Who are your favorite actors for each role? (In other words. What would be your ultimate cast?)
Some context for anyone who doesn’t know: I have seen Hamilton 29 times in 4 different cities: New York, San Francisco (Angelica Tour), Chicago, and London. I have never seen the same cast twice, even if it’s just a change of ensemble. (I have literally gone to see a show just to see certain swings on in certain tracks.) But, I have not seen literally every iteration possible and have definitely slowed down in my Hamilton-going habits in the last year. I also did not see the full OBC (only Anthony, Chris, Oak, and Jasmine, so this does not 100% take them into account, which imo makes it a bit more interesting).
Disclaimer: Each and every person who is in Hamilton has been cast for a reason. They are all incredibly talented, and I don’t want this to be seen as objective rule or me bashing other actors. It is not. This is all very subjective and based on my personal tastes. That being said, I do think it is interesting to see how different people view this show, which is why I am doing this.
Alexander Hamilton: Michael Luwoye (NY/Angelica Tour)
Runner up: Miguel Cervantes (NY/Chicago)
Eliza Hamilton: Julia K. Harriman (Angelica Tour/And Peggy Tour)
Runner up: Syndee Winters (NY)
(I haven’t seen Jennie in this role, but knowing she’s a fucking goddess I’m sure i’d want her to play Eliza too.)
Aaron Burr: Gregory Treco (NY/Chicago)
Runner up: Nik Walker (very close) (NY/Philip Tour)
Angelica Schuyler: Jennie Harney (Universal Standby) (If this was physically possible. Since it’s obviously not and her Peggy/Maria is to die for, I’d go with Mandy Gonzalez (NY))
Runner up: Syndee Winters (NY)
George Washington: Christopher Jackson (NY, OBC)
Runner up: Obioma Ugoala (London)
Marquis de Lafayette/Thomas Jefferson: Jordan Donica (Angelica Tour)
Runner up: Chris Lee (Chicago/Angelica Tour)
Hercules Mulligan/James Madison: Okieriete Onaodowan (NY, OBC)
Runner up: Tarinn Callender (London)
John Laurens/Philip Hamilton:
Anthony Ramos (NY, OBC) as Laurens
Anthony Lee Medina (NY) as Young Philip
Jordan Fisher (NY) as Older Philip
If I had to pick just one: Anthony Ramos (NY)
Runner up: Jordan Fisher (NY)
Peggy Schuyler/Maria Reynolds: Jennie Harney (Universal Standby)
Runner up: Jasmine Cephas Jones (NY, OBC)
King George: Alexander Gemignani (London)
Runner up: Taran Killam (NY)
Obviously, I didn’t include the ensemble tracks, but if you want to see those, I might take the time to write it up.