unbearablyblackâ:
âItâs not that simple,â Sirius presses, shaking their head. Theyâre fighting the urge to get angry, their hands, apart from Lilyâs now, clenched into fists in their lap. Their nails dig into their palms, painfully so, and yet they donât loosen their grip. They donât want to argue with her, especially not about this, but they knew she wouldnât understand. If her words arenât enough of a giveaway already, the look on her face and the tone of her voice do the trick. Terrorists. They suppose sheâs right, but that doesnât make the word sting any less. They wince at it, like a slap in the face.
All their life, they were conditioned to believe that blood was thicker than water. Even with their love for their friendsâ they would do anything for them, even before all thisâ Sirius believed it to be true. Above all else, they were a Black, the Black, the once-upon-a-time heir to an ancient line of witches and wizards.Â
The Noble and Most Ancient House of Black. Thatâs what they were. Thatâs what Sirius was, could have been. Theyâve lied awake many nights since James died thinking about how easily they mightâve been on the other side of the war, fighting alongside their brother and cousins. Perhaps if they hadnât met James, standing in line for the Sorting Hat thirteen years ago. Perhaps if theyâd been Sorted into Slytherin, like the rest of their family. Perhaps, perhaps, perhaps. Theyâve run a thousand likely scenarios in their head. It scares them how easily one little trick of fate couldâve made them someone else entirely.
Sirius is realizing only just now how much they and Lily donât know about one another. Then, immediately after: how much sheâd hate them if she did.
Is it vengeance? Absolutely. James was ripped from them, Sirius and Harry and Lily all at once, unfairly and far too soon. But itâs much more than that, too. Fighting this war is redemption, for not being there to protect their friends, their own twisted way of asking James for forgiveness, to assuage their guilt, to protect Lily and Remus and Harry and everyone else left in Godricâs Hollow from meeting the same fate. Maybe, after all that, theyâll feel whole again.
âNone of it is.â Sirius has already admitted they were wrong. If they could tell Lily whatever she wanted to hear, they would, but they donât know what that is. âI wish I had such clear an idea of right and wrong as you did,â they say instead, uncurling their fists, âbut I didnât. Iâm sure whatever it is you grew up learning, I was taught the opposite.â They sigh heavily, their shoulders slumped, looking like a defeated dog. âI donât know what to say, Lily. I know Iâve made a lot of mistakes. Iâm trying my best here.â
The poetic thing: to soften, to stave off the argument and reclaim their hands in hers, to accept the effort and forgive the mistakes. Thatâs what might happen if this were a book, or if Lily were someone else, James perhaps. Lily is not soft. She used to want to be.
But sheâs like Petunia: flinty, with sandpaper where a soft palate should be. She rises to anger too easily; motherhood and grief may have dampened her reaction time, but the reaction itself has not changed.
By now, James would have stepped in. Clarified for her what Sirius was saying, put it in terms that made sense for her, a Muggleborn with no concept of being raised in a pureblood supremacist household. To Lily, it is like hearing my parents are racist, and even after I learned that was wrong I chose not to stand up to them for you. Itâs like hearing Mudblood from your best friendâs mouth.
And sheâd turned her back on Severus then, and itâs only Jamesâ ghost at her shoulder keeping her from doing it to Sirius now.
âI know youâre trying,â she says, and sheâs trying too, trying to keep her voice gentler than she feels. Sheâs failing and her throat hurts from the tension. âCan we--can we keep talking about this when you get back?â There, something: something for them to hold onto. Something for them to come back for.









