ECHOES OF NIGHT - PART 2 - CHAPTER TWO
Pairing: dad! Noah Sebastian x reader
author's note: Once again, I'm so thankful for all the support EON part 2 is receiving, thank you so much for all the love!!
The kitchen feels smaller tonight, even though nothing has changed about the space itself. The same wide island where Kara once stood on tiptoes to “help” stir pancake batter two years ago, the same fridge covered in her evolving artwork: purple family portraits that have grown more detailed with time, with stick-figure versions of you, Noah, and herself holding hands under increasingly elaborate suns, complete with bees buzzing overhead and sparkly rain boots on everyone’s feet. You stand at the island now, arms wrapped tightly around your middle, fingers tracing the edge of her latest drawing like it might anchor you to the present and quiet the whirlwind in your chest.
Dinner is long over. The house has settled into that gentle post-tour hush you’ve come to crave after months of rumbling equipment trucks, echoing arenas, and the constant low buzz of life on the road. The low hum of the fridge, the faint creak of floorboards upstairs where Kara is finally asleep after demanding three stories and an extra song about brave bees, the distant murmur of the city beyond the windows. Noah wipes down the counters with slow, deliberate movements, giving you time. He always does that now. He’s learned when to push and when to wait, just like you’ve learned how to let him in without the walls slamming shut out of old habit.
You’ve been thinking about his words since he said them earlier in the golden afternoon light, the quiet confession that had settled deep in your bones: I want another baby with you.
“I’ve been thinking about what you said,” you start, your voice soft but carrying that heavier edge you can’t quite hide tonight. The words feel heavy on your tongue, laced with two years of love, growth, and the lingering shadows you’ve never fully outrun.
Noah sets the dish towel down and turns to face you fully. His boba eyes meet yours across the island, a flicker of hope and nerves twisting there in equal measure. He leans against the opposite side, arms resting on the cool granite, giving you space but clearly aching to close the distance. “Yeah?”
You exhale shakily, finally meeting his gaze head-on.
The last two years flash through your mind in a rush of vivid snapshots: the chaotic move from Oregon to LA, where Kara’s eyes had lit up like stars at the sight of her new room with the bee-themed walls you’d painted together late into the night while Noah steadied the ladder and cracked jokes to keep her giggling; the first full tour where you officially stepped into the role of the band’s merch coordinator, juggling inventory spreadsheets on your laptop in green rooms while keeping a curious toddler entertained with sticker charts and stories about “tour bus magic”; the quiet nights in cramped hotel rooms where Noah would collapse beside you after shows, sweat still clinging to his skin, pulling you close like you were the only thing keeping him grounded amid the chaos of screaming crowds and endless travel.
Kara has grown so much in that time, her routine now a beautiful, chaotic rhythm you’ve all settled into like a well-worn favorite song. Mornings start with her bounding into your shared bed (or the tour bus bunk when you’re on the road), her wild curls a halo around her sleepy face as she demands “Daddy pancakes with extra smiley faces and chocolate chip eyes.” Noah makes them religiously whenever he’s home; sometimes deliberately burning the edges just to hear her dramatic giggles and declarations that “they’re adventure pancakes now!”; School drop-offs are followed by backyard adventures where she rules over her stuffed animal kingdom like a tiny queen, narrating epic battles between Bee, Bun-Bun, and whatever new plastic dinosaur she’s claimed as Sir Stomp that week. Evenings wind down with storytime, her little body curled against Noah’s chest as he does all the voices with theatrical flair, her insisting on “just one more chapter, Daddy, please” until her eyelids grow heavy and she drifts off mid-sentence about brave bees flying to the moon.
She’s bolder now, more confident than the three-year-old who once poked his neck tattoos with wide-eyed judgment in that grocery store aisle. She’s learned to swim without floaties in the backyard pool, proudly showing off to her “uncles” during visits and earning cheers that make her beam with pride. She’s started asking deeper questions during car rides or quiet moments; why Daddy has to leave sometimes for “big stages with loud lights,” why the fans scream his name like he’s a superhero, why she has his nose but your smile. Two years of watching her bloom has been everything you never dared dream of. And yet the fear still lingers, sharp and insistent, like an old scar that aches when the weather turns.
“It’s not that I don’t want it,” you continue, the words tumbling out in a rush now that the dam has cracked. “God, Noah, part of me does. so much. Watching you with her these last two years… the way she lights up when you walk through the door after a long day at the studio, how you’ve become her safe place, her storyteller, her superhero who makes ceiling pancakes and sings the bee song perfectly off-key even when you’re exhausted from rehearsals… it makes me ache for more of that. For us to give her a sibling to boss around and protect. For you to have all the firsts you missed: the kicks, the cravings, the overwhelming joy of that first cry in the delivery room.”
You pause, swallowing hard against the lump in your throat. Your gaze drops to the floor, tracing the familiar grain of the wood you’ve walked a thousand times during late-night feedings or anxious pacing when Kara had nightmares after a particularly loud show.
“But I’m scared. Really scared.”
The words land heavy in the quiet kitchen, thick with the weight of everything unsaid. You see the way Noah’s shoulders tense slightly, a flicker of hurt crossing his handsome features before he schools it into something gentler. He steps closer but stops just short of touching you, leaning against the island, his hands flexing at his sides like he wants to reach for you but is giving you the room you need.
“Talk to me,” he says gently, though his voice carries that raw undercurrent you’ve come to recognize as the place where his own vulnerabilities live. “What are you scared of, babe? All of it. I want to hear it.”
Your fingers tighten on your arms until your knuckles whiten. The memories flood in unbidden; the raw panic of those early pregnancy days alone in your old bathroom, staring at those two pink lines while your world tilted on its axis; the bone-deep exhaustion of solo parenting through colic nights and teething fevers while wondering if you were enough; the quiet tears in the shower so Kara wouldn’t hear you breaking. “Everything,” you whisper. “I’m scared of doing it again, the pregnancy aches, the exhaustion that makes you feel like you’re moving through molasses, the fear that something could go wrong and I wouldn’t know how to fix it. But mostly… I’m scared of what it would mean for us. For Kara. For you.”
You look up at him, eyes glistening with unshed tears. “These last two years have been this beautiful, hard-won balance. We finally got to a place where the distance doesn’t tear us apart anymore. You chose us over the tour when it mattered most, flying home in the middle of everything because Kara needed you. You’ve been here for the tantrums in the green room, the milestones like her first lost tooth on stage side, and the late nights when she wakes up scared from a bad dream. Kara’s routine is stable now, but another baby… it changes everything again. Sleepless nights multiplied, endless diapers, the constant worry that you’re not splitting yourself evenly enough between them. What if the label pushes back harder next time, saying a family of four is too much for the road? What if touring with two kids becomes logistically impossible? What if I can’t be the merch girl and the present mom at the same time without dropping something important?”
Your voice cracks on the last words, raw and trembling. “And what if… what if you realize it’s too much? I kept Kara from you for three years because I was terrified you’d leave or resent me. I built those walls high because I didn’t trust that you’d stay through the hard parts. Now we’re here, and it’s good; so fucking good, with our routines and our little traditions and the way Kara calls you Daddy like it’s the most natural thing in the world, but part of me still waits for the other shoe to drop. Another baby would mean trusting you with even more of my heart. Trusting that you won’t miss the important parts this time, even when the world and the tours and the expectations pull at you from every direction. I know that’s unfair. I know you’ve proven yourself over and over, showing up in ways I never dared hope for. But the fear is still there, Noah. It lives in me, quiet most days, but loud when I let myself imagine it all again.”
Noah’s jaw tightens visibly.
Sadness blooms sharp and deep across his features; not anger, never anger directed at you, but a quiet, aching hurt that settles in the lines around his eyes and makes your chest constrict painfully. He looks away for a long second, jaw working as he processes the sting of it: the implication that after everything, after choosing you both, after putting his name on her birth certificate, after two years of showing up, he still carries some shadow of that old doubt in your heart.
“I get it,” he says finally, his voice low and rough, like the words scrape against something tender inside him. He meets your eyes again, and the raw vulnerability there nearly undoes you completely. “I do. You carried her alone for so long. You made every hard choice by yourself because you didn’t trust me enough to let me in back then. And now… even after I flew home in the middle of a tour, dropping everything because she was sick and you were falling apart, even after I put my name on her birth certificate and fought for both of you, even after two years of choosing you both every single day, some part of you is still waiting for me to disappear when it gets hard again.”
You feel your face crumple, fresh tears burning hot behind your eyes. “Noah-”
“No, let me finish, please.” He steps around the island, stopping just short of touching you, though his hands flex at his sides like every instinct is screaming to pull you close. “It hurts. It hurts because I love you so much it feels like my chest is cracking open sometimes, like there’s not enough room for how big this feeling is. Because Kara is my whole world, the greatest gift I never knew I needed, and the idea of another little one… God, I want it so bad I can taste it. I want to be there for the cravings and the ultrasounds and the 3 a.m. feeds where I’m the one rocking them while you finally get some sleep. I want to watch you grow round and glowing and exhausted with our baby and know I’m not missing a single second of it. I want Kara to be the best big sister in the world: bossy and protective and full of love, teaching them all her bee facts and how to make Sir Stomp dance.”
His voice wavers, the sadness deepening into something exposed and achingly tender. “But I understand why you’re scared. I do. I missed so much of her beginning. You had to be strong enough for both of you when I wasn’t even a thought in your life. That fear you carry? It makes complete sense. It’s not unfair, it’s what kept you and her safe for years when you had no one else. I just… I wish you could see how much I’ve changed. How much we’ve changed together. I’m not the guy who left after one night anymore, chasing a dream that didn’t include diapers and midnight feedings. I’m the one who wants to build a life with you. The one who would burn every tour date to the ground if it meant being here when you need me. The one who lies awake some nights just listening to you both breathe because it still feels like a miracle that I get to do that.”
Tears slip freely down your cheeks now. You reach for him then, hands fisting in the soft fabric of his hoodie, pulling him close like you need the solid warmth of him to steady the storm inside you. Noah wraps his arms around you immediately, one hand splaying across your back while the other cradles the back of your head, burying his face in your hair. He holds you like you might slip away, like he’s afraid the fear might pull you under if he lets go even for a second.
“I’m sorry,” you whisper against his chest, your voice muffled and thick with emotion. “I do trust you. I trust you more than anyone in this world. You’ve shown me over and over what that looks like. But becoming a mom again… it brings it all rushing back. The panic of those first months alone, staring at pregnancy tests in a campus bathroom while my whole future shifted. The nights I cried in the shower because I was terrified I wasn’t enough for her, that I was failing her by giving her only half a family. The fear that one day you’d wake up and realize this life wasn’t what you signed up for when you met a nervous girl at a show four years ago and invited her back to your hotel room just to talk.”
Noah pulls back just enough to cup your face in his hands, his thumbs gently wiping away the tears tracking down your cheeks. His own eyes are wet, glistening in the soft kitchen light, the sadness lingering there but softened by the deep, unwavering love that has always won out between you. “I signed up for you,” he says fiercely, his forehead resting against yours, breath mingling warm and steady. “All of it. The beautiful parts and the terrifying ones. The late nights and the laughter and the fear. I missed Kara’s beginning, and that ache will always be there, a quiet shadow in the corner of my heart. But I’m not missing ours. Not this time. Not ever. If you’re not ready, we wait. We take all the time you need. If you decide you never want another, I’ll love the family we have with everything I am, Kara, you, our routines, our imperfect perfect life. But if even a small part of you wants this too… I’m here. Every craving. Every fear. Every joy. Every 3 a.m. feeding and every milestone. We do it together, love. No more oceans. No more waiting on the other side of a screen. Just us.”
You stand like that for a long time, wrapped in each other in the quiet kitchen, the weight of two years of healing and growth and lingering scars settling between you like a shared blanket. Upstairs, Kara sleeps soundly in her room, dreaming of bees and big sisters and the family that finally feels whole and unbreakable.
Later, after Noah has slipped upstairs to check on her one more time; his low, murmured goodnight carrying faintly down the hall even though she’s already deep in sleep, you slip into the guest room with your phone, needing to hear your mom’s voice. She answers on the second ring, warm and steady like she always has been, the familiar anchor you’ve leaned on through every storm.
“Hey, sweetheart. How’s my grandbaby doing after that tour? She sounded so excited in her last video about the pool adventures.”
You sink onto the edge of the bed, knees drawn up, and the words spill out before you can stop them; the conversation with Noah in the golden afternoon light, the raw ache in his eyes when he talked about the firsts he missed, your own swirling fears that feel both valid and unfair all at once. You tell her how much you want it too, how the idea of another baby with him fills you with a terrifying, beautiful longing that makes your chest tight. How you can already picture Kara as a big sister: protective and bossy and full of endless love, teaching a little sibling all her bee facts and how to make Sir Stomp dance in the backyard. How Noah has been everything you never dared hope for these past two years: present, patient, choosing you both even when the label grumbled and the tours pulled.
But the fear is still there, sharp and insistent, refusing to be ignored. The panic of those early days alone. The exhaustion. The worry that you won’t be able to balance it all again without something cracking.
Your mom listens without interrupting once, her breathing steady on the other end of the line. When you finally run out of words, she sighs softly, the sound full of maternal understanding. “Oh, honey. Wanting it and being scared don’t cancel each other out. They can live in the same heart, side by side, fighting for space. You’ve carried so much alone for so long. It makes complete sense that trusting him with even more of that responsibility, with another piece of your heart, feels huge. It brings back all those old shadows, doesn’t it? The nights you wondered if you were enough, if you were failing her by giving her only one parent.”
You nod even though she can’t see you, fresh tears slipping free and tracking down your cheeks. “It does. I keep remembering how terrified I was back then, staring at those two pink lines and knowing exactly who the father was but too scared to reach out. And now… I want this with him. I want to see him experience it all; the first kicks, the cravings, the joy of holding a newborn. I want Kara to have a sibling to love and protect. But what if it’s too much? What if the fear wins again and I push him away without meaning to?”
“That fear doesn’t make you weak, sweetheart,” your mom says gently, her voice wrapping around you like a warm blanket. “It makes you human. And from everything you’ve told me these past two years. how he flew home mid-tour when Kara was sick, how he’s been there for every milestone since, how he looks at you both like you’re his whole universe, he’s shown up. Every single time. Maybe this is the next step in trusting that he always will. You don’t have to decide tonight. You don’t have to be fearless. Just honest with him, and with yourself. Wanting another baby doesn’t erase the scars. It just means you’re ready to build something new on top of them.”
You let out a shaky breath, the ache in your chest easing just a fraction. “I do want it, Mom. I want our family to grow. I can picture it; Kara being the best big sister, Noah finally getting all those firsts he missed. It’s beautiful and terrifying all at once. I just… I need time to sit with the fear first. To let it breathe without letting it win.”
“That’s okay,” she says, warm and reassuring. “You’ve got time. And you’ve got him. And you’ve got me, always. Call anytime, day or night. I love you, sweetheart. Give my grandbaby an extra hug from Nana.”
When you hang up, the ache feels lighter, more manageable. Down the hall, you hear Noah’s low voice murmuring one last goodnight to Kara, even though she’s already fast asleep. You press a hand to your stomach, imagining for a moment what it might feel like again, the flutter of new life, the shared joy, the fear met with his steady presence.
The fear is still there, sharp and real. But so is the hope.
And for the first time tonight, they don’t feel quite so impossible to hold at the same time.
taglist: @theanarchymuse95 | @platespaghetti | @enbytarin | @heavilyfadingpower | @pipidoll | @swimming-selfishes | @lowergroundfloor | @shayseeker | @mrslumi | @itsfarbettertolearn | @branika182 | @leosunshine | @chipotlebagnoah | @buttercupbabyyy | @chey-h | @mushrumink | @haileebluee | @alwaysfightforwhoyouare | @flowery-mess | @r3prise | @lost-in-stereo72