The olives unfurl their petals in December, on the brink of breaking into fruit. The sunset that draped across the sky seared into our bodies, the orange sinking into purple. I asked you with a lilt to my voice, "Do you have a favorite sunset, Yeshua?" You didn't take your eyes off the sky and answered, "In every sunset is its own pocket of beauty, Judas. There is no sunset to be branded as a favorite."
Perhaps that's where it all began.
You are a sheep branded for slaughter, your head destined for the knife right after you got out of the womb. Perhaps my hunger for you was my first sin against you. You could feed five thousand people but my own hunger you could never satisfy. I want your limbs, your spine, your ribs, your thighs—beneath me, above me, your weight against mine. You remind me to breathe every time because I forget to, because I believe breathing you in would have me swallowing you whole until there's nothing of you left to devour. I compete with all of the bigger mouths out there for you.
Out of all of these mouths, you've closed mine shut with a kiss.
Do you count all of the feet that you've washed with your own hands? I wonder about the bottomlessness of your heart; how there's enough room for every person in the world in it. I wonder where I stand in your heart—if I stand in it at all. "I love you, Judas." You always told me, when you can, your nose against my own. In my mind, I didn't believe it—the world comes before me. I wanted to ask you if you would look for me in a crowded room. I wanted to ask you if you'd recognize the sound of my voice amidst a million others. I wanted to ask you if you could be capable of knowing me not when the world falls silent, but when the world clamors into the most noise and all you can hear in your heart is my song.
I know the kiss I left on your cheek didn't burn your skin, not one bit. I know that the spit I left on your face in my dreams (or nightmares, perhaps) didn't sear the skin off of their hinges.
"And I forgive you, Judas."
"Do you remember when you asked me if I had a favorite sunset? I told you every sunset is its own pocket of beauty."
"That's the thing. You don't have to be for me to love you."
I was never your favorite, Yeshua.
At least let me bring this lie to the grave with me.