you act like you just saw a ghost.
âShit, youâve still got it bad, huh?â
Mason kept his focus on trying out different chord progressions to find the best fit for lyrics written last night in a notebook heâd left open in front of him on the coffee table. He hoped continuing to play his guitar would be taken as a hint he had, like, zero interest in discussing why he had such a sudden burst of inspiration when the band agreed to take a small hiatus to regroup after Jane left. They needed to decide how to move forward but Mason had remained quiet during most of those discussions, simply stating heâd continue to work on new songs no matter what everyone else wanted to do.
Spencer, however, had no issue with still showing up whenever theyâd normally meet for practice, even if heâd usually find Mason sitting on the couch instead of hanging in the garage where they used to rehearse. He liked to think of himself as the glue that kept the band in good social standing. How hopeless would the twins be without him? And Roderick? Forget it. He couldnât straight up abandon them, even if nobody felt up to playing shows any time soon.
The biggest upside to everyone thinking youâre the asshole of the group? Nobody gives you too much crap when youâre blunt âcause they totally expected it by now.
âDid you even get to hit that before she left?â
The music stopped then and Mason pulled the guitar in a little closer to his chest, like some kind of security blanket that could protect him from questions he didnât want to answer. ââŠWhat are you talking about?â
âHate to break it to you, bro, but Songs About Jane already got used by someone with a way better voice than you,â Spencer leaned back against the arm of the couch with his arms crossed. âBut itâs almost cute you havenât hooked up with anyone else when itâs been-â
âLike, two months,â Mason sighed. He knew the exact number of days it had been since Jane boarded a plane to Boston, but he hated the thought of anybody knowing that he had kept track of something that depressing. Why make himself seem more pathetic?
âYou two werenât secret dating or anything?â Spencer asked and Mason shook his head. âWell, thatâs what Iâd do,â he went on, glancing downward for a moment. âYour sister can be a little psycho about wanting to know all of our business and I donât think sheâd take it well if any of us jumped into a relationship.â
âSheâs not psycho,â Mason huffed, lazily strumming his fingers along the strings of his guitar just to give himself something to do. âMads just⊠likes to feel⊠I donât know⊠involved? Maybe she can be a little overbearing but I think itâs sweet she cares enough to want to protect all of  us.â
âEven when sheâs trying to protect you from Jane?â
If you knew the McCarthy twins at all, youâd realize pretty early on that Mason took Madisonâs side even when he disagreed with her. He supported his sister no matter what and he valued the bond they had more than anything in the world. He loved Madison, flaws be damned, and he always thought of her as the most important piece of his puzzle. For instance, if Madison had chosen to go to Boston, Mason wouldâve started an action plan to make it possible for him to be there, too.
Hell, they never stopped sharing a room even when their parents found a bigger house the summer before fourth grade. Every year, their mom or dad would ask if they thought theyâd finally reached an age where they wanted to be separated, but they both hated the idea of sleeping in different rooms, especially if it meant letting go of all their late night conversations about how they couldnât wait to be out on the road someday.
Mason told Madison everything. Thatâs just how they worked. Or at least thatâs how it used to be. See, he couldnât tell Madison the finer details of how he felt about Jane or what he had done with Jane. NO WAY, JOSE! He once admitted he considered Jane the prettiest girl in the school during a game of Truth or Date and, holy moly, Madison never let him live it down that he hadnât said her, as if any teenage boy should respond to that question with his sisterâs name.
It felt awful not to fully trust Madison with something as big as falling for a girl, but he cared so much about Jane that it scared him to imagine anybody trying to talk him out of that feeling. Madison wouldâve been the sensible one to tell him it could rip the band apart. Or she wouldâve pointed out that you can expect to tie down a girl as strong and independent as Jane. Or she wouldâve simply thrown a fit about Mason putting his energy into trying to win over a girl when he should be focused on their inevitable rise to fame.
Whatever the reason, Mason had never really told Madison the extent of his feelings for Jane, and he had never really talked about much of what had happened between them. Even so, he assumed Madison had an idea. She probably used her twin telepathy to figure it out and then added Broke Masonâs Heart to her list of reasons to be angry with Jane for leaving, letâs be real.
âYou not saying anything kind of proves the point I wanted to make.â Spencer reached over to take the guitar from Masonâs lap and propped it up against the couch to force his friend into actually engaging in conversation without a distraction. âMadisonâs amazing, we all know that, but you canât let her run your whole life, especially when it comes to you wanting somebody as much as you want Jane.â
Mason shifted uncomfortably and slowly drummed his hands on his knees. âItâs not⊠Sheâs not the reason we didnât work out,â he admitted, wetting his lips anxiously and lifting his shoulder sheepishly. âI couldâve asked Jane out so many times and I couldâve done something to make her want to stay, but I couldnât be the guy who made her feel like she needed to stay when she deserved to go.â
âSo youâre telling me you were actually trying to be fuckinâ noble instead of a total pussy?â
His nose wrinkled and he fought the urge to gag. ââŠI donât think Iâd put it that way.â
Spencer mulled this over for a moment and then punched Masonâs forearm. âAlright, well, I think thatâs bullshit and you just wussed out and now itâs too late but whatever you wanna believe, dude.â
Deep down, Mason knew that Spencerâs version of events had a lot more truth to it than his. Of course he never wanted to stand in the way of Jane achieving whatever the future held for her, but he had also kept his mouth shut because he had been too scared of rejection or what could happen to their friendship if they somehow failed as a real couple. He had never really dated anybody back then, so he felt like the odds of staying with his middle school crush forever probably didnât lean in his favor.
But it was hard to be around Jane now and not feel like some small bit of hope existed that they could work it out. She had dated some other guy, right? And he had, you know, tried to make a relationship or two work in the past couple years. Maybe now that they were older they could finally learn how to fit together the right way.
âI think the best selfies managed to squish in a second person,â he nodded, smiling at the memory of that old travel book filled with their ridiculous plans for places to stop while they drove across the country. It had been filled with Post-It notes and theyâd highlighted the most exciting facts. Mason had even doodled in the margins of a few pages. âWe can definitely make it through some of the old checklist. For sure.â
Mason never wouldâve guessed that Go Wildcats! would get their first big break without Jane being a part of the band, but he felt lucky that she still got to be a part of that experience, even if she wasnât technically in their little circle anymore. He hoped that everybody could get along enough for the two bands to build a brand new bigger family, but he wasnât about to hold his breath when it came to Madison cooperating with that dream.
He didnât want to rain on Janeâs parade though. âItâll be amazing and weâll get to do so much together and, yeah, Iâm just⊠so glad this is happening,â he rambled, glancing toward the door and letting out a sigh of relief that Madison didnât somehow know that should be her cue to storm out ready for an argument about why exactly Jane had no right to be acting all chummy with Mason.
Time had gone by and they had lost track of each other at some point but Jane still seemed the same in too many ways for Mason to really feel as if they had truly grown apart. She still loved vinyl and milkshakes and that meant he still longed to be the only boy who kissed her underneath the stars of cities he barely knew. Â
âWait, are you saying Iâm too cheesy to know whatâs cheesy?â He tried his best to seem offended but his narrowed eyes and frown only lasted so long before his face brightened up into a playful grin. âI will gladly accept that being my biggest problem as long as you donât use that as an excuse to keep me from record hunting and sharing shakes with you. Thatâs way too high on my bucket list for me to get shut down before we even get started.â Â
âCan I ask you a question? Like⊠girl to girl, or whatever?â
Jane looked up from her guitar, shooting Tina a curious look with furrowed eyebrows.  She sat back a little against the mountain of pillows behind her on her bed.  âIs this about, like⊠something that Iâm really not going to want to discuss?â
Tina looked confused for a moment before her cheeks were flushing and her eyes were widening. Â âGod, no, Iâm not asking you a sex question,â she said quickly, tone somewhat exasperated that Jane would bring that up in the first place, as if she hadnât been the one to say girl to girl in the first place.
âI was just clarifying,â Jane pointed out, giving her a look for a moment before she was smirking a little to herself and shaking her head. Â âAnyways, you were saying something about a girl-to-girl question?â
Tina took a seat next to her, tapping her finger on the open notebook sitting by Janeâs knee, a pen sitting on top.  âItâs about your songs, more than anything.  Like⊠the inspiration behind them, I guess.â
Jane stiffened for only a moment, shooting Tina a slightly perplexed look. Â âYou know that I was going out with that Robbie guy, andââ
âNot those ones,â Tina was quick to cut her off.  âI meant the, like⊠the nice ones, I guess.  I mean, there has to be a story there, right?â
Yeah. Â There was totally a story there. Â A story about a boy who was the human equivalent of Gumby, who had a head of curly hair a big, bright smile that always made Jane weak in the knees. Â A story about a boy who Jane never should have walked away from, but did, because maybe she was just sort of selfish sometimes.
âI think everyone from every song has a story, Tee.â
âYou are being annoyingly vague,â Tina countered, shooting her a glare for a moment and shaking her head at her. Â âAre you going to actually engage in any sort of details or do I just need to play connect the dots on my own and figure it out from there?â
âItâs just⊠a guy I went to high school with,â she said with a shrug, and clearly that wasnât enough to make Tina any more convinced, if the look that she was sending Jane right then and there was of any indication.  Jane rolled her eyes, shooting her a pointed look and lifting her shoulders into a shrug. âHis name is Mason,â she said, and she didnât really remember the last time that sheâd said his name out loud.  âWe were in the band together before⊠everything, I guess.â
âYou were dating a dude in the band?â Tinaâs voice raised a couple pitches and she leaned forward, as if that was the one hook that had finally suckered her into this conversation once and for all. Â âHow did I not know this?!â
âWe werenât dating,â Jane was quick to argue.  âWe justâŠâ she fell quiet a second later, because even if sheâd known Tina for well over a year and even if The Other Sister had started to have a relatively decent following among the YouTube and hipster blogger crowd, that didnât really mean that she was at that level with Tina.  She didnât know if she was at the level with Tina, or with any of the girls, really, where she wanted to talk about Mason.
The Go Wildcats! chapter of Janeâs life was a chapter of Janeâs life that was personal to just her. It was hers. Â She didnât want to share that with everyone else â she didnât want to share them with everyone else, because they were her friends, and they were their stories.
Maybe it was stupid. It was probably really stupid, actually. Very, very stupid. Â But that as the way she felt. Â She wanted something to hold onto, and something that she didnât have to talk about.
âItâs a long story,â she finally said with a shrug. Â âComplicated, or whatever.â
âDo you guys still talk?â
âYeah,â she said, but she wasnât really sure if a few text messages back and forth and a couple phone calls at two in the morning could really account for much.  âYeah, heâs great.  Heâs⊠youâd really like him.  I mean, everyone who meets him loves him.  Heâs Mason.â
Not everyone loved Mason like Jane loved Mason, though. That was the kicker. Â That was the thing.
After Jane bored Tina enough with her simple and short-winded answers, Jane found herself grabbing her phone from where it sat beside her, and going right to Masonâs number. Before she had the chance to talk herself out of it, she pressed Call, and brought the phone to her ear.
It rang once, twice, three times. Â She was holding her breath all the way up until the sixth and final ring, when Masonâs peppy voice came through the other end in the form of an outgoing message followed by a beep.
She had half a mind to hang up, to lose her nerve right then and there and just hang up. Â But sheâd already called, and sheâd already let the phone call go into the actual leave a message part of the process, and that meant that Mason was going to have to check his voicemail at this point anyway, even if just to hear the sound of her hanging up.
He already would know that she had called, because it would show up as a missed call. Â There wasnât any way that she could really get herself out of the situation at this point. Â So she might as well just roll with it.
âMase, hey,â Jane finally spoke up with heart hammering in her chest.  âI, uh⊠I kept trying to come up with some reason to have to call you while the phone was ringing, and I didnât really come up with anything.  But I just wanted to say hi, I guess.  I miss your voice.  And you, in general.  Youâre a very easy person to miss, Mason McCarthy.â  She bit down on her lip, swallowing hard and trying to blink fast before any tears could decide to grace her eyes with their presence.  âAnd now that Iâve filled my pathetic quota for the day, I guess Iâll let you go.  Call me later?â
Even right now, even standing in front of him, talking to him, looking at him right now⊠she still missed him.  Did that make sense?  That seemed like it shouldnât make a lick of sense.  But she did.  She still missed him.  Because even if he was here with her right now, even if they were standing across from each other and about to spend the next few months together at all times, she still missed him.  Because they were together in the physically together sense.  But that was it.  That was the only way they were together right now.
And that hurt more than she really cared to admit.
Here he was, talking about that old scrapbook theyâd made what seemed like a different lifetime ago, and all the plans theyâd made for when Go Wildcats! finally got to go on tour. That was the way that it should have been, really, and Jane⊠Jane screwed that up.  Jane wished she could stop thinking about how much she screwed that up.
It wasnât that she regretted her success. Â It wasnât anything like that. Â It was more that none of it really seemed like the way that it was supposed to happen. Â She was so, so happy, but that didnât necessarily mean that it felt right. None of it did. Â It didnât feel like it was the way that it was supposed to be.
âMy selfie would be honored to be mixed with your selfie,â she said with a slightly timid smile, as if that was a sentence that actually made any sort of sense. Â âAnd I actually brought the book with me,â she added on a beat or two later, nodding her head back at him. Â âI didnât realize I still had it with me until I was unpacking and saw it there. Â But I figured if anything deserved to go on tour, it was the book.â
Something about hearing Mason say how excited he was for everything just sort of made Jane hurt even more than she already did, but she still nodded her head back at him and shot him her biggest and brightest smile. Â âMaybe itâs not the way we really planned it or anything, but I think itâs still going to be enough to knock our socks off.â
A moment later, at the mention of vinyl shopping and milkshake sharing, her face lit up like a kidâs on Christmas morning. Â âThat reminds me,â she nearly blurted out in a tumble all at once, âIâve been compiling a list of the last standing legit soda shops in America and the best record stores. Â So you and me are going to make it our mission to hit up every last one of âem. The bucket list sort of demands it, you know?â
She was glad that he still remembered that, that he still thought about that.  That he still wanted to do all of these things with her. Despite everything and even with everything that had happened between them, this remained the same.  And that meantâŠa lot.
Jane stepped forward without even thinking about it, and her arms were locking around him like that was exactly where theyâd belonged all along, holding him in close and not moving to let go. Â Her heart was beating out a lullaby against her chest, and her eyes squeezed closed as the two of them swayed back and forth. Â âIâm really, really happy to see you.â














