Finally Safe
Summary: After a really hard case, and a couple months of pure exhaustion. Hotch can't watch you struggle internally anymore.
Warnings: angst!!!, guns mentioned, child death, grieving, sleep deprivation, discussions of violence against children.
Word count: 5,081
Narrator: I needed this.
"No! She's just a kid! Killing her wont take away what happened to you, just let her go and we can get you the help you need. We already have your mother in custody for the horrific actions she did to you! But you have to let her go and we can work through this!"
You reached your hand out trying to grab hold of the horrified seven year old staring at you with wide, confused, and watery eyes. The man holding her hostage with a gun to her head eased up his grip on her slightly. Just as you felt her finger tips brush against yours-
-Bang-
"Noo!!" You wake up screaming, tears streaming down your face. Any case involving children has always proved to haunt you. It was sickening to see kids learn early in life what true "boogy men" look like. You catch your breath, try to stop your stomach churning, and walk to the bathroom. Where you turn the hot water on in the shower after brushing your teeth. You look in the mirror and let out a small sigh hoping, praying, the case you and your team just closed doesn't stick in your mind for too long. When you finally step into the steamy sanctuary you call your shower, you lean your head back and close your eyes. To no surprise the first thing you see is the same image playing over and over. You knew then that this one was definitely going to fester in your soul for a while.
2 months go by. The team works more cases. One after the other. Successful outcomes keeping everyone else feeling accomplished, like it is worth the nightmares on occasion. Not you. On the plane ride back, after another 'best case scenario' ending, everyone is in their unassigned signed seating. Most everyone is sleeping, best case scenario doesn't mean it was any less exhausting. Hotch is working on paperwork, go figure, and you? You are trying to focus on the sudoku puzzle in front of you, but currently there is a battle between your eyes and eye lids and your eye lids are starting to win. "Do you want to talk about it?" You hear from beside you.
Emily noticed from the start how you were feeling. Yes she's a profiler, but with her also being your best friend. It didn't take a professional to notice you were off. You never tried to necessarily hide it, but you also didn't make it anyone's responsibility to take on. Of course you know everyone cares and they do try to talk to you, but you tend to just give a small smile, nod, and quickly move on in return. Which is exactly what you did when Emily asked.
Any single person on this team would not hesitate to help whether they were sought out for advice, just a listening ear, or a shoulder to cry on. Even still knowing this, for some reason it was an impossible task for you to let someone take care of you in anyway. You always had a bad habit of pushing it all on the back burner until it inevitably boiled over when the busyness of the day quiets down and you were by yourself.
The plane finally landed, everyone getting up and getting into their respective vehicles. As you were about to unlock your SUV a hand came out of no where and snatched your keys. "You are mistaken if you think I'm about to let you drive home knowing you're past the point of exhaustion" Hotch stood with his hand on the door handle on the passenger side. Opening it before you could even begin to protest. He was right to be worried, you knew it. You knew you were dangerously sleepy and shouldn't be behind the wheel, so you crawled into the passenger seat. After buckling up and resting your head on the window you felt the car start up and pull out the parking lot. Your eye lids finally winning the ongoing war you've been waging against yourself.
There she was. A picture of the little girl, Delilah, on the board in the police station. You immediately woke up, guessing it's cause your brain knew what was coming next. "I know, you know I don't have to tell you anyone of us are here for you-" Aaron began speaking, he thought maybe if he got you alone, away from everyone, you'd be more likely to finally let your guard down. "I know, I appreciate y'all Hotch." You cut him off trying to brush by the conversation. He doesn't let you though and keeps talking like you never interrupted him, "But I also know you feel like we have our own issues to worry about and don't want to feel like you're putting more on someone's plate." He didn't take his eyes off the road while he spoke. "Hotch, look, it's okay. I'm going to be fine! Really!!" You try to argue back. Both of y'all knew it was a lie. Hotch finally glanced over at you then, just for a second at a red light. The exhaustion written all over your face made something in his chest tighten. Your eyes were glossy, your shoulders tense even though you were practically falling asleep, and he hated how familiar this looked. He'd seen agents burn themselves into the ground before. He just never expected you to be one of them. "You haven't slept," he said quietly.
"I sleep."
"You pass out from exhaustion. That's not the same thing." You let out a humorless laugh and turned your face back toward the window. Rain droplets from an earlier storm y'all weren't around to see still clung to the glass, blurring the city lights outside. "Look at you profiling me." You say in a weak, almost not there voice. "I'm serious." He says gently, his hands shift for a second, like he almost reached for your hand. "I know." That's the only two words you're able to muster up without losing control of the emotions you've been holding back. The silence that followed wasn't comfortable, but it wasn't hostile either. It was heavy. Thick with all the things neither of you seemed willing to say out loud. Hotch pulled into your apartment complex a few minutes later. You reached for the handle immediately, desperate for escape before the conversation dug any deeper.
"Y/N."
Your hand froze. He had that tone again. Calm. Controlled. The same voice he used during negotiations right before someone talked a suspect off the ledge. You sighed softly, eyes closing for a moment. "Please don't."
"Don't what?"
"Do the concerned dad lecture thing."
One side of his mouth twitched slightly at that. "I'm not lecturing you."
"Could've fooled me."
He turned the car off completely now, the engine falling silent around you both. Without it, the tension somehow became louder. "You know what I think?" he asked. You stared ahead. "I'm sure you're gonna tell me."
"I think you've convinced yourself that if you stop moving for even a second, all of this is going to crush you." That hit too close to home. You swallowed hard but forced out a shrug. "Occupational hazard." "No." His voice softened. "It's fear." You finally looked at him then. Aaron Hotchner wasn't an easy man to read. Everyone on the team knew that. He kept himself composed with almost terrifying precision, every emotion locked neatly behind professionalism and discipline. But right now? You could see it. Concern. Real concern. And somehow that made your chest ache worse. "You think I don't see it?" he continued quietly. "Every time we have a case involving kids, you stop eating. You stop sleeping. You withdraw from the team. You start carrying everything by yourself because you think that's somehow protecting everyone else." Your throat tightened. "I just..." Your voice cracked slightly, embarrassing you instantly. "I couldn't save her." The words finally left your mouth after two whole months. Hotch's expression changed immediately. Delilah. Seven years old. You still heard the gunshot every time you closed your eyes. "I know," he said gently. "No, you don't." You shook your head quickly, tears already threatening again. "I was right there. I almost had her hand, Aaron." The use of his first name made his eyes flicker slightly. "I was supposed to save her."
"You tried."
"She was a child."
His jaw tightened now, the controlled mask slipping just enough for frustration to bleed through. Not at you. At the situation. At the unfairness of it all. "Do you think the rest of us don't carry victims with us too?" he asked carefully. "I know you do."
"Then why are you holding yourself to a different standard?"
You didn't have an answer for that. Because the truth was, you did know everyone on the team carried ghosts. Rossi carried them. Emily hid hers behind sarcasm and confidence. Spencer buried himself in statistics when cases got too close. Morgan got angry. JJ got quieter. And Hotch... Hotch carried his pain so silently it almost scared you. But somehow your grief felt uglier. Weaker. Your breathing started shaking before you even realized you were crying. You immediately turned your face away, wiping furiously at your cheeks. "God, I hate this." Hotch didn't say anything for a moment. Then slowly, carefully, he reached over and pulled your hands away from your face. The gesture startled you enough to look at him. His hands were warm. Steady. "You don't have to hide this from me," he said softly. The sincerity in his voice completely shattered whatever wall you had left. A broken sob escaped your throat before you could stop it. And then suddenly Aaron was moving. Unbuckling your seatbelt. Pulling you toward him.
You ended up half collapsed against his chest in the front seat of the SUV, crying harder than you had in weeks. Months, maybe. Hotch held you without hesitation, one hand cradling the back of your head while the other rubbed slow calming circles against your back. "It's okay," he murmured quietly above you. "Just let it out." You hated how desperately you clung to him. But he didn't seem to mind. Your forehead pressed against his shoulder while years worth of exhaustion, grief, guilt, and horror poured out of you all at once. The kind of crying that leaves your lungs aching afterward. Through all of it, Hotch stayed steady. Solid. Safe. And when your breathing finally started evening out, his hand still rested gently against the back of your head. "You wanna know something?" he asked quietly. You sniffled miserably. "What?"
"I think you're one of the strongest people I've ever met." You let out a wet laugh. "Clearly not." His fingers tightened slightly against your hair. "No," he said firmly. "Strong doesn't mean unaffected. It means you keep showing up despite it." Your chest tightened painfully. Because no one had ever said it like that before. You pulled back slightly just enough to look at him, suddenly hyperaware of how close the two of you were. The dim parking lot lights cast soft shadows across his face, making him look less like your unit chief and more like just... Aaron. Tired eyes. Gentle expression. A man carrying his own unbearable weight. His gaze dropped briefly to your lips before returning to your eyes so quickly you almost thought you imagined it. Almost. The air shifted. Neither of you moved. And for the first time since joining the BAU, you realized this thing between you and Aaron Hotchner might not be one-sided after all.
"You ready to go inside?" He asks with an incredible amount of gentleness in his eyes You silently nod your head and open the door. You notice Hotch get out too and you look at him confused. "You didn't think I was going to leave you alone right? Someone needs to make sure you get some sleep. Real sleep." He says sternly, but still with care. "What about Jack?" You didn't want to keep him from his son. "He's with Jess tonight, he's asleep right now and won't be awake until after I get home anyways." You don't argue with him because you thought it'd be nice to have someone around anyways, and you just literally bawled your eyes out on his shoulder, so he's already got his foot in the door right? More like tore down that first layer you worked so hard to put up around your heart. As you walk inside, Aaron follows behind you. You set your bag down and take off your shoes, he does the same and then looks at your tense, exhausted body. "Go take a shower and change. I'll lock the door and get settled on the couch."
"Aaron..." You whisper softly. "Yes?" He asks, there's that flutter in his chest again. "Please come with me...I don't...I don't wanna be alone..." You know you sound broken. Right now you don't care. And Aaron just wants you to feel safe and comfortable. He doesn't answer with words. He walks to your bedroom and opens the door to your on suite bathroom. You follow him this time and go to your closet picking out something comfortable to sleep in. He's turned your shower on and is waiting for you to walk back in his sight. "Is this warm enough?" You feel the water and it's perfect, you shake your head at him, "Can you pick a movie for us? I don't want to use any brain power." Again, no words were needed. he just nods his head, gives you a small smile, and shuts the door enough for you to be out of side and still have privacy, but wide enough where he can hear if you call his name. He sits on the edge of your bed and as he settles on a movie, his eyes drift around the room unintentionally. It was strangely intimate being here. Seeing the books stacked unevenly on your nightstand, the sweater tossed on the of your desk chair, the framed photo of you and Emily laughing at what looked like some terrible attempt at karaoke. Pieces of the real you. Not the agent that sat across from in briefing rooms, just you.
He looked through different streaming services, after seeing you don't own any movies. Then he heard the shower shut off after settling on The Office, it was in your 'Continue Watching' list and it just felt easy to watch after an exhausting day, or in your case. Two months. You slide back the curtain and slowly step onto the soft, memory foam mat under you. After taking a look in the mirror you sigh deeply, your heart still aches, but at least you had company there to keep you from being so indulged in your own thoughts. Might've been your boss, who you always felt a little more for than your other colleagues. And you knew there were some lines you just don't cross. "You okay in there?" You hear Aaron through the crack of the door. "Yeah! Yeah, I'm okay." You reply almost convincing even yourself. You slip into pajamas and walk back into the bedroom. Aaron stares for just a second too long and you feel butterflies in your chest. You lay on the bed, careful not to touch him. He noticed immediately, how you were always careful to keep your distance, the way you kept your hands folded in your lap, you were always trying to make yourself smaller or 'take up less room'. He hated you felt that way. "The couch was a real option, you know," he said softly leaning against your headboard. "No, I want the company, plus you'd pop more than bubble wrap in the morning." You try to let a small chuckle. The theme song to The Office is playing quietly in the background when you glance over at him and notice he's just as tired as you are. "You don't think I already pop more than bubble wrap?"
Finally, you let out a real laugh, it was small, but Aaron noticed it immediately. And what he wouldn't do to hear that laugh more often. You get under the blankets offering him some as you do. "I would've never thought you'd watch The Office." You say, sounding a lot more relaxed than you have in months. His lips twitch up slightly "It was in your continue watching" He says. "That sounds like profiling"
"Is it?" He says with slight confusion in his voice, "I figured that'd just be an observation skill." You start relaxing into your own mattress, still trying to not get cozy with your boss, who you have to see in the office tomorrow. "Same thing." You say back. He just lets out a small chuckled, eyes glued to the screen. Honestly thought, he wasn't paying the show any attention. He was too focused on the warmth radiating off of you next to him, just a few inches away. Your shoulder brushes over his arm has you roll over trying to get comfortable. Both of y'all notice and go still for a second. "Thank you." You say quietly. Aaron immediately looks over at you. "For what?"
"For staying." The sincerity in your voice hits him in his chest, hard. You didn't genuinely believe someone would stay with you. "You never have to thank me for that." He says with a soft expression on his face. Your throat tightens slightly. The room grows loudly quiet again, minus the tv softly playing in the background. "Do you take care of everyone like this?" You finally break the silence. Half teasing, and half genuine curiosity. Aaron lets out a sharp exhale through his nose. "Not everyone." It makes your heart stutter. He says it too calmly, like he accidentally let it slip. Then you fully meet his eyes and suddenly neither of you are pretending to watch the tv anymore. "Sometimes you make it very hard to remember you're my boss," You say quietly before you can even realize what you're saying. There is a look of surprised amusement on his face. "Trust me." He says lowly, "The feeling is mutual." Butterflies explode in your stomach. His eyes are softer than you've ever seen before. That 'unit chief' persona has completely vanished. "You know you looked terrified earlier." He says quietly. "When?" You blinked. "When you asked me to stay"
"Sorry." You can feel the embarrassment turning your cheeks cherry red. "Hey, don't do that." He says with extreme gentleness in his voice. "Don't apologize for needing someone." That sentence almost unraveled you instantly all over again. In a different way this time. You look down and start playing with the fabric of the blanket in your lap. "I'm not good at this." You admit quietly, barely above a whisper. "I noticed." He says with an indescribable look in his eyes. You laugh softly at those two words, and Aaron smiles at you, a genuine one. "You should do that more often." You mumble without even thinking about the words coming out of your mouth. "Do what?" He asks with raised eyebrows, genuinely curious as to what you're talking about. "Smile." You say plainly. The eye contact afterwards lasts a little too long, a little too warm, and a little too dangerous. Then quietly and teasingly Aaron says, "Maybe I would if you stopped glaring at me during briefings." You gasp at his words saying, "I absolutely do not glare at you!"
"You absolutely do." You stare at him for a second before dissolving into quiet laughter again, the kind that finally makes your shoulders loosen after a few months. Aaron noticed it, he was watching you carefully, and there was that feeling in his chest again, it wasn't concern or responsibility. It was something far worse. Something that had been building up for a very long time. "Aaron...I think I-" Just as you were about to accidentally let your true feelings slip out. You get a phone call from Emily. Her contact picture flashes across your screen as your picking your phone up from off your nightstand. "You should probably answer that." You quickly clear your throat and nod, trying to forget what you were about to just say. "Hey Em!" You say trying to keep your tone steady and normal. "Well?" She says immediately, like you were supposed to just know what she's calling about. "Well what?" You blinked. "Are you crying in your apartment right now? Or did Hotch actually listen to me for once?" Your eyes widened with horror while Aaron's eye brows slowly raised next you. "Oh my god, Emily!" You whisper aggressively into the phone. "What? Put me on speaker." She says, she's enjoying this way too much. "No!" You start protesting, Aaron is obviously trying to not smile. Emily then dramatically gasps on the other end of the line, "Wait! Is he there?!" You then bury your face in one hand saying, "I hate you."
"No you don't," she says proudly, "now hand the phone over to Mr. Lover Boy." Aaron let out a small laugh at that, the sound warm and quiet right next to you. Your stomach flips instantly. "Emily." You groan out. "What? The entire team has been waiting a year for something like this to happen." Aaron raises his eyebrows next to you, again. "A year?" He repeats back before you can stop him. "Oh my god, he didn't know!" Emily sounds extremely delighted about this. "Know what?" Aaron asks calmly, but you can definitely hear the amusement creeping up in his voice. You try to point the conversation away from your own personal humiliation ritual, "She thrives on chaos." But she's right there to contradict you. "I thrive on being right." Aaron glances over at you then, eyes noticeably softer now, "And what exactly is she right about?" Your entire body heats up and Emily makes a frustrated noise through the phone. "You two are profilers. Figure it out." You immediately hang up the phone. The room goes silent again. Aaron breaks that silence by laughing, and not the polite little breath he normally gives at the office. No. This one is a real laugh. You honestly think it might be your new favorite sound in the world. You stare at him helplessly. "I can not believe she just did that." "Actually," Aaron says still smiling a little bit, "I can." You groan and pull the blanket over your face in embarrassment. "I'm going to transfer departments." His hand gently catches the blanket before you can fully disappear beneath it. "Don't." The single word comes out so much softer than he expected it to. Your eyes meet his again, and suddenly the teasing atmosphere shifts back into something quieter. Aaron's fingers still lightly hold the edge of the blanket near your shoulder, neither of you moving. "What were you about to say before she called?" he asks quietly, and you can feel your heartbeat stumble over itself instantly. "I don't remember." You break the gaze first. "That's interesting." He says after a small huff of amusement. "Why do you say that?" You say with your eye brows raised. "Because I profile liars for a living." You narrow your eyes slightly. "Are you trying to say you're going to profile me in my bed?"
"Maybe." You try to fight the smile tugging at your lips and start failing miserably. Aaron watches it happen with his own expression softening even more. God, he was looking at you like you were something precious and worth treasuring. "You know," he says after a moment, "Emily's not wrong." He says quieter than he's been all night. "Aaron-" Your breath catches slightly. "I think..." he pauses for second, unusually hesitant. "I think I've been trying not to cross that line with you for a very long time." The confession settles over y'all heavily, not in a bad way, just honest. Your chest feels incredibly tight as you look up at him. "Why didn't you?" A faint smile pulls at the corner of his mouth. "You're my agent." You smile back softly at him, "And you're my boss" He looks at you in the eyes. "Exactly." The silence stretches out again. Then Aaron quietly adds "That didn't stop me from wanting to." Your stomach does backflips, and before you can overthink it, before either of you can retreat back behind professionalism and caution you slip your hand under the blanket into his hand. Aaron stills immediately. His eyes drop to where your hands are intertwined in his, then back to you. The look on his face alone nearly steals the breath out of your lungs. "I think I suddenly remembered what I was going to say..." You start out slowly and terrified. He looks at you inquisitively "Oh yeah?" You just nod your head and quietly, softly, almost whisper. "I think I might love you Aaron."
His heart does a backflip in his chest now. Before he can talk himself out of it, he pulls his hand from yours, gently cradles your jaw in his hands and pulls you in for a kiss, the kind of kiss both of you have been imagining for a while now. "Normally I would've taken you out to dinner before any of this." He says after pulling away from you. You just let out a breathless chuckle and shake your head. "We always have time for dinner." Aaron's forehead rested quietly on yours for a second. Both of you were smiling in the quietness, almost in a disbelieving way people do when something they wanted to happen for so long finally does. The Office is continuing to play quiet episodes in the background that both of y'all were never watching. "You know," you whisper softly, fingers entangled in his hair. "It's kind of embarrassing how long it took us to figure it out." Aaron huffs out a laugh, his thumb brushing across your cheek. "I've figured it out a little while ago." Your eyebrows lift immediately. "Oh really?" You question him and he lets out a faint "mhm" in response. "And you just...What? Suffered in silence?" His mouth twitched upwards. "Professionally suffered in silence" He corrects you. You burst into laughter after that, the sound making his entire expression soften again. God, he looked at you like you hung the moon. You don't think anyone has ever looked at you like that. "You're smiling again." You mumbled. "That seems to happen around you." The butterflies in your stomach get impossibly worse. Your eyes drift over his face slowly now that you're finally allowing yourself to. The tiredness around his eyes, the faint stubble on his jaw line, the softest side of him that only appears when he's with people he trusts the most. And right now, that was all directed towards you. "You know what's unfair?" You ask quietly. "What?"
"You've been attractive this whole time." Aaron actually laughs again, fuller this time. "That's your complaint?" You look at him seriously, "Yes! Do you know how difficult briefings were for me?" Aaron looks at you with a noticeable grin. "I had my suspicions." You looked at him blankly. "Oh you had your suspicions?" You repeat back to him incredulously. "You glared at any woman who flirted with me" Your hand goes straight to your chest, dramatically. "I did not!" Aaron lets out another laugh, you could bottle the sound for your own personal records. "You absolutely did!" Your jaw drops in offense and he just watches you with amusement on his face. "Penelope asked me once if I was aware you looked homicidal sometimes." He says teasingly at you. You just bury your face in your hands. "I'm not talking to any of you ever again." Warm fingers wrap gently around your wrists to slowly lower them, like he did in the car earlier. "No hiding." He murmurs softly at you. Your heart melts a little at the two words. The room grows silent again, not awkward. Just intimate. Aaron's hand never left yours. "You should try to sleep" He says eventually, voice low and careful like he doesn't actually want to night to end either. "I will if you stay." You say quietly. "I never planned on leaving" The sincerity in his voice settles somewhere deep in your chest. You shift a little closer to him without even thinking about it this time, your head rests on his shoulder. Aaron goes still for half a second, almost like he's savoring it, before relaxing completely next to you. His arm slowly slides around you, cautious at first, giving you every opportunity to pull away. You don't. If anything, you curl closer to him. The tension that lived in your body for months finally starts to ease little by little under his touch. For the first time in what feels like forever, your mind isn't replaying gunshots, crime scenes, and guilt. It's just focused on him. Your fingers lazily trace the fabric of his shirt. "You know what's crazy?" He looks at you, "What?" You look at him with your eyes beaming. "I think this is the safest I've felt in months." Aaron's arms tighten around you slightly, his lips brushing softly against your hair before he can stop himself. "You are safe." He whispers back. The terrifying part is you instantly believe him. Your eyes start growing heavy again, but this time not from exhaustion. This time it's from comfort, and from finally letting yourself stop fighting for one night. Aaron notices, he always does. "There she is." He murmurs teasingly. "The human being beneath sleep deprivation." You murmur something incoherent from his shoulder. "Shut up." All he can do is smile into your hair. Your breathing starts to even out, fingers still curled to his shirt. Aaron looks at your carefully after a few minutes just to make sure you're actually sleeping, and not passed out from exhaustion, or trapped in nightmares. You weren't, you were sleeping peacefully against his chest. Something in his chest ached at the sight. His hand gently hair away from your face, eyes lingering on you with an expression no one from the BAU has ever seen on Aaron Hotchner's face. And quietly, so quietly you'd never hear it, he whispers against your forehead, "I love you too."








