“How else would you expect me to react, Charlotte?” Benji raised a brow at her. He could have handled this situation so much more maturely, but this was Benji after all….and he never handled situations maturely. As her eyes locked with his, Benji’s eyes narrowed slightly. She closed a bit of the space between them and Benji slowly closed the rest. Well, just until there was about a rulers length between them now. Again, as he stood so close to her, he realised just how much of a height gap there was between the both of them.
"So what? If you couldn’t be my wife, we couldn’t be together? Is that how things work with you? If there’s no certificate promising a lifetime together, I’m just….not worth it? I didn’t say that marriage was something I never wanted to do. I just wasn’t ready for it. We were young, Charlotte. We’re still young. If marriage was so important to you….then I’m glad that you’ve finally found someone who wants to give that to you.” his last words weren’t truthful, but they sure did sound like they were. Maybe because they’d come out of his mouth sounding so harsh. “I wasn’t terrified of marrying you. I was never terrified of doing anything with you. That year and a half we were together were some of the best memories I had. Now they’re all just painful to think about, but hey— that’s my fault right? It’s all my fucking fault because I’m the one with the committment issues. I’m the one that didn’t want to get married. I’m the one that couldn’t give you want you wanted.” he motioned his hand towards himself and then put a space between them again, not wanting to be close to her.
This had all been bottled up for so long. Benji wished that they’d had a chance to talk about things after their break up. To try and get things off their chests…..or maybe even resolve everything, but it had never happened. He’d cut her off from contacting him, and she’d moved back home. “I might have cut you off from contacting me, but I’m not the one who left the country. Even if I did contact you, was I just supposed to expect you to move all the way back over to New York for me?” he shook his head. “You could have waited. You could have fucking waited for me to be ready. We had a whole lifetime together. I didn’t want to rush anything. I wanted to just enjoy my life with you. I was happy with the way things were between us. Clearly you weren’t. You wanted more. You needed more.” he paused for a moment. “So what’s your new man like huh? Bet he’s going to fucking love watching this shit on TV. What does he do for a living? Is he a lot more put together with his life than I am? Is he less of a mess than I am? Does he make you happier than I ever could?”
“Um, maybe like an adult?” she retorted, tilting her head back to keep her gaze firm as he stepped closer, once again reminding her of how tall he actually was. Being this close to him normally would have given her butterflies but in this moment she was too angry to think about anything else.. even if he did still smell good.
“That wasn’t the case at all, and of course you were worth it. Jesus christ Benji you’ve always been worth it but I don’t understand why getting married was such a problem if you were so sure about how you felt about me, how you felt about us.” she replied, but his next words felt like a slap in the face. ‘I’m glad that you’ve finally found someone who wants to give that to you’
“You say that marriage in the future wasn’t off the table for us but at the same time everything you said, everything you’re saying tells me that you don’t want it at all. We’ve been through so much in the past, is it so wrong to want to have a day to celebrate us? A day that’s followed on by being legally recognised as each other’s partners? I have no idea when life is going to throw the next curveball at me, when something else is going to go wrong so I’m sorry but you can’t blame me for wanting to have some stability in my life.” shaking her head she glanced away for a moment, brushing the hair out of her face in frustration. “If you weren’t scared of marrying me then what were you scared of?” she asked, taking in the rest of his words but not commenting on them. It was well known by probably anyone who watched the show that commitment had always been a big thing between Benji and Charlotte.
“What was I supposed to do? Wait around for you to unblock me? Are you serious?” she almost scoffed. She had remembered the first time she noticed he had cut her off from social media, she had still been in New York and was going to reach out to him to apologise but after noticing she couldn’t contact him at all she had felt stupid. “I moved home so I could focus on my career, how was I supposed to know you even wanted anything to do with me when you had shut me out like that?” she asked, shaking her head again and rolling her lips inwards as he spoke, but as he started questioning her about her fiancé she looked back at him again quickly, her eyes narrowed. “Stop.” she warned him quietly as he continued to speak. His questions weren’t fair, and they definitely weren’t ones she could answer with cameras on them but they just kept coming and she knew now that he was heated up he wouldn’t stop, so she did the only thing she could think of to cool him down. Stepping forward again just as his last question was leaving his lips she shook her head, put her hands on his chest and gave him a shove back into the pool in an attempt to stop him from talking. There was no way she could have lied to him about anyone making her happier than he had, and she couldn’t admit that of course no one ever could without breaking the heart of the man back home in the worst way possible.