So my irl friend read this and asked me to make a part two so... hi hello here it is! Also, if you hadn’t read part one please do because it will make more sense with this... we back? Okay let’s keep going.
Pairings: Dreamsibling!reader x c!Karl Jacobs, c!Sapnap, c!Georgenotfound. c!Tommy will also be in this but it’s STRICKLY PLUTONIC! (reader and Tommy are gonna be besties... let me have this) Badboyhalo and Skeppy will be in this too, Crow father being father of parrot (Tommy)
Changes because sad: Karl’s memory is fine, Sapnap is a fireborn (is that canon? Let me know I actually don’t know), Demon Egg? Nah fam! Badboyhalo and Skeppy are fine, Philza being Tommys dad/father figure
Warnings: Trauma (poor Tommy), They/Them pronouns used, crying?, only lightly edited
Summary: Y/N is learning to trust her new family but what happens when she is the one who has to GAIN the trust of another? How are they going to trust a loud and obnoxious boy that doesn’t want them anywhere near him? Hope you enjoy :)
Life had been pretty good since you started living at Kinoko Kingdom. You felt like you really had a family, it felt good. You were pulled from your thoughts when you felt heat start to waft towards you. You opened your eyes and saw Sapnap sitting next to you with a small smile.
“Thinking again?” he asked. You laughed softly.
“Yeah, a little bit. Nothing bad if that’s what you’re worried about.” you said looking into the pool and seeing the Yin and Yang made out of mushrooms and hearing the water slosh lightly against the walls of the pool. “Is Karl reading in his library again?” you asked looking up to Sapnap.
“Yeah, I don’t know how he can read so much.” he laughed at the thought of his fiancé curled up with one of his many books. “You know, I’ve been thinking, now that you’re starting to trust Karl and I, I think you should branch out and start making friends and trust them too.” he said, now having a more serious look on his face.
“I don’t know Sap.” you said, trying to not look him in the eyes.
“I know it’s hard, but you got to give it a try. Karl and I will always be here if something happens or you need help.” he said wrapping his arms around your shoulders to give some comfort.
“I can try, but don’t except anything okay?” you said looking up at him again. He smiled.
“That’s fine. I just want you to try.” he said patting your back. You got up and made your way towards Eret’s castle and onto the Prime Path as that was the most popular spot and you would most likely find someone there to befriend. As you walked, you admired the world around you. Punz’s house was still standing and the museum looked like it had new things in it.
‘I should go see what’s new in there at some point.’ you thought to yourself. As you walked, you must have spaced out part way through because you somehow found yourself at the ruins of L’manburg. It looked quite nice actually, Earth had reclaimed the grounds once again. As you looked, you saw someone on the bridge connecting the two grounds. As you got closer you could hear him humming a song that you couldn’t put your finger on.
“It’s quite beautiful now isn’t it, with the Earth now reclaiming it?” you asked as you came closer to the boy. Once you were close enough you could see him clearly. He had dirty blonde hair, a red and white t-shirt, but the one noticeable thing about him was the few white strands of hair. He turned to look at you in surprise.
“Who the fuck are you?!” he yelled, looking ready to fight. You put your arms up in surrender.
“Woah man! I’m was just walking and I thought I could talk to you since you’re here too.” you said in a calm voice. He looked you up and down and up again.
“I guess you could-” he short stopped.
“Hey, umm, are you okay? Is something, uhh, behind me?” you asked scratching the back of your neck. He had a scared look on his face.
“Your-your eyes.” he stammered. You cocked your head to the side with a raised brow. You thought about your eyes for a moment, people usually described them as emeralds.
“Umm- they’re green?” you asked, still confused.
“They look just like his.” he said under his breathe.
“Looks like whos?” you asked.
“GET AWAY FROM ME!!” he yelled, starting to run away.
“Hey wait! What’s wrong?!” you yelled out to him, trying to get his attention, but he just kept running. You sighed.
“Guess I’ll just go home.” you looked down and started to walk back to Kinoko Kingdom.
You sat on your bed looking out the window. The events of today didn’t really make you feel to good. The creak of your door opening made you look over to see Karl.
“Hey Y/N how was your day? Sapnap told me you where going out to make friends! How was it?” he said sitting down next to you on your bed. You took in a deep breath.
“Oh yeah, umm, I kind of hopped you wouldn’t bring it up.” you said looking down at your feet.
“What happened?” he asked.
“Well, it was going fine until I got to L’manburg. There was some guy there and he got freaked out by me and I don’t know why.” you explained fiddling with your fingers to try and distract yourself.
“He was scared of you? Do you know why? Did he say anything?” Karl asked, putting a gentle hand on your back.
“I don’t know, the only thing he said was that he mentioned something about my eyes, but that’s it.” you explained, still seeing everything that happened in your head.
“Do you know who it was?” he asked. You tried to think of him again, finally getting the picture you needed.
“Well... he had a white and red t-shirt and blonde hair with a white streak in it.” you said, describing the boy you saw in your head.
“Sounds like Tommy to me.” came a voice from the door. You looked over and saw Sapnap in the doorway to your room. “Tommy scared of you because of your eyes because Dream has the same eyes as you do.” Sapnap explained. “I thought you knew who Tommy was?” Karl asked.
“I don’t know him formally. I’ve heard Dream complain about him and I’ve seen him stay in that hut by your guys' old house so my guess was that was his house.” you said. They nodded in understanding.
“Well, why don’t you get some rest, Honey? You can forget about this day and start fresh tomorrow.” Karl suggested.
“I do have to admit that sounds nice.” you said, feeling your eyes start to get heavy.
“Okay, goodnight, Darlin.” Sapnap said hugging you and Karl hugging you next.
“See you guys in the morning.” you said, lying down and getting covered up by the blankets, the warmth welcoming you and lulling you to sleep.
When you came downstairs, you heard discussing outside. ‘Was something happening today?’ you thought. You followed the sounds of the talking and found Karl, Sapnap, and George outside talking to someone. “Hey, what’s going on?” you asked.
“Morning Y/N! How’d you sleep?” Karl asked, giving you a quick hug and you hugged him back.
“She’s staying here?! You have to be kidding!” someone yelled. You looked over and saw Tommy.
“Tommy, if you talk to her like that again I will kill you on the spot.” George said and flames appearing around Sapnaps body. Tommy's eyes widened in surprise and fear.
“O-okay, yeah I g-got it.” Tommy stuttered, looking towards you with fear. “So umm, what uhh, do you want to do?” he asked, walking towards you. You looked at everyone around you.
“Look Tommy, if they’re forcing you to hang out with me then I don’t want to.” you said crossing your arms over your chest. Tommy look at you with a surprised expression on his face.
“Y-you’re not going to force me to hang out with you?” he asked surprised.
“Of course not. I know you think of me as Dream but I’m not him and I won’t force you to do things you don’t want to do.” you said in a soft voice. Tommy stared at you for a moment, seeming to be having a conflict in his head.
“Do you wanna walk around the SMP?” he asked in a soft voice. You were speechless, absolutely speechless. What changed with him?
“You... want to?” you asked confused. He nodded, looking you right in the eyes. You thought about it for a moment.
“Okay, lead the way Tommy.” you said gesturing for him to start walking. He made his way towards the Prime Path. The walk was in an awkward silence, no one really knowing what to say. You decided to make small talk with a general question that you hope would make him start talking. “So, umm, what do you like to do Tommy?” you asked. He looked over at you with cautious eyes before finally speaking.
“Well, uh, before Dream was in prison, my friend Tubbo and I would go and annoy him or just try to make him mad. It was super funny.” he said with a smile on his face, clearly lost in memory of the times he had done this. “Or swearing at Badboyhalo is pretty fun because he gets so mad when I do it.” he explained. You thought about Bad, he was like a dad to you when he took you and Dream into his home. You really had to reconnect with him too. “Hey, you listening or did I bore you?” he asked. You felt bad for not listening to him.
“No, sorry. It’s just when you mentioned Bad I just had some memories of him when I was younger.” you explained, which Tommy responded with nodding in understanding.
“Yeah, really good ones. I remember when Sapnap and I were wrestling and he burned me by accident and Bad was the only other person besides my brother to help me when I was hurt.” you said, recalling the story very vividly in your head.
“You have a brother? I thought Sapnap said you weren’t related to anyone at Kinoko Kingdom?” he said confused.
“Well he was right,” you said. He nodded.
“So, who is your brother? And where is he? Do I know him?” he asked excitedly. You hated that he was so excited to know.
“Yeah, I think you’d know him. He’s a bit popular but that could’ve changed. I haven’t seen him in a while, and I really don’t want to.” you said looking down to the path you were walking on. You couldn’t bare to look at him.
“Yeah, I’m quite cool and awesome and I don’t know why I wouldn’t know him.” he said in a cocky voice which made you laugh.
“Of course Mr.Coolman.” you said with a similar cocky tone of voice, you both started to laugh at your antics.
“Okay, okay, but really, who is your brother?” Tommy asked again once you two had calmed down from your prior laughing fit.
“Well, umm, hey could you remind me again of who I look like again?” you asked in fake confusion. You really didn’t want to say it. You were finally getting along with someone and Dream might just ruin everything for you.
“Oh yeah, you remind me of the Green Bitch, Dream! Why? Do you know-” he stopped himself.
‘Oh god, oh no he realized. Would there be any shame in running back to Kinoko Kingdom right now? I could tell Karl and Sapnap that he didn’t want to hangout with me! But, George said he’d kill him! Why’d he say that again?’ you had a million thoughts going through your head at once. Tommy still didn’t say anything and it just made you want to run more and more.
“So, you and that asshole are related huh?” he asked in a sickeningly calm voice. You nodded slowly.
‘This is the calm before the storm.’ you thought to yourself. “Yeah, I am.” you finally said. He nodded.
“Are you a manipulative bitch like he is?” he asked now with a louder voice, it caught you off guard.
“What?! No I’m nothing like him!” you exclaimed. You knew this would happen eventually but you hoped not as soon as it did.
“Yeah right! I’m sure you’re just doing his work while he’s in prison!” he yelled loudly. You could feel tears start to prickle in the corners of your eyes.
“Tommy please, listen to me I swear I’m not-”
“Yeah right bitch! Get away from me!” he yelled and started to run towards his house. You tried to keep the tears at bay.
“Remember Y/N, NEVER, EVER, show any kind of weakness. Hide it away and show you’re strong!” Dreams words echoed through your head over and over again. You couldn’t hide this, you just couldn’t, so you ran back to Konoko to hide your weakness.
When you finally reached Kinoko, you could see the shining of a diamond. ‘Please don’t tell me Skeppy and Bad are here right now, please.’ you thought, you were just not having a break today. When you entered the house you speed walked to your room.
“Oh Y/N! Bad and Skeppy are-” George short stopped now seeing your distraught state.
“Wait muffin! What’s wrong?!” Bad called to you but you kept walking. When you made it to your room, you shut the door and flopped onto your bed. You didn’t even bother locking it since you knew Sapnap would just burn the door down if he wanted to. You felt like you’d been crying for hours, you didn’t know why this affected you so much but it did. Your thoughts were broken by a gentle knock on the door.
“What?” you said in a weak and small voice. The door opened to reveal Bad standing on the other side. He gave you a soft smile showing his sharp fangs.
“Hey muffin, are you doing okay? Why are you crying?” he asked in a soft voice. He walked into your room and sat on your bed.
“It’s nothing Bad. Anyway, how have you and Skeppy been? It’s been forever since I’ve seen you guys!” you said wiping your tears away to try and hide how you were feeling.
“Y/N, I know better then that. You seem to forget that I’ve raised a child before and have seen this before. Now, what’s wrong?” he asked wrapping an arm around your shoulders. You leaned into his side as tears threatened to fall again.
“I try to make friends and I can’t because Dream made it imposable for people to like me!” you exclaimed, tears now running down your face again. Bad hugged you properly while running his hands up and down your arms.
“Oh muffin, who made you feel so bad?” he asked in a calm voice. You sniffled.
“Tommy. He freaked out on my twice because my eyes are the same color as Dreams and then we were getting along and he asked about my brother and told him it was Dream because I didn’t want to lie to him and he freaked out and ran again!” you explained, trying to wipe your eyes away. Bad sighed.
“Listen muffin, Tommy has had a rough life and he annoys me as much if not more then anyone else, but he’s a good kid! The only reason he went crazy on you is because him and Dream have, well, a lot of history. Dream wasn’t the nicest person to Tommy and you bring back bad memories for him.” Bad explained.
“I know muffin, but you can show him you’re different then Dream. You are what I remember him to be and wish he still was.” when you opened your mouth to speak another knock came to the door.
“Is it important?” Bad asked his voice raised slightly.
“It’s for Y/N. Someone want’s to see you.” George said through the door. You stood up and opened the door. George pulled you into a quick hug and leading you downstairs with Bad following behind you. When you got downstairs you saw a winged man with a green and white stripped bucket hat.
“-Again I’m sorry to just drop in.”
“No problem Phil! If anyone could talk to him it’d be you.” Sapnap said, looking to Tommy.
“So this is the lady I’ve heard about!” ‘Phil’ said looking to you. He walked over to you and kneeled down. “Wow, you really look like Dream.” he said in amazement.
“Yeah, she really does.” Tommy said in a quiet voice. Phil turned to him with an annoyed look.
“Okay Tommy, you’re going to sort this out okay?” Phil said crossing his arm over his chest. Tommy let out a deep sigh.
“Fine.” he said. Phil nodded and walked over to Tommy and started to push him towards you until he was standing in front of you. You both stood in silence for a moment not wanting to say anything and not knowing what to say. You took a deep breath.
“Why did you run.” it was more of a statement then a question but you wanted an answer.
“You already know why.” he said
“No! I want a better answer then I look like Dream! So spit it out!” you said now with raised voice. He cowered a little.
“Fine, you really want to know? It’s because your brother is an absolute dick and I hate him!” he yelled in frustration.
“You think I don’t know that?! All him and I ever did together was train and train and train! He told me that after he dealt with your stupid brother’s country he would be back but he never came!” he yelled back. You felt out of breath from that and everyone was looking at you in surprise.
“Look Tommy, just like Dream hasn’t been good to you, he hasn’t been good to Y/N either. In fact, you and Y/N have quite a bit in common.” Sapnap said. You and Tommy both looked to him to continue. “Just like Y/N’s brother Dream wasn’t good to her, Tommy your brother Wilbur wasn’t that good to you either after the revolution.” you both looked to one another. “And because of Dream, Y/N only knows to fight and because of Wilbur all you know is L’manburg.” Sapnap finished. You and Tommy were silent for a moment. You two really were similar.
“Walk. With me.” Tommy said looking at the ground. You looked to Bad, who gave two thumbs up and a big smile. You looked back to Tommy.
“Okay. Just don’t run off again.” you joked which made Tommy chuckle.
You laid on the grass, your head in your best friends lap as you talked about whatever came to mind with your best friend, Tommy. You both had put your differences aside and now were inseparable. Tommy even told you maybe Tubbo was even jealous, that always made you laugh. You were telling him about how Foolish came and advertised some kind of cult and Tommy was looking down at you the whole time just enjoying your time together.
“Tommy.” you turned around to see Sam.
“Make it quick Sam, I want to sit with Y/N for a bit longer.” he said and you nodded wanting to do the same.
“We have a problem at the Prison.”
And it’s done! That took some much longer then I wanted but I’m happy with it. I hope you liked it! :)