summary: working alongside Aaron Hotchner at the BAU means most people have no idea you’re married. But when a local detective starts taking a little too much interest in you during an out-of-state case, Aaron’s patience begins to wear thin— until he finally decides to make your relationship impossible for anyone to misunderstand
Aaron Hotchner x Reader
authors note: I hope you enjoy. Your support for my writing is very much appreciated 🥰💗💗
The thing about working at the BAU with your husband is that people rarely realize you’re married.
Part of it is Aaron.
Aaron Hotchner isn’t exactly the type to wear his heart on his sleeve. He doesn’t hover around you, doesn’t sneak kisses in hallways, doesn’t drape an arm around your shoulders during briefings. To everyone else, he’s Unit Chief first and husband second.
To you, though?
He’s the man who brings you coffee exactly how you like it before every flight. The man who always notices when you’re tired. The man who calls you sweetheart in a voice so soft nobody would ever believe it came from the same person who can stare down serial killers without blinking.
The other part is you.
You keep things professional. You don’t want your marriage becoming office gossip, and honestly, the team respects that.
Morgan knows.
Garcia definitely knows.
Reid figured it out three years ago because he noticed Aaron unconsciously turns toward you whenever someone raises their voice.
The rest of the world?
Not so much.
Which is exactly how you find yourself in the middle of a homicide investigation in Colorado with a problem neither of you expected.
His name is Detective Ryan Walker.
And Detective Ryan Walker has decided he likes you.
A lot.
The first time Aaron notices it, he says nothing.
You’re standing at the local precinct reviewing victim files when Walker appears beside your desk.
“Need anything?” he asks.
You smile politely. “Just the autopsy reports.”
“I can get those.”
Aaron looks up from across the room.
Walker stays.
For twenty minutes.
Talking.
Laughing.
Asking questions.
Aaron tells himself he’s imagining things.
Then Walker starts finding excuses to be around you.
Every briefing.
Every crime scene.
Every witness interview.
If you’re there, somehow Detective Walker is there too.
You notice it eventually.
Mostly because Morgan notices it.
“Oh, he’s got it bad,” Morgan says while the two of you wait for coffee.
You nearly choke.
“What?”
Morgan grins.
“The detective.”
“He does not.”
“He absolutely does.”
“No.”
“Baby girl, yes.”
You roll your eyes.
But then Walker appears from nowhere holding your coffee.
Your coffee.
The exact one you’d ordered.
Morgan doesn’t even try to hide his laughter.
“See?”
You groan.
Unfortunately, Aaron sees it too.
And Aaron is handling it… poorly.
Well.
Poorly for Aaron.
Which means nobody else notices.
Except you.
You notice the slight tightening of his jaw whenever Walker stands too close.
You notice the way Aaron’s answers become shorter whenever the detective directs questions toward you.
You notice the glare.
God.
The glare.
Walker seems completely oblivious to the fact that your husband is staring at him like he’s considering several felony-level solutions.
One night, after fourteen straight hours on the case, you finally find Aaron alone in the conference room.
He’s reviewing geographical profiles.
You close the door behind you.
His eyes lift immediately.
The tension in his face softens.
Just a little.
“Hey.”
“Hey.”
You walk over and sit beside him.
For a moment neither of you speaks.
Then you reach for his hand under the table.
His fingers immediately lace with yours.
“You’re jealous.”
Aaron stares at the case file.
“No.”
You laugh.
“Aaron.”
“No.”
“Aaron.”
His expression remains perfectly serious.
“He’s a local detective.”
“Who flirts with me.”
“He hasn’t actually said anything inappropriate.”
“He’s flirting.”
Aaron finally looks at you.
“He is.”
“There it is.”
His jaw clenches.
You smile despite yourself.
“Aaron.”
“What?”
“I love you.”
His expression softens immediately.
Like magic.
Like it always does.
You squeeze his hand.
“I married you.”
“I know.”
“You’re the only person I want.”
A long silence follows.
Then:
“I know.”
You lean over and kiss his cheek.
The faintest hint of pink appears on the tips of his ears.
It’s adorable.
You never tell him that.
The case drags on for another four days.
Four very long days.
Four days of Walker appearing beside you every chance he gets.
Four days of Aaron pretending he isn’t bothered.
Four days of Morgan looking increasingly entertained.
Then everything goes sideways.
The unsub takes a hostage.
A chase follows.
Hours pass.
Nobody sleeps.
Everyone’s exhausted.
And by the time the case finally ends, every nerve in Aaron’s body is stretched dangerously thin.
The arrest happens just before midnight.
The team gathers outside the precinct while paperwork gets finalized.
Everyone’s tired.
Everyone’s relieved.
You lean against a patrol car while waiting for Aaron.
Walker approaches.
Again.
At this point you’re almost impressed by his dedication.
“Looks like we’re done here.”
“Looks like it.”
He smiles.
“I was thinking maybe before you leave town—”
You already know where this is going.
“Oh.”
“Maybe dinner?”
Your heart sinks.
Not because you’re interested.
Quite the opposite.
You actually feel bad for him.
Because standing twenty feet away is Aaron Hotchner.
And Aaron has definitely heard that.
Every.
Single.
Word.
You open your mouth.
“Aaron and I—”
Before you can finish, a familiar voice cuts through the night.
“Detective.”
Walker turns.
Aaron walks toward you.
Slowly.
Calmly.
Looking every bit like the Unit Chief everyone fears.
Except his eyes are fixed entirely on you.
The detective straightens.
“Aaron.”
Aaron doesn’t answer him.
Instead he stops directly in front of you.
Close enough that your heart immediately starts racing.
His gaze drops to yours.
For a second, the world seems to disappear.
Then Aaron reaches up and gently brushes a strand of hair behind your ear.
The gesture is unexpectedly intimate.
Your breath catches.
The detective looks confused.
Morgan, somewhere in the background, starts grinning.
Aaron never takes his eyes off you.
“You ready to go home, sweetheart?”
Sweetheart.
Oh.
Oh, no.
The detective freezes.
You feel your lips twitch.
Aaron’s hand settles against your waist.
Possessive.
Certain.
Completely unbothered by the audience.
And suddenly Walker understands.
His eyes widen.
“Oh.”
You almost laugh.
Aaron finally glances at him.
The look he gives the detective is perfectly polite.
Which somehow makes it worse.
“My wife and I have an early flight.”
The silence that follows is spectacular.
Walker blinks.
“Wife?”
“Yes.”
Aaron’s arm tightens slightly around your waist.
Not enough to hurt.
Just enough to remind everyone exactly where he stands.
And where you stand too.
The detective immediately looks horrified.
“Oh my God.”
Morgan actually snorts.
“I didn’t know.”
“So I’ve gathered.”
You bury your face against Aaron’s shoulder to hide your smile.
Walker mutters several apologies before practically fleeing the scene.
The second he’s gone, the team loses it.
Morgan is laughing.
Garcia is cackling over speakerphone.
Even Emily looks amused.
Aaron ignores all of them.
“Let’s go.”
You look up at him.
“Feel better?”
“No.”
“Really?”
“No.”
You raise an eyebrow.
Aaron’s mouth twitches.
Just slightly.
Then he leans down and presses a quick kiss to your forehead.
Right in front of everyone.
A collective chorus of shocked noises erupts from the team.
Aaron doesn’t care.
For once, he genuinely doesn’t care.
His hand finds yours.
And when he looks at you, all the jealousy and frustration from the last week has vanished.
Replaced by something much softer.
Something that belongs only to the two of you.
“Come on, sweetheart.”
You smile.
“Home?”
His expression finally breaks into a rare, genuine smile.
when you dislocate your shoulder, hotch is your emergency contact
You feel dumb waiting in the ER for Aaron to pick you up.
You loathe to think about how you’re supposed to explain to him that you’d managed to dislocate your shoulder from falling off the bed.
When he walks through the doors to find you sitting on a hospital bed with a frown, he looks nothing short of distressed.
“Hey,” he rushes over to you, scanning you with his eyes before he catches sight of the sling on your shoulder.
“Oh honey,” he croons, sounding all too sweet for the petulant expression you’d been displaying.
“I’m fine,” you grumble half-heartedly.
Aaron tsks softly, placing a hand softly on your shoulder and motioning you to stand.
“How’d you do this?” He asks, walking behind you to scan the back of the sling.
You huff, refusing to admit your fault.
“It’s dumb,” you admit, “they shouldn’t have called you, I was just about to get an uber home—”
“Wait what? baby no.” Aaron protests, moving to stand in front of you with his well known frown.
“You were gonna get an uber?” Aaron looks horrified that you’d even suggest that.
“Well I knew you were stressed over the reports from—”
“Sweetheart,” His eyes are soft and warm, his entire expression adoring if not mixed with mild amused exasperation.
“Well I’m glad they called me then because you apparently wouldn’t have,” He remarks teasingly.
You slump slightly and can’t help the grimace as your shoulder pulls at the motion.
Your grimace pulls Aaron right back into his concerned partner aura, “don’t move around too much, your ligaments probably haven’t even started to heal yet,” he frowns.
You can’t help the snort you let out, “you’d know that with the MD you managed to acquire on the ride over?” You laugh softly.
Aaron rolls his eyes in fond amusement, “I actually badgered Reid with a couple of questions on the phone.” He replies snarkily.
Your smile softens, as much as you’d like to believe your worry about inconveniencing Aaron outweighs most other emotions, its moments like these that you can’t help but be thankful for him being there for you.
“Tired?” He murmurs, shuffling closer to you so that you sit on the bed.
He moves to stand in between your legs, frowning as he tucks a piece of hair behind your ear.
“I’d kill for a nap,” you acquiescence, pressing your cheek into Aaron’s palm as he cups your face.
He hums, “Well lucky for you little miss, you’ve got your own FBI escort waiting for you right outside.”
Your smile widens, “Tell me you didn’t use your badge to park in the emergency parking.”
Aaron doesn’t even have the decency to look guilty, shrugging with a smirk as he turns around to signal for a nurse to get you signed out.
The unsub sat shackled at the table, hunched but humming—this low, breathy sound that made your skin crawl as soon as the heavy door shut behind you. You moved just slightly behind Hotch, and his presence blocked the man’s view of you for a moment.
But the second you stepped to Hotch’s right and sat down, the unsub locked in. Like he’d been waiting for you. Your breath hitched—barely—but it was enough. He noticed.
“Agent,” he greeted, smiling at you, not Hotch. “You’re prettier in person.” Hotch’s eyes cut to you immediately, picking up on the freeze in your posture. He turned back to the man, jaw flexing. “You already know that comment’s not going to help you.”
The unsub didn’t blink. Just stared at you. Your badge. Your neckline. Your hands. “Do you wear that lipstick for the job, or for me?” he asked, smile widening.
Hotch didn’t wait—his fingers snapped toward the one-way mirror. “Tighten the restraints. Now.”
Two guards came in instantly. One placed a firm hand on the unsub’s shoulder, forcing him down as the other jerked the cuffs tighter around his wrists, metal biting into skin. He flinched but didn’t yell. Didn’t even wince. His eyes were still on you, hungry, assessing.
You inhaled, then exhaled carefully. He wanted a reaction. You didn’t give him one. Until you had to lean forward and push the file across the table.
That’s when he moved. Just a shift. Just a lean. But it was deliberate—his face closer to yours than you liked, enough that your own twisted in disgust before you could stop it.
“Stop,” Hotch said, his voice dark, deadly. His tone was enough to freeze the unsub in place. Still, the bastard smiled. “You’re not gonna let her talk for herself, Agent Hotchner?”
Hotch reached forward and took the file you’d opened, flipping it toward the unsub himself. His broad shoulders shifted, moving slightly in front of you again.
“She doesn’t need to,” Hotch said. “I already know what you are.”
“She’s better than the others,” he purrs. “You see it too. That’s why you walked in front of her. Like a shield. That’s sweet, Agent Hotchner. She deserves someone strong.”
You barely resist the urge to snap back. But Hotch’s hand reaches out—under the table—and briefly brushes your knee. A silent signal: Don’t react. Let me handle it.
“Why would I look at those,” he rasped, his voice low and oily, “when I’ve got her to look at instead?”
You froze. Hotch’s fingers twitched near his pen. His tone stayed flat. “That’s not how this works.”
“I already know all about her,” the unsub continued, still smiling. “She runs at five-thirty in the morning. Orders that lavender tea at the café across from the field office. Drives a black bmw. License plate ends in... seven-two-nine. Right?”
Your blood ran cold. You didn’t answer. You didn’t move.
Hotch stood abruptly. “You’re done.”
“No,” the unsub said, eyes still locked on you, smile growing. “I’m just getting started.”
Hotch was already at the door, signaling for the guard again. You stood slower, trying not to let the nausea show.
“You’ll speak to me,” Hotch said, voice a dark, contained growl. “Not her.”
“She’s the one I’ve been thinking about.”
“She’s not the one you're confessing to.”
“She’s the reason I started.” The unsub grinned, wild and victorious. “And she’ll be the reason I finish.”
You stood so fast your chair scraped backward, screeching against the floor.
Hotch turned to you instantly. “Agent,” he said quietly—his voice gentle now, only for you. “Step out.”
“I’m fine,” you said too quickly, jaw clenched.
His eyes searched yours for a beat longer than necessary, then nodded once.
The unsub chuckled. “Cute. Like a guard dog. I bet you like it when he barks for you.”
Hotch moved before you could blink. He was on the table, both hands planted, leaning in so close his voice was practically in the unsub’s ear.
“Say one more word about her,” Hotch growled, “and I will make sure your sentence includes solitary until you rot.”
Hotch’s hands were still flat on the table, his broad shoulders locked in tension. He didn’t move until he was sure the man’s mouth would stay shut.
“Guard. Get him out,” Hotch snapped, low and lethal.
The unsub laughed as the door slammed open behind you again. “You’ll think about me, sweetheart,” he called as they dragged him backward, wrists still bleeding from the restraints. “When you’re alone. When he’s not around to protect you.”
“Let’s go,” Hotch muttered under his breath to you, not even glancing back at the unsub again. His hand grazed your lower back as you turned—protective, firm, grounding.
You walked out together in silence, the door slamming shut behind you, drowning out the last of the unsub’s twisted chuckles.
“Hey,” he said gently, his voice lower now, quiet. “You okay?”
You blinked. “Yeah. Just... hate how he looked at me. Like he knew me.”
Hotch nodded slowly. “He’s been watching. We found photos in his storage unit. Some were taken last week.”
Your stomach dropped. “Of me?”
Hotch hesitated. “Of your apartment. Your car. A few of you in your running gear.”
You swallowed hard.“I had no idea—”
“That’s not your fault,” Hotch said firmly. “He’s good at hiding. That ends now. I should’ve gone in alone.”
You turned toward him, surprised. “Why?”
His jaw tightened again. That same damn muscle. “Because I saw the look in his eyes when you walked in,” he said, stepping closer, voice low. “And I knew exactly what he was thinking.”
Your heartbeat stuttered. He paused, then stepped just a little closer.
“You shouldn’t go home alone tonight.”
That surprised you. “I wasn’t planning to.”
His brows lifted just a fraction. “Good. Because I wasn’t going to let you.” That made your heart skip. Not because of what he said—but how he said it.
“I’ll stay at a hotel,” you murmured.
He paused, then offered, “You could stay at mine.”
You looked up. His expression didn’t change. He wasn’t playing. Wasn’t flirting. It wasn’t about that. It was about keeping you safe.
“…Okay,” you whispered. “Yeah. That’s probably best.”
His shoulders eased slightly.
And it wasn’t long before you found yourself standing in the hallway just outside his bedroom door, suddenly uncertain.
Hotch stepped behind you again. Close. Just like in the interrogation room.
“I’ll take the couch,” he said, already reading your hesitation.
“No,” you said quickly. “You don’t have to.”
He paused. “I want you to feel safe.”
“I do,” you whispered, looking back at him. “With you.”
“I’ll get you a shirt,” he murmured.
A moment later he returned and handed you a long, soft cotton t-shirt—gray, plain, worn thin at the collar.
You took it with a grateful smile and went into the bathroom.
When you came out, you were swimming in the shirt. It hit halfway down your thighs. Your legs were bare. You had never felt so exposed in something so modest.
Hotch was already lying down, propped on one elbow, the comforter pulled up around his waist. He wore a black t-shirt and soft plaid pajama pants. You had never, in your life, seen him so…human.
You climbed in slowly, tentatively. His side of the bed was warm. Yours felt cold.
It was awkward. Weirdly awkward.
And that’s when it hit you. A sudden, absurd giggle bubbled up in your throat.
Hotch turned toward you, brow furrowed. “What?”
You bit your lip, grinning. “Nothing. It’s just—” You gestured vaguely at him. “Seeing you like this—in actual pajamas—? It’s adorable. I’m sorry, I can’t unsee it.”
He stared for a beat, expression unreadable. You swallowed hard, worried you might’ve crossed a line.
But then—then—he smiled. That small, rare curve of his lips that made you feel like the only person in the world.
“Don’t twist my words,” you warned, still smiling. “You’re intimidating as hell at work.”
“But not now?”
You looked at him—really looked—and swallowed hard. “No. Now you’re…”
Your voice faltered.
Hotch’s hand lifted slowly, brushing a piece of hair behind your ear.
“Safe,” you whispered. “You feel safe.”
His fingers didn’t move from your face. “I want you to feel safe,” he said softly. “Always.”
You exhaled shakily. “Even now?”
“Especially now.”
He curled it around your waist and slowly, slowly pulled you into him.
His body was so warm—heat radiating off him like a furnace—and you exhaled the breath you hadn’t realized you were holding. His chest was solid, his hold careful. Too careful. Like he didn’t trust himself.
You nestled into him, your nose at his shoulder, cheek resting against the soft cotton of his t-shirt. You smiled against him.
“You’re tense,” you whispered.
“I’m not,” he said immediately.
“You are, Hotch,” you laughed. “Your arm feels like it’s trying to protect the nuclear codes.”
His chest rumbled faintly in amusement. “I’m trying to be respectful.”
You smiled wider. “You’re letting me cuddle you. That’s pretty respectful.”
He didn’t argue that.
You tilted your head up slightly, looking toward the sharp line of his jaw in the dark.
“I’m not gonna combust if you relax.”
He didn’t say anything, but the arm around your waist loosened just a little. He exhaled—and the tension in his chest eased. Just enough to make you feel it. You took your chance.
You reached up slowly and ran your fingers through his hair.
At first, he flinched—just a twitch, barely noticeable. But then he stilled, letting you continue.
Your hand moved lower, smoothing down over his chest, then his shoulder, until it found one of his hands resting on his stomach.
His huge hand.
You picked it up gently, letting his fingers relax in your grip.
“What are you doing?” he asked, voice low.
You cradled his palm and gently cracked one of his knuckles.
He winced. “That hurts.”
You looked up, mock-pouting. “You’re supposed to say thank you.”
He chuckled. “For joint pain?”
“For your nerves. You’re all… balled up like a stress knot.” You moved to his other hand, gently stretching each finger. “And this one? This one’s the button-pushing hand. I bet it’s tired from dealing with assholes all day.”
He huffed out something that might’ve been a laugh. “You’re ridiculous.”
You tilted your head and reached up to brush your fingers through his hair—soft, thicker than it looked at work, with the faintest wave. He looked down at you, stilling completely under your touch.
“You’re really bad at relaxing,” you whispered.
“And you’re really good at tempting me,” he said softly.
You leaned in again, closer this time, your legs brushing. His arm came around you slowly, tentatively, drawing you toward his chest until your head rested just below his collarbone.
You exhaled shakily. “Is this okay?”
“Yeah,” he said, voice low and quiet. “Just… not used to this.”
You tilted your head to look at him. His expression was unreadable in the low light, but his jaw was tight.
“Your hands,” you said quietly, lifting one of them between your palms. “They're so big.”
His brows lifted slightly. “That a problem?”
“No,” you said, voice dipping. “It’s hot.”
He huffed a soft laugh, but his thumb rubbed lightly across your side. You turned his palm over and started gently cracking his knuckles again. One by one. Each pop was soft, and you smiled as you moved to the next.
But when you got to his index finger and pressed just enough—
“Mm—hey,” he winced, pulling his hand back slightly. “That actually hurts.”
You blinked. “Seriously? You wrestle unsubs to the ground, but you can’t handle me cracking your knuckles?”
“I don’t wrestle people who sneak up and break my fingers.”
You laughed again, more relaxed now, and leaned in close enough that your nose brushed his shoulder. “I’m sorry,” you said with a smirk. “You’re so delicate, Hotch.”
He turned to look at you, and this time, he was smiling. Really smiling. Barely-there dimple, soft eyes, warmth radiating from him.
“You think I’m delicate?”
“I think you’re secretly a marshmallow,” you whispered, inching even closer. “All this serious FBI Alpha Male stuff is just an act.”
He didn’t answer. Just looked at you, gaze dark and quiet and far too intense for the softness of the moment.
You swallowed. Suddenly very aware of how close you were. Of his hand on your waist. Of the warmth between you. Of the ridiculous oversize shirt that was definitely not a barrier. Not now.
“Is that what you really think?” he asked, voice so low it made your skin prickle.
You tilted your chin up slightly, your lips dangerously close to the line of his jaw. “Maybe.” Your hands in his hair, soft and uncertain, pulling him in closer. Your lips brushed again, then again—until it turned into something real. Something deep and needy and so full of everything you hadn’t said.
Hotch shifted, rolling you gently onto your back, his body hovering over yours, held up on one arm.
“You’re trembling,” he murmured against your cheek.
“I’m nervous,” you admitted, voice cracking just slightly. He didn’t answer. Just looked at you, gaze dark and quiet and far too intense for the softness of the moment.
Your heart stuttered. Your legs shifted, thighs tightening as you accidentally ground your hips slightly against his under the covers.
He exhaled sharply through his nose, grip tightening.
You surged up into him, kissing him, wrapping your arms around his neck as he slid a thigh between yours. His weight was comforting, grounding—and yet, your whole body felt like it was floating.
He pulled back slightly, lips brushing yours. “Tell me if you want to stop.”
“I won’t,” you whispered. “Not with you.”
Hotch’s mouth found your neck—slow and reverent, dragging warmth down your throat as he settled between your legs. His hands roamed cautiously under the hem of your borrowed shirt, palms warm and rough on your bare skin.
You moaned softly as his thigh slid between yours, pressing.
“You have no idea what it did to me,” he whispered into your skin, “hearing him talk about you like that.”
“I hated it,” you breathed. “I wanted to claw his face off.”
Hotch laughed. “That’s my girl.”
The words hit you straight in the core—made you shiver.
His hands moved beneath the shirt he’d given you, sliding along your bare thighs, up to your hips. When he realized you weren’t wearing anything underneath, his breath hitched.
“Jesus,” he muttered, pulling back just enough to look down at you. “You’re not wearing—?”
You flushed. “Didn’t feel like it.”
In one fluid motion, he sat up, his arms wrapping around you, mouth claiming yours again—hotter, hungrier now. You let him take the lead, let him slide your shirt up over your head and toss it somewhere off the bed. The way he looked at you then—like reverence, like worship—made heat pool between your legs.
“You’re beautiful,” he rasped, fingertips ghosting down your spine. “So fucking beautiful.”
You gasped when he leaned forward, taking one of your nipples into his mouth, tongue flicking over it before he sucked—slow, teasing, patient. One hand moved between your legs, fingers brushing you just enough to feel the slickness there.
He tugged his waistband down just enough to free himself, and you gasped at the sight of him—thick, flushed, already leaking at the tip.
You reached down and gripped him, guiding his head to your entrance. The first brush made both of you groan.
The second his tip slid through your slick. “Fuck, sweetheart—look at you.” Hands tightening around your hips.
You lowered yourself slowly, inch by inch, your thighs trembling at the stretch.
“That’s it,” Hotch growled. “Take your time. I’ve got you.”
Once he was fully inside, you sat still for a second, breathing shallowly.
He brushed your cheek again. “Look at me.”
You did—and that’s when it changed. Because there wasn’t just lust in his eyes. There was something far deeper. Something that told you this wasn’t just sex for him.
You whimpered and leaned forward, hands braced on his chest, and the shift in angle made stars flash behind your eyes. He pushed up into you now, shallow, controlled thrusts that made your clit drag just right with every motion.
Your thighs trembled as you moved, your breaths turning into gasps. He sat up slightly, arms wrapping around your back, and you clung to him as you moved together.
“I’ve never…” you breathed against his neck. “I’ve never felt like this with anyone.”
He stilled inside you, holding you tight. “That’s because they didn’t deserve you.”
You clutched at his shirt. “But you do?”
He pulled back just enough to look at you, his gaze dark and reverent.
“I’m going to earn you,” he said. “Every day.”
Your heart cracked open. You kissed him with everything you had, hips rolling down onto him again, chasing that high, and he let you ride it out, guiding you with soft praise and firm hands and that warmth—God, that unshakable, grounding warmth.
And when you came, it was with his arms wrapped tight around you, his voice in your ear, whispering that you were safe.
summary - The game is simple. Two players. One gun. One bullet. One winner. When an investigation into a sadistic serial killer takes a devastating turn, both you and BAU Unit Chief Aaron Hotchner find yourselves trapped in a subterranean nightmare, chained by your ankles to the floor of an abandoned swimming pool. As the killer broadcasts your capture live to a horrified Quantico bullpen, days of freezing cold, psychological degradation, and impossible choices force the professional barriers you’ve maintained for years to completely shatter. Stripped of rank, authority, and any hope of easy rescue, you must navigate a sadistic game of survival where refusing to pull the trigger means risking everything, and where surviving the darkness requires finally facing the feelings you’ve kept buried for far too long. The choice is yours, Agents. Kill. Or be killed.
word count - 9.2k
content warnings -bau!reader, kidnapped reader and Aaron, forced nudity, humiliation, descriptions of injury and blood, s3 characters, physical violence. I always write Hotch with an age gap in mind but I don't think it actually makes a difference.
The first sensation was sensory violence, the sharp, metallic tang of dried blood in your mouth, the excruciating ache of a bruised ribcage, and the smell of ancient water, stagnant, laced with pulverised lime and dry rot. Your eyelids felt clamped shut by dried sweat and filth. When you dragged them open, the world was a smear of dark grey and sulfurous yellow. You were lying flat on your stomach against grit strewn concrete, your right cheek pressed into cold tile that smelled faintly of dead algae. A brutal, rhythmic throbbing hammered against the inside of your skull, matching the ragged cadence of your pulse. You pushed yourself up with a weak groan, your hands scraping against slick, granular concrete. Your vision swam, blue spots dancing across the shadows of a massive, cavernous space.
Tiled walls, discolored by decades of black mold and mineral streaks, stretched upward into a high ceiling of skeletal steel trusses. High overhead, narrow windows held broken panes of glass, letting in faint, sickly shafts of moonlight that sliced through clouds of suspended dust motes. You were in the deep end of an abandoned indoor swimming pool. The steep incline of the floor rose up behind you, leading toward a shallow end that was completely swallowed by shadow.
A sharp, heavy metallic clank echoed through the basin, the sound ringing off the hard walls like a gunshot. "Don't move too fast. You have a concussion." The voice was rough, gravelly, and stripped raw, but the underlying cadence, even in a rasping whisper, belonged to Unit Chief Aaron Hotchner.
"Hotch?" You whipped your head around, a sudden spike of motion that sent a nausea-inducing ripple through your brain.
Aaron sat roughly fourteen feet away, his back pressed against the sloped wall of the pool’s deep end. The sight of him was unnerving. His dark hair, usually parted and immaculately styled, fell across his forehead in damp, dark clumps. His suit jacket was gone, his crisp white dress shirt was ripped at the collar and heavily stained with oil, dirt, and a thick smudge of dried blood along the left shoulder. Yet despite the physical devastation, his dark eyes were focused, and moving over you with relentless, mechanical precision. "Check your limbs," he instructed softly, his baritone vibrating through the damp air. "Are you bleeding anywhere else? Any major fractures?"
"I... I don't think so," you breathed, your throat feeling as though it had been scrubbed with raw wire. "My head. My ribs."
You instinctually scrambled to cross the floor toward him, but a violent, unyielding jolt ripped through your right leg, snapping your heel back and slamming your body hard onto the tile. A sharp, lightning-hot spike of agony shot up your shin. You gasped, clutching your lower leg as a heavy, sickening rattle echoed off the tile floor. Wrapped firmly around your right ankle was a thick, industrial iron shackle. The metal was cold, biting directly into your skin. Attached to the collar was a dense, heavy-gauge steel chain, its links welded together and anchored directly into an iron eye-bolt sunk six inches into the pool wall behind you.
"Don't pull," Hotch ordered. His voice dropped into its familiar, stern register, the voice he used when de-escalating barricaded suspects, grounding subjects in shock, or commanding an operating room. "The edges are sharp. If you yank against the anchor, it’ll tear through your Achilles." He flexed his own right leg, pulling back the hem of his dark trousers to reveal not only that he had also been stripped of his shoes, but a matching iron cuff clamped around his ankle, its heavy chain stretching back to a secondary anchor bolt in the wall. “Ask me how I know.”
"Where are we?" you whispered, your fingers tracing the biting edge of the iron ring around your skin. "How long?"
"I woke up twenty minutes ago," Hotch said, his eyes scanning the steep, featureless tiling above your heads. "Based on the drying state of the blood on my shoulder, we've been unconscious for at least six hours. We were taken from the staging area outside the warehouse in Maryland."
Panic flared, a hot, suffocating burn in your throat. You dragged yourself to your feet, the chain clinking loudly, dragging through the dirt like a lead weight behind you. You rushed to the absolute limit of its slack. The heavy iron links went taut with a sharp ping, pulling your ankle back. The smooth, tiled pool walls rose at least twelve feet directly above your head, slicked over with a wet sheen of moss and mineral crust. The stainless-steel rungs of the ladder had been sawed off near the lip, leaving only rusted stubs embedded in the concrete above.
"There's no grip," you gasped, your nails scraping uselessly against the glazed tile. "It's completely smooth."
"Look at the floor angle," Hotch said smoothly, standing up. Even filthy and restrained, his posture was rigid, commanding space through sheer force of will. "The chain length gives each of us roughly an eight-foot radius. Our reach overlaps by about three feet in the center near the drainage grate."
"Hotch, look up there," you breathed, pointing toward the high rim above his side of the wall. "If I can get onto your shoulders, I might be able to reach the top of the pool floor, pull myself up, and find something to anchor a rope to."
Hotch didn't waste breath debating. He immediately dragged himself to the threshold of his chain's reach, stretching every link until the metal creaked and bit viciously into his skin. "Step on my knee first," he gritted out, bracing his palms flat against the cold tile wall, flexing his frame. "Then my shoulder. Drive your heel up, don't lean back."
You crossed the small circle of space where your two chained territories intersected. The moment your skin brushed his, your hands steadying against the solid, warm mass of his back, a surreal, sharp shock cut through the cold terror. For months at Quantico, between late-night case reviews, coffee runs, and shared silences over file folders, there had been an unspoken tension, a rigid line neither of you crossed due to protocol, rank, and fear of what lay beyond it. Now, stripped of rank and trapped in dark concrete, the physical proximity felt explosive.
You placed your bare foot on his thigh, then shifted your weight up onto his shoulder. Hotch exhaled sharply through his teeth, his shoulder muscles locking beneath your weight as he pushed upward, hoisting you higher into the gloom. "Can you reach?" he rasped. Warm breath fanned against your leg through the tear in your pants.
You stretched your arms until your shoulder sockets burned, your fingertips desperately scraping at the curved concrete lip of the pool deck. An inch. Just two inches more. You strained upward, your foot slipping slightly against his damp shirt. "I can't get a grip!" you gasped, your fingers slipping over smooth, algae-slicked tile. "It's slipping, there's no edge. I can't hold on!"
"Push!" Hotch commanded, his voice strained as his legs trembled under the uneven weight. "One more inch!"
You pushed onto your toes, the balls of your feet digging into Aaron’s shoulders as you desperately reached towards safety. Your fingers slid completely off the slick lip. Your center of gravity failed, and you slid down his back, falling heavily onto the concrete floor. Hotch turned instantly, catching you by the waist to break your impact, taking the brunt of your fall as you both crashed into the grit.
For three ragged heartbeats, you were pinned against his chest. His arms wrapped firmly around your waist, his heart hammering like a trapped bird against his ribs, his breath hot against your neck. His fingers tightened into your shirt, not like an officer holding a subordinate, but like a drowning man clinging to a lifeline.
Then, the cold reality of the room crashed back down. Hotch slowly let his hands fall away, his jaw clenching as he pulled back, instantly rebuilding the invisible wall between you.
You were trapped. Completely, utterly, and structurally trapped.
Before the terror could fully settle into your bones, a deafening, high-pitched screech tore through the cavernous space.
It was feedback, a violent, high-decibel audio crackling through a hidden horn speaker high up in the rafters. You both winced, slamming your hands over your ears as the sound ricocheted off the hard tiles, rattling through your teeth. Then came a voice. It was electronically altered, shifted down into a heavy, gravelly rasp that sounded synthesised and metallic, yet underlined by an unmistakably mocking, sing-song cadence.
"Oh, look at you two," the voice purred from above, dripping with cruel amusement. "The great FBI profilers. The intellectual elite from Quantico. You spent three weeks reading my crime scenes. Analysing my pathology. Writing little notes on your glass whiteboards about my insecurities. And now... look at you. Scrambling in the dirt like rats in a bucket."
Hotch stood up instantly, putting himself half an inch in front of you, his body instinctively forming a barrier, his eyes searching the dark rafters for the lens of a camera.
"You like games, don't you, Aaron?" the speaker crackled, followed by the wet, clicking sound of someone chewing tongue-in-cheek. "You study human behavior. You think you know what people do when they're pushed to the edge. So let's test your little theories. Let's see how noble the BAU really is when the light goes out."
A harsh, mechanical clunk echoed near the center of the pool, followed by the metallic skittering of something heavy sliding across the concrete incline.
Your eyes snapped down to the drain at the lowest point of the floor, right in the center of your overlapping reach. Resting squarely over the rusted iron grate was a sleek, matte-black Glock 19 pistol. Next to it, glinting dull yellow in the pale shafts of moonlight, lay a single brass 9mm cartridge.
"The rules are so very simple," the unsub’s voice crooned, mocking and light, as if explaining a children's board game. "Eeny, meeny, miny, moe... catch a profiler by the toe. One gun. One bullet. One door that unlocks when the scale is balanced. One of you leaves alive. The other stays behind to rot. Who lives and who goes? I'll let you two draw up the profile on that." The speaker cut out with a sharp, static pop.
Silence rushed back in, heavy, cold, and suffocating.
The profile screamed through both of your minds simultaneously. This was the unsub's exact MO from the regional cases you had been tracking, forced psychological cannibalism. He didn't execute his victims himself, he captured pairs, partners, siblings, lovers, and forced them into a zero-sum nightmare where survival required murder, leaving the survivor destroyed by guilt.
Hotch’s dark eyes locked onto the black metal weapon on the floor.
"Don't move," Hotch said softly. The tone was no longer that of a trapped victim. It was Unit Chief Aaron Hotchner, cold, absolute, terrifyingly composed. "Stay where you are."
"Hotch-"
"That is an order," he said, turning his head slightly, his gaze sharp enough to cut glass. "You do not touch that weapon."
"We aren't in a briefing room!" you yelled, the fear and adrenaline finally boiling over, your voice echoing off the damp tiles. "You don't get to pull rank down here! Look at us! We are chained in a hole!"
"Which is precisely why you need to listen to me!" Hotch snapped back, his stoic veneer cracking, his voice dropping into a harsh, desperate whisper. "You take the gun. You load it. You shoot me."
A cold, nauseating shock hit your stomach. "What?"
"You heard me," he said, stepping as far toward the drain as his chain allowed, his eyes burning into yours with a terrifyingly clear resolve. "You pick up the round, you load the magazine, and you put a bullet through my heart. You walk out of here."
"Are you insane?!" you whispered, your voice cracking. "I am not shooting you!"
"Listen to the math!" Hotch demanded, his jaw clenching so hard the muscle twitched wildly beneath his pale skin. "It is a cold, tactical reality! Jack needs a father, yes, but more than that, I cannot allow you… a member of my team to die on my watch while I stand here and survive it! I won't do it!"
"So you think your life automatically means less than mine?!" you countered, tears of rage burning behind your eyelids as you stepped right up to the limit of your chain, mere inches from his chest. "You think you're just some noble sacrifice? 'The Unit Chief dies so the subordinate lives', is that the script you wrote in your head?!"
"It isn't a script, it's my responsibility!" Hotch shouted back, the sheer volume of his voice shocking you into silence. His chest was heaving, his breathing jagged. "My responsibility is to keep you safe! If one person walks out of this pool, it has to be you!"
"I am not letting you commit suicide by cop through me, Hotch!" you sobbed, the tears finally spilling over, cutting clean tracks through the grime on your face. "You have a son! You have Jack! He lost his mother! Do you have any idea what it would do to him to lose you too?! Do you think I could ever look that little boy in the eye, knowing I pulled the trigger on his father just so I could keep breathing?!"
"You wouldn't have to look him in the eye," Hotch whispered, his voice fracturing, a raw, bleeding edge of agony showing through his brown eyes. "You would live.”
"I am replaceable! The Bureau can assign another profiler to your unit by next Monday. Morgan is your muscle, Reid is your brains, Garcia is your tech. I-...The team can find another generic agent! But Jack cannot get another father! You have a life waiting for you out there! I am not trading your life for mine!"
Hotch stared down at you, his breathing shallow, his face inches from yours. Something deeply buried in his eyes broke, a floodgate of emotion he had kept locked behind steel doors for years.
Without another word, Hotch suddenly lunged downward toward the drain.
"NO!" you shrieked, diving forward, but your chain snapped taut, jerking your leg backward and slamming your knees into the harsh tile.
Hotch snatched the Glock off the concrete. With terrifying, practiced muscle memory, his hands worked in a blur, he slammed the single 9mm cartridge into the magazine, slapped the baseplate into the magwell, and racked the slide back with a sharp, heavy clack.
He didn't point the weapon at you.
He reversed his grip, turned the muzzle inward, and pressed the heavy steel barrel directly against the skin underneath his chin. His thumb rested firmly over the frame, slipping off the safety.
"NO! Stop! Please, Aaron, stop!" you screamed, dragging yourself through the dirt, reaching out your arms, but you were three agonising feet short of reaching his hands.
"Tell Jack I loved him," Hotch whispered softly, his fingers tightening against the trigger, his dark eyes fixed on yours with a cold, devastating peace. "Tell him I’m sorry."
"AARON, NO-!"
A high-pitched, mocking buzzer blasted through the horn speaker, cutting through the cavernous pool like a knife.
"Tsk, tsk, tsk... oh, Aaron. How predictably melodramatic," the unsub's electronic voice purred, practically dripping with sarcastic disappointment.
Hotch froze, the steel barrel still pressed hard against his jaw, his breath catching in his throat.
"Did you really think I didn't profile you?" the voice mocked, laughing softly, a cold, wet sound. "I knew you’d try the hero routine. martyr complex. 'I'll just shoot myself and save the girl.' How noble. How utterly boring."
A pause stretched over the tannoy, heavy and malicious.
"Let me clarify the rules for the hero," the voice continued, dropping into a low, vicious whisper. "If you pull that trigger and blow your own brains out, the game doesn't end. The door stays locked. And your precious little agent will sit down there in the dark, chained with your decaying corpse, listening to the flies, until she dies of dehydration over the next five days."
The speaker let out a final, taunting chuckle. "Choose wisely, profiler. Your death doesn't save her. It just guarantees she suffers longer."
Click. The tannoy went completely dead.
The silence that followed was suffocating, heavy enough to crush bone.
Hotch stood motionless in the center of the floor. The weapon trembled slightly in his hand. The horrifying, mathematical reality of the unsub's trap settled over him like a shroud, self-sacrifice stripped away. Suicide was not a rescue, it was a slow, tortured execution of the person he was trying to protect. Slowly, his fingers shaking, Hotch eased his finger off the trigger. He engaged the safety, pulled the slide back to catch the unfired cartridge as it ejected, and let the empty pistol and single brass bullet fall back onto the iron grate between you with a dull clatter.
He sank to his knees in the dirt. Moving slowly, as if carrying the weight of the entire world on his shoulders, Hotch dragged himself across the concrete until he reached the absolute limit of his chain, mere inches from where you sat curled with your knees against your chest, weeping on the floor.
Reaching out a trembling, dirt-stained hand, Hotch gently cupped the side of your face. His skin was cold, but his thumb was unbelievably soft as it swept across your cheekbone, wiping away a streak of tears and grime. "I'm sorry," he breathed, his voice breaking into a quiet, fractured whisper. He leaned forward until his forehead rested lightly against yours, his dark eyes searching yours with an unbearable, heartbreaking vulnerability. "I'm so sorry... you're not replaceable. Not to the team. Not to me."
Your fingers curled into the ripped sleeves of his shirt, pulling the fabric taught around his arms. Your breath hitched in your throat, a sob that echoed off the vast tiles. As Hotch’s fingers curled around the back of your head, a single red LED light began to blink slowly high up in the dark.
–
The atmosphere inside the BAU bullpen was suffocating.
Twelve hours.
Twelve harrowing hours had passed since you and Aaron had missed your mandatory morning check-in while following up on a local lead in rural Maryland. Twelve hours of silent cell phones, dead GPS trackers, and a cold case file sitting open on the glass round table in the conference room.
Penelope Garcia sat at her primary console, her usual bright, eccentric clothing replaced by an oversized black cardigan. Her eyes were bloodshot, mascara smudged down her cheeks, her fingers flying across her glowing keyboards in an absolute, frantic blur of desperation. Derek Morgan paced the perimeter of the bullpen like a caged predator, his leather jacket discarded, his sleeves rolled up, his hands clenched so tightly into fists that his knuckles were stark white.
Spencer Reid stood near the central glass board, staring blankly at the tactical map of your last known cell tower ping, holding his notebook so tightly the covers ripped.
JJ stood near the glass wall of the briefing room, her arms wrapped tightly around herself, her phone glued to her ear, listening to an automated voicemail for the hundredth time.
"Give me something, Garcia," Morgan growled, his voice dangerously low, stripped of all its usual humor. "Anything. A traffic camera, an ATM sweep, a credit card hit, give me a direction."
"I'm trying!" Garcia choked out, her voice cracking as a fresh tear spilled down her face. "I'm scrubbing every closed-circuit feed within a sixty-mile radius of the dump site! They vanished off the grid! Their state vehicles were wiped clean! There’s no-"
A sharp, piercing digital tone chimed through the bullpen's main audio array. The entire room froze. The click of keyboards stopped instantly.
"What was that?" Spencer asked, taking three long strides toward Garcia’s desk.
"An incoming high-priority network packet..." Garcia whispered, her hands trembling so violently she could barely hit the spacebar. "It bypassed the FBI gateway security... it’s an auto-executing socket connection routed through a darknet proxy."
"Trace it," Morgan snapped, instantly leaning over her shoulder, his jaw set like iron. "Isolate the node before you execute-"
"I can't block it!" Garcia cried out, burying her face in her hands for a brief second before pulling back. "It’s an auto-launch video stream! It's forcing itself onto the main bullpen display!"
The massive glass screen mounted on the wall of the bullpen flickered. A line of corrupted red code scrolled across the top, followed by a harsh burst of static. Then, the picture resolved. It was a high-definition, crisp video feed. There was no audio, the stream had been intentionally muted at the source, but the visual clarity was nightmare inducing. A dimly lit, abandoned indoor swimming pool. The steep concrete floor of the deep end, covered in dirt and dried water stains. Two figures sitting in the center of the frame, heavy iron shackles wrapped tight around their ankles, chains anchored into the solid wall.
And lying directly between them, resting on a rusted iron drain grate, sat a black Glock pistol and a single, brass bullet.
"Oh, God..." JJ gasped, slamming her hand over her mouth, stumbling back against the glass wall.
Morgan stepped back as if he had been physically hit in the chest, his eyes wide, his chest heaving. "Hotch..."
On the wall display, the team watched in agonising, silent terror as the drama unfolded in real time.
They saw Hotch on his knees, reaching out to gently, desperately cup the side of your face. They saw the raw, unshielded tenderness in his body language, a soft, disturbing vulnerability that none of them had ever seen on their stoic, unyielding Unit Chief in all the years they had worked beside him. They watched you weeping, reaching for him, your foreheads pressed together in the dark hole, locked in a silent, desperate exchange of words the team couldn't hear.
"He didn't just take them," Spencer whispered, his voice dropping, his dark eyes locked onto the black gun on the screen. "He's making them play his game."
"And he's forcing us to watch," Morgan gritted out, his knuckles popping as his hands balled into fists.
Garcia looked up at the screen, her heart breaking into a thousand pieces as she watched her boss, the man who held the entire team together, hold your face in his hands like you were the only thing keeping him tethered to the earth.
"Find them, Garcia," Morgan demanded, his voice cracking with lethal intent. "Find them right now."
–
The metallic echo of the unsub’s voice slowly dissolved into the vast, cavernous silence of the abandoned pool. The air remained dead and heavy, thick with the stench of stagnant dampness, pulverised mortar, and the lingering, sulfurous bite of industrial chemicals. In the dim light, the matte-black glock lay undisturbed atop the iron drain. It was no longer just a weapon, it was a physical monument to your helplessness, a cruel centerpiece around which your captivity revolved.
Hotch remained kneeling in the grit, his breathing slow and measured, though the muscles along his jaw were locked so tight they twitched. His eyes hadn't left yours. The thumb that had wiped away your tear lingered against your skin for a second longer than protocol ever allowed before his hand slowly, reluctantly dropped back to his side.
"We need to preserve our energy," Hotch said softly, his voice returning to that low, steady baritone, though the raw strain beneath it was unmistakable. "Dehydration will set in within twenty-four hours. Shock and blood loss will accelerate it. Every unnecessary movement, every rise in heart rate, consumes resources we can't afford to waste."
You nodded numbly, the reality of your predicament settling like lead in your chest. You looked up into the dark rafters, your eyes scanning the heavy iron trusses and ruined skylights. The cavernous ceiling was swallow-whole by shadow, completely obscured by decades of soot and dust. There was no visible glass, no glint of metal, nothing to indicate where the speaker had been placed, or that a hidden lens was tucked deep within the dark scaffolding above, silently capturing every breath, every flinch, every involuntary touch, and transmitting it directly to the horror-struck bullpen in Quantico.
To you and Hotch, you were completely alone in the dark.
"Come here," Hotch murmured, gesturing to the narrow strip of concrete floor where your two chains overlapped. Moving with a weak slowness to spare your throbbing head and bruised ribs, you dragged yourself across the gritty floor. The iron shackle scraped loudly against the concrete, a dull, harsh clank that made you wince. Hotch shifted his weight, backing up until his broad spine pressed flush against the damp, mold-stained tile wall of the deep end. You settled beside him, pulling your knees up toward your chest to trap what little body heat remained in your shivering frame. The concrete beneath you was mercilessly cold, seeping through your clothes and settling deep into your bones. Hotch didn't hesitate, he shifted closer, closing the small gap between you until his shoulder pressed firmly against yours, providing a solid, unyielding anchor of warmth in the freezing dark.
For a long time, neither of you spoke. The silence stretched, filled only by the distant, rhythmic dripping of water somewhere in the upper pipes and the synchronised cadence of your breathing.
"How is your head?" Hotch asked softly, breaking the silence without looking over. His eyes remained fixed on the far wall, vigilant, constantly calculating.
"It throbs," you admitted, your voice small, swallowed by the vastness of the room. "Feels like someone’s squeezing my temples. But I can focus. I don't think my skull is fractured."
"Good," he murmured. "And the concussion?"
"Manageable. I'm not nauseous anymore." You turned your head slightly, looking at the dark profile of his face, the sharp line of his jaw, the dark circles bruising the skin beneath his eyes, the grime smeared across his cheekbone. "What about you? Your shoulder..."
"Soft tissue damage from the impact when they took us," he replied dismissively, classic Hotchner, brushing aside his own pain as if it were a minor inconvenience. "Nothing broken. I'll survive it."
You let out a faint, dry breath that was almost a laugh, though there was no humor in it. "You always say that. I'll survive it. Like it's just an administrative task on your desk."
A faint, almost imperceptible tilt appeared at the corner of his lips, a shadow of a smile that vanished as quickly as it came. "It's a necessity."
"We're off the clock, Hotch," you whispered, leaning back against the cold tiles, your eyes tracking the pale moonlight drifting through the broken skylight above. "You don't have to put on the armor down here."
The silence returned, heavier this time, carrying all the unsaid things that had piled up between you over months of late-night file reviews, shared flights on the jet, and longing glances across crowded rooms.
Hotch exhaled, a long, shuddering breath that rattled faintly in his chest. "I should have seen the counter-surveillance," he said quietly, his tone dropping into a rare, painful register of self-reproach. "When we went to verify the secondary warehouse address in Maryland. The vehicle parked two blocks back... I logged it, but I didn't push for local backup before we breached the perimeter. I broke protocol."
"Stop," you said firmly, turning your face toward his. "He ambushed us with a localised flash-bang and CS gas in a closed hallway. You didn't break protocol. He set a trap, and we walked into it together. Profilers aren't psychic."
"It's my job to foresee the variables," he insisted, his voice laced with guilt. "My job is to bring every single member of my team home alive at the end of a case. And right now... I have put you in a position where survival depends on a monster's whim."
"You didn't put me anywhere," you said softly, reaching out to catch his arm. Your fingers gripped the rough, torn cotton of his sleeve, feeling the rigid, tense muscle beneath. "I'm here because I chose this job. Because I chose this team. Because I chose to follow you into that building."
Hotch slowly turned his head. In the dim moonlight, his dark eyes met yours. The stoic, unyielding chief of the Behavioral Analysis Unit was gone, replaced entirely by a man stripped raw, exhausted, and utterly terrified, not for himself, but for you.
"I can't lose you," he whispered. The words were so quiet, so devoid of his usual authority, that they sounded almost fragile. "I've lost... I have lost too much. If I lose you like this..." He swallowed hard, his throat working as he cut himself off, unable to voice the end of the thought. Your chest ached with a physical, crushing tightness. Without thinking, without care for protocols or boundaries or the professional distance you had maintained for so long, you let your head drop sideways, resting it firmly against the crook of his shoulder.
Hotch stiffened for a single heartbeat, his breath catching in his throat at the sudden, intimate contact. Then, with a long, trembling exhale, the tension bled out of his frame. He let his head tilt slightly, his cheek coming to rest lightly against the crown of your hair.
Slowly, deliberately, Hotch brought his hand down. His large, calloused fingers brushed against your wrist, tracing the sensitive skin before his palm encompassed yours. His fingers laced through yours, his grip firm, steady, and unyielding, a human anchor tethering both of you to reality in the middle of a nightmare.
"I won't let him break you," Hotch murmured into your hair, his voice fierce, low, and absolute. "I promise you. Whatever comes next... I won't let him break you."
You squeezed his hand in response, burying your face deeper into the solid warmth of his shoulder, letting the rhythmic rise and fall of his chest steady your own frantic heart. “I know.” You murmured gently.
High above you, hidden deep within the black lattice of the ceiling trusses, the tiny red lens of the concealed camera continued to blink silently in the dark. And miles away in Quantico, projected in sickening, high-definition clarity across the main monitor of the bullpen, the entire team stood frozen in total, breathless silence, watching their boss hold your hand in the dark, tethered to a cold concrete floor, waiting out the night together.
–
Your eyes flickered open to a heavy, suffocating darkness, broken only by the faint, icy shaft of moonlight filtering down through the broken skylight above. Your body was rigid with cold, every muscle aching from the relentless chill of the concrete floor. But you weren't lying flat against the grit. Your head was resting in the soft fold of warm, coarse fabric. A heavy, comforting weight on the crown of your head as Aaron’s palm cradled you, his fingers lightly curled around the strands of your hair. You shifted slightly, wincing as a dull spike of pain throbbed behind your eyes. Above you, the steady, rhythmic rise and fall of a chest vibrated against your temple. You looked up into the gloom.
Aaron was leaning back against the cold, mold-stained tiles of the pool wall. His chin was resting against his collarbone, his dark eyes closed, his breathing long and deliberate. His face was a mask of pale exhaustion, deep dark circles bruised under his eyes, grime and dried blood smudging his cheek. Yet his jaw was tight, his body tense, a man locked in a state of hyper-vigilance even while motionless. He hadn't slept. He couldn't.
Your movement caused his eyes to snap open instantly, dark and piercingly sharp in the gloom, instantly assessing your surroundings before dropping down to lock onto yours. "Don't move too fast," Aaron whispered. His voice was raw, a rough rasp stripped down by hours of cold air and zero water.
You didn't move away. The warmth radiating from him was the only thing keeping the shivering in your limbs manageable. "How long was I out?"
"Roughly four hours," Aaron murmured, moving his hand to rest on the concrete inches from your head, his fingers twitching slightly before he pulled them back, keeping a rigid handle on himself. "It's close to four in the morning."
You let out a soft, dry breath, your throat feeling like it was lined with glass. "You didn't sleep at all."
"Someone needed to stay awake," he replied simply. His voice carried that familiar, immovable weight, standing guard even when chained by the ankle to a floor. "The temperature dropped significantly around midnight. If I let you slide onto the bare concrete, hypothermia would set in faster."
You slowly pushed yourself up, sitting beside him against the tiled wall. The heavy iron shackle around your right ankle clinked softly, a cold reminder of the iron ring binding you to the concrete floor. You pulled your knees to your chest, shivering violently as the damp chill seeped back into your clothes.
"Any sign of him?" you asked softly, your eyes scanning the dark, cavernous rafters overhead.
"No," Aaron said, his gaze fixed on the matte-black Glock sitting in the middle of the floor atop the rusted drain, its solitary brass round gleaming dully in the dim light. "He’s watching. But he hasn't moved. He's letting the environment do his work for him. Hunger, dehydration, isolation, sleep deprivation. He wants our cognitive functions to degrade until impulse overrides judgment."
"He doesn't know us very well then," you murmured, resting your side against his broad shoulder for warmth.
An almost imperceptible exhalation escaped Aaron, a phantom of a laugh. "No. He doesn't.” He paused, his lips setting into a straight line again, his eyes trained on the gun, unmoving and deep in thought. “If it comes to that-”
“No.” You cut him off, sensing the direction of his conversation. “No.” You repeated, watching as his eyes moved to you, registering the clarity in them, the unmoving stubbornness that he admired so much. His throat worked as he swallowed, and he bowed his head in a single nod before leaning it back against the tile again.
Silence settled between you again, heavy and thick, but no longer suffocating. In the dark, stripped of Quantico's glass walls, case files, and tactical vests, the silence felt remarkably soft.
"What were you thinking about?" you asked softly, watching the faint rise and fall of his breath. "While I was asleep."
Aaron was quiet for a long moment. His eyes remained fixed on the shadow-draped incline leading up to the shallow end. "My first year at the Bureau," he murmured, his baritone dipping into a lower, introspective register you rarely heard. "I spent six months convincing myself I was entirely prepared for the weight of the job. I thought logic, procedure, and emotional detachment were absolute shields."
"And were they?"
"No," he said gently, turning his head to look at you in the dim light. "They're just tools to keep you moving forward. But the weight never leaves. You learn to carry it, or it crushes you." He paused, his dark eyes searching your face with unbreakable intensity. "I was thinking about how much of that weight I've watched you take on since you joined the unit. You carry it well. Too well, sometimes."
Your chest tightened, a strange, bittersweet ache blooming behind your ribs. "I learned from the best."
"Don't copy my mistakes," Aaron murmured, his voice dropping an octave, laced with an undeniable sincerity. "I spent years building these walls because I thought it protected the people around me. It didn't. It just left me alone."
You reached out, your fingers finding his arm, lightly resting against the torn, filthy sleeve of his dress shirt. "You're not alone down here, Aaron."
Aaron looked down at your hand on his arm, his expression shifting, a subtle, vulnerable crack in his iron composure. He didn't pull away. He turned his palm upward, his large, calloused fingers gently wrapping around yours, squeezing with a grounding strength.
"No," he whispered, his eyes meeting yours in the dark. "I'm not."
–
The BAU bullpen was bathed in the harsh, sterile glow of overhead fluorescent lights and computer monitors. Nobody had slept. Coffee cups, cold and abandoned, littered the desks alongside maps, property deeds, and tactical schematics. On the massive glass monitor at the front of the room, the silent feed continued to stream.
On the screen, Aaron and you sat side-by-side against the dark wall of the pool. To anyone else, it was a picture of two hostages freezing in the dark. But to the team who knew Aaron Hotchner better than anyone, the way his body was angled toward you, shielding you from the cold draft of the room, holding your hand in the dark, was a silent, heart-wrenching revelation.
Morgan stood in front of the board, his eyes red-rimmed, staring at a map of Maryland with a marker gripped so tightly in his hand that his knuckles were white.
"He took them from a secondary site in suburban Baltimore," Morgan gritted out, his voice hoarse from hours of shouting and endless phone calls. "We found their abandoned SUV three miles out. Tires slashed, comms jammed. He had a two-hour window before we even flagged them missing."
"Look at the masonry in the background of the feed," Spencer said, walking up to Garcia’s desk, pointing a laser pointer at the top left corner of the live stream. "Garcia, zoom in on those structural beams above the pool deck."
Garcia’s fingers flew over her keyboard, her face pale, her eyes rimmed red with dried tears. The image enlarged, grainy but readable. "Okay, zooming in. What am I looking at, Reid?"
"Those aren't standard residential trusses," Spencer observed, his voice cold and analytical. "They're reinforced steel beams with rivets used in late 1920s civic construction. This isn't a private mansion or a gym. It's a municipal pool built during the public works administration era."
"Public works... public works..." Garcia muttered, her fingers becoming a blur across her glowing light-board. "Filtering closed municipal facilities, high schools, and recreational centers built between 1930 and 1940 within a fifty-mile radius of the snatch site..."
"Cross-reference with properties foreclosed or abandoned after the county water treatment in the 1980s," JJ added, leaning over Garcia’s chair, her voice tight with suppressed fear. "The unsub needs an isolated facility with industrial drainage,somewhere he could set up heavy chains and a closed-circuit stream without drawing power grid spikes."
"I've got seventy-four potential sites," Garcia gasped, her screen lighting up with a dizzying list of addresses.
"Filter it further!" Morgan snapped, slamming his hand onto the edge of the desk, his eyes darting back to the live monitor where Aaron was gently adjusting his position to cover your shoulder with his frame. "Look at him down there! They've been in that hole for over twelve hours without food or water! We don't have time to knock on seventy-four doors, Garcia!"
"I'm working as fast as I can!" Garcia cried, tears spilling over her lashes. "He's running the feed through seven bouncing proxies in Eastern Europe! I can't reverse-trace the IP without triggering an auto-kill switch on the stream! If I mess up, the feed goes black and we lose line of sight entirely!"
Rossi placed a firm, steadying hand on Garcia's shoulder. "Breathe, Penelope. Look at the feed. Look at Hotch. He’s keeping her alive. He’s keeping her focused. They are buying us time. Now let's do our job and buy them theirs."
–
Down in the deep end, the stillness was broken by a sudden, harsh, high-pitched squelch of electronic static.
The sound exploded out of the darkness like a physical blow. You both flinched violently, Aaron instantly shifting his body in front of yours, his arm extending to push you back against the wall as his eyes snapped up toward the hidden speakers in the dark ceiling.
The static smoothed out into the wet, sickeningly cheerful rasp of the unsub’s electronically pitched voice. "Good morning, my dear profilers," the speaker crackled, dripping with cruel, sing-song mockery. "Did we sleep well? Oh, wait... of course you didn't. The concrete is so very cold, isn't it? And look at you two, curled up together like stray dogs in an alley. How sweet. How thoroughly touching."
Aaron didn't say a word. His face hardened into a mask of pure stone, his dark eyes cold, calculating, searching the shadows of the ceiling for any glint of hardware or movement.
"You know," the voice continued, chuckling softly, a wet, clicking sound that echoed off the tiles, "I’ve been watching your little team back at Quantico. They are running around like ants in a flooded nest! Oh, if you could see them, Aaron! Agent Morgan is practically vibrating with rage. And the blonde one... poor girl looks like she’s about to throw up."
Your heart hammered against your ribs.
"They can see you, you know," the unsub purred, his tone shifting into a malicious, delighted whisper. "Right now. High definition. Muted audio, of course, I like to keep some secrets, but they can see every pathetic, desperate little detail. They saw you holding her hand, Aaron. They saw her resting her head on your chest in the dark. So very romantic for a Unit Chief and his subordinate."
Your breath hitched. A sickening spike of heat flushed through your skin despite the freezing cold. The thought of the entire bullpen watching you trapped down here, watching the vulnerable moments you had shared.
"So," the unsub snapped his fingers, the sharp sound popping loudly through the speaker, "let's give your audience a real show. Let's see how much dignity the BAU has left when forced to strip away the uniform."
"Whatever you're planning, it ends with you in a cell," Aaron said, his deep baritone cutting through the cavernous room, loud, firm, and entirely devoid of fear. "You want a psychological reaction. You won't get it."
"Oh, I think I will, Aaron," the voice sneered. "Because right now, you two still look like federal agents. You still think you have control. You still hold yourselves like you're above the mud. Let's fix that."
A heavy mechanical latch clicked somewhere near the top of the pool incline.
"In that little hole in the wall… you see it Aaron, don’t you? there is a silver tin and a full bottle of fresh water," the unsub crooned. "Inside the tin is a single ration of thick, medical-grade antibiotic salve and fresh gauze. Your poor agent's ankle shackle is already chafing, isn't it? By nightfall, without treatment, the open sores against that rusted iron will turn septic. And without water... Well, neither of you will last another twenty-four hours."
You looked down near the drain. Sitting inside a hole in the wall, behind a locked grate, was a small silver tin and a clear plastic bottle filled with pristine, clean water.
"To get the water and the medicine, there is a small price," the voice whispered, dropping into a dark, intimate purr. "Aaron... I want you to strip her of her upper clothing."
Your stomach dropped.
"What?" you breathed, your voice barely a rasp.
"You heard me," the unsub laughed, the sound twisted and distorted through the speaker. "The shirt, the undershirt…. The bra. All of it. I want you, Aaron, to undo every button, pull the fabric off her skin, and toss it up over the pool lip where neither of you can reach it again. Leave her exposed to the freezing cold, sitting in nothing but her trousers in front of that camera."
"No," Aaron said immediately, his voice dropping into a register so dark and lethal it vibrated through the concrete floor. "I will not."
"Think carefully, Aaron," the unsub taunted. "If you refuse, I leave the water where it is and turn off the air circulation. She dehydrates, her wound rots, and she suffers while you watch. But if you comply... if you violate protocol, if you strip down your subordinate in front of her colleagues, in front of the entire FBI hierarchy watching this stream... you both drink. She gets the medicine. She survives the day."
The speaker let out a wet, mocking chuckle.
"I want to see the unshakeable Aaron Hotchner unbuttoning his subordinate's clothes like a petty predator. I want your team at Quantico to watch their boss reduce you to bare skin in a concrete hole. I want you to look each other in the eye afterward and pretend you're still professional colleagues. You have two minutes."
Click.
The tannoy went dead.
The silence that returned was thick, suffocating, and vile. You sat frozen against the wall, your skin crawling, tears of pure humiliation burning hot behind your eyelids. It wasn't about physical pain, it was about psychological violation. It was designed to strip away every layer of professional boundaries, to force Aaron into performing an act of forced vulnerability upon you, and to broadcast that humiliation to everyone who respected you both back home.
Aaron stood rooted to the spot. His face had drained of all color, turning a ghostly, deathly pale. His hands were clenched into tight, violent fists at his sides, trembling with an uncontrollable, silent fury.
"No..." Aaron whispered, his voice cracking, raw as scraped iron. "No. I won't. I won't touch you."
"Aaron..." your voice trembled, dry as ash in your throat.
"I won't do it!" Aaron suddenly roared at the dark ceiling, his baritone tearing out of his chest, echoing violently off the tiles like a wounded animal. "DO YOU HEAR ME?! I WILL NOT TOUCH HER!"
"Aaron, stop! Look at me!" you demanded, dragging yourself forward as far as your chain allowed, ignoring the torturous bite of the iron against your swollen ankle. "Aaron, look at me!"
He turned his head slowly, his breath coming in ragged, shallow gasps. The unshakeable Unit Chief of the BAU looked completely destroyed. His dark eyes were wide, filled with a suffocating, unbearable horror.
"We need that water," you whispered, your hands trembling violently as you reached for him, grabbing his wrists. His skin was burning hot against your freezing fingers. "Look at my leg, Aaron. It's already infected. If we don't get that water and that salve, we won't last long enough for them to find us."
"I can't," Aaron breathed, a single tear slipping past his lashes, cutting a clean track through the grime on his cheek. "I can't do that to you. I won't strip you down... I won't violate you like this. Not in front of them. Not in front of anyone."
"It's not a violation if I'm asking you to do it." you argued, your voice as calm as you could muster as you pulled his hands toward your chest. "It's just fabric, Aaron. It's just clothes, he wants to break your spirit, he wants to make you feel dirty so you give up, don't let him win."
"No-”
"Do it, Aaron." you said, pressing his trembling hands flat against the top buttons of your shirt. "Please. I need you to do it. We need that water, Jack needs you to come home… Please."
Aaron stared down at your hands holding his against your chest. His jaw twitched, his teeth grinding together so hard a muscle flared violently in his cheek. He looked into your eyes, seeing the terrifying blend of humiliation, terror, and despite everything… trust shining through your tears.
"I'm sorry," he choked out, his voice a broken, agonising whisper. "I'm so sorry..."
His hands, usually so steady and precise, trembled fiercely as his fingers fumbled with the top button of your shirt. He kept his eyes locked firmly onto yours, refusing to look down, refusing to give the hidden lens overhead the satisfaction of seeing him treat you as anything less than sacred.
One by one, the buttons slipped free under his calloused fingers. The cold air hit your bare skin like a physical slap, making you gasp and shiver uncontrollably. Aaron’s hands were gentle, heartbreakingly so, as he peeled the ruined fabric off your shoulders, his fingertips barely brushing your skin, careful not to touch you any more than necessary.
With a ragged breath, he pulled your shirt and undershirt away, before gently placing his hands on your shoulders to turn you. With your back to him, his fingers lowered to the hooks on the clasp of your bra. The fabric fell from your chest, your nipples peaking in the cold. His jaw pulled taught as he let out another breath that fanned across the bare skin of your back before turning and hurling the fabric high up onto the pool deck out of reach. You stood exposed in the freezing dark, clutching your arms around your ribs, shivering violently from both the cold and the sheer, crushing humiliation of the moment. The grate that the water and tin were hidden behind lifted with a metallic clunk as the lock disengaged.
Without a word, Aaron lunged toward the drain. He snatched the silver tin and the water bottle, scrambling back to you in a frenzy. He uncapped the bottle with shaking hands and held it to your lips, steadying your chin with one warm hand while you drank greedily, the cool water rushing down your parched throat.
"Save half," you gasped out, pushing the bottle back toward his chest. "You need to drink, Aaron. Take it."
Aaron didn't argue. He threw his head back and swallowed the remaining water, his throat working as he emptied the plastic bottle. He immediately cracked open the silver tin, scooping out the thick antibiotic salve with his fingers. He knelt at your feet, his hands trembling as he tenderly applied the cold paste over the raw, bleeding skin around your chained ankle, wrapping it swiftly in the clean gauze.
When he finished, Aaron didn't move away. He immediately pulled off his own torn dress shirt, leaving himself in his undershirt, and wrapped the warm fabric around your bare shoulders. He pulled you hard against his chest, wrapping his broad arms entirely around your frame, burying his face into the crook of your neck to shield your exposed skin from the camera's view.
"I'm sorry," Aaron breathed into your skin, his body trembling with a mixture of rage, exhaustion, and fierce protection as his arms locked around you like iron bands. "I've got you..."
You buried your face into his shoulder, sobbing quietly as the warmth of his body seeped back into yours, the taste of clean water still on your tongue.
The silence that followed the ordeal was hollow, heavy, and thick with the scent of stale water and raw humiliation.
You sat pressed firmly against Aaron's chest, wrapped in his dress shirt. His broad arms remained locked around you like iron bars, his chin resting against the crown of your head, shielding your shivering frame from the cold air and the invisible eye of the camera overhead. His heart hammered in a hard, erratic rhythm against your ear, a wild contrast to the steady, unyielding mask he presented to the world.
For a long time, neither of you spoke. The water was gone, the empty plastic bottle crushed beneath Aaron's heel near the drain, and the cold paste on your ankle throbbed with a dull, manageable ache.
High above you, hidden deep within the dark rafters, the tiny red lens of the camera continued to blink silently in the dark. And miles away in Quantico, standing in front of the silent, high-definition display screen, Derek Morgan covered his mouth with a trembling hand, Rossi turned his face away in sickened, helpless fury, Spencer kept his eyes firmly locked on the floor, his jaw so tight his teeth could crack, JJ’s fingers dug into Emily’s arm and Garcia sobbed into her hands, watching their unshakeable leader hold you against his chest in the dirt, wrapped around you like a shield.
–
Time in the pool lost its meaning, measured not by hours or minutes, but by the slow, struggling decline of your bodies. The chill of the concrete floor had settled deep into your bones, a constant, dull ache that made every breath feel heavy. Your skin was cold, covered by Aaron’s ruined dress shirt. Aaron himself sat in his pale undershirt, his posture rigid despite his obvious exhaustion, his arm locked around you to share what little body heat he had left. His knuckles were still red from where he’d balled his hands into fists during the ordeal, his jaw set in a line of grim, unyielding determination.
The silver tin and the empty water bottle lay discarded near the drain. The water had taken the sharpest edge off your thirst, but it was a temporary mercy. Dehydration and shock were steady, silent enemies, wearing down your resolve bit by bit.
Then, the silence of the deep end was shattered.
A loud, ear-splitting screech of static ripped through the dark, bouncing violently off the damp, mold-stained tiles. You both flinched, Aaron instantly shifting his weight to pull you tighter against his chest, his body instinctively positioning itself as a barrier between you and whatever was coming.
High above, deep within the black lattice of the roof trusses, the speaker crackled to life once more.
"You've been very resilient," the unsub’s voice rasped, the electronic distortion giving it a flat, mechanical tone that made the words even colder. "You've survived the cold. You've survived the indignity. You've held onto each other like children in a storm. But patience is a luxury I am no longer inclined to extend."
A heavy, mechanical thunk echoed from the shadows above the pool deck, followed by a dull, rhythmic clicking sound.
On the tiled wall opposite your position, high above the reach of either chain, a bright red LED display flickered to life. Crimson numbers glowed in the darkness, sharp and unforgiving:
06:00:00.
With a soft, electrical hum, the numbers shifted. 05:59:59.
"Six hours," the speaker crooned, the unsub’s tone dripping with dark, theatrical satisfaction. "Six hours to make your choice. The gun is still where you left it. One bullet. One trigger pull. If one of you is dead when that clock reaches zero, the survivor walks out. I will unlock the heavy steel doors at the top of the incline, and you may return to your lives."
The red light from the digital timer cast a long, bloody glare across the dark concrete floor, reflecting off the matte-black finish of the Glock resting on the rusted drain grate.
"And if the clock reaches zero while both of you are still breathing?" the unsub continued, his voice dropping into a sinister, low purr. "Then I will come down into that pit myself. And I will execute you both. The decision is yours."
A final, sharp click signaled the end of the broadcast, leaving only the relentless hum of the digital clock as it ticked down the seconds.
summary: it takes you almost kissing someone else for him to realise just how much he cares
pairing: aaron hotchner x bau!reader
warnings: angst, tension, angry kisses, jealous!hotch, he's so hot, did i mention tension? bcs there's so much tension tension tension, a few swears, her bag sort of disappears.. oops
word count: 5.2k (oops x2)
Aaron doesn’t even look at you anymore.
Okay, that’s not true — he does. When he has to. When there’s a case file in his hands and you’re just another member of the team he needs to brief — another agent he’s in charge of. When there’s a question about geographical profiling or victimology and you’re the one who can answer it. When he’s assigning roles and has to say your name.
But everything outside of that? Nothing. Cold silence. Controlled distance.
And it killed you.
You wouldn’t even know you kissed him. More than once. Wouldn’t know how his hands felt in your hair, or how he’d said your name like it physically hurt him. Wouldn’t know that there was a moment — no, a string of moments — where he looked at you like you were the only thing grounding him to earth.
Because now? Now he’s pretending none of it ever happened.
And the worst part?
You know he still wants you.
Not in the arrogant way. Not in the I’m-so-irresistible kind of way. No — you know it because you see it. In the way his eyes flicker to you when he thinks you’re not paying attention. In the way his jaw ticks when Morgan jokes too casually with you. In the way he goes quiet when your laugh cuts across the room — his lips pressing into a thin line while his body tenses, almost like he’s trying to stop himself from laughing along.
He wants you. And he’s made that clear before.
But he’s also your boss. Older. Emotionally constipated. A man who shuts people out just before they get too close.
So of course, he made the decision for both of you. Of course, he pulled away, said it wasn’t appropriate, said you needed to keep it professional. Of course, he slammed that wall up between you and iced you out like he didn’t miss you the moment he left.
And now? Now you’re in Florida. The local PD is stretched thin, there’s a suspected spree killer hitting tourist-heavy areas along the I-4 corridor, and you’re operating out of some small, humid precinct where the AC rattles and no one knows how to use a case board.
Hotch pairs you with Officer Pretty Smile — an actual cop, around your age, golden tan, charming, full of casual grins and easy compliments. You don’t even hear most of what Hotch says when he assigns you; you’re too busy fuming at the fact that he’s done it again.
Just like the last two cases, he pairs you with some random officer, keeps you away from the scene, away from the precinct, away from anywhere he might be — in a way, he’s not letting you do your job.
Distanced from the rest of the team, you’re not much help.
How is that professional?
You know the game he’s playing. Avoidance. Distance. Control.
You’re sick of it.
But Officer Pretty Smile — his name’s Ryan — doesn’t seem to mind the stormcloud hanging over your head. He makes it easy to forget, just a little. He’s perceptive, actually listens when you talk, knows when to make you laugh and when to stay quiet. It’s a relief.
He flirts — lightly, respectfully — and you flirt back. Why shouldn’t you?
Aaron’s the one who put this wall up. He’s the one not speaking to you.
You don’t owe him your loyalty if he won’t even look at you outside of a damn case briefing.
The case wraps up after a few days of gruelling profiling, false leads and one late-night stakeout that finally caught your UnSub at a rest stop. You’re debriefing the locals, coordinating transport and starting to pack things up when Ryan walks you out to the parking lot.
He offers you his number, and you take it, pocketing it with a smile that widens when he leans in to press a soft kiss to your cheek. It’s innocent, really. Careful and sweet, but when he pulls back, he doesn’t go far. His face stays close, breath brushing against your skin as his eyes lock onto yours.
Then his gaze drops — not just to your lips, but the space between you — like he’s weighing the distance and what to do about it. It takes a breath or two before he meets your eyes again.
He leans in, slower this time, and his lips just barely graze yours. A featherlight touch that barely classifies as a kiss. It’s more of a hesitation. A silent question — do you want this too?
Yes, you do.
You answer by lifting a hand and placing it gently on his jaw, your touch light but certain.
He exhales softly, and his hands move to your waist, holding you like he’s been wanting to all day.
Your lips are so close, a breath away, and just as you’re about to close the gap—
“Agent!”
Aaron’s voice cuts through the humid Florida air like a gunshot, sharp enough to turn heads. It’s not just a call — it’s a warning. A demand. His tone carries weight, and everyone nearby instinctively pauses, glancing over to where he stands near the SUV, his jaw tight, posture coiled like he’s seconds away from snapping.
You freeze.
Where the fuck did he spawn from?
Ryan pulls back, but not completely. His hands stay on your waist, holding you close, as his eyes look over your shoulder.
You, however, don’t turn around — stubbornly refusing to give Hotch the satisfaction of ruining this moment.
He can wait.
He can watch.
You keep your gaze locked on Ryan. On his lips that are a bit further away than before, parted in confusion as he stares at your boss.
Your fingers shift slightly against his jaw — a gentle nudge meant to draw his attention back to you. And it works. His eyes flicker away from whatever intensity Hotch is radiating behind you and settle back on yours.
You lean in, slow and deliberate, and the moment you do, he seems to forget everything else as he leans in too.
And, just like before, just as your lips graze—
“Agent!”
Somehow, his voice is harsher than before — each syllable laced with barely contained fury.
Your hands fall from Ryan’s face and drop to your sides as you sigh, letting your head dip forward slightly.
“What’s his problem?” Ryan murmurs, his frustration mirroring yours as he shoots Aaron a brief, irritated glance before turning his attention back to you.
You lift your head, just enough to meet his eyes again, and mutter, “I don’t know. He’s just—” You wave a hand vaguely behind you. “A hardass.” You pause. “Or an ass. A normal ass. Whichever floats your boat.”
Ryan snorts, nodding as he looks back at Aaron. “Yeah. That tracks.”
You smile, wide and genuine. “Well then,” you say, looking up at him, “duty calls.”
He nods, looking a bit reluctant as he returns your smile and asks, “Will I see you again before you go?”
You hesitate, just for a second, before finally glancing over your shoulder.
Hotch stands by the entrance of the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office — arms crossed, back stiff, jaw tight. His eyes are locked on you like he’s trying to dissect every inch of the moment he just interrupted. He looks furious. Controlled, as always, but furious nonetheless.
You look back at Ryan. “Probably not.”
There’s a brief pause — just a breath of silence — before he nods. He doesn’t push, doesn’t ask for anything more. Instead, he steps in and kisses your cheek again, soft and quick, like a quiet goodbye. When he pulls back, he lets his hand brush down your arm before stepping away.
You turn without another word, lowering your head as you approach Aaron. With each step, the feeling of his stare on you burns hotter, sharper.
You stop in front of him, standing there for a moment before you glance up.
His blazer is off, his blue button-up clinging slightly to his skin. His sunglasses perched on his nose and his jaw is tight.
You hate yourself for thinking that he looks hot.
You cross your arms, exhaling sharply before saying, “You called?”
He doesn’t waste a second. “Get the scene logs from the officers inside. I want them scanned and uploaded before we leave for the jet.”
His tone is dry, detached. The words hang in the air like a weight that doesn’t match the way he’s looking at you. His expression is stone-cold, all business, and it only fuels the frustration coursing through you.
You blink, your chest tightening. That’s it? That’s the urgent reason he called you out of a kiss like the sky was falling?
It’s a bullshit task. You both know it.
But he’s your Unit Chief. And right now, he’s pulling rank — not for the case. The case is over. Solved.
He’s doing it for himself, and it makes you want to scream.
You bite back the thousand things you want to say, give a tight nod, and walk past him without a glance.
—
On the jet, the tension is unbearable.
Aaron is sitting near the front, a stack of case files spread in front of him that he hasn’t touched since takeoff. He just stares at them, unmoving, like he’s willing them to make him forget.
You’re in the back, headphones on, glaring out the window as your forehead rests against the glass of it.
The others feel it — the tightrope tension stretching across the cabin. No one says a word.
After a while, you can’t help but glance his way, your eyes rolling when you see how he’s glaring at the files in front of him.
He’s clearly seething. The image of you, about to kiss someone else, seemed to be carved into his memory.
If he’d been closer, he might’ve punched the guy. Hell, if he wasn’t so goddamn professional, he might’ve dragged you away himself.
But he didn’t. He waited. He watched.
He hates that he waited.
And now he’s stewing in it.
When the jet lands, everyone moves quickly — eager to escape the static pressure in the air. You stand, grabbing your go-bag before heading for the stairs.
And then — low, sharp, right in front of you:
“Stay.”
He’s still seated, leaning forward slightly, elbow propped on the table. His hand is pressed to his face, fingers buried in his hair while his palm digs into his temple like he’s desperately trying to hold his thoughts together.
His eyes are closed — not from sleep, but something heavier — and despite the jet landing, his papers are still out, strewn in front of him. Clearly, he’d given up trying to read them — or pretending to read them.
His face is taut, shadowed — caught in a quiet storm of exhaustion or thought. Maybe both.
He looks really hot.
Swallowing, you will that thought away.
‘Stay.’ He had said, in a tone that made you freeze — one that left no room for argument.
You hesitate, your grip on your bag tightening a bit as you stare before deciding.
No.
With your lips set in a frown, you start walking again.
Just as you’re about to move past him, though, his hand reaches out to wrap around your wrist.
You tense, his touch making you feel warm and a bit breathless despite your anger.
“I said stay.” His voice cuts through the quiet — steady with an edge that sends a jolt through you.
Shit.
You look down at him, jaw set. “Let go.”
He doesn’t move at first — just lifts his eyes to meet yours, something unreadable flickering behind them. Then he exhales before rising to his feet in a fluid motion. His grip on your wrist doesn’t loosen as he stands over you, shoulders squared.
You falter, thrown by the sudden nearness. “Hotch—”
“Aaron.” He interrupts you, his eyes narrowing as he stares down at you. His tone is sharp, stern like hearing his last name offended him.
“Hotch.” You repeat it, just to piss him off.
If distance is what he wants, distance is what he’ll get.
He stares at you for a second before exhaling, a tired look in his eyes as he says, “We need to talk.”
“Oh, now you want to talk?” Your voice rises a bit and you barely manage to hold back a laugh. “You ignore me for weeks, send me off like I’m a problem you can delegate, and now — suddenly — you want to talk?”
His jaw clenches. “You don’t understand—”
“No. You don’t get to—“
Before you can finish what you’re saying, he uses his grip on your wrist to pull you into him. Fuelled by everything he hasn’t said, it’s not a gentle gesture.
You gasp as you stumble forward, crashing into his chest. Your cheek brushes the soft fabric of his shirt and your hand splayed instinctively against him for balance. When your eyes finally meet his, he’s already looking down at you — jaw tense, eyes dark, your faces now inches apart.
“You were going to kiss him.” His voice is quiet, but the words hit harder than if he’d shouted them.
His grip on your wrist tightens slightly, and for a moment, he closes his eyes. The sight of you both leaning in replays in his mind — the tension in his jaw is visible as his lips press into a line. His expression looks as if the image physically hurt him.
When he opens them again, his eyes lock onto yours, searching, checking to see if you understand the severity of it.
Your lips are parted as you stare at him.
You’re not surprised that he brought it up. You knew it was coming, but the way he says it — the weight in his voice — wasn’t something you were expecting.
His words carried an undertone of pain that make you falter. It’s not just about the kiss, you realise. It’s about everything he’s been holding in.
“You were about to kiss him.” He repeats, slower than before, his eyes still boring into yours.
Hearing the word ‘kiss’ a second time, along with the sudden proximity, had your gaze falling to his lips.
You couldn’t help it.
You looked back up quickly to find his eyes still on you.
A flicker of guilt creeps into your chest — something small, unwanted. Maybe it’s the way his voice quietened when he said it. Maybe it’s the look in his eyes, like he wasn’t prepared for how much it hurt him — you almost kissing someone else.
For a split second, you start to feel bad.
But it doesn’t last.
Not when you remember the last few weeks — how he’s iced you out, kept his distance like you didn’t matter, like the moments you shared never happened.
Your jaw tightens and your brows furrow in the way they always do when you’re annoyed.
“Stop.” You say, the word sharper than you intended. Shaking your head, your voice comes out quieter the second time. “Just… stop.”
He doesn’t move, doesn’t speak, just watches you — eyes flicking across your face like he’s trying to read you.
Like he’s trying to profile you.
What happened to never profiling each other? Probably the same thing that happened to being ‘professional’.
“You’re being unfair, Aaron.”
You avert your gaze, unable to hold his anymore. It drops to his chest — the fabric of his shirt stretched a bit beneath your hands that are still resting there. You can feel the steady rise and fall of his breathing, slightly faster than it should be.
He has no right to be upset, you think, and it takes everything in you not to say it out loud first. But when you look back up at him, your anger catches fire again, sharp and unforgiving.
“You’re the one who pushed me away.” You bite out, voice low. “You iced me out. For weeks, Aaron.”
Your words land heavy in the space between you, but you don’t stop.
“You told me we couldn’t—” You falter slightly, pain catching in your throat, “—that we had to keep things professional. And then you avoided me. You acted like I didn’t matter.”
His jaw flexes again, but he says nothing.
“And now what?” you continue. “Now you’re upset because I almost kissed someone else? You don’t get to pull me in two different directions like this. You can’t tell me to stay away, and then look at me like that when someone else gets close.”
His hand is still on your waist, his grip on your wrist still firm. He hasn’t let go, hasn’t backed off, and that makes it worse — the contradiction of it. The ache of being wanted but not claimed.
“It’s confusing. You’re confusing.” My voice goes back to being quiet as I lower my gaze again, missing the way his expression softens a bit.
It softens because he knows you’re right.
He can’t argue with you, not really. Not when you’re looking at him like that. Or rather, not looking at him at all. Your eyes are fixed on his chest now, lips pressed together in that tight little frown that always means you’re trying not to show how hurt you are.
He can’t argue with you because you’re right.
He’s being unfair, and the guilt of that realization hits him instantly, swallowing him whole. The weight of his own selfishness also sinks in, making him feel stupid for not realizing how much he’s hurt you.
When the silence stretches for too long, you look up, and your frown deepens when you see how he’s watching you.
“Stop profiling me.” Your voice shakes a bit as you try to yank yourself free of his grip. But Aaron doesn’t let go. His hands stay firm on your waist, like letting go would mean losing something he’s not ready to give up.
It only makes you angrier.
You shove at his chest, hard, but he barely budges. “Let go.” you snap, glaring up at him, but his expression doesn’t shift. He just watches you, jaw tight, eyes unreadable behind the shield of his silence.
That silence cuts deeper than anything.
“You ignored me for weeks!” you shout, your voice rising, cracking with something raw. “You didn’t even look at me. You shut me out like I meant nothing!”
You try again to pull away, like his touch burns. Like the heat of his hands is searing through your skin, cracking you open.
And it hurts him — more than he thought it would. Watching you try to escape him like he’s done something unforgivable — which he has — makes something twist in his chest. He wants to fix it, but he doesn’t know how. Every word you throw at him lands like a blow, and still, he doesn’t move. Doesn’t let go.
He just hurts.
“Let go!” you yell, louder now, fists balled as you push at him again. “I said fuck off, Aaron!”
You look up at him then — eyes blazing, cheeks flushed with anger, your frown etched deep into your face. The fury in your expression is undeniable, and it hits him like a punch.
And before he even realizes what he’s doing — he kisses you.
It comes out of nowhere. Like something snaps inside him, like instinct. It’s not gentle. It’s not soft. It’s angry and desperate and messy—like he’s trying to shut you up and apologize all at once. Like everything he’s been holding back has just erupted, too big to contain.
You freeze at first, tensing against it, breath caught in your throat.
But then you break.
Your hands fist in the lapels of his blazer, gripping hard like you need something to hold you upright. Your lips move against his with the same kind of fury you’d just thrown at him — like this is a fight, too. But somewhere in that chaos, your shoulders slump, and so do his.
Like you’re both exhaling for the first time in weeks.
Like this is the first breath either of you has taken since everything fell apart.
His hands move — one, then both — rising to cradle your face, fingers splayed across your cheeks like he’s terrified you’ll disappear if he lets go.
You pull back first, breaking the kiss with a gasp, your breath catching somewhere between his mouth and your own. His grip loosens, and for a second, something like a whine escapes him — soft and involuntary — like he can’t believe you’re already pulling away.
You’re breathless. Lips swollen. Heart racing.
“You’re such an asshole.” you hiss, voice low, hoarse, but still furious.
His eyes darken. “You were gonna kiss him.”
“Stop repeating that!” you snap, but there’s no bite behind it now — just exhaustion and heat and emotion so tangled you can’t separate any of it.
You don’t even think about it — you just lean in again, drawn like a magnet. And this time, he meets you halfway. Your lips part just before they touch, and when they do, it feels like the ground shifts beneath you. Like the jet could be spinning or crashing and you wouldn’t even notice.
It’s slower, deeper — but just as intense. His hands are still on your face, and yours are clinging to him like you don’t trust gravity anymore.
But then he pulls away.
His forehead drops to yours — close, so close — and for a moment you almost let him stay there. But something in you twists, and you turn your head just slightly, breaking the contact. You keep your eyes shut, breathing shallow, your face turned toward the wall of the jet like if you don’t look at him, you can hold onto the last piece of your anger.
His heart sinks.
“I’m sorry.” he says, his voice quieter now. Cracked open. “I’m sorry for all of it.”
You don’t move. Don’t look.
“I— I thought it was the right thing.” he says, and now it’s all unraveling, everything he’s shoved down clawing its way out. “I didn’t know how to handle what I felt for you. I didn’t know if I should. So I convinced myself the best thing — the most responsible thing — was to shut it down. To shut you out.”
He lets out a breath, sharp and rough. “I told myself you’d be better off. That you didn’t need someone like me — someone older, someone who barely knows how to process his own shit, let alone drag you into it. My hours are a nightmare, I’m exhausted all the time, and I have nothing to give you except… this mess.”
His voice softens but doesn’t steady. “And if Strauss found out, she wouldn’t hesitate to pull you off the team. To punish you for something that was always my fault.”
You still don’t speak. Your eyes remain closed.
“I thought I was doing the right thing,” he says again, quieter now, like it physically hurts to say. “But it felt like cutting off my own oxygen. Seeing you every day, hearing your voice, pretending you were just another agent — it fucking destroyed me. Every moment I stayed away, I felt like I was unraveling. But I thought… if I could just hold the line a little longer, maybe I could let you go.”
His voice cracks then, barely above a whisper. “But I couldn’t. I can’t.”
You don’t say anything, and the silence eats at him. He shifts slightly, eyes scanning your face like he’s trying to read anything — any flicker of emotion, of softness, of something.
“Please say something.” he murmurs.
There’s no anger in him anymore. Just regret. Just longing.
“I haven’t slept,” he says, after a second. “Not really. Not since I let you go. You’ve been in my head every day. Every night. You walk into the room and I can’t think straight. I hear your voice down the hall and I forget what I’m doing. It’s pathetic.”
Then gently — cautiously — he reaches out, fingers brushing against your chin. He turns your face to him, coaxing your eyes to his.
And when you look at him, he looks wrecked.
There’s exhaustion in his features, shadows beneath his eyes, but it’s the look in them that breaks you: raw, sincere, desperate. Like you’re the only thing anchoring him to earth right now.
“I’m sorry.” he says again, like it’s the only thing he has left to give. Like he means it with everything he’s got.
And he does.
It’s silent for a second.
His eyes search yours, unsure and a little frantic, like he’s trying to profile you again — trying to get an understanding of whatever’s going on in your mind.
He gives up quickly, wanting to find out whatever it is your thinking from you yourself. But just as he’s about to ask, you kiss him.
When you pull back, your hands stay on him, sliding down to his chest where you can feel the rapid, uneven rhythm of his heart.
“I don’t expect you to be perfect, Aaron.” you murmur, voice soft but steady. “I’m not. I barely have my own shit together half the time. And I’m not looking for some ideal version of you — just you. The version that cares too much and thinks too hard and carries everything on his back like it’s his job to keep the world spinning.”
You pause, your eyes searching his, and he doesn’t look away.
“I don’t want anyone else.” you say, more firmly now. “I can’t want anyone else. My heart’s already decided. It’s you. It’s always been you. These past few weeks without you—feeling you pull away, watching you pretend like nothing mattered—that was hell. And if you think I just brushed it off and moved on, you really don’t know me at all.”
You don’t stop there, because you can see it — how he’s still doubting, still not sure what you see in him. So you tell him.
“You don’t even realize how much I see you.” you whisper. “How good you are. You’re strong, yeah, but you’re also… unbelievably kind. You’re the one who makes me feel stable when everything else is a mess. You make me feel safe without trying to control me. You make me feel… things I didn’t even know I was capable of feeling.”
His brow creases like he doesn’t know what to do with that, like it’s too much, too pure.
“And I don’t give a damn about your age. If anything, it makes you hotter.” you add with a breath of a laugh. “It means you’ve lived, you’ve learned, and you listen. You make me feel taken care of in a way no one ever has.”
He’s blinking at you like his brain short-circuited somewhere along the way.
“As for Strauss…” You shrug a little. “She’s not a profiler. We barely even see her. If we keep things professional at work, we’ll be fine. We’re good at this — at keeping calm under pressure. This isn’t gonna change that.”
Then you take one of his hands and hold it tightly, pressing your fingers to his palm.
“All I want,” you say, voice low, “is for you to let me love you.”
Something in him breaks. Or maybe it mends. You can’t quite tell.
His eyes widen just a little, and for a second he just stares at you — like his brain is still catching up. Like the word punched the breath right out of him.
“What?” he asks, the word so soft it’s barely audible.
“I just want to love you, Aaron.” you repeat, quieter this time, like it’s a promise.
His breath shudders out of him, and he leans forward again — not kissing you yet, just resting his forehead against yours, like he needs the grounding.
“I love you.” he says, the words raw and unfiltered. “And I’m sorry. I’ll talk to you next time — really talk. I won’t shut you out again. I won’t let myself forget what this feels like.”
“You better not.” you murmur.
And then he kisses you again.
It’s steadier now. Certain. Like he’s finally, finally giving in to the truth he’s been denying. Like he knows what he wants — and it’s you.
As your lips move together, the world outside the jet fades into the background. His hand moves slowly, purposefully, down your side, and then it shifts, lowering until he reaches into your pocket.
You pull away a little, eyebrows furrowed in confusion. Before you can fully process it, he pulls out the small piece of paper — the one with Ryan’s number scrawled on it.
Your heart skips a beat. He saw that?
The thought stings for a second — had he seen everything? You’d assumed he’d stepped outside for some reason and had just happened to catch a glimpse of you two — coincidentally, when you were about to kiss.
But Aaron’s mind works in a different way. He had seen you leave with Ryan, noticed the way you two were talking, the smiles on your faces. And something in him tensed. He didn’t like it. The way you were walking so close, how easy it seemed between you. So he followed, curiosity gnawing at him. He hadn’t meant to — but it felt like he had to know.
You break the silence with a quiet question, still trying to make sense of it all. “You saw that?”
Aaron’s jaw tightens, his face flickering with a flash of frustration, then quickly hardening as he remembers it.
“I saw all of it.” he says, his voice colder than you expected. A wince pulls at his expression as he scrunches the paper up in his hand, turning to toss it in the small bin beside the exit of the jet, the movement sharp and final.
You can’t help but let out a small, amused laugh despite the tension. His reaction, his possessiveness — it’s almost too much to ignore. But then, before he can get too far in his thoughts, you soften and murmur an apology. “Sorry. I didn’t mean to—”
He cuts you off with a question of his own, his gaze still intense as he watches you, his tone now a little guarded. “Were you actually going to kiss him?”
You blink, surprised by the bluntness, but you can’t help the smirk that slips onto your face. “Hey, you’re the one who paired me with him.”
Aaron rolls his eyes, the hint of frustration fading a little, but you can still see the sharp edge to his expression. “From now on, you’re with me for every case.”
You laugh at the thought, shaking your head, but the joke settles in as you reply, “I don’t think that’d help with keeping Strauss off our trail.”
Aaron chuckles, his eyes softening just a fraction, but he doesn’t back down. “I’ll risk it. It’s fine.”
Your laughter fills the space between you, and it warms Aaron’s heart more than he’d care to admit. He’s missed hearing it, hearing you so carefree, even when things feel a little chaotic.
He pulls you a little closer then, wrapping an arm around your waist as if he can’t let you go now that he’s got you. He starts guiding you off the jet with that same quiet confidence he always carries, but there’s something different now — a sense of peace between you both, even if the world outside still feels a little unsettled.
“You’re coming to my place.” he says, his voice low and steady. “I’m making you dinner.”
Warnings: Fluff, angst, tiny tiny tiny amount of smut. Canon is none existing. Family moments, slow-burn romance, workplace banter and teasing, grief and loss of a parent (terminal illness (not disclosed), hospice, mourning), vomiting, breakdown, hospital scenes (emergency c-section and labor complications), canon type cm cases, mental health struggles, very brief non-graphic breakup, lots of kisses, nothing directly explicit, but insinuated that they have sex (a lot), pregnancy and childbirth (but only the finding out and birth (mildly) is described)... Y/N and L/N very sparsely used when I couldn't move around it.
Summary: You and Hotch are desk neighbours in the bullpen, back in a time where Gideon was still unit chief. And the two of you were fairly new agents. Late nights turn into competitions and conversations about anything and everything, until eventually you find each other and flash forward: become the “mom and dad” of the BAU.
A/N: DANDADADAAAAAAAA!!!!! HERE IT IS!!! MY PRIDE AND JOY!! This has been one very long process and i'm so in love with the entire fic, even though I'm super duper tired and pulled way too many long nights writing.
Bon appétit!!!
Also I didn't have the strength to edit this, so hopefully my 2 a.m. writing skills haven't fucked me over completely. 🫣
Christmas came early for you this year, more precisely in September of the year 2000, when you first step into the bullpen of the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit. There's a lingering scent of stale coffee and freshly printed paper in the air—either it will soon be your favorite smell, or the worst, only time will tell.
There's a constant buzz and popping sounds coming from the fluorescent lights overhead, already begging to give you a migraine if the Bureau doesn't change the tubes soon. Kill me already, you think as you look around, trying to spot Agent Gideon to announce your arrival for your first day.
At twenty-eight, you're fresh out of the Academy, a psychology degree in your toolbox, and one hell of an ability to spot lies through micro expressions, which initially was the reason your attending agent fast-tracked your resume from the bottom of the food chain and straight into Gideon's inbox.
Your transfer papers still feel warm in your hands as you spot Gideon coming toward you. He gives you a quick nod and a small smile before he reaches you.
"Ms. L/N," he stops in front of you. You can already sense that Gideon is a warm person from the cadence of his voice. "Welcome to the team." He extends his hand, and you shake it—it's the kind of handshake that speaks louder than words and says 'I already trust you to keep up'.
"Follow me." And so you do, crossing the bullpen until you reach an empty desk across from a dark-haired agent, hunched over a file and surrounded by several more. His tie is barely loosened, sleeves rolled up, and hair slightly tousled as if he has been running his hands through it in frustration. "That's Agent Hotchner," Gideon says. "He joined us last year. Good man, and the best ex-prosecutor we've managed to steal from the field office in Seattle. You'll be desk neighbors for the foreseeable future."
Agent Hotchner looks up from his file at the introduction and offers you a polite smile before he stands up and extends his hand. "Hotch. Welcome to the unit." He greets.
You shake his hand, wow, his grip is firm, and his hand is warm, you note at the back of your head as you introduce yourself. Gideon's smirk is almost imperceptible as he leaves the two of you, standing at the juncture where your desks connect, hands clasped longer than strictly necessary.
You quickly learn that he's thirty-five, joined the Bureau in '95 after he figured out that he'd rather be catching the killers than prosecuting them for the rest of his life. He's ambitious and plans to one day make director if everything goes to plan, methodical, the kind of guy who color-codes his case notes by the severity of the case, who never leaves a form half-finished, or leaves the office in the middle of writing a report.
And rumor has it that the director is already eyeing him for a leadership role in another unit, despite his current lag of seniority with the Bureau.
And you, your ambitions? Right now, you're just the new kid, hungry to learn and to prove you belong with the travelling profile team, and not just behind your desk from 9-5, scratching notes in the margins of old case files as you study the serial killers the team has already caught.
Neither of you knows it yet, but the rest of your lives just started.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
The first few weeks end up being a blur of consultations, training files and videos, observing and learning the rhythm of the unit. The way they speak, the way they move, how they work, basically studying their behaviour to the best of your current training.
Gideon leads the team quietly, mostly keeping to himself in his office and letting his agents run on their own. But he's always willing to lend an ear, or answer a question in a way that is so cryptic and so provocative that it leaves you no other option but to rework your theories and learn even more about the ubsubs. AND YOU LOVE IT.
And then there's you and Hotch, trading polite 'Good mornings', first thing, bringing each other a new cup of coffee from the kitchen if either of you were getting up, and occasionally asking the other for a second pair of eyes on a particularly annoying case file.
It doesn't take long for you to realize that you're both night owls when it comes to work. Cases pile up quickly around here, and not just on your desk, but every desk around the bullpen has a minimum of ten files stacked in the inbox at all times. And while the other agents head home by no later than eight, you and Hotch linger.
You don't plan it at first. It just sort of... happens.
On a late night in October—Gideon has finally deemed you ready to climb a step higher on your case clearances—you're working on your first active serial killer case, a serial arsonist from Oregon, trying to get to the bottom of his MO, reviewing victim statements, mapping timelines, trying to get inside the unsub's head before time runs out and he kills again.
It's not until you finally look up that you realize that the bullpen is empty except for the two of you. It's past midnight, and time has completely run away from you. You rub your eyes, feeling them get heavier and heavier the longer you're looking away from the file in front of you.
Hotch leans back across from you, pulls his arms over his head, and stretches himself as far back as he can. His back is stiff and protesting the many long hours hunched over his desk.
"You know you can go home, right?" He questions, cocking his brow at you. "Gideon's not keeping score about who's here the longest."
"Right, why are you still here then? Don't you have a girlfriend at home?" You retort, you know he can take your push back.
"Touché." He chuckles with a slight huff. Hotch's eyes quickly avert, glancing up at the clock. It's already 12:47 a.m., Haley is asleep by now, and there's no use in him rushing home with a bouquet from the nearest bodega open at this hour. She's used to it by now, it'll be okay, he tells himself.
So, you both keep working. The clock keeps ticking: 1:15, 1:44, 2:13. And finally, 2:30 a.m., you yawn so hard your jaw pops, you can't help but smile as you look over at Hotch, his lips slightly upturned as he tries not to giggle at your sudden burst of noisiness.
"Fine." You mutter in defeat, shutting the Bureau-stamped manila folder. "You win tonight."
"Win?" He looks up from his own file, almost looking confused.
"Yeah! You stayed later tonight. Tomorrow the loser buys coffee—aka me." You stand up from your chair, grab your bag from its usual spot on the floor under your desk, and head for the elevator with a small 'Goodnight, Hotch' as you try to hide the grin currently inhabiting your face.
The next morning, you show up at 7:45 with two coffees in a take-out tray—how you're up and awake after getting less than four hours of sleep, is beyond your knowledge. You place his cup in front of him, black and light roast, you noticed how he took it last week. And yours, almost identical, but with a slash of milk.
"And this is the loser buying?" He raises his brow at you, clearly finding your follow-through amusing.
"Rules are rules, Agent Hotchner."
"Call me Aaron." A small smile tugs at his lips; it's truly the first real one you've seen from him since you joined the BAU.
"Okay, Aaron." You smile back at him.
That night, the game starts, and from that point on, it's on.
The bullpen becomes your battlefield, quiet battlefield that is. No one notices your harmless competition at first. Gideon leaves at five if he can, always with a 'Don't stay too late, kids' on his way past your desks. Anderson waves goodbye around six, and the rest of the agents disappear sporadically sometime between the two, leaving the two of you alone, again.
But you and Hotch? You trade glances across the desks as the team leaves, already trying to figure out which of you will cave first.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
You're working on a case from Billings: three children kidnapped in the past nine weeks, all under ten, all taken from public parks between 5:00 and 7:00 p.m. on weekdays, indicating that the unsub(s?) works a regular 9-5 job. No bodies yet, no ransom demands, no fingerprints, no witnesses who saw more than a dark sedan idling in the parking lot on all three occasions, and a single fresh bootprint near the swings from victim number two's abduction that doesn't match any of the visitors to the park during that time frame.
The photos in the file are the kind that make you feel completely hollowed out as you stare at cheerful, gap-toothed school portraits, birthday parties, one little boy in a Spider-Man costume holding his mother's hand as they went trick or treating last Halloween. And every time you look away, you feel like their eyes follow you, screaming at you, asking why you haven't found them yet.
You've been staring at the timeline from the first victim for forty minutes now, highlighter hovering slightly over the copy you made of the original, trying to force the unsub's pattern to reveal itself to you.
Your chest feels like someone parked their car on it.
It's around 11:30 p.m. when you finally blink away from the case—unable to take another glance at a freckled face with a snotty nose—you realize that Hotch hasn't turned a page in a while. He's watching you instead, elbows resting on his desk, chin resting on his steepled fingers.
He's looking at you, barely containing the fact that he's concerned about you. His eyes are soft, carefully trying to study you, find a clue, anything that can lead him to figure out what's bothering you.
"You okay?" He finally asks, coming to terms with not being able to profile you, yet.
"Just... I hate these ones." You swallow the lump in your throat, not realizing how dry your mouth has become.
Hotch nods once, slowly, understanding you perfectly. "Me too." A moment passes. "Do you want to talk through it, together?"
You do. God! Yes, you do.
You nod.
Hotch rolls his chair around the corner of the desks and straight into your space, stopping so close that your knees nearly touch under the desk. He starts spreading the evidence across the desk, moving pictures, reports, and interview logs into three distinct areas based on which victim the evidence is connected to.
"Okay," he starts, tapping the map in the middle of the desk. "All three abduction zones overlap, here." He circles the elementary school in the middle of the three parks, all exactly six miles away from it. "He has to be local."
"But the presumed comfort zone has a twenty-mile radius out from the school in each direction based on other similar cases," you counter, searching for the ruler, you know it's around here somewhere. Hotch hands it to you. You put it on the map and trace a straight line out from the school and circle the perimeter with a compass. "He's risking a lot of travel time with a live child in the car." You state, staring at the now visual preliminary comfort zone.
"Which means he's either extremely confident, or doesn't fit the regular profile for these types of cases. He most likely has a location nearby, where he holds the kids first." Hotch reaches for the highlighter at the same moment you do. You both freeze, then laugh.
"Sorry," he chuckles, but doesn't move his hand away, letting it linger for a moment as your thumbs and pointer fingers stay slightly interlocked with each other.
"By all means, Mr. Unit Chief-in-training," you tease him, letting him take the highlighter. Hotch told you last night, over a fairly sad and beige plate of leftover canteen food, that the director had approached him about becoming Unit chief of the National Security Branch. Which he had declined, arguing that, for one, he didn't feel that his time with the BAU was a closed chapter yet, and two, the commute to DC during morning rush hour was terrible, and he'd be seeing Haley even less than he already did.
Instead, the director had "offered" Hotch training courses in what it takes to be a Unit Chief—in Hotch's own words, it was more of a 'take the offer, or you're fired' kind of negotiation in the end.
"Not for years, hopefully." He snorts. Leaving it at that.
For the next two hours, the bullpen shrinks down to a tiny desk island, current inhabitants: 2.
You argue about possible stressors—job loss? Divorce? Death? It's hard to tell when a body hasn't shown up yet. You discuss whether the lack of a body could indicate that the unsub is sexually assaulting these kids, if he could be impotent, or simply isn't motivated by traditional dominance and "need" the kids for a bigger purpose—potentially trafficking.
You map possible locations within the perimeter, abandoned farms, storage unit facilities, and closed-down gyms on the edge of town, but quickly scrap those ideas, recognizing that most likely, he's keeping them trapped in a basement somewhere—or something similar.
Every time one of you hits a wall, the other is already there, ready to take over with a new angle.
At one point, you're both leaning over the same photograph of the third victim, missing for six days now, and despite your shoulders pressing together, neither of you does or seems to want to shift away from the other.
"Do you think she's still alive?" You ask, turning your head to look at him, the tips of your noses merely inches away from each other.
"I'll believe that, yes. Until we have a body, we'll keep searching for them all."
The clock on the wall ticks past 2:00 a.m. Your eyes are burning, but the fog around the profile is finally lifting, taking shape, teaching you more and more about what might drive this unsub to abduct children under ten.
You lean back in your chair, rolling your neck until it cracks.
"I can't, not tonight," you admit, mostly to yourself. "My brain's turning to mush, and I fear we're minutes away from me babbling pure nonsense." You smile at him.
Hotch looks at you for a moment, taking in the cloudy look in your eyes, the way you yawn every few minutes, the way you fiddle with the pen in your left hand, trying to keep yourself busy and awake.
He says your name softly. "You win this round." He leans back, looking exhausted, yet amused at the confusion slowly spreading across your face. "Coffee, tomorrow, on me. You take it black with a splash of milk still, right?" He questions.
You blink at him. You never told him that. And he certainly never has had to buy you coffee before.
"I pay attention." He winks before rolling back around to his own desk.
And as you get up to grab your coat, you can't help but glance back at him, still sitting at his desk, but instead of being nose deep in his own files, he's watching you as you leave, with an expression you can't quite place, but all you know, is that currently, a very taken man is making your chest feel full.
You have no idea that twenty-five years from now, this night, is still one of those you look back at with fond memories, realizing that it was the first time you let him see you vulnerable due to a case and the first time—of many—he rolled his chair over, just because you needed him close.
All you know for now is that the case still feels like it has no ending, that three children are still out there somewhere, waiting to be rescued. And for the first time all week, you finally believe that you'll bring these kids home, one way or another.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
The competition between you becomes your thing. Unspoken and at times a little ridiculous, but nonetheless perfect in its own sleep-deprived kind of way.
Some nights you win—or as you've come to believe, he lets you win—he trudges in the next morning with two coffees in hand, but is met by a steaming latte waiting on his desk, with a pink sticky note stuck to it saying "Loser" in thick, sharpie lines. On those days, Hotch just huffs, raises his brows, and tries to contain his giggles as he shakes his head at you.
Most nights, he wins, and you return every single time with a black coffee, trying all the different shops along your commute until you find the one you swear you hear him slightly moan at when he takes the first sip.
On his winning days, Hotch somehow always ends up bringing you breakfast, because he knows by now that you would rather sleep thirty more minutes than get up and eat.
The 'Good mornings' no longer feel like necessary politeness, but rather like two friends greeting each other for another, looong, day at work.
The nights become yours entirely along the way, the bullpen giving way to real conversations after midnight, that aren't just: can you take a look at this? Or, do you want anything to drink?
It starts innocently enough one evening when you're both nursing the terrible vending-machine coffee, which is sour, most likely because the machine hasn't been cleaned since the day it was installed in the corridor.
The bullpen is down to the two of you again, the floor dark except for the soft glow from each of your desk lamps.
You're working together on a case for Gideon, something about his two brightest agents working together on something important, or... something ;). You're both running on empty as you keep going through crime scene statements from the field office in Oregon.
Hotch's gaze drifts up from the legal pad he's been scratching notes on all evening as you rub your temples. You hope that you somehow, within the past hour, gained the ability to massage new knowledge into your brain. Because this case feels like you're looking for a needle in a needle stack.
His eyes don't stay on you for long; instead, they glide toward the corner of your desk. And there, half-buried under a stack of fabric analysis reports, lay your battered paperback of Persuasion.
The cover is soft from years and years of rereading, the spine cracked in all the places you love most.
He reaches over without asking and carefully pries it out of the stack. Hotch turns it over in his hands, like he's weighing a pound of meat in the grocery store.
"Jane Austen? In the middle of researching a firebug?" He says, voice low and a little rough from the many long nights and too little sleep. Although his words come as questions, you don't feel like he's judging you for your choice. "That's a new one."
You lean slightly back in your chair, rolling your shoulders until they pop. You look at him, trying to figure out where his sudden fascination with your reading material comes from.
"She's my reset button," you finally say, giving in to his questions. "When everything else feels like chaos, Jane somehow manages to put the world back in order."
He nods.
"I've read this one," Hotch admits, and it almost sounds like he's surprised at his own statement. He quickly glances up at you, waiting for a reaction, before flipping it open carefully, his thumb brushing the edge of a page you've clearly read a hundred times. It's annotated with several different pens and colors, indicating each time you returned to the story.
"You've read Persuasion?" You raise a brow at him.
He nods once, slowly. "Third year of law school. I couldn't turn my brain off after a criminal law final. So, I went to the library, found the most boring-looking book I could on the shelves at two in the morning." Hotch's lips pull slightly up as he sees the—fake—disgust/hurt crossing your features as he messes with you. "I started reading it to bore myself to sleep. Ended up finishing it at sunrise instead."
You stare at him for a moment, trying to picture a younger Aaron Hotchner, tired eyes, ruffled hair, college shirt, and maybe even sweatpants, curled up in his awful dorm room bed with a two-hundred-year-old love story.
The image is so unexpectedly soft and fuzzy that it makes something warm spread through your chest.
"So the stoic prosecutor is secretly a softie for second-chance romance." You try to tease him, but your voice ends up coming out softer than you meant to. In the end, you don't really want to tease him about it, because you're in awe of the fact that a man, yes, a man‚ read a "girly" classic, without complaining.
It doesn't take long for Hotch to huff out a quiet laugh and place the book back down. He doesn't push it back across the desk right away, just gently keeps his fingers curled around the edges.
"It's not the romance," he says, eyeing the cover. "It's the waiting. The way someone can walk away and still come back when the timing finally lines up. The idea that some things are worth the years in between."
There's something in the way he speaks about the story that changes the air between you, thickens it, makes it feel like the exact moment the wind stops blowing after a storm, the exact moment the sun peaks out after the rain. The exact moment you realize that you might be catching feelings for an unavailable man.
"Yeah," you manage, swallowing the lump in your throat. "That part always gets me, too."
Hotch looks up, meets your eyes, case files forgotten, no profile, no pretense. Just the two of you and the quiet that follows as you stare into each other's eyes.
"Some people are worth the wait," he smiles, so quietly you almost miss it entirely.
Your breath catches in your throat for a split second. You don't answer him, you don't have to, not now, maybe never, but the look in his eyes tells you everything you need to know, for now.
He finally slides the book back to you, fingers brushing yours for the briefest second as you reach out to tug it fully over the line between your desks. You curl your hand around the cover, feeling the contact buzzing in your fingertips.
Neither of you opens another file for a long time.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
It's no less than a week later. The bullpen smells like soy sauce and noodles. You're sitting cross-legged on the floor opposite each other, with your backs leaning against your desk's leg and whoever owns the desk next to you. Various boxes of—none authentic—Chinese takeaway surround you, everything from deep-fried meats, rice with curry sauce, noodles with some sort of sweet and sour sauce, and so on.
The food isn't exactly the greatest, but it was the best option at this hour of the night.
The conversation has drifted from case theories to anything but.
You nudge the carton of rice toward him with your chopsticks, hoping that he will eat the last of it, because it is actually awful and you don't want to punish your taste buds with it even more than you've already done. "Come on, Hotchner. You can't hold out on me forever. Worst first date. Go!"
Hotch groans and leans his head back against the desk. He closes his eyes for a split second, praying for strength, cause he knows you won't rest the case until he has told you exactly what went down. "Fine. It's Seattle ´95. I just joined the bureau, and Haley and I decided to take a break to test our relationship. A friend of a friend swore he'd found a perfect match for me. She shows up with a three-ring binder full of pictures. Not of her, but of her cat. Mr. Whiskers—"
"—No way!" You interject.
"Yes way!! Anyway, the binder starts with kitten pictures, then moves to vacation shots from a trip to the French countryside, then..." Hotch drags a hand down his face. "She proceeded to spend forty-five minutes describing the colonoscopy he had a week prior. In detail. I'm talking diagrams, recovery timelines, medication, specialty diet he went on afterward, vet notes. Everything! I ended up timing how long I could go without making eye contact with the waiter. The record was eleven minutes."
"Stop! Please! I can't breathe." You wheeze out, trying to compose yourself, but it's to no avail, so you press your forehead to your knees, trying to quiet your laughs down.
Hotch peeks at you through his fingers, grinning, hands covering his face. "Your turn! Don't think you can get out of telling your worst one!"
"Okay, Okay!" You wipe your eyes, "It's a bar here in Quantico, two years ago. Guy says he's a 'trekkie with a capital T.' He shows up in the red command uniform. Shirt, phaser, badge, the works. Greets me with a Vulcan salute and asks if I'd like to 'boldly go where no man has ever gone before...' to Denny's at 3 in the morning. Then he tries to pay for my coffee with replicator credits he printed in his mom's basement."
Hotch drops his head and laughs. "You win," he manages through uncontrained bursts of giggles. "At least Mr. Whiskers had personality."
"Mr. Whiskers had detailed medical records," you counter. "It's safe to say that you win this one with crazy Ms. catlady."
"Let's never speak of replicator credits or catladies ever again." Hotch points his chopstick at you before he leans over and steals the last few noodles, emptying another box.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
The child-abduction case from Billings, finally, finally, is blessedly closed. All three children were found curled up in the crawl space of the unsub's garage, dehydrated, in various states, but alive—all of them are alive. You sighed loudly and extremely heavily the second the news hit your inbox.
You've spent most of the time since the news broke searching up articles, watching videos of the police and field office agents breaking down the unsub's door, and several different news coverages, everything you can find on the ending of your first nightmare case.
It feels like the first real deep breath you've been able to take in the past two weeks.
You sit on top of your desk, cross-legged, one elbow on your knee, with your head resting in your palm, while the other hand stirs a cube of sugar into the cup of tea you're making.
Your shoes are kicked off somewhere under your desk—because you're a civilised person who doesn't put dirty footwear on the furniture.
Hotch sits across from you in his usual spot, leaning back in his chair, his head tipped back, and his eyes closed—it's been a long day.
His tie is wrapped around your head, something that happened around hour five after the team left, when you both had a sudden burst of insanity. The top button on his shirt is undone, and his sleeves are rolled as far up as he allows himself—which is to the elbow, like a normal person.
Hotch opens his eyes slightly, watching you as you lift your mug and take the first sip, burning your tongue in the process.
"They're really okay," you say, voice small and quiet in the massive expanse of the bullpen. "I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop." You admit.
He leans forward, now resting his elbows on the edge of his desk, and puts his head in his hands, looking at you. "They're okay, because we didn't stop," he says. "Because you didn't forget them, because you didn't stop."
You place the mug back down and slowly slide off the desk. It's almost as if you're thinking the same thing, because he stands up too, and you meet at the line where your desks meet and embrace each other. Needing the reassurance. Your arms wrap around his waist as his chin comes to rest on the crown of your head.
For a long time, neither of you speaks, you just stand there. Embraced.
"Thank you," you finally whisper, pulling your head out from under his chin to look up at him. "For not letting me fall apart on this one."
"You were never falling apart," his arms tighten slightly. "Everyone has that type of case that gets to them more often than not. And you tend to... feel everything. Mine are the ones about fathers and sons."
"Will you tell me about it one day?" You ask, sensing that there's something buried deep within his person, something he wants to talk about, but also something he fears will change the way people view him.
He nods. "Maybe someday."
It's not until an hour later, when you're packing up to leave, that you finally speak again.
"Why'd you really join?" You ask, unprompted.
"My dad was a lawyer," he states, stuffing the last of his things into his bag. "Old-school, 'justice is blind' type. Expected me and my brother Sean to follow him into corporate law, make partner by thirty-five, marry well, die respected." His mouth turns into a frown. "Then I watched a serial rapist walk away because his dad played golf with the judge. I was twenty-seven. Decided I wanted to stop them instead of arguing about whether they were guilty or not. That's the gist of it." He waves his hand in the air at the last part. "Your turn."
"My mom moved us to Ohio when I was a kid because her dream was to open a diner off the I-70," you pick at the label on your water bottle before packing it into your bag. "Open 5 a.m. to 10 p.m. every day, no fail except on Christmas and Thanksgiving. I saw and observed my fair share of truckers, cops, runaway teens, cheating husbands, and plotting wives, you know the works. I started waiting tables when I was twelve. Learned to read people before I even knew what algebra meant. The regulars had patterns: the way Mr. Henderson always ordered decaf after church, how Tammy, the night cook, flinched when men raised their voices. I figured out who was lying over time, who was running from something, who was one bad day away from becoming one of the very people we hunt. I thought... if I could understand why people turn into monsters, that maybe I could keep someone else from becoming the next scared person hiding in a diner bathroom, because their abuser tracked them down." You shrug, a little embarrassed. "I don't know, it sounds a little stupid when I say it out loud."
"It doesn't," he says. "It sounds like the reason we're both still here on a Thursday at 2 a.m."
Over time, you learn more and more about each other.
He tells you about summers on the James River, catching catfish with his little brother Sean, his mother's gardenias that smelled exactly like church on Sunday mornings.
You tell him about your mom teaching you to make pie crust with vodka, because it keeps it tender apparently, about the jukebox that only played Springsteen and The Beatles, because it was broken and you couldn't afford to have it fixed. About the night you caught a line cook stealing from the register and talked him into turning himself in instead of telling your mom and calling the cops.
You learn that he hates peas, but will eat them if they're hidden in a pie or casserole dish. He learns you secretly love cheesy 80's ballads and sing them in the shower like nobody's watching, cause they aren't obviously. You learn that he still has a worn copy of 'The Federalist Papers', which his father gave him when he was accepted into law school, even though they barely spoke before he died. He learns that you lost your mom in a car crash during college, but that she would send you care packages every month with your favorite homemade dishes and a note that always read: "Don't let the bastards get you down, honey."
Piece by piece, you trade small, sacred details of your lives over burnt coffee, like kids swapping baseball cards in the school yard, only these feel like they matter more.
Neither of you wants to admit it out loud, but somewhere between the midnight house, laughter, and brutal cases, your desks stop feeling like two separate entities and start feeling like shared territory.
It's not about who stays the latest anymore.
It's about who you want to stay the latest with.
By mid-December, you're both pretending to read your reports through before delivering them to Gideon's inbox and heading home, but really, you're talking about everything and nothing at all. The best pizza places in the D.C. area, whether aliens would be evil and turn into unsubs, and his terrible attempt at baking cookies last Christmas as an apology to Haley for not being home enough.
"I should go." You yawn, barely able to keep your eyes open.
He looks up. "Yeah. Me too."
Neither of you moves, neither of you wants to move.
"Truce?" You finally laugh, figuring your little competition was having a flare again.
Hotch just smiles and closes his eyes. "Truce. Coffee's on me tomorrow, though. No loser this time."
"Deal, Aaron." You grab your coat from the back of your chair and start heading home.
You've nearly made it through the first six months of your first year now.
The bullpen is once again dead quiet, and half the lights are off except for your two desk lamps that burn like two tiny campfires in the dark.
You're both still here, as usual, finishing a couple of overdue reports and sometimes even pretending to work before the silence turns into silly conversations.
You've won the last three nights in a row, meaning Hotch has shown up every morning with a coffee, exactly how you like it. But there's something about the past couple of days that has been feeling off about him. You don't know what it is, but it's not like him to leave work before 8 p.m.
Tonight, though, something's definitely off. He's been staring at the same page for twenty minutes now. Pen hasn't moved, not even jotting a tiny dot down on his pad by accident. His shoulders are rigid, and his jaw clenched like he's biting words back he doesn't want nor know how to say.
"Aaron." You say as you close your file.
He blinks, looks up from his own file, like he forgot you were there. "Yeah?"
"You've read that autopsy report four times now, and you still look like you want to set it on fire. What's going on? Talk to me." Your voice cracks slightly; you hope he didn't catch it, but you know better—he's a profiler, for Christ's sake, he notices everything.
He exhales through his nose and sets the pen down, harder than he intended to, you can tell by the slight surprise in his eyes at the sound. "I'm fine." He mutters, his words short and almost sounding clipped.
"You're the worst liar I've ever met, and we profile liars for a living, remember." You roll your chair around the corner of the desks until you're sitting beside him instead of across. Close enough to see the faint shadows under his eyes, the tension around his mouth, the stubble starting to show, which is the biggest indicator that something is definitely wrong—he never neglects his grooming habits, never. "Come on. It's me."
Hotch glances at the clock.
"No one else is here. Spill." You try again.
He rubs a hand over his face, and for a long, very long, minute you think that he's about to shut you down, to tell you to keep your nose to yourself, maybe even go as far as telling you it's none of your business—Hotch would never go that far, not with you.
Then he leans back in his chair and stares at the ceiling. You don't know if it's a strategic move or just his subconscious way of trying to avoid confrontation.
"Haley ended it," he says, voice so low, so dead, that you almost miss it. "Last week."
Haley's name lands between the two of you like a brick being thrown through a window. You know, Haley, you've seen the framed photo he kept on his desk—come to think of it, it recently disappeared. Why didn't he say anything?—You've met Haley.
Haley, the high-school sweetheart, Haley, the prom-queen, Haley, the future-Mrs.-Hotchner.
"I'm sorry," you finally speak, because it feels too small and too big at the same time. You don't really know how to react. You're sad for Aaron, really sad, but you also know exactly how many hours he spends in the office compared to at home. So you completely get Haley.
He gives a tight shrug, trying to seem casual, but it doesn't come off that way. "We'd been together since we were sixteen. She waited while I attended George Washington, waited through law school, waited through the Academy, through Seattle. She said that she couldn't keep waiting for a life that never really started." His voice cracks, catching on the last word; he clears his throat like it never happened. "The hours here... they're worse than in the field office. Before you started with the team, I came home around 3 a.m. and left again by seven, before she even woke up. Sometimes I'd forget to call to tell her I would be home late. She said I was married to the job." Hotch lets out a laugh. "She isn't wrong."
You don't say anything, not yet; he has more he needs to get off his chest, you can tell. You watch him pick up the pen again, roll it between his fingers like he needs something to do with his hands to keep himself focused.
"She wanted kids," he continues, this time quieter. "A house with a yard and a dog. Normal things, really. And I kept telling her soon, soon, soon, after the next case, after I make supervisor, after, after, after." He finally looks at you, his eyes glaze over in a way you've never seen before. He's always so strong; you're usually the one on the brink of tears. "Turns out 'after' never comes."
Your chest aches for you. You reach out without thinking and cover his hand with yours on the desk. He flinches, just barely, stops rolling the pen, and lets your fingers stay, your thumb gently brushing the back of his hand in a, hopefully, calming motion.
"You're allowed to be upset, Aaron."
"I'm not upset, I'm angry," he admits. "At her for giving up on us, at myself for—" he trails off, "for letting it happen. For choosing this over my partner." He gestures vaguely at the files, at the bullpen, at the life. You know he isn't referring to you, but it stings a little as he says it, knowing that you're a part of this. "I don't know how to be anything... anyone else anymore."
"You're not alone in that," you say, exhaling softly. "Half this unit is allergic to normal. Doesn't mean it makes us broken and unlovable. Just... a little complicated."
Hotch huffs out a tiny laugh; it doesn't quite reach his eyes, but at least he didn't look sad for a split second. "Complicated. Right."
Silence settles between you. Your thumb brushes a last time across the back of his hand before you pull away, rolling your chair backward toward your side of the desks.
He clears his throat, which stops you in your tracks, and sits up straighter. "Anyway. That's... that's why I've been..." He waves at his untouched—now cold—cup of coffee and the unread pages of the autopsy report.
"Thank you for telling me."
"You're easy to talk to. Dangerously easy, do you drug my coffee in the mornings or something?" He jokes, meeting your eyes, finally letting the real Aaron break through.
"Dangerous is my middle name," you deadpan before sending a quick wink in his direction. He bursts out laughing, and you follow quickly after.
When you both come back down to reality, Hotch glances at the clock. "You should go home. Get some sleep."
"So should you."
"Truce?" A asks after a beat.
"Truce," you agree.
You both start packing up, very slowly, neither of you wants to leave, not yet. When you reach the elevators, he holds the door open for you.
"Hey," you smile, turning to him as the doors slide shut. "Tomorrow, the coffee's on me."
He looks at you for a moment before softening with a grateful expression.
"I'd like that," he says.
And just like that, as the elevator starts its descent, you and Hotch leave the office before midnight for the first time since your first day sitting across from him.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
You make it all the way to the women's restroom on the fifth floor—the one no one uses and especially not after 5 p.m.—before you crack.
The door swings behind you before shutting completely—you definitely pushed it open too hard—and the fluorescent tube lights flicker once as the automatic censor turns them on.
You take the stall farthest back and lock yourself inside, hang your bag on the hook, close the seat, and crawl onto the toilet. You draw your knees to your chest, praying that if anyone actually comes in, they won't notice your hiding spot.
And that's when everything hits, all at once.
The hospice doctor's voicemail from earlier, the one you didn't get to listen to until now, two hours later, because you were in a meeting.
"We need to talk about whether your father qualifies for continuous care still... costs could increase significantly..."
The email from their accounting department lay untouched in your inbox, because you're already hemorrhaging your savings on uncovered medications and day rates on his room alone.
The consult file on your desk that's due tomorrow, but you haven't touched yet, because every time you try to read the victimology, your eyes fill and the words blur, leaving you unable to map the profile.
The way your dad didn't recognize you for a full ten minutes yesterday when you went for a visit, he just stared at the ceiling and called you "Linda,"—his sister's name, who died in 1987. Most days, he remembers you, but the days he doesn't hurt, hurt more than you want to admit.
Your chest starts hitching before you can stop it, and you press the heels of your hands into your eyes, like it's physically possible to shove the tears back in. Still, they come anyway—hot, messy, silent at first, but then end with those awful choked noises you can't swallow, the ones when you've been crying too long and can't catch your breath.
You're terrified that you're going to lose your job if anyone finds out how badly you're drowning. That you won't be able to finish another profile or report ever again.
You're terrified of losing your dad, terrified of not being there with him when it happens, terrified of being alone, orphaned. You're not ready, and you'll never be.
You're terrified that the last real thing he said to you, before he started slipping, was 'Don't spend all your savings on me, honey,' and you lied and told him you wouldn't.
You cry until your throat is raw and your sleeves are soaked and your ribs hurt from trying to keep it quiet as physically possible. You count the ceiling tiles—twenty-seven—and try those Bureau-recommended breathing exercises that were attached to your welcome package. But they don't work when the bad thing is real life, and not a case you can close and happily forget.
Eventually, the storm passes—somewhat—leaving you shaky and hollowed out, barely able to stand on your legs—Great, Bambi, it is for the rest of the day, you think. You exit the stall and splash cold water on your face. Your eyes are swollen, nose red and running. You look like you have the wildest case of seasonal allergies... or like someone who's been crying in a federal building—which is exactly what you have.
You rummage around your bag and dig concealer out, dab it under your eyes, praying it'll cover the worst of it. You tell yourself you can do this. You're a profiler—in-training. You can compartmentalize. You work with cool people, people who've stared down serial killers at gunpoint; you can survive one more day of pretending everything is fine.
You practice a smile in the mirror, but end up looking like a corpse pretending to be alive.
Your phone buzzes in your pocket as you're about to push the door open and emerge back into reality. You almost ignore it, but something feels weird, which makes you answer.
"(Y/N)? It's Dr. Singh. I'm sorry to call so late. Your father's asking for you, and I promised to relay the message. He's lucid tonight. If you can come–"
"—I'll be there in thirty." You cut her off, your voice only wobbles a little. You hike your bag further up your shoulder and head out, walking out of the bathroom, slightly hurried, but as if nothing happened.
You don't see Hotch standing at the far end of the hallway, half-hidden by the vending machines, holding two fresh—awful—coffees he came up to deliver, worried about you, when he noticed you'd been gone a little too long.
He watches the restroom door swing shut behind you, watches you swipe under your nose one last time before you enter the elevator with a spine that is entirely too straight and with a smile too bright for you to be okay.
He makes it his mission to figure out what's going on with you, the same way you kept 'pestering' him about his bad day.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
A few weeks later, the hospice parking lot is still dark when you pull in. The sky is just starting to fade into that bruised-purple color it gets before sunrise.
You sit in your car for a minute, gripping the steering wheel, knuckles turning white, telling yourself you can do this. You've done this before. You've done it every morning for weeks.
One more time. You can do it one more time. You tell it to yourself every morning before work.
Inside, the night nurse gives you a small smile and waves you through as she's doing the handover to the next shift.
The hallway always smells the same—antiseptic, instant oatmeal, and something faintly sweet that you've decided is hopelessness trying to be kind to you, but is definitely spilled orange juice that dried before it got mobbed up completely.
Room 214 is dim; the bedside table lamp is turned on. Your dad is awake, eyes open, staring at the ceiling like he's waiting, waiting for something you can't see.
You pull the chair next to his bed closer and take his hand in yours. It's cold. Lighter than yesterday, and the day before that, and the day before that. Every day, you never expect how much his health has declined compared to the day before.
"Morning, Dad." You greet softly.
He turns his head slowly, and for one heartbreaking second, his eyes focus on you—really focus. Not like usual, when he's there, but not really there at all.
"There's my girl," he rasps, voice shaky and lower than a whisper. A small smile tugs at his cracked lips. "You're too pretty to be up this early, honey."
You laugh, it sounds a little wet, but thankfully, he doesn't seem to notice. "Had to beat the awful D.C traffic," you joke. "How'd you sleep?"
"Like a dead man," he says, then winces, seeing the pained expression crawl into your eyes. "Bad joke. Sorry, kiddo."
"Don't be sorry. If anything, you're allowed bad jokes, dad." You squeeze his fingers, hoping it comes off as reassuring and not pitying.
You talk about nothing important, because everything important hurts too much right now. You tell him the Reds won last night—they didn't, but he won't know, and what's a little white lie when you're putting a smile on a dying man's lips.
You tell him about the stray cat that keeps visiting the dumpster behind your apartment, the one you've considered adopting, but can't bring you to, because you're never home.
He tells you the nurses have started sneaking him extra Jell-O and that the ceiling tiles above his bed look exactly like the 1965 Mustang he and your mom still drove when you were born.
You pretend his breathing isn't getting shallower with every passing minute.
At 6:45 a.m., he starts to drift off, eyes fluttering shut, fighting to stay awake. You lean in and kiss his forehead, tasting salt and the lingering aroma of the hospice soap. "I love you, dad," you whisper, trying not to wake him up. "I'll be back tonight, okay? We'll watch that awful game show you really like."
He manages a barely there nod, already half asleep.
You stand in the doorway to his room for a moment longer, memorizing the rise and fall of his chest under the thin blanket, barely keeping him warm. Then you force yourself to turn away, needing to get to work.
Dr. Singh is waiting by the nurses' station, arms folded, expression trying to stay gentle, but you sense the seriousness in her stance. She touches your elbow as you pass. "Can we talk for a minute?"
Your heart drops straight through the floor. You already know what's coming, but you follow her into the family room anyway—the one with the faded couch and the box of tissues that never seems to empty.
She closes the door behind her and sits down in a chair opposite you. "I'm sorry to do this when you're on your way out."
"It's okay," you lie.
She's close enough that you can smell the coffee on her breath and the hand sanitizer she reapplies after every patient she visits. "The latest labs came back overnight," she folds her hands and leans slightly forward. "His kidneys are failing faster than we expected. The infection isn't responding to anything we have left." She pauses, lets the information settle. "Realistically, we're looking at days. Maybe three to five if we're lucky. A week would be... optimistic at best."
The words land exactly like you knew they would, but hearing them spoken out loud still knocks the air out of you.
Days.
You stare at your hands resting in your lap, watching them slightly begin to shake. You twist the silver ring he gave you when you graduated college, the one that used to belong to your mother.
"Is he... suffering?" You question, voice coming out small and on the brink of tears.
"We've increased the morphine. He's comfortable. Most of the time he's not in any pain at all—he's just... slipping away peacefully, if that makes sense to you." She reaches over and covers your hands with hers. "You've done everything right. He knows you're here; he talks about you every time he's awake." She smiles, trying to reassure you.
You nod, because speaking feels absolutely impossible. Tears blur your vision now, turning the room into watercolor streaks.
"Call anyone who needs to be here to say goodbye," she says softly. "And take care of yourself, too. You've done so much for him; you don't have to be strong every second you're here. It's okay to not be okay." She reassures.
You wipe your eyes with the tips of your fingers. "Thank you."
She walks you to the door. "We'll call if anything changes, day or night. No matter what it is."
You step out into the hallway, pull your coat tighter around you, almost as if it alone can hold you together. The morning sun is finally breaking through the windows. You stand in the hallway for a long time, breathing in the antiseptic air as you try to make the world feel solid beneath your feet once again.
Then, you take one last deep breath, square your shoulders, and walk out to your car. You start the drive to the Academy—because right now, putting one foot in front of the other is the only thing you know how to do, the only thing that seems easy to do right now.
You badge yourself in on autopilot, through the several security checkpoints, until you sit down at your desk. It feels like it takes an hour alone just to make it to the bullpen, the bullpen who's already half-alive—phones ringing, printers printing, Anderson probably running another errand for section chief Strauss... because of course he is, he's the biggest teacher's pet you've ever met.
Your desk is exactly how you left it last night, except there's a fresh coffee waiting in front of your monitor with a post-it note stuck to the to-go cup in Hotch's neat block handwriting:
Latte, two sugars, thought you could use something a little sweet.
— A
You drop your back beneath your desk and sink into your chair before you wrap both hands around the cup like it's the only thing able to warm your cold, cold soul.
The coffee tastes like nothing—Which probably isn't true, but to you, you taste nothing.
Hotch looks up from his desk, eyes flick over you once, twice, cataloging everything your body language tells him: red-rimmed eyes, trembling fingers, the way you're sitting too slouched as if you've given up, like you'll shatter if anyone as much as blinks at you the wrong way.
"Morning," he says softly, tempted to ask questions, but sensing that you need time, how long he doesn't know, but you need time to just be.
"Morning." Your voice is gravel-rough.
He waits, giving you an opening to talk, giving you the opening you always take, to tell him what's going on. But you don't take it. You just open the first file in the pile stacking up in your inbox, and stare at the words. Although they refuse to form any coherent sentences in your head right now.
By eight, Gideon stops by your desk to drop off the Atlanta consult you worked on last week, asking for a few revisions to the profile with a: "Need these by noon."
You nod.
He hesitates, too, sensing that something is up. He glances at Hotch, with a subtle shrug and a look that's asking all the questions Hotch doesn't have the answers to.
Hotch just nods back, signalling that he has it under control—he doesn't. Gideon lets the two of you be.
Later in the morning, you're proofreading the same paragraph over and over when Hotch's chair rolls from his own side of the desks and into your peripheral vision.
"Hey," he whispers, keeping his voice so low that no one outside of your desk bubble had any chance of catching the conversation. "You okay?"
"I'm fine." It comes out snappier than intended, but honestly, you have very little control over your emotions lately, and Hotch is so... so comfortable to be around that you can't help it.
"You don't look fine."
"I look how I look. I'm here, I'm working. I'm fine!" You flip to the next page harder than necessary, your emotions getting the better of you.
He doesn't move. "You missed the staff meeting."
"I was in the restroom," technically true; you were hiding in a stall trying not to hyperventilate. "Is that illegal now?"
He leans his side over your desk, face popping into your field of vision. He doesn't take your hand, but you can tell he wants to, that he wants to squeeze it, to reassure you, to let you know that everything will be okay, even though he doesn't know what's going on. "Talk to me."
"There's nothing to talk about." The words come out like venom. You barely manage to soften as you turn your attention completely to your file. "I just need to get this done."
"You're shaking." He states, studying you.
You glance down, your left hand is indeer trembling around the pen. You drop it on the desk, curl your fingers into a fist, and crack your knuckles. "I said. I'm fine, Agent Hotchner." You spit at him.
His eyebrows shoot up at the use of his last name. You never call him anything but his name anymore; you rarely use Hotch, only when mentioning him around the other team members.
He lowers his voice further. "Whatever it is, you don't have to carry it alone. I'm here to lend an ear if you need it."
Something inside you snaps like a rubber band pulled too tight.
"I'm not some victim you need to profile, okay?" It comes out loud enough that the agents at the cluster of desks right next to yours glance over, confused that Batman and Robin apparently are 'fighting'.
You drop your volume but not the edge. "I don't need rescuing. I need to finish this damn consult before Gideon decides I'm useless, not cut out for the job. So please! Just. Back. Off."
The bullpen goes quieter than it has any right to at nine-thirty in the morning.
Hotch's face doesn't change, but something appears to shudder behind his eyes. He gives a single, tight nod. "Understood." He says and rolls his chair back to his desk.
He doesn't look at you again for the rest of the day.
The rest of the day is a special kind of hell. Its own kind of nightmare that you can't seem to wake from.
You power through the consult revisions, finally feeling like you're making progress—if that's what you can call it. Every keystroke feels like dragging nails across your own skin. You skip lunch, because the thought of food makes you nauseous. You drink more coffee that tastes like nothing. Answers a few emails in short, brittle sentences.
When Agent Damien asks if you want to join the afternoon run to the food trucks, you bite out "Can't" so harshly that he, for once, doesn't try to pester you into joining. He just leaves you be.
The floor has mostly cleared out by six. You, too, are packing up, movements jerky when Hotch appears again, coat draped over his arm.
"I'm heading out," he says, his tone neutral. "You need a ride?"
"I have a car." Your voice is flat.
He nods, like that was the answer he had expected. "Just... text me when you get home, please."
"I don't need a babysitter, Aaron."
"I'm not offering to babysit," his voice is concerningly calm, but there's still an edge of steel underneath it. "I'm asking you to let me know that you made it home safely, because you're clearly upset, and I don't want to read your name in the headlines tomorrow morning. Humor me, please."
You want to snap again. Instead, the fight drains out of you all at once, leaving you swaying for a bit, not really knowing what to say.
"I'm sorry," you whisper. "I didn't mean to—"
"I know." He cuts you off, steps closer, and lowers his voice so it feels more intimate. "Whatever happened this morning, whenever you're ready. I'm here. No judgement. No profiling. Just... here. But ripping my head off won't make you feel any better; it'll only delay whatever explosion you clearly need to have."
Your eyes start to burn. You nod once, faster than intended, before the tears can fall in front of him. You don't want to cry in front of him, don't want him to view you any differently.
He hesitates, then reaches out and squeezes your shoulder before walking toward the elevators.
You watch him leave, throat tight, guilt and grief tangled together so thoroughly that you can't tell which is which and which of them you're feeling the strongest right now.
You wait for a moment, then grab your bag, shut off your desk lamp, and head down to the parking lot through the back stairs.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
The bullpen is a ghost town, and it's just you and Hotch once again. The case files in front of you blur into meaningless ink on paper as your thoughts drift toward your father.
You're both quieter than usual tonight, the tension from your snap three days ago still lingers like a bruise neither of you wants to touch. He hasn't pushed the matter since, and you know that he isn't holding a grudge, but you keep catching him watching you when he thinks you're not looking, trying to read you, trying to figure out what's going on.
You're not ready to tell him, tell anybody—maybe never.
Your phone vibrates under a few scattered files, and when you finally find it, the words: HOSPICE, slap you straight in the face. It feels like your heart stops, then lurches into your throat, all the while a pit is forming in your stomach.
You grab the phone and stand so fast that you nearly tip your chair over. Hotch looks up at the sudden noise.
"I'll be right back," you mutter, already halfway out the door.
Hotch just nods, eyes narrowing slightly, but he doesn't say anything.
You make it to the hallway and lean against the wall by the vending machines, the ones out of sight from the glass doors into the bullpen, before you answer with a voice you barely recognize as your own. "Hello?"
"Hi (Y/N), this is Dr. Singh." Her tone is soft, a little too soft, you think, it's the kind of soft that can only mean bad news, really, really bad news, so you brace yourself, crossing your fingers. "I'm so sorry," she starts. "Your father passed about ten minutes ago. It was very peaceful, he was sleeping and his heart just... stopped." You can tell she's trying to lessen the blow by her phrasing.
But the world still tilts, everything blurs, and it feels like you've had your skull bashed in with a sledgehammer. You slide down the wall to a crouch, phone still pressed to your ear. You hear the words, but not really processing them.
Passed. Peaceful. Stopped.
They play on loop.
"Are you there?" Dr. Singh asks gently when you don't answer her.
"Yeah," you croak out after another few silent seconds. "I... thank you for calling." You blink back tears, trying to keep yourself composed enough to get through the rest of this call.
"Do you want to come in now? We can talk about next steps—"
"—I'll... I'll call back later. I need a minute." You cut her off."
"Of course. Take your time. I'm on the night shift, so you can send me a message if you'll be stopping by tonight." She reassures.
You don't answer her, just hang up. The phone slips from your hand and clatters on the tile. You don't bother looking at your screen—it's probably cracked from the fall.
Your stomach churns, acid burning up your throat, and before you know it, you stumble to your feet and lurch toward the bathroom down the hall. You barely make it to a stall before you're retching into the bowl. Whatever comes up mostly consists of bile and the very healthy diet you've had the past twenty-four hours, of coffee, and the skins of the few grapes you managed to keep down.
Your hands shake so hard that you have to grip the porcelain to keep yourself from collapsing headfirst into the bowl.
When you finally stop, you sink back and slide to the floor, knees pulled to your chest, back against the stall wall. The sobs come fast and violent, tearing out of you like something wild.
You press your forehead to your knees, trying to muffle the sound, but it's no use. You're breaking, and there's no one here to see it, and somehow that makes it all feel ten times worse.
You don't know how long you're sitting in the stall—minutes, maybe ten, maybe twenty, maybe an hour. The tiles are cold through your slacks, cold enough that your shivers now come from the cold and not from your emotional outburst. Your throat is raw, eyes swollen shut, and burning. You don't hear the footsteps outside until there's a soft knock on the door into the bathroom.
"Hey," you hear Hotch's voice call out, low and steady, like he's cooing at a scared animal. "You in there? I saw your phone on the ground and—"
"—Go away," you sob, the words coming out muffled against your knees. "Please, Aaron. Just go."
He doesn't. The door creaks open, and you hear the click of his shoes on the tile as he comes closer and closer to the stall you're in. Then he stops. You don't look, but you know he's there, that he's standing just outside the stall, and if he were to push the door open, that he'd see you curled into yourself, face streaked with tears, shaking as if it's physically impossible for you to stop.
You don't want him to see you like this.
"Talk to me," he says quietly, so quietly it almost sounds like he's... begging? "What happened?"
"I said, go away!" It comes out half-scream, half-whimper.
Hotch ignores your request once again. You hear his palm as it touches the door, pushing it slowly open. You curse yourself for not taking the time to lock it while you were face deep in the toilet bowl. You peek at him from behind your knees as he crouches down in the opening once the door is fully open. The jacket of his suit brushes the probably filthy and germ-ridden floor. He lays his hands, palms up, on his knees, like he wants to grab your hands and hold them, but isn't sure if he should, or if he's allowed to.
"I'm not going anywhere," he says. "Not when you're in this state. Not until you tell me what's going on."
You shake your head at him, tears flowing silently down your cheeks faster and faster. "You can't fix this, Aaron."
"Maybe I don't need to try to fix it. Maybe I just want to be here, because my friend is hurt and too stubborn to ask for help."
You choke on a sob, press your hand over your mouth, trying to hold it all in. He waits, silent, patient, waiting for you to make this next move. His presence is so solid in the stall that it almost feels unbearable.
Finally, the words claw their way out.
"My dad died." Your voice breaks on the last words. "His doctor at the hospice called. He's gone.
Hotch's face softens, grief and understanding in his eyes. He doesn't say 'I'm sorry' or any of the useless things people say when you're grieving. Because in truth, it's bullshitt, and none of it works when you're in such a deep state of pain, that the only thing you feel is misery.
Instead, he shifts to sit beside you on the floor, shoulder barely touching yours, trying his best to ground you without crowding.
"Tell me," he says. "Everything or nothing at all. Just... talk, please."
And you do. It spills out like blood for a stab wound: How you've been drowning in hospice bills and the guilt of feeling like you're not visiting him enough. How you've been terrified every day this week of getting that call. How you're not ready to be alone in the world without the man who taught you how to tie your shoes and believed you could be anything you set your heart on.
You tell him about the doctor's warning three days ago, the days-to-a-week timeline, how you thought you'd have more time—prayed... begged ...for more time. You tell him you're falling apart, and you've been hiding it because you're supposed to be strong, supposed to be a profiler, not a complete mess who throws up in the bathroom stalls at work.
He listens, doesn't interrupt, doesn't flinch when your voice cracks and breaks or raises when you get angry with yourself, or when you start crying again halfway through.
When you're done, you're shaking even harder, so hard your teeth chatter.
He reaches out then, slowly, giving you time to pull away if you aren't ready yet. You don't. His hand finds yours, gently unwrapping your curled form; he's warm, and he pulls you into him. You let him, collapsing against his chest, your face pressed into his shirt as fresh sobs rip through you.
His arms come around you, one hand cradling the back of your head, pushing you closer to him, the other rubbing slow circles on your back.
"I've got you," he murmurs into the crown of your head, over and over, until the words start to sound real to you. "You're not alone. You don't have to be alone. "I've got you."
You don't know how long you stay like that, him holding you together on a bathroom floor, his tie is probably ruined from all your tears, your hands are fisted in his jacket like it's the only connection keeping you from falling apart completely.
Eventually, your breathing evens out, and the sobs slow to hiccups.
"I don't know what to do," you whisper, uncurling one of your hands to wipe your eyes.
"You don't have to know right now," he says. "You just have to let yourself grieve right now. And when you're ready, we'll figure out the next steps. Together."
You pull back, just enough to look at him. His eyes are warm, no trace of judgment. "Why are you doing this?" It comes out as a whisper.
"Because I know you'd do the same for me," he says, simple as that. "And because I care about you."
The words hit harder than they should've. You nod, wipe your face with the back of your hand on instinct, before letting him help you to your feet. You sway, dizzy from the crying. Hotch keeps a hand on your elbow and the other around your hips, steadying you.
"Do you want me to drive you to the hospice?" He asks. "You shouldn't be alone tonight."
You feel the need to argue, to tell him that you need to do it alone, that this is your war to fight, but the fight's gone out of you. "Okay."
You make your way back toward the elevators, Hotch pops into the bullpen quickly—leaving you in the hallway with a blank and emotionless stare in your eyes—he grabs your coat and bag, and slings it over his shoulder before meeting you and calling for the elevator.
The drive to the hospice is quiet, not even the radio is turned on.
Hotch keeps one hand on the wheel, while the other rests on the console between you, palm up, in case you need something to hold. You don't take it, but you steal glances at it the whole way there.
When you walk into Room 214, the lights are dimmed to almost darkness. Your father is still in his bed, sheet pulled up to his chest, and his hands folded, like he's simply resting. Someone has brushed his hair and turned his head so he's staring toward the ceiling. It feels unnatural because he always sleeps on his side.
You stop in the doorway, legs unwilling to move, to walk up to him, to acknowledge that this is, in fact, real. Hotch rests his hand gently on your shoulder, giving it the smallest of squeezes.
"Remember, I'm right here," he murmurs close to your ear.
You take the first step slowly and carefully cross the room until you reach his bedside. The chair is still pulled close to the bed from when you moved it this morning. You sink into it and reach for your dad's hand—it's so cold now, no give in his fingers as rigor mortis has started by now, and worst of all, no answering squeeze.
The reality slams into you all over again.
"Daddy," you whimper, the word breaks in half as your whole world feels like it is crumbling around you.
You fold forward, forehead pressing to the back of his hand, shoulders shaking so hard that you hear the bed rail rattling. The sobs are loud, animalistic, and nothing like the tears that flowed earlier in the bathroom.
You curl over him, like you can shield him from what's already happened, like if you hold onto him tight enough, that you can pull his soul back into his body, that you can warm him back to life again. Your tears soak the sheet, forming a small puddle where your head is resting. Your fingers clutch his like you're drowning, and he's the life ring keeping you afloat.
Hotch moves to stand behind you, one hand resting lightly on your back, letting you know that he's there. He doesn't try to hush or fix you. Doesn't tell you that you'll be okay. He just stays.
After a while—minutes, maybe even an hour—your cries turn to ragged breathing. You stay hunched over your dad, cheek against his knuckles, afraid that if you let go, he'll vanish in a puff of smoke. Instead, you turn your head and stare up at him—he looks peaceful, like he's sleeping, you think.
Dr. Singh appears in the doorway, quietly and apologetic. She grabs Hotch's attention and gestures for him to follow her into the hallways. He hesitates, looks at you, and then leans down.
"I'll be just outside the door," he says softly. "I'm not leaving."
You don't speak, just nod against your dad's hand.
In the hallway, Dr. Singh keeps her voice low. "I know this is an awful time, but there are some decisions we need tonight or first thing tomorrow morning: funeral home arrangements, whether he'll be transported, clothing, personal effects..." She glances at you through the open door to the room, still bent over the bed. "She's in no shape to handle any of this right now."
Hotch nods, throat a little tight as he too glances into the room.
"Technically protocol says next-of-kin only," Dr Singh continues, "but as her boyfriend, if you can sign for—"
Hotch's ears go hot.
"—Uh, no, we're not..." he stops and clears his throat, cheeks slightly flushing. "We're not together. Just... colleagues. Friends. Close friends."
"Oh! I'm so sorry, I assumed..." Dr. Singh's eyes widen, and she winces slightly at her mistake. "You came in together, and the way you appear to know what she needs in a time like this... I shouldn't have—"
"It's fine," Hotch says quickly, maybe a little too quickly. "Really. I'm happy to help however I can. If there's anything I'm legally allowed to sign for her tonight to take pressure off her, I will."
"Thank you! There are a few consent forms for the release of the body and property. They only need a responsible adult, not necessarily kin. After that, I can try to work around the rest until she's ready." She exhales, relieved that she doesn't have to put any more stress on you for now.
"I'll sign whatever you need."
Dr. Singh gives him a tired, but grateful smile. "You're a good man, Mr. Hotchner." Hotch knows he should've been concerned at the use of his name, but on the other hand, he did have to sign the two of you in, in the visitor's log, so perhaps the doctor just looked at his signature.
He glances back through the door. You're still folded over your dad, completely still, and he hopes that you're sleeping.
"I'm just trying to be the person she needs tonight," he says, still glancing at you.
He goes back into the room, kneels beside your chair, and rests his hand carefully on the back of the chair and the other on your thigh. "Hey," he whispers. "I'm going to take care of some paperwork so you don't have to think about it right now. Okay?"
You don't answer him, but you turn your face just enough that he can see the glassiness in your eyes. It's the smallest movement, but it's enough for him to understand that you trust him with this.
Hotch checks his clock at 2:17 a.m. and decides you no longer can stay bent over your father's body. At least not for your own sake.
Your breathing has gone slow and slightly even, forehead still pressed to his hand—he's impossibly cold now. You're not crying anymore, you're just... gone, exhausted, stuck to the vinyl chair.
Hotch crouches beside you and brushes a strand away from your damp cheek. "Hey," he whispers. "Sweetheart, we have to go." You know you should react to the nickname, and he knows he shouldn't have said it. But it felt so right.
You don't move.
He tries again, this time softer. "You need sleep. Real sleep."
A tiny, broken sound escapes you. You shake your head violently, a choked 'No' ripping out of you as you curl closer over the bed, arms locking around your dad’s still hand.
He hates this part. He's seen it done enough times on cases to know it won't go down easily. Hotch slides one arm behind your shoulder, the other under your knees, and gently starts to lift you away from the chair and bed. You start thrashing, although weak, frantic, and grief-fueled, you manage to knock your elbow against the bed rail with a metallic clang; your shoe scrapes the floor as you try to plant your feet.
“No, please, don’t make me, I’m not ready, I’m not—” The words fracture into raw sobs.
He has to use his full strength to lift you away. You fight harder than he thought possible for someone so hollowed out, fingers clawing for the sheet, legs kicking once, nearly hitting him, body arching back toward the bed with a desperate, broken cry the moment the contact breaks.
Your head lolls against his chest only because exhaustion finally wins, but you still reach a trembling hand toward your father even as Hotch pulls you fully into his arms.
“I’ve got you,” he murmurs, over and over, voice cracking as he cradles you tight against him, carrying you out past the nurses’ station like it’s the most natural thing in the world.
Dr. Singh meets his eyes, gives him a sad, grateful nod. Your face is buried in his neck, fists clenched in his shirt, the fight gone out of you, but the sobs still tearing free in waves.
In the parking lot, the air is cold enough to bite, although it's April and should be warming up. He settles you into the passenger seat of his car and buckles you in—it somehow feels too intimate and not intimate enough. He tucks your coat around you like a blanket, hoping it'll keep you warm. You're asleep before he even starts the engine.
When he pulls up outside your building, you stir, but don't wake up. And he's happy that you don't, because explaining how he grabbed your address from your file after he first noticed something being off with you is a lot harder than just carrying you upstairs.
He comes around and lifts you into his arms. Hotch carries you up the three flights of stairs because the elevator is still broken, despite your landlord promising all of the tenants that it would be fixed within a month—it's now month three. Your keys are in your coat pocket. He fiddles around for them, trying to keep you up with one arm, and when he finally finds them and unlocks the door, he shoulders the door open and steps inside.
The apartment is exactly what he expected, and yet it's also much, much worse.
Take-out boxes are stacked on the coffee table. Unopened mail is in teetering piles around the living room and kitchen. Laundry spilling out of the hamper, like it's trying to escape. A week's worth of coffee mugs stacked in the sink, probably on the verge of growing mold.
The air smells stale, like windows haven't been opened in over a month. It's not you, you're not like this, it's the physical evidence of someone who's been barely surviving, while fighting to keep someone else alive.
He doesn't flinch at the mess. He just carries you past it, through the living room, and into your bedroom. Hotch lays you on the bed and kneels to tug off your shoes, careful not to wake you up. You curl onto your side almost immediately, knees to your chest in a fetal position, still fully dressed.
Hotch pulls the quilt at the foot of your bed up and over you, brushes your hair back, and whispers, "Sleep." And your face smoothes into something almost peaceful.
He stands in the doorway for a long moment, observing you, watching the rise and fall of your shoulder, then closes the door halfway—so he can hear you if you wake—and turns back to the disaster zone that is the rest of your apartment.
He can't leave it like this. Not tonight.
He starts quietly by tying up the trash, placing the first bag near the door. Then he continues with the kitchen, rinses and washes the mugs, placing them on a dry tea towel to dry the rest of the way, and wipes down the counters.
He finds a laundry basket of clean clothes and folds them along with the clothes that never made it off the drying rack and stacks them on the dining table.
He opens the window a few inches to let in some air to chase out the staleness. And every so often, he pauses outside your door, listening to make sure you're still asleep.
By 4:45 a.m., the place isn’t perfect, it's far from it, but it’s livable. Trash is waiting by the door—three bags it turned into—dishes are clean and drying, and mail is in one neat pile while all the colorful advertisements are in recycling, ready to be taken out too.
The couch is clear except for a single throw blanket and a few pillows.
He sits down just to rest his eyes for a minute.
You wake slowly, the way you do when your body has forgotten how to rest properly. The room is dim, curtains still drawn, but the light that sneaks around the edges is soft and golden.
Your eyes are swollen and your throat raw from all the crying yesterday, your chest aching like someone parked a truck on it overnight.
And for one terrifying second, you forget exactly why you feel like you've been run over and then backed right back over.
Then it slams back into you, the call, the bathroom floor, your dad’s cold hand, Hotch carrying you out like you weighed nothing to him.
You sit up a little too fast, and the room starts to tilt. You’re still in yesterday’s clothes, shoes off, quilt tucked around you, but you don’t remember going to bed last night.
The apartment is quiet. A little too quiet.
You shuffle to the bedroom door and push the cracked door open further.
The first thing you notice when you emerge from the bedroom is the smell. No gross and sour take-out stench, no stale coffee. Just the faint smell of dish soap and the smell of cold air.
You step into the living room and stop dead in your tracks.
It's so... clean?
Not spotless—Hotch clearly didn't have the energy to scrub baseboards at four in the morning, but there's no doubt that he would've done it if he had. Every surface is clear, trash gone, dishes done, laundry folded with a post-it note slapped on top saying 'clean :)' in his handwriting.
Even the throw pillows are straightened.
And then you see him.
Hotch is asleep on your couch, clearly too long to lie comfortably on the two-seater. His shirt is a little rumpled, tie loosened, and half-hanging off his neck like a limp snake. One of his arms is flung over his eyes, while the other is dangling off the edge. Shoes are lined up neatly next to the couch, like he had meant to leave, but got too tired and simply couldn't. You notice the faint shadow of stubble starting to grow along his jaw as he lets out the softest snore you've ever heard.
Something warm flutters awake in your chest, right beneath the crushing weight of grief. It’s not happiness—Oh, God no. You don't know if you'll ever be happy again—but it’s close to peace.
Gratitude so sharp it almost hurts.
You stand in the doorway for a long time—just looking—blanket wrapped around your shoulders, watching him breathe. He cleaned up your chaos while you slept. He stayed when he didn’t have to. He held you together when you shattered. He's done so much for you these past twenty-four hours, and you feel like you haven't done anything in return for him at all.
The flutter grows, spreads, becomes a quiet ache behind your ribs that feels a lot like falling—slow, inevitable, and terrifyingly falling.
You pad across the room on bare feet, careful not to wake him, and crouch beside the couch. Up close, you can see the faint tear tracks dried on his own cheeks—he cried too, sometime during the night, when he thought no one would know that he too felt your pain.
You reach out for him, hesitate, then brush the back of your fingers lightly across his cheekbone. Just once, barely there, needing to feel him, to know that this man is real.
“Thank you,” you whisper to the sleeping room.
His breathing hitches, eyes fluttering but not quite opening. You stay crouched there a moment longer, memorizing the way the light falls across his face, the way safety feels when it’s shaped like Aaron Hotchner asleep on your couch after the worst night of your life.
Eventually, you stand, pull the throw blanket from the floor—you recon that he must have dropped it during the night—and drape it carefully over him. He sighs in his sleep, shifts onto his side, and settles again.
You linger another heartbeat, then head to the kitchen to start coffee—two mugs, black for him and one with a splash of milk for you, two sugars for you—because the least you can do is make sure he wakes up to something a lot nicer than how you've been treating him the past couple of weeks.
The flutter is still rooted deep in your chest, like the first tiny green thing pushing through the earth after a long and harsh winter.
By summertime, the bullpen is like a hotbox, and every time someone opens the glass doors, waves of hot air drift through, making it miserable to work.
Gideon is gone more than he's there these days, and whispers about a leave of absence are circling like smoke around the office. The team is in shambles lately, most of the travel team is suspended for misconduct during their last case, morale is down, and everyone looks like they hate their jobs.
But the work keeps coming, and the team keeps working despite everyone's lackluster enthusiasm to finish their cases in a timely manner.
You, somehow, are... lighter.
Not healed—because some holes never heal, and this one will never heal—but grief has settled from a constant jabbing pain, into a dull, manageable ache, and it gets better week by week. You feel like you can breathe without doing counting exercises. You can laugh at Anderson's terrible knock-knock jokes without feeling guilty five seconds later.
And Hotch, Hotch has been the constant you needed through it all.
He still brings you coffee every morning, even though the 'who stays latest' competition officially ended last month. You still find sticky notes on your files in his handwriting—"Victim #3's timeline is off by six hours, check page 14"—when he notices new things in M.O. and victimology, or gives you a second pair of eyes when you ask for help. Or on the mornings, when grief over your dad's death creeps too close, he simply tells you to take a moment for yourself and that he'll hold the fort down while you're gone.
He never mentions the night he cleaned your apartment, or the fact that you cried into his shirt until there was nothing left for you to cry out. He just… shows up. Every day. Without fail.
Tonight is a Thursday, almost midnight. The rest of the floor is dark. You’re both still here, because of course you are.
You’re cross-legged in your chair, hair twisted up with a pencil, eating cold lo mein straight from the carton. Hotch is across from you, jacket off, sleeves rolled high, tie abandoned hours ago. There’s a smear of highlighter on his cheek that he hasn’t noticed. And you're not planning on telling him, because he looks way too cute when he's a little messy.
“Tell me I’m wrong,” you say, waving your chopsticks at the geographic profile spread between you. “But the comfort zone is shifting north. He’s getting bolder.”
He leans forward, elbows on his desk, studying the map like it owes him money. “You’re not wrong. Look at the dump-site-to-victim-residence distance. First two were under four miles apart. Last one was eight. Either he’s escalating, or he moved.”
“Or both,” you say, mouth half-full. You're not exactly charming, and your mother would roll over in her grave if she heard you speak with food in your mouth. But he looks up and smiles, before he reaches over, plucking the carton from your hand to steal a bite.
You let him.
You always let him now. Sharing food feels like nothing after he had to wrangle you off a dead body like one of those working dogs resource guarding their dead handlers.
Somewhere in the last few months, the boundaries blurred between you. You touch his arm when you pass him files. He brushes imaginary lint off your shoulder during briefings when you sit next to each other. You hang out together on days off, fall asleep on each other's couches after working on cases together at home, and wake up with blankets draped over you.
He keeps a spare toothbrush in your bathroom 'just in case,' and you keep one in his. You have an extra tie of his folded in your desk drawer because he spilled coffee on his favorite one during a stakeout, and forgot it in your car when you drove him home.
No one in the unit has said anything yet, but everyone's eyebrows climb into their hairlines on a near-daily basis as they observe your desk island.
Tonight, the air conditioning is struggling, badly. You fan yourself with a case folder. “It’s a million degrees in here.” You complain
Hotch stands, stretches, and shrugs out of his jacket. “Rooftop?”
You’re already moving as the words leave his mouth.
The rooftop door sticks—it always does—and he has to shoulder it open for you.
The evening air is warm but better than the stale office. D.C. glitters slightly in the distance, barely visible, but there. You both lean against the ledge, shoulders almost, but not quite touching.
For a while, you just breathe. Enjoying the faint chirping of crickets, the wind rustling, and natural silence.
“Thank you,” you finally say quietly.
He glances over. “For what?”
“For the last three months. For… everything.” You pick at the label on your water bottle. “I don’t know where I’d be if you hadn’t—”
“—Hey.” He bumps your shoulder with his, gently. “You don’t have to thank me. I’m exactly where I want to be.”
Your heart does a slow, traitorous flip. You tell yourself it’s just gratitude, gratitude that he helped you through the worst time in your life, gratitude that you have a friend to turn to when in need—despite being an asshole about it in the beginning (but let's not talk about that).
He keeps talking. “Besides, you’ve been pulling me out of my own head since the day you beat me three nights in a row last November. Fair’s fair.”
You laugh, softly. “I still say you let me win night two. Ain't no way your brother called you for help at nine p.m. to move an antique wardrobe he found in the newspaper.”
“I absolutely did not,” he says, mock-offended, but he’s smiling that full smile now—the one that reaches his eyes and makes tiny lines appear at the corners. You’ve started cataloging those smiles like they're evidence in an unsolved case—which technically they are, because you still haven't locked down the answer to why Aaron Hotchner rarely smiles.
Silence settles between you; it feels comfortable and familiar.
Fireflies blink lazily over the parking lot below. You shiver a little in the breeze. And without a word, he shrugs out of his suit jacket and drapes it over your shoulders.
It smells like him. You love the smell of him.
You pull it tighter. “You’re going to freeze.”
“I run hot,” he says, and the way he says it—quiet, matter-of-fact, eyes on the skyline as if it's no big deal—makes heat pool low in your stomach for reasons you refuse to examine.
You stand there like that for a long time, city lights flickering, his jacket warm around you, the space between your bodies shrinking inch by inch until your pinky brushes his against the railing.
Neither of you moves away.
Neither of you names it yet.
But something tender and inevitable is growing in the quiet spaces. In the way he always saves you the last sip of coffee in the pot, in the way you know exactly how he takes his tea when he’s sick, in the way your hands find excuses to touch and linger.
It’s still just friendship, you both tell yourselves.
For now.
You've been with the BAU for nearly a year now.
The bullpen is almost empty, save for a few agents still complaining about paperwork due that they could've finished hours ago if they didn't stand at the damn coffee machine and chat all day. But they quickly leave.
Gideon has been locked in his office all evening, door cracked just enough for the occasional frustrated sigh to leak out.
You and Hotch are the last ones standing—as usual.
You’re both on the floor now, backs against the front of your desks, case files spread around you like a thick crime-scene carpet. You’ve been arguing good-naturedly for forty minutes about whether the unsub is devolving or just getting sloppy.
“He’s devolving,” you insist, flicking a photograph toward Hotch. “Look at the overkill on the last victim. That’s rage, not control, in the way we saw on victims one through five.” You point out, gesturing at the pictures of the other victims lying in a half circle in front of you.
Hotch catches the photo mid-air and sets it down carefully next to the other victims. “Rage can be controlled. He staged the body perfectly. That takes discipline.”
His knee is touching yours. Has been for the last twenty minutes. Neither of you has moved away.
You reach for the same file at the same moment. Your fingers collide, stay there, overlapping on the manila folder. The air between you goes suddenly, electrically still.
He doesn’t pull back. You don’t either.
You’re close enough to count the flecks of gold in his irises, close enough to see the tiny scar on his upper lip you’ve never noticed before. His gaze drops to your mouth for half a heartbeat—so fast you almost miss it—then flicks back up, something unreadable flaring behind his eyes.
Your breath catches.
The moment stretches, until the door to Gideon’s office bangs open so hard the hinges bounce it back off the wall.
Gideon strides out, coat half-on, briefcase in hand, clearly intending to leave without a word. He stops dead when he sees the two of you on the floor, hands still touching, faces inches apart, the entire room vibrating with something neither of you has said out loud yet.
He stares for three full seconds.
Then he throws his head back and groans like a man who has reached the end of his patience with the entire universe.
“Oh, for the love of God, just kiss already!”
You jerk apart like teenagers caught behind the bleachers. Hotch's ears go scarlet, and you feel your own face ignite.
Gideon points a finger between the two of you, coat flapping dramatically. “I have watched you two moon over each other for months. Months! I am old. I am tired. I have unsubs writing manifestos in blood, and I do not have time for this level of sexual tension in my bullpen. Kiss, date, do whatever it is you children do these days... just stop making it everyone else’s problem!”
He doesn’t wait for a response. Just spins on his heel, muttering something that sounds suspiciously like “finally” under his breath, and storms out.
The glass doors swing shut behind him, and you hear the ding of the elevator.
Then... silence.
You risk a glance at Hotch. He’s staring at the floor, jaw working like he’s trying to decide whether to laugh or die of embarrassment. His hand is still halfway reaching for the file you both abandoned.
You start laughing first, mortified and unstoppable. He follows half a second later, the low, surprised sound he makes when something actually catches him off-guard.
“Oh my God,” you wheeze, pressing both hands over your burning face. “He did not just—”
You peek through your fingers. He’s looking at you now, something soft and stunned and hopeful in his expression.
The laughter fades, but the air stays as charged as ever.
You swallow. “So… Gideon’s not subtle.”
“No,” Hotch agrees, quieter. “He really isn’t.”
Another beat. Your heart is hammering so loud you’re sure he can hear it.
He shifts, just slightly, closing the small distance Gideon’s outburst created. His voice drops to almost a whisper.
“Would it be… completely inappropriate if I took his advice?”
Your breath stalls. The world narrows to the few inches between you, the warmth radiating off him, the way his eyes search yours for permission.
You manage the tiniest shake, giving him the go-ahead.
He leans in slowly and carefully, giving you every possible second to change your mind.
You don’t.
The first brush of his lips is barely there, warm, trembling just enough for you to feel it against your lips.
He smells faintly of coffee and the soap he always uses.
The second is surer, his lips settling over yours with certainty, the softest pressure that makes your breath catch in your throat. You taste the lingering trace of peppermint on his tongue when your mouth parts under his, feel the faint rasp of growing stubble along your upper lip, the warmth of his exhale mingling with yours.
His hand cups your cheek, thumb sweeping slowly across your skin, calloused thumb stroking once along your cheekbone; his other hand threads into your hair, fingers spreading at the nape of your neck like he’s anchoring himself to you. The kiss deepens just enough for the world to tilt, your pulse roaring in your ears, your toes curling hard inside your shoes, every nerve lighting up at the gentle, deliberate slide of his mouth against yours.
When you ease apart, it’s only a breath. Foreheads still pressed together, noses brushing, the air between you warm and a little shaky. The lines are definitely blurred beyond return.
When you open your eyes, he’s smiling, happier than you’ve ever seen him.
“Hi,” he whispers, voice rough.
“Hi,” you whisper back, grinning like a complete idiot.
From somewhere down the hallway, you’re both almost certain you hear Gideon’s ghost mutter 'about damn time'.
You start laughing again, muffled against Hotch's shoulder this time as you lean forward into his chest, and he laughs too, arms wrapping fully around you, holding you close on the bullpen floor like he never wants to let go.
And he doesn’t.
Not for a very long time.
That first kiss doesn’t fix anything, but it changes everything.
After Gideon’s dramatic exit, you and Hotch ended up staying on the bullpen floor another hour, kissing slowly and carefully like teenagers who’ve just discovered the concept, talking in whispers, laughing every time one of you remembers Gideon’s exact phrasing. When you finally stand up, knees stiff, files forgotten, he walks you to your car with his hand at the small of your back like it always belonged there.
You date quietly at first, almost secretly, because neither of you trusts the Bureau rumor mill and because the newness feels too precious to share with anyone but the two of you.
He picks you up on Saturdays when you’re both off rotation. You go to tiny diners outside the Beltway where no one knows your names, or to the Smithsonian after closing because one of the night guards owes him a favor from back in his prosecutor days.
You sit on benches in front of the Hope Diamond and argue about whether it’s cursed. He brings you coffee in bed on Sunday mornings and reads the parts of the newspaper aloud while you steal the comics section and draw little hearts in the margins next to his name when he’s mentioned in an article.
You learn the small, sacred things about him:
He hates surprises but loves planning them for you.
He keeps a spare tie in your glove compartment now—officially 'in case of emergencies'.
When he’s exhausted, he falls asleep with his head on your chest and one arm locked around your waist like he’s afraid you’ll disappear if he lets go.
He says your name differently when you’re alone, much softer, almost like a whimper.
December brings the first snow, and the first time he says “I love you.”
You’re in his apartment, stringing popcorn for a tiny, lopsided Christmas tree because neither of you had time to get one before all but the small apartment-friendly ones were the only option left.
You’re on the couch, legs tangled, the Muppet Christmas carol crooning in the background.
You prick your finger on a needle and mutter a curse. He takes your hand, kisses the tiny drop of blood away, and just says it, as natural as breathing: “I love you.”
You freeze, popcorn garland half-finished in your lap. He looks suddenly terrified, like he’s broken some unspoken rule in the relationship guide.
You tug the garland carefully aside, crawl into his lap, and kiss him until neither of you can breathe.
“I love you too,” you whisper against his mouth. “So much it scares me.”
He exhales like he’s been holding that fear in for months and tightens his arms around you. “Good. We can be scared together then.”
January of 2002 is brutal, back-to-back cases, forty-eight-hour consult marathons, but you survive it the way you survive everything now: together.
You fall asleep on each other more often than not, steal kisses in the elevator when no one’s looking, and leave each other notes in case files.
“Meet me on the rooftop at midnight. Bring the good coffee. –A”
“Only if you bring the blanket. –Y/N”
Valentine's Day falls on a Thursday. You both have to work, but he leaves a single red rose on your desk with a sticky note: Dinner. 8 p.m. Wear the black dress. Trust me.
You do.
He takes you to a hole-in-the-wall Italian place in Alexandria you’ve never noticed before. Halfway through tiramisu, he slides a small velvet box across the table.
Your heart stops, and you panic slightly.
He sees your face and actually laughs a tiny chuckle. “Relax. It’s not that. Yet.”
Inside is a delicate silver key.
“To my place,” he says quietly. “I want you to have it. I want… I want this to be official. You and me. No more pretending we’re just really good friends who occasionally make out in the parking garage and have sex in our time off.”
You stare at the key like it’s made of large sparkly diamonds.
“Aaron…”
“If it’s too fast—”
“—It’s not,” you cut in, voice cracking. You lean across the tiny table and kiss him in front of the entire restaurant. “Yes. A thousand times, yes.”
He smiles against your mouth, relieved and giddy and so in love it shows on every line of his face.
Later, back at his apartment—well, kind of your apartment now, too, in every way that matters at least—you hang your coat next to his on the rack, put your hairbrush next to the comb in the drawer, and fall asleep tangled together under the same blanket that used to live on your couch, the one he slept with the first night he saw your apartment.
Outside, snow falls softly and quietly over Virginia, covering the city in a hush that feels like the world permitting you to finally be happy again.
You are a couple now—no, almosts, no, hesitations.
Just you and Hotch against the world, desk neighbors turned lovers, building something together.
And you both start to feel like coming home at night isn't something so terrible to do at all.
The years blur in the best way possible.
September 2002
The inn’s garden is small and perfect, and the late-summer roses still cling to the trellises; the air is warm enough to carry the scent of honeysuckle and fresh-cut grass.
Forty white chairs are set in uneven rows on the lawn; fairy lights are already strung even though the sun won’t set for hours. Someone’s old jazz standard drifts from hidden speakers; it’s Ella Fitzgerald, the song you and Hotch danced to in his apartment the first night you ended up admitting you were in love.
You wait in the bridal suite upstairs, heart hammering so hard you’re sure it’s visible through the lace bodice of your dress. Your mother’s veil—now shortened—falls in soft waves over your shoulders.
And when you catch your reflection, you almost don’t recognize yourself: eyes bright and cheeks flushed. You look so... happy.
Downstairs, Hotch stands beneath the arbor in a charcoal suit that fits him like it was invented for his shoulders (A/N: to the people who get this reference, I love you).
His hands are clasped behind his back to hide the slight tremor, but you can see it from the window, the way he keeps rocking forward on the balls of his feet, the way he can’t stop staring at the inn door like the moment you appear might be a dream he’s terrified of waking from.
Gideon—wearing an actual suit and tie for once—clears his throat at the head of the aisle, after your walk, and begins.
His voice is steadier than anyone expected until Hotch repeats “in sickness and in health,” and it cracks on the last word. Gideon’s eyes go glassy instantly; he has to pause, press his lips together, and fan himself with the printed vows like a southern belle.
A ripple of soft laughter moves through the guests, but no one’s eyes are left dry.
You reach for Hotch, and he takes your hands like they’re made of glass. His palms are warm, trembling just slightly, and the stunned, luminous smile never leaves his face during the entire night.
When Gideon finally says, 'You may kiss your bride,' Hotch doesn’t wait for the words to finish. He cups your face with both hands, rushing closer, thumbs brushing the corners of your mouth, and kisses you like he’s been starving for it.
It goes on long enough that his friend Rossi—you've met him once and heard the stories of the few cases the two had together before Rossi retired from the BAU—lets out a low, appreciative whistle.
And Andi Swan, the newest BAU agent, fans herself dramatically with her program, and Gideon throws his hands in the air with a triumphant “I told them to kiss eighteen months ago! You’re welcome, people!” And you know that that will be his go-to line when it comes to tales about the relationship he 'basically made possible'.
Hotch finally pulls back, but only far enough to rest his forehead against yours. His eyes are shining.
“Hi, Mrs. Hotchner," he whispers against your lips.
"Hi, Mr. Hotchner," you whisper back, and the grin that breaks across his face is the same one he’ll wear in every photograph for the rest of your lives.
Behind you, forty people cheer, Ella keeps singing, and the mountains hold their breath, and you know—without a single doubt—that this is the moment every late-night bullpen, every shared highlighter, every quiet 'I’ve got you' was leading to all along.
You’re married.
And Aaron still looks like he can’t quite believe you said yes to him when he proposed.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
2003
Fairfax, Virginia
The search takes four months, forty-three open houses, and one near-breakup—not really, you were both being dramatic—over whether 'good bones' is real-estate speak for 'you’ll be sanding floors until you’re sixty.'
You’re both stubborn, both exhausted from cases—both promoted to the travel team one month apart—and both secretly terrified of choosing wrong, because this will be your sanctuary away from serial killers and psychopaths.
Then the realtor unlocks the gate at 127 Oakridge Lane, and you know the second the gravel crunches under your shoes, that this is it.
It’s a 1930s red-brick colonial set back from the street, white trim peeling just enough to feel loved instead of neglected. The wrap-around porch creaks under your weight in the most comforting way; a massive, hundred-year-old oak spreads its branches over the front yard like it’s been waiting for children who haven’t been born, yet.
Inside, the hardwood floors glow honey-gold in the late-afternoon, the fireplace still smells faintly of the last family’s Christmases, and the kitchen—God, the kitchen—has windows on three sides that turn the whole room into a sunlit heaven every morning.
You stand at the farmhouse sink—hands braced on the porcelain as you look into the backyard, imagining growing old here—when Hotch comes up behind you, arms sliding around your waist, chin resting on your shoulder.
“This one?” he asks quietly, like he’s afraid to jinx it.
You nod, throat tight. “This one.”
You close on a Thursday in May, sky so blue it hurts to look at. The moving truck is late, so the house is mostly echoing emptiness and stacked boxes labeled in Hotch's neat block letters and your chaotic scrawl.
Sunlight pours through the bare windows of your now-empty apartment, dust motes dancing like confetti.
Hotch scoops you up without warning, one arm under your knees, the other behind your back, and carries you over the threshold bridal style, even though your jeans are streaked with paint, and you’re both laughing too hard for it to be dignified.
The front door swings shut behind you with a solid, final click that feels like the house exhaling in welcome.
You don’t make it past the foyer before he’s kissing you against the wall, hands already tugging at the hem of your T-shirt, your legs wrapping around his waist like muscle memory.
Boxes topple somewhere down the hall; neither of you cares.
That night, you christen the kitchen island while the pizza you ordered goes cold on the porch, because you "forgot" to open the door when the delivery guy knocked.
The next morning, the sun wakes you in the master bedroom, pouring through east-facing windows you didn’t bother to curtain yet, and you make love on your mattress on the hardwood floor because the bed frame is still in pieces.
By Sunday, you’ve claimed the wide-plank stairs... twice, the claw-foot tub, the window seat in the library that overlooks the oak, and the backporch swing that squeaks in the most perfect rhythm.
Somewhere between the third and fourth room, Hotch starts laughing into your neck, breathless and delirious. “We’re going to need to buy furniture eventually,” he gasps.
You bite his shoulder, grinning. “Later. Much, much later.”
By the end of the first week, the house smells like coffee, fresh paint, and sex; every corner holds the echo of laughter and the imprint of two people finally, finally being home.
The oak tree shades the front yard like it’s keeping your secret, and every morning the kitchen windows flood the room with light.
You hang your mother’s lace curtains in the dining room first, just so the house knows it’s loved.
And every night, when Hotch pulls you into his chest in whatever room you’ve ended up in, he whispers the same thing against your hair:
“Welcome home, Mrs. Hotchner.”
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
2004 - 2005
The BAU is still small enough that every new face feels like it rearranges the gravity in the room.
Derek Morgan arrives first, in the spring of 2004, all swagger and leather jacket, straight from the Chicago PD. He shakes Hotch's hand a little too hard, like he’s testing whether the stories about the grumpy agent are true.
Gideon waits exactly one week before dragging him to the coffee station and launching into the tale of how he's the reason you're married today: the empty bullpen, the unbearable tension, the night he finally lost patience and bellowed, “Just kiss already.” And after that day, Morgan’s go-to greeting becomes a cheeky “Morning, Mama Hotch,” usually followed by him ducking whatever office supply you lob at the rascal's head.
Penelope Garcia blows in that summer like a glitter bomb, pink boa trailing behind her after Hotch manages to snatch the black queen away from the web of hackers interfering with government websites, and onto the team. Gideon barely lets her set down her bedazzled laptop in her tech cave before he’s steering her toward the round-table room, eyes gleaming.
Ten minutes later, she bursts out, finds you at your desk, and squeals so loudly the windows nearly rattle. “You’re the desk-neighbor soulmates! The sacred ‘kiss already’ origin story! I have shipped you since the academy rumor mill got to me a few weeks ago!” She throws her arms around you, then, without hesitation, around Hotch too, who's emerged from his—new—office next to Gideon's. He freezes mid-sentence, arms half-raised, before awkwardly patting her sequined shoulder. From that day on, she declares herself your joint fairy godmother and threatens to make couple T-shirts if she doesn't see you kiss, just once, before the year is over.
Thankfully, she does—although it's by hacking into the bullpen cameras and watching tape from the night before when you were both staying late, again.
Fall brings Spencer Reid and Jennifer Jareau within weeks of each other. Spencer is drowning in a cardigan two sizes too big, clutching three PhDs and the conviction that Gideon can read minds.
JJ is calm on the outside and vibrating on the inside, terrified of choosing the wrong photograph for the press packet. Gideon corners them together in the hallway on their very first day, blocking escape with his whole body, and delivers the performance of his life: sweeping gestures, pregnant pauses, the whole thing.
Spencer turns the color of a ripe tomato and starts reciting workplace-romance statistics under his breath. JJ just laughs, delighted, and by the end of the month, she’s slipping you lists of baby names “for future reference” with a perfectly straight face, because to her, babies are the most wonderful thing in the world.
Elle Greenaway is last, late 2005, striding in like she already owns the bullpen and everyone in it after helping the team on the Seattle strangler case. Gideon waits until she’s halfway through her first official BAU case file, then plants himself on the edge of her desk and launches into the now-legendary retelling—complete with slow-motion reenactment of his dramatic exit and a claim that the overhead lights flickered for cinematic effect.
Elle listens with one eyebrow arched, arms folded, then looks across the room at you and Hotch—who are pretending, very badly, not to hear any of this—and deadpans, “So your entire marriage is because an old man lost his patience?” Hotch mutters “Don’t encourage him” into his coffee, but the corner of his mouth betrays him.
By the third round, with every new hire, the story has grown mythic: wind machines that definitely do not exist, a single heroic tear rolling down Gideon’s cheek, the faint sound of angels singing when your lips finally met.
Each time he tells it, you and Hotch trade the same long-suffering glance across wherever you're standing together—the one that says we will never live this down and we don’t actually mind. Gideon catches the look every single time, grins like a proud, meddling father who knows exactly what he did, and keeps talking anyway.
Because the day he stops telling the story is the day he admits the team has outgrown him, and none of you—no one—is ready for that yet.
So you let him have it. You let them all have it. The whistles, the teasing, the running slideshow Garcia keeps threatening to present at the next holiday party.
You and Hotch just reach for the same highlighter—on purpose—like you’ve done for years, fingers brushing, and smile the tiny, secret smile of two people who know the real story is quieter, slower, and infinitely better than any legend Gideon could invent.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
September 2006
Exactly six years after you join the BAU. You’re both still raw from Oregon, a case that ended with a twelve-year-old girl alive and a father who will never come home.
You come back to your home hollow-eyed and quiet, sleeping in snatches, waking from nightmares you don’t talk about.
Two weeks later, you’re late. Not just late; late enough that your body feels foreign, breasts tender, exhaustion bone-deep in a way no case has ever managed.
You buy the test on your lunch break, hide it in your purse like contraband, and take it in the restroom on the third floor because you can’t wait the fifteen minutes to get home.
You sit on the closed toilet lid, timer on your phone ticking down three endless minutes, and when the second pink line appears, and you feel the world tilt sideways.
You drive home in a daze. Hotch is already there. He took the afternoon off after you texted, “Can you be home early?” with no explanation, worried that something was terribly wrong.
He’s in the kitchen in sweatpants and an old T-shirt, hair still damp from the shower, making coffee like it’s any other Tuesday.
You walk straight into his arms without a word. He stiffens for half a second, sensing the tremor in you, then folds you in tight.
“What is it?” he asks against your hair, voice low and treading carefully.
You pull the test from your pocket and press it into his hand.
He looks down. The little plastic window is face-up, two unmistakable lines staring back at him. His breath stops. You watch the color drain from his face, then flood back in a rush. He stares so long you start to worry.
“Aaron?”
He drops slowly, like someone cut his strings. One knee hits the tile, then the other, until he’s kneeling in front of you. His hands find your hips, tentative, reverent, and he presses his forehead to your stomach. The first sound he makes is half-laugh, half-sob, muffled against your shirt. Then the tears come, the same tears you saw the night he asked you to marry him, and the morning you said “I do.” He wraps his arms fully around your waist and holds on like you’re the only solid thing in the universe.
“We’re having a baby,” he whispers, voice cracking on every word. “We’re… God, we’re having a baby.”
You thread your fingers through his hair and let your own tears fall into it.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
May 23, 2007, 3:14 a.m.
Thirty-one hours of labor, twenty-eight of them back labor that leaves you sobbing into Hotch's shoulder, certain you can’t do this. He never leaves your side, phone turned off so the world can't disturb this perfect moment in his life, and never stops whispering “You’re so strong, I’ve got you, just one more,” even when his voice is hoarse, and his shirt is soaked with your sweat and tears.
At 2:56, the doctor says, “One more big push,” and you find strength you didn’t know you had. And Grace Hotchner comes out screaming, red-faced and perfect, a shock of dark hair plastered to her tiny head, your nose already visible in miniature form.
The nurse lifts her onto your chest, and Hotch's hands shake so violently that he almost can’t hold the scissors. When he finally cuts the cord, the snip sounds like the loudest thing in the world.
They place her on your chest; she's so, so small. She stops crying the instant she hears your heartbeat, tiny fist curling against your skin with a grip the nurse actually gasps at. “That’s the strongest newborn grasp I’ve ever felt,” she laughs, a little teary-eyed herself.
Hotch is crying openly now, leaning over the bed rail, one hand cradling your head, the other resting on Grace’s back like he’s afraid she’ll disappear if he lets go. His forehead presses to yours, tears mingling with yours.
“Hi, Gracie,” he whispers, voice raw. “Hi, baby girl.”
She blinks up at him with unfocused eyes and squeezes his index finger with that iron grip. Something in his face breaks open—wonder, terror, love, you can't pinpoint which it is, or if it's all at once. All you know is that you feel the exact same.
He doesn’t let go of either of you for the next forty-eight hours. He sleeps in the vinyl chair with Grace on his bare chest, skin-to-skin, her tiny breaths syncing with his.
When the nurses try to take her for routine checks, he follows, hovering like a Secret Service agent. He changes the first diaper with the concentration of someone who only just learned what a diaper is and cries again when she falls asleep on him mid-burp, mouth open, one fist tangled in his collar.
You watch them from the bed, exhausted and euphoric, and think: this is what the Oregon case took from that little girl’s father, and this is what we get to keep.
Grace Hotchner, eight pounds three ounces, the strongest grip in Fairfax County, and already wrapped impossibly tight around both your hearts.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
2010
You’re thirty-eight, and Hotch is forty-five. Grace is two weeks shy of three, obsessed with dinosaurs and convinced she’s going to be a paleontologist-slash-princess when she grows up.
One Sunday night, you’re both in the kitchen cleaning after she's been put to bed, you washing sippy cups, Hotch drying, the house quiet except for the soft hum of the dishwasher.
You catch him watching you over the rim of his coffee mug, as he pauses to take a sip, that familiar, thoughtful look in his eyes.
“We should give her a sibling,” you say, before you lose your nerve.
He sets the mug down very carefully. “You sure?”
“I’m sure I don’t want her to be an only child. And I’m sure I want another one who looks like you.”
He crosses the kitchen in two strides, cups your face, and kisses you like the conversation is already settled.
It is.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
In late 2010, labor starts... politely... at least for the first twelve hours, then turns vicious.
Contractions come hard and all over the place, and progress stalls at seven centimeters.
Grace had been fast; this baby is stubborn as hell. Thirty hours in, your blood pressure spikes, the fetal heart monitor starts its frantic dance on the monitor, and the room fills with quiet and urgent voices.
The OB says the words no one wants to hear: emergency C-section.
They wheel you down the hall under the bright hospital lights that make your head spin. Hotch walks beside the gurney in paper scrubs, one hand wrapped around yours so tightly your fingers go numb.
His face is pale, jaw locked, but his voice never wavers as he keeps reassuring you, even though you can tell he's terrified. “You’re doing so well, sweetheart. I’ve got you. We’re almost there.” He chants it over and over, like a prayer.
In the OR, the spinal takes forever to kick in; you’re shaking, terrified, tears leaking sideways into your hair. Hotch sits by your head, forehead pressed to yours behind the drape, still whispering the same words against your temple.
When the pressure starts, it feels strange, impersonal, like someone rummaging in your insides, without you feeling anything at all. His grip tightens, and he counts every second out loud with the anesthesiologist.
At 3:19 a.m., you hear it: the thin, furious wail of a newborn who is deeply offended by the cold sterility of the OR. The doctor lifts him over the curtain. He's tiny, red, fists pumping like he’s ready to fight the world already.
Benjamin Hotchner, seven pounds eleven ounces, a shock of black hair sticking straight up, just like his sister, and lungs that clearly work perfectly.
They clean him, swaddle him, and place him on your chest while they’re still stitching you up. He’s warm and a little slippery.
His eyes blink open and fix on you with startling intensity—just like his dad staring down an unsub, you think to yourself.
You start crying so hard that the nurse has to steady him in your arms.
Hotch leans over both of you, taking over for the nurse standing beside you, one big hand cradling Ben’s entire back, the other stroking your hair. His voice is wrecked. “You’re the strongest person I’ve ever known,” he whispers against your temple, lips brushing the skin there again and again as he kisses you, like he can’t stop. “Thank you. God, thank you. For giving me so much!”
In the afternoon, the hospital room is quiet except for the soft beep of monitors and the squeak of your bed when you shift. Hotch is asleep in the recliner pulled up next to your bedside, still in his scrubs, Ben is asleep on your chest under the hospital blanket, tiny fist curled around the necklace Hotch gifted you after Grace was born—You kept telling him that he didn't have to, that it was way too expensive, but he had insisted that not even diamonds could do justice telling you just how much he loves you.
The door creaks open slowly. Grace pads in, wearing her dinosaur pajamas and light-up sneakers with Garcia in tow, hair a wild halo from hanging out with the entire team, and most likely sleeping, flopped against them like a lazy little cat.
She climbs up the bed rail like a monkey, eyes huge.
You brace for jealousy, for tears, for anything, not knowing how a child should react to no longer being an only child.
Instead, she leans over, studies her brother with grave three-year-old seriousness, then looks at you.
“He’s cute,” she announces in her bossiest big-sister voice. “Can we keep him?”
Hotch wakes at the sound, and his daughter bracing her feet on his thigh to lean even further over the bedside. His eyes are bleary and soft as he comes to.
You meet his gaze over Grace’s head, both of you starting to laugh, tears streaming again because the relief is too big to fit inside normal emotions.
“Yeah, baby,” Hotch says, voice thick from sleep. He reaches out with the arm closest to Grace and pulls her into his arms. “We’re keeping him.”
Grace lays her head on his shoulder, sticks her—slightly sticky, you never get used to how quickly kids get sticky—hand out for you while curled into her dad's side. You take it at the same time as Ben stretches his tiny arms with a yawn too big for a newborn body.
And just like that, your family of three becomes four. One exhausted, stitched-up mom, one slightly stunned and besotted dad, one very proud big sister, and one brand-new human who already has all of you wrapped around his perfect, furious little fist.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
Life settles into a rhythm, as the kids grow older, so steady it almost feels unreal.
5:45 a.m.
The alarm never gets the chance to go off. Hotch is already sliding out of bed, careful not to jostle you, pressing a kiss to your temple, forehead, whatever part of your face is closest to his lips as he wakes.
He’s done it every morning without fail since Grace was born.
You hear the soft pad of his feet down the hall, the creak of the third stair, the low hiss of the coffee maker starting, before he comes back upstairs to get dressed. Ten minutes later, the scent of coffee drifts upstairs, and you smile into the pillow because it means the day has officially begun, and he’s still taking care of you first.
6:30 a.m.
The peace lasts exactly forty-five minutes. Then the thundering of small feet announces Hurricane Grace. She bursts through the bedroom door like her only mission is to create a Grace-shaped hole in the middle, hair wild from sleep, wearing mismatched princess pajamas—because she can never decide which pair to wear.
“MOM!!!!! I need triceratops pancakes, and I need them NOW.” Ben is half a step behind, dragging his—once blue—stuffed elephant that Auntie JJ gave him, it's now gray and threadbare by one ear, rubbing his eyes with a chubby fist.
Hotch emerges from the hallway and scoops them both up in one motion, one under each arm, and carries them downstairs, pretending to be a caveman who just found his next meal, while they squeal and kick.
You follow more slowly, tying your robe, already smiling at the chaos.
The kitchen is pure chaos.
Hotch is at the stove, flipping dinosaur-shaped pancakes you once made the mistake of buying from the frozen aisle in the grocery store, and now is the only breakfast food the kids will eat.
Grace is perched on the counter, “helping” by pouring half a bag of chocolate chips directly onto the pan—she's chocolate coating them, if you ask her.
Ben stands on a chair, banging the spatula like it’s a drum solo in between Hotch needing it to flip the pancakes. There are banana chunks on the floor. There’s syrup in someone’s hair. And Hotch meets your eyes over the chaos and mouths 'coffee' or 'Help me'; somehow, the two look dangerously similar when mouthed from afar.
You hand him a mug with one hand and steal a kiss with the other.
7:15 a.m.
Shoes, backpacks, lunchboxes, the eternal hunt for the left sparkly sneaker.
You and Hotch move like a well-oiled SWAT team. He buckles Ben into the car seat while you braid Grace’s hair in the driveway, both of you trading kids mid-sentence:
'Don’t forget show-and-tell!'
'He has swim diapers in the blue bag!'.
Drop-offs are a blur. Grace sprints into school, shouting goodbye without looking back; Ben clings to Hotch's leg until the preschool teacher peels him off with promises of play-dough.
You watch Hotch crouch to Ben’s level, smooth his hair, kiss the top of his head, and something in your chest still flips every single time.
Then it’s the two of you in the car, Quantico-bound, hands linked over the console, debriefing the morning like it’s your version of foreplay now—which honestly, it's starting to be.
Who has the 9:00 a.m. consult, who’s picking up dry cleaning, whether Garcia can babysit Friday night so you can finally have some mommy and daddy time.
He still traces idle circles on the inside of your wrist at red lights.
You still feel it everywhere.
Evenings
Soccer fields, dance studios, and the occasional emergency room visit for split chins or swallowed Lego pieces.
You sit shoulder-to-shoulder on tiny bleachers as often as you can—which is nearly a perfect score still, except for one game where you were on a case.
Hotch's arm drapes along the back of your seat, fingers playing with the ends of your hair while Grace scores her first goal and Ben cheers so loud he falls off the bottom row.
Recitals mean Hotch in a suit outside of work with glitter in his hair because Grace insisted on doing his makeup backstage. You keep the photo on your desk forever.
The kids love every time he's "forced" to wear a suit outside of work, because he looks so sad, they once told you. Which, first of all... evil. And second, you love, because the tiny demons don't know that he's pretending to be miserable and secretly loves dressing up for stuff with them.
After bedtime—two stories, three drinks of water, one monster check under the bed—the house finally quiets. You spread case files across the kitchen table like you once spread them across bullpen desks and floors, only now there are crayon drawings mixed in with crime-scene photos and a half-eaten dinosaur pancake on a plate nearby.
Hotch sits beside you, tie gone, sleeves rolled, reading glasses low on his nose. His hand finds your knee under the table, the same way it has since 2001.
Sometimes you work until 2 a.m.; sometimes you abandon the files entirely and end up slow-dancing in sock feet to whatever’s playing in the radio, foreheads pressed together, swaying more than dancing.
The team folds into your life like they were always meant to be there.
Penelope shows up on Saturday mornings with rainbow sprinkles and her laptop, teaching eight-year-old Grace how to code her own choose-your-own-adventure game while you and Hotch sneak a nap on the couch.
Morgan spends an entire blistering July weekend in your backyard building Ben the most elaborate treehouse known to man—complete with a tire swing and a rope ladder.
He teaches Ben to throw a perfect spiral, and you later try to teach him to stop aiming at Morgan’s head.
Reid reads bedtime stories in English, Spanish, and—once, memorably—Latin, when Ben requests “the dragon one with the big words.”
He still blushes every Thanksgiving when Gideon—retired now, but omnipresent in your lives—launches into the “kiss already” saga with new embellishments like a crazy old man; lightning flashes, swelling orchestral music, the whole works.
Reid hides behind his pie; Grace and Ben chant “Tell it again, Grandpa Gideon!” until Hotch threatens to revoke pie privileges for the entire table.
Years later, when the kids are old enough to ask why Uncle Spencer turns red every holiday, you’ll just smile and say, “Ask your father—he was there.”
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
2015
Mateo Cruz accepts the Deputy Director position on a Wednesday. By Friday afternoon, the Director’s office has made it official: you’re the new Section Chief.
The announcement email goes out at 4:17 p.m.; the bullpen erupts in cheers loud enough to rattle the windows. Hotch pretends to scowl from his office doorway, arms folded, muttering, 'Great, now I have to salute my own wife,' but the corner of his mouth keeps betraying him, because he couldn't be prouder of you.
You stay late for the ceremonial handover, shaking hands, signing the last of the paperwork that makes it real. And when you finally pull the car into the garage, it’s past 10:00 p.m., the house is dark except for the porch light, which Grace still insists on leaving for the 'porch fairies'—you'd hoped she would outgrow it by not, because it brings the electrical bill up by unnecessary amounts.
Hotch is waiting just inside the mudroom door, jacket off, sleeves rolled high, tie already loosened like he’s been pacing, not caring to change out of his work clothes yet.
The second the door clicks shut behind you, he’s on you.
One step, two, a lot of steps, and your back meets the bedroom door before you even realize you made it upstairs.
The new brass nameplate on your credentials folder digs into your palm; he plucks it from your fingers and tosses it onto the dresser without looking.
His hands slide up your sides, under your blazer, pushing it off your shoulders and letting it drop to the floor.
“Section Chief Hotchner,” he says, voice low and rough, lips brushing the shell of your ear. “Do you have any idea how long I’ve wanted to say that?”
You start to laugh, but it turns into a gasp when he presses you harder against the door, mouth finding the spot just below your jaw that still makes your knees weak after all these years.
His stubble scrapes; his fingers thread into your hair, tilting your head back so he can kiss down the column of your throat he’s mapped a thousand times and somehow never gets tired of.
“Aaron... the kids—”
"They're with Will and JJ," he quickly answers before he continues. "My boss,” he growls against your pulse point, and the possessive, reverent way he says it sends heat flooding straight through you. “Say it.”
You’re already breathless. “I outrank you now, Unit Chief.”
He makes a sound that’s half-laugh, half-groan and kisses you properly then. His tongue slides against yours like he’s been thinking about this all day. One hand splays across the small of your back, the other cups your jaw, thumb stroking over your cheekbone with that same stunned tenderness he had the night he proposed.
You fist your hands in his shirt, pulling him closer until there’s no space left, until the only thing in the universe is the heat of his body and the way he keeps murmuring “my boss, my boss” like a prayer between kisses.
When you finally break apart, you’re both breathing hard, foreheads pressed together, noses brushing. His eyes are dark, pupils blown wide, lips swollen and curved in a grin that’s pure mischief and pride.
“Bed! Section Chief,” he says, voice gravel-rough. “That’s an order from your subordinate.”
You laugh and let him push you down on the bed.
Turns out outranking one Agent Hotchner has some very compelling perks.
And he spends the entire night proving he’s more than happy to follow your orders.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
The team has made it official without ever actually voting.
You are Mom.
Hotch is Dad.
There is no escaping it.
It starts small.
Penelope bursts into the bullpen at 2 a.m. with new surveillance footage and yells, “Mom, Dad, you’re gonna want to see this!” She freezes, horrified, but you and Hotch are too tired to correct her, so you just wave her over.
From that day on, the nicknames stuck.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
Grace is thirteen, all long limbs and sarcasm and her father’s intense eyes. Ben is ten, fearless, missing two front teeth, and convinced Uncle Spencer can actually talk to aliens.
The house is loud and messy and perfect: drawings taped to the fridge next to family photos, Hotch's running shoes by the door next to Grace’s cleats, your wedding photo on the mantel between Ben’s first-grade portrait and a framed newspaper clipping of your promotion with the headline “BAU Power Couple Still Unstoppable.”
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
Reid skids into your office holding two mugs. “Mom, I made you coffee exactly the way you like it because Dad said if I didn’t, he’d make me redo all the geographic profiles from the last ten cases.”
You take the coffee without looking up from the budget report you’re murdering. “Tell Dad his threat worked.”
JJ corners Hotch in the hallway. “Dad, Grace texted me—she got accepted early decision to Georgetown. She wanted you to hear it from family first.” Hotch's eyes instantly go soft and watery; JJ pats his arm like she’s done this a hundred times—she has.
Tara is presenting when Luke raises his hand.
“Question for Mom: Can we get approval for the extra surveillance hours?”
You don’t even blink anymore. “Ask Dad, he controls the budget this quarter.”
Hotch, without looking up from his tablet: “Approved, but only if you two stop calling us that in front of the Director.”
Everyone, in perfect unison: “Yes, Dad.”
Emily—who swore she would never—slips once on a case in Kansas City: “Dad, the ME’s office is stonewalling us.”
Aaron just sighs and pinches the bridge of his nose. “I will call them. Again.”
Garcia over comms during a tense takedown: “Be careful, children, Mom and Dad are watching, and we do NOT want the lecture if someone gets shot.”
You and Hotch exchange the weary, fond look of parents whose kids just said “shit” in front of the neighbors.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
Some nights, when the kids are asleep and the house is quiet, you and Hotch sit on the porch swing you installed the year Ben was born. He wraps an arm around your shoulders, pulls you into his side, and you watch the stars come out over the same oak tree that shaded your first family photos.
“Still think Gideon was right to yell at us?” you ask, tracing the wedding ring you’ve worn for eighteen years now.
Hotch laughs and presses a kiss to your temple.
“Best thing he ever did.”
And you sit there, two kids asleep inside, careers that have saved lives countless of times and broken your hearts in equal measure, a house that always smells faintly of coffee and children, and you know—without doubt, without hesitation—that every late night, every loss, every terrifying leap brought you exactly here.
Home.
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
Grace and Ben think the whole mom and dad thing is hilarious.
Grace, now eighteen, texts the BAU group chat from college: “Tell Dad that Grandpa Rossi's carbonara recipe is trending on TikTok and people are calling Dad the ‘Hot FBI Dad’.”
≻──────────────⋆✩⋆──────────────≺
The team is sprawled across their desks after closing another case, this one a little too brutal, even for them.
You and Hotch are the last to pack up, as always.
Penelope yawns, slings her bag over her shoulder, and calls out: “Night, Mom. Night, Dad. Don’t stay too late making out on the conference table.”
Morgan, Reid, Tara, Luke, and JJ chorus “Night, Mom and Dad!” as they file out.
Hotch waits until the elevator doors close, then looks over at you, deadpan.
“We’re never living this down, are we?”
You hook your arm through his, lean your head on his shoulder as you walk toward the elevators.
“Nope. And honestly? I kinda love it.”
He presses the down button, then drops a kiss to the top of your head.
“Me too... Mom.”
You elbow him in the ribs. He laughs and pulls you into the elevator.
The doors close on the two of you, Section Chief and Unit Chief, Mom and Dad, twenty-four years after Gideon yelled at you to kiss already, still stupidly and perfectly in love.
summary: reader is a defense attorney who had a history with aaron during his prosecution days. reader has to help during an interrogation to find an unsub.
t/w: cursing, mentions of drug usage, criminal activity
"i want my lawyer!" the handcuffed man calls to aaron hotchner as he exits the interrogation room. he rattles the cuffs against the table to make his point known.
"get him his attorney," hotch seethes to emily, walking past her in route to his office. emily shares a look with morgan when she reads the name of the attorney representing this criminal.
"things are about to get interesting," she says, dialing the number.
∼
"hotchner!" a sharp voice calls from the bull pen. heels click across the linoleum flooring of the bau, and up the stairs. you could find his office with your eyes closed.
as you step into his office, aaron sits behind his desk with his eyes closed, murmuring something unintelligible. annoyance floods his features as he opens his eyes, making contact with yours. your name exits his mouth following a nice string of profanity.
the annoyance in his features switches to hard anger as he stands behind his desk. smoothing his tie, he takes a deep breath before setting a stern gaze on you. no one rattles him like you can, and you sure as fuck take a lot of pride in that.
"still defending criminals, are we?" he asks you.
"cut the bullshit, hotchner, where is my client?" you match his anger tenfold. going toe to toe with aaron hotchner is your favorite thing to do, and as soon as you saw emily's name come across your caller id, you were ready to go.
he gestures in the general direction of the interrogation room. not waiting on aaron, you spin on your heels and stalk out of his office. reid gives you a little wave as you pass him, and despite the many issues the bau gives you, you do have a soft spot for the cute doctor.
stepping into the holding room, you snatch the file from morgan's hands. "what are you holding him for?" you ask no one in particular, reading over the information.
"obstruction of justice, among other things," emily answers.
you swivel to aaron. "really, aaron?" the words drip condescendingly from your lips, which aaron takes a second too long looking at before raising his eyes to yours.
"i do not have time for this. we have a child missing and we are up against the clock," his voice is hard. "he was in contact with the unsub three days ago. we found him in possession of a controlled substance, and the last time i checked, that is in direct violation of his parole. i need him to talk." you shiver beneath his penetrating gaze. the department of justice sure knew what they were doing when they made him a district attorney. he sure made your job a little harder, but going up against him was such a turn on. a better sparring partner just hasn't come along since aaron's move to the bau.
"i've missed this, hotchner," you smirk. he works his jaw back and forth, closing his eyes once again, most likely trying to stop himself from handcuffing you and throwing you in a holding cell.
aaron lightly grabs your bicep, guiding you toward the door. when you don't put up a fight and follow, morgan looks to emily. "you think they've ever..." his thought trails off.
"we haven't, but not for lack of trying, derek," you wink over your shoulder. you shake aaron off of you before taking charge and throwing the door open.
"there she is," your client, hudson, beams. "didn't i tell you, agent hotchner, that she's the best in the area?"
you throw the file down in front of hudson. "what the fuck?" his confidence fades immediately. this lowly criminal is scared shitless.
"listen, i've been doing better. hanging around a nicer crowd, it just gets hard, you know," he pleads, with bloodshot eyes.
"i don't want your excuses!" you cut him off. you worked your ass off getting him parole after his last stint. and now he's in contact with kidnappers, breaking that parole with drugs?
hudson looks to aaron, then you, then back to aaron, his mouth agape. aaron shrugs, "i don't know why you're looking at me like i'm going to call her off. i've seen your rap sheet. must've taken a lot of work to get you parole."
the admission of your hard work stirs something in your stomach. you're used to working off his hatred and annoyance, but this awe is something different.
"agent hotchner says you were in contact with the person of interest?" you ask him. hudson seethes under your gaze, only offering a shrug. a humorless laugh leaves your mouth, and you stand. smoothing out your skirt, you look at aaron. "well, if he's not going to talk, charge him. i won't be able to get him before a judge for," you pause to think, "i don't know? three weeks? some time in dc's finest may be just what he needs." you add a little shrug.
as you approach the door, hudson calls out to you, "wait!" you pause, your hand hovering over the door handle. "i can't go back to jail," he whispers, a vacant look in his eye.
"then you better tell me what you know, and i will tell the DA you cooperated," you tell him. hudson's shoulders slump in defeat. he turns to aaron and starts singing like a canary.
∼
"thank you, for coming down here," aaron tells you in his office, later. hudson was a huge help for the case, leading the team exactly where the unsub was. they made the arrest and saved the girl.
and of course, hudson will spend a little time in dc's finest for breaking parole, but you won't make him wait long before seeing a judge.
you wave him off like it was nothing. deep down, if aaron calls, you'll come running. he's always been able to do that to you. he pissed you off during a trial, anticipating your every move, ready to box you in. that cocky look in his eye when he realized you knew that he'd won made you want to set buildings on fire.
but dammit if you didn't respect him professionally.
"must feel good to help the good guys every once in a while, huh," he teases, his mood lighter thanks to the closed case.
you roll your eyes. "you know i don't defend axe murderers, right?"
aaron looks at you like you've grown a second head. "you were the defense attorney on four of my murder trials."
"was i?" you feign. "that was back when i was a public defender. a lot's changed since then. how many of those did you win, anyway? one?"
"all of them," he deadpans, but there's a slight smirk wanting to break through.
you shrug, picking your bag up from the floor of aaron's office. "goodnight, aaron. gimme a call next time you suck ass at interrogating one of my clients."
he answers you with a chuckle. "yeah, okay." he pauses. "wait," he says as you cross the threshold into the hall. you turn to him, your brows raised.
"when have you ever tried to sleep with me?" he asks, recalling derek's comment from earlier. the question is so blasé it catches you off guard.
"aaron," you chide. "i'm disappointed. every time i have ever interacted with you, i've wanted nothing more than for you to shut me up with a kiss and fuck me into next week."
the look on his face is priceless as you give him a wink and leave his office.
a/n: i don't know where this was going to go, but it's been in the drafts for weeks. lemme know if you want a part 2
summary: aaron sees you at the bar with another man, and is soooo jealous he's turning green <3 based on this request.
warnings: jealous hotch, reader winding him up for funsies, team is also in love w reader because she's so cool
wc: 2.7k
✰ masterlist
A bar was the least likely place Hotch thought he’d find himself in this evening. Loud, sticky, overcrowded and not nearly upscale enough to stock the bourbon he actually liked. But you had prior commitments tonight, Jack was at Haley’s, and he’d run out of excuses to dodge the monthly bar outing with his team.
He’d tried, obviously. Muttered something about a financial report that’s due for his quarterly budget meeting with Strauss—his go-to deterrent. Everyone hears budget and immediately starts yawning. Everyone except Rossi, apparently. So there he was, bumping shoulders with people who clearly thought personal space was optional when in a dungeon with over-saturated lighting.
There was no denying that he looked wildly out of place. Think overworked accountant who’d walked into a frat party by mistake. The man probably had an Excel spreadsheet open somewhere in his mind while everyone else was doing tequila shots.
All Hotch wanted was to be home. Tie off, shirt half undone, waiting for your ‘made it home safe’ text before collapsing into bed like a responsible, emotionally repressed adult. He could be collapsing into bed right next to you—if he ever worked up the nerve to ask you to move in already—but that’s a whole other issue, one that only reinforces the ‘emotionally repressed’ part.
Unfortunately, he was collapsing into a booth Penelope affectionately dubbed their ‘usual spot’ instead. It looked exactly like every other table in this sweltering purgatory, except this one came with Rossi grinning like the Cheshire cat and Prentiss running a bet on how long Hotch would last before faking a work emergency.
“You can unclench, you know,” Rossi starts, sliding into the booth beside him with a grunt. “No one’s going to make you dance.”
“I’m not clenching,” Hotch argues, which is exactly what someone clenching would say.
“Mhm. You’ve got the look of someone counting down the minutes till their escape.”
“I’m not counting.”
“Sure. And I don’t own three humidors and a signed Sinatra record.”
Hotch exhales, pulling out his phone to check the time, and to see if he’s somehow missed a text from you. Spoiler, he hasn’t. “You really don’t get tired of hearing yourself talk, do you?”
“Not when I’ve got such an engaged audience.”
“Be nice,” Garcia scolds, plucking up a laminated cocktail menu she definitely doesn’t need. “He showed up. That’s growth.”
“Barely,” Morgan says, stealing a chair from a different table and settling at the end of the booth. “You look like you’re waiting for your dentist appointment.”
“He’s clenching isn’t he?” Rossi mocks, only deepening Hotch’s frown.
“I’m not clenching.”
Prentiss tilts her head like she’s deep in thought. “You look like you’re clenching a little bit.”
“Oh, for the love of all that sparkles, can we not bully our Unit Chief during happy hour? Now—” Garcia waves the menu like a wand “—shots. I want orders, people. We’ve got eight minutes left of the sacred free shot window, and mama intends to make it count.”
Hotch can say with complete certainty that he’s lost track of how many times Prentiss and Garcia have vanished to the bar. The only real time stamp he has is the beer they insisted on ordering him, now warm, flat and deeply depressing.
He’s just about to make his exit, deciding he has more than fulfilled his social obligations for the night, when Prentiss reappears—Garica nowhere in sight—carrying two cocktails and wearing an expression that makes him pause. Not out of curiosity, but out of pure self-preservation. The ‘if I leave now, there’s a high chance I’ll end up bailing someone out at 2 am’ kind of pause.
She sets the cocktails down. “Okay, so…guess who we just saw.”
Before anyone can answer, Garcia appears behind her, breathless and giddy. “I’m still trying to figure out if she’s into him or not.”
“Who’s into who?” Morgan asks, turning in his seat to follow Garcia’s line of sight.
“Remeber the prosecutor from the Tanner case? She’s here,” Prentiss says, sliding back into the booth.
“She’s here?” JJ asks, eyebrows lifting as she leans over Reid to get a better look.
“Yup,” Prentiss confirms, popping the p. “And some guy in a button-down has been chewing her ear off for the last twenty minutes.”
Hotch lets go of the beer, hand curling into a fist on the table as he follows Prentiss’s gaze. He knows exactly who they’re talking about. You worked the Tanner case.
He knew you were going out with friends tonight, he just didn’t know it would be here. Sticky floors and cheap vodka are not your usual scene.
But there you are. Leaning against the bar, listening while some overconfident guy talks at you with his whole body. Hands flying, head tilting, the complete performance. Hotch can’t hear a word over the noise, but he can read your lips well enough to make out an “oh, really?” and see your eyebrows lift like you’re impressed.
And that makes something in him twist, because he knows that face. He knows the real version of it. And this one is close enough to it.
“I didn’t peg her as single,” Morgan says, squinting in your direction.
Hotch takes a slow breath, rearranging his expression into something neutral while he has the chance, before anyone bothers looking at him instead of you.
Prentiss shrugs, taking a sip of her drink. “She didn’t have a ring on during the trial.”
“Could be intentional,” Reid adds thoughtfully. “Wearing a wedding ring could make her appear more personable or sympathetic, but removing it creates psychological distance. Makes her seem less emotionally accessible. Intimidating, even. Which, in her position, is probably beneficial in front of a jury or a suspect.”
You’re still smiling—polite, maybe amused, but making no effort to move away. Your elbow is propped on the bar, drink forgotten about mid-conversation. Your body language is telling Hotch that you’re not uncomfortable. Which almost bothers him more.
“Fifty bucks says you can’t walk over there and get her number.” Prentiss blurts out, elbowing Morgan.
Hotch nearly chokes on nothing.
“Please. I absolutely could.”
“Mm-hmm,” Prentiss hums, unconvinced. “But you won’t.”
Morgan shakes his head and begins pushing his chair back, fueled by spite and charm.
“I wouldn’t,” Rossi interrupts and Hotch is unsure if he should be thanking him or preparing for the situation to get worse.
“What, you're scared I’ll actually pull it off?” Morgan finally tears his eyes away from you.
Rossi sighs like he’s explaining basic etiquette to a toddler. “You’re forgetting rule number one of bars like this.”
“There are rules now?”
“There are always rules,” Rossi says. “If a woman like that wanted to be interrupted, she wouldn’t be standing with her body angled towards the bar. She’d be angled towards the room.”
Morgan stares at the man blankly. “…You just made that up.”
“Yes,” Rossi agrees easily. “And it still sounds smarter than whatever you were about to do. Sit down before you make Monday’s briefing awkward.”
If Hotch wasn’t clenching before, he definitely is now because you’re moving. You’re picking up your drink and motioning for button-down to follow you.
“Oh—oh, she’s on the move,” Garcia squeals, spilling her drink as she turns back to the bar.
Prentiss leans forward. “Is she leaving with him?”
“No,” JJ says, squinting. “She’s… taking him somewhere.”
And you are. You lead him across the room, weaving through the crowd, making a stop at a table of women—your friends. Hotch recognises a few of them from the times he’s met you for lunch, and from the dinner parties you insist on hosting even when you’re dead on your feet.
He watches as you lean in to say something, probably an introduction and as button-down’s back is turned, you flash a quick thumbs up to Lucy–Hotch thinks that’s her name. She covers her smile with her glass.
“She was vetting him,” Prentiss gasps. “Looks like you might have a shot after all, Morgan.”
You don’t bother sitting back down, even though your fresh drink is still on the table. Instead, you’re pulling out your phone, fingers flying over the small screen and as soon as you’re slipping it back into your bag, Hotch’s phone buzzes against the table. It’s too loud in the bar for it to grab anyone’s attention, but Hotch doesn’t miss the way Prentiss furrows her brows as he checks his phone.
“Wait–” she says slowly, looking from Hotch to you, suspicion starting to form.
You: Sorry for going MIA! Just spent the last hour playing matchmaker so Lucy will stop drunk-dialling me every Friday. I’m leaving soon, should I cab to yours or are you still working?
Hotch’s thumb hovers over the screen. But before he can reply, Prentiss turns her attention back to Rossi. “What did you mean earlier about making Monday’s briefing awkward?”
When Hotch looks up, you’ve already spotted him, a confused smile pasted on your face. You murmur something to your friends, and start making your way over.
“Think you’re about to find out,” Rossi mutters, finishing off his bourbon.
When you stop at their table, your eyes remain fixed on one man. “Guess I won’t be needing that cab after all.”
The table goes silent.
“Oh. My God.” Garcia’s hand flies to her chest.
You look at Rossi next. “Hello, Dave.”
He gives you a smug nod. “Counsellor.”
“It’s nice to meet you all properly,” you beam at the blank faces surrounding Hotch. “Aaron speaks very highly of you.”
JJ is the first to find her voice. “You two… know each other?”
You glance at Hotch, struggling to fight a grin. “Do we know each other?” you echo, gazing at him expectantly. “Or are you still intending to keep me a secret?”
He looks like he’d quite like the Earth to open up beneath him.
Garcia, still wide-eyed, blurts, “Okay but—wait—what about the button-down guy?”
“Chris? Oh, god—no. He’s for my friend Lucy. Great guy. No priors, close with his mom—but not in a weird way—runs his own business, likes dogs, pays his taxes on time–”
“Wow,” Morgan mutters. “You ran a full background check at the bar.”
Prentiss leans forward, grinning now. “So how long has this been going on?” She points between the two of you.
You raise a brow at Hotch. “Hmm. Are we answering questions tonight?”
He clears his throat. “We should go.”
You sigh dramatically. “No questions tonight, I suppose. But I’d love to have you all over for dinner sometime.” You say it just as Hotch slides out of the booth and reaches for his jacket.
“Dinner?” Morgan repeats, still blinking. “At Hotch’s house?”
“No,” you say sweetly. “At my place. He doesn’t get hosting privileges until he stops putting files on the dining table.”
Hotch exhales. “That happened one time.”
“Three,” you correct.
Garica is already reaching for her phone. “Just let me know when and I’ll be there.”
“I’ll bring the wine,” Rossi adds.
“Perfect,” you smile. “It’s a date.”
Hotch shrugs into his jacket and gives the table a quick, borderline-grumpy goodbye. His hand settles at the small of your back as you pass your friends’—and Chris’s—table before you’re out the door. The second it swings shut behind you, the noise drops away, your senses narrowing to the faint smell of rain on asphalt and someone’s cheap cigarette break.
“It’s nice to see your grumpy self,” you say lightly.
“I’m not grumpy.”
“No,” you agree, stopping beside the car as he unlocks it and opens the passenger door for you. “Jealous is the better adjective, I think.” You slip inside, smoothing your jacket over your lap, Aaron waiting patiently as you settle in before closing the door.
You watch as he rounds the car and gets in. “You know, if you were jealous, you could just say so. We’re mature adults. Allegedly.”
He fastens his seatbelt, glances at you once. “Do all of your friends get the counsellor-approved vetting session?”
“Why? Any of your friends hoping to book one?”
He pulls out of the parking space, headlights sweeping across the wet asphalt. “You seemed pretty invested.”
“Wouldn’t be a counsellor-approved session if I wasn’t,” you reply and you know you’re pushing it, but you don’t get to see this side of Aaron often and it would be a crime to let it go unappreciated. Your smirk widens when you catch the way his hands tighten on the wheel, shadows shifting across his forearms.
“I didn’t get the chance to tell you what his business is,” you say casually, turning in your seat to face him more fully.
Hotch doesn’t look at you. “I don’t want to know.”
“He imports coffee beans,” you continue cheerfully anyway. “Ethically sourced. He said he could give me a discount.”
He turns on the indicator a little harder than necessary. “Good for him.”
“And he speaks Italian.”
“I’m aware you also speak Italian.”
“He lived in Florence for a year,” you add, just to watch his jaw tighten. “Did a lot of volunteering. Said it helped him find a piece of himself.”
“Do you know if he’s planning to return there?”
You grin. “Why? You want to buy his ticket?”
“If it means he stops telling you about soul-searching and espresso beans,” he mutters.
You hum, like you’re really thinking it over. “Well, if he and Lucy hit it off, he’ll probably end up at a lot of our dinner parties. Plus-ones and all that.”
“There’s no chance that’s happening.”
“Oh yeah? Says who? The man who’s not jealous?”
“I don’t like him talking to you like that.”
Your head turns. He’s still watching the road, but there’s a faint, irritated flush at the tips of his ears. “Sorry—what was that?”
He exhales. “I said, I didn’t like it.”
“Didn’t like…?”
“I was jealous,” he finally confesses.
For a second, all you can do is smile triumphantly. “See? That wasn’t so hard.”
“I want you to move in with me.”
Your smile freezes. “I–what?”
His eyes are still on the road, and it doesn’t help that he seems more focused on driving safely than looking at you. “Move in with me.”
“That’s…not the usual follow-up to a jealousy confession.”
He risks a glance at you. “Is that a no?”
“No! I just—Aaron, you can’t go from ‘I was jealous’ to ‘please relocate your entire life’ in the same breath.”
He shrugs, completely adamant. “I’ve been thinking about it for months. Tonight just made it clearer. I don’t want you going home to anyone else’s place but mine.”
You let out a breath, half incredulous, half fond. “Well, as entertaining as it’s been watching your neck veins pop from jealous denial, there was—and is—absolutely zero chance I’d be going home with Chris. Or anyone else but you. So if this is you proposing cohabitation out of territorial panic, you can take it back. I won’t be mad.”
“It’s not panic.”
“No?”
“No,” he repeats, quieter now. “You already spend most nights at my place. Your shampoo’s in my shower. Half your clothes are in my drawers. Jack asks when you’re coming over before he asks what’s for dinner. It’s not panic. It’s… time.”
You’re thrown off by how simple his answer is. “Oh.”
He glances at you again, longer this time. “Is that all you’re going to say?”
“Yes. And that… I suppose Morgan was right about us having dinner at your house.”
One corner of his mouth lifts. “So that’s a yes?”
“It’s a yes, Aaron,” you sigh, even though your heart is knocking against your ribs.
He finally exhales, like he’s been holding the air in his lungs since the bar. “Okay.”
“Okay,” you echo, shaking your head with an amused, disbelieving smile because of course this is how he’d do it. Only Aaron Hotchner could turn jealousy, existential panic and a left-hand turn into a moving-in proposal.
“What is it?”
“You know, most people plan these kinds of things. Maybe wait until dinner. Light a candle. Present a key in a box rather than—this.” You gesture vaguely between the two of you.
His fingers drum once against the steering wheel. “Keys can still come in a box.”
“And dinner?”
“I can order takeout.”
You let out a snort. “You are so incredibly lucky I’m in love with you that I'm going to let this slide. But in future, if you’re planning to spring any life-changing proposals on me, at least make sure I have a glass of expensive champagne and I’m not in a moving vehicle.”
“I will absolutely make a note of that.” He nods, hand coming to rest on your thigh. “For any future proposals,” he adds, continuing driving the both of you home.