you a hypocrite. If you’re only looking at a situation from one angle, you’re missing most of it. You have to see it from multiple different angles in order to observe stuff that was previously hidden to you