Summary: Jacob Hill isn't someone Melissa Schemmenti could ever forget.
Jacob Hill has always been someone who intrigued Melissa Schemmenti, whether she wants to admit it or not.
"I love Jacob, I do. But you know what? He's a lot like paint fumes. Like, small doses, fine, even somewhat enjoyable. But too much just gives you a headache,” Melissa states in an interview for the camera. And when she utters those words, she means them.
After watching Jacob Hill live his life the way he did for the past three years, he is something of an enigma to the second grader teacher. An enigma that she perhaps doesn’t want to get too close with, but an enigma nonetheless- a somebody that no matter what happened in this life, she isn’t sure she would be able to forget about him and his quirks.
She finds herself studying him over the years. Finds that Jacob was a lot more than this... character he seemed to put on whenever the cameras were around. It’s in small ways- the way that he makes his coffee quietly when the cameras aren’t around. It’s something in the way that he can actually maneuver through the staff lounge silently if there isn’t a lens on him. Sometimes, even his facial expressions are less broadway and more... human. And over time, she realizes that the quirky middle grades teacher upstairs that somehow managed to worm his way into the lower grades friend group has much more going on in his mind and being than he ever shows to the cameras.
So, when Melissa is looking for a roommate, and Jacob just so happens to be the “Lester” that she’s agreed on letting move in? The redhead can’t say she’s thrilled, but she also can’t say that she isn’t a bit interested to see how Jacob is outside of school.
The now landlord can’t help but laugh to the cameras and to herself when she watches Jacob struggle to bring in box after box of things. Hadn’t he seen the posting? It was a ‘cozy guest room’- certainly not a room where he could fill it with all of his belongings.
“Ooh, you need help?” the redhead asks sarcastically. He’s been coming in and out for the last hour or so with bins and boxes.
Jacob is struggling with the door when he stutters out, “No thank you. This is- this is the last of them.”
He misses the way that Melissa glances at the camera and affirms that she is well aware of this fact.
“So, that looks heavy, huh?” the redhead can’t help but tease. It’s clear to her that her new tenant isn’t picking up on the tone at the moment, more focused on getting the last of his things to his room.
“Listen, so I made puttanesca, but I only know how to cook for twelve. So, if you want some, I’ll make you a plate. But let me know in the next five minutes ‘cause my show’s comin’ on.” Does she really want to share what she could have as leftovers for days? No. But... she didn’t help him move the boxes. She couldn’t, really. Not with her knee and the way it’s been acting up, not that Jacob knows that. But there’s that little guilty feeling gnawing at her, so Melissa offers the plate of food.
The middle school teacher abruptly turns to put his box on the counter. “Oh! Real housewives of New Jersey is also on in five, and I simply must watch it live.”
Melissa practically throws down the cheese she’s grating. “Okay, that’s my show.”
“No,” Jacob gasps in disbelief.
And somehow, that tiny little similarity sparks something between the two teachers.
It’s long after their show is over, that they’re still eating popcorn coated in sour cream and onion flavoring while a new show that neither of them are really paying attention to, when Melissa breaks their somewhat comfortable silence.
“So, you know you can’t keep all that shit in my house,” she states.
Jacob lets out somewhat of a snort. “Trust me, I know. I can barely walk in that room. It’s just until I can take it all down to a storage unit.”
“Why do you have so much shit to begin with?”
“Somehow, even though I truly am a minimalist when it comes to living, I ended up with almost everything from the apartment in the breakup. Zach said something about how he needed to shed everything from the past. And I know you think I’m naive, but I’m not stupid enough to just throw it away.”
“I never said you was naive.”
“I know that’s how you think of me,” Jacob mumbles as he sinks into the cushions a bit further. “It’s all there just until I can take it down to a storage unit to sort through. Probably going to sell most of it.”
When Jacob does find a storage unit to take the remnants of his past relationship to, Melissa may not help him load everything and unload everything. Her knee really is acting up, not that he knows. But she is there to offer to drive the uHaul he rents so he can take some of the smaller bins in his car.
“Make less trips,” the redhead shrugs. “You know?”
Jacob gives her one of his lopsided grins. “Thanks, Mel.”
“Don’t mention it, kid,” Melissa rolls her eyes fondly. Then she points an accusatory finger at him. “Seriously, don’t mention it at work. I need to maintain my badass reputation, and helpin’ you’ll only show I’m gettin’ soft in my old age.”
“You’re not old,” Jacob refutes part of her statement. He does not refute the fact that she’s getting softer as she ages. He remembers being terrified of the elementary teacher when he first started at Abbott, and now he’s living with her.
Over time, Melissa and Jacob’s friendship only continues to grow. Jacob becomes a normal figure in the kitchen. He becomes something of a companion to Melissa- having dinners with her, settling down on the couch to have a glass of wine with and watch their shows. He’s even introduced her to a few shows that the two now watch religiously. Melissa finds that she doesn’t find him to be as much like paint fumes anymore- he’s dried paint that has just become a part of her everyday now. She won’t be able to forget about him now, even if and when he does move out. He’s made his mark on this house.
It’s about a year after Jacob’s moved in with Melissa that the holiday season rolls around. Halloween at Abbott is chaotic as ever, and the holiday is only more vamped up in South Philly. They go out to their favorite bar for a costume contest, and it’s only when Melissa is convinced for the second time that she lost Sweet Cheeks does Jacob know he has to attempt to get the woman home.
“Oh, c’mon,” Melissa groans. She attempts to do another apple shot with Barb, who is so far gone that Jacob has already taken it upon himself to call Gerald. Maybe once he gets here, the two can corral their... their people out of here.
The next day, the second grade teacher is beyond hungover. Jacob is there to take care of her. And when they have to hand out candy to the children who come trick or treating, the two are more than content to sit out on the porch and hand out candy while laughing over their own shared bowl of sour cream and onion flavored popcorn.
Thanksgiving comes and goes- Jacob going to spend his time with Janine and Gregory, and Melissa being forced over to Kristen Marie’s. It’s when the two reunite that the chaos that seemed to consume them for the day dies down.
“Oh, it was... fine,” Jacob says quietly as he settles on the couch with a glass of red. “How was your Thanksgiving?”
“Never a Schemmenti family dinner without some sort of drama,” the redhead laughs as she lowers herself to the cushions. “Kristen Marie tried to beat the hell outta me, so I’m gonna bet that I’ll be sore for the next few days.”
She is. Jacob is always there with an extra cushion to prop her leg up on or to offer her an ice pack.
“Thanks, kid,” Melissa will grumble out, although she has to admit that it’s nice to be helped. “I- I’m thankful for you. Today, and... most days.”
As soon as December hits, Christmas mode is in full swing. The Schemmenti house is decorated in a way that it feels like Jacob is back to his parents’ house up in Albany. But instead of yelling... well, there’s still yelling. He lives with Melissa Schemmenti; of course it’s going to be loud. But as opposed to the yelling that he didn’t want to hear and would actively avoid, he finds himself being drawn to it. A shout to bring up the bulk container of spices. A yell to grab the baking sheets from the basement. A loud, “Jake, the garland fell again, and I can’t reach it!” It’s something entirely different. Of course, there’s stress... the redhead has finally been put back into the dinner rotation, but it’s a stress that reminds him of what Christmas should actually feel like. Stress over if there’s enough room to fit the right amount of seats for everybody, are there enough plates? Did she buy enough carrots? The cookies have to be baked to perfection. And Jacob is there every step of the way. It’s... familial, and nothing like anything he’s ever had before. Does he think of Melissa as family? Maybe.
He doesn’t really have a plan for Christmas. He would hate to have to crash on Janine and Gregory’s plans again. He wonders if Melissa will allow him to stay in the house for the holiday.
Caleb ends up coming down from Albany for the holiday, and he somehow gets an invitation to Schemmenti Christmas dinner, but Jacob is still on the waitlist. Now this feels like what he’s used to. He was used until something, or someone (Caleb, always Caleb), comes along- just like when he was little. Melissa reminds him a bit too much of his own parents at that moment.
Jacob ends up worming his way into family dinner- and at this point, he feels like maybe he should’ve just gone to Janine’s. He hates hearing and seeing the way Melissa’s family treats her. It reminds him of his own family. Two black sheep, they are.
It’s clear to him how much the second grade teacher needs her family’s approval though, so he and his brother vow to do everything that they can to try to keep this family dinner afloat.
And then everything with Uncle Archie happens. And then Captain Rob shows up. And then Seamus happens.
But eventually, it’s just Jacob and Melissa in the living room. Caleb decided to turn in early for the night- he has to drive back to Albany tomorrow. So, the two roommates wind down as they usually do.
“So, it’s normally that chaotic?” Jacob asks, trying to ease the slight tension in the room.
Melissa snorts. “Chaotic? Yes. That level of chaotic and thinking Uncle Archie died? No.”
The man’s lips quirk upwards. “I- I know that my opinion doesn’t matter to you, but I think you did a great job hosting family dinner.”
Green eyes land on Jacob, his eyes cast downward and unsure of his words. “I care more about your opinion than you think I do, you know.”
Melissa nods. “I do. And I also don’t think I could’ve done it without you, or that stunad you have for a brother. So... thank you.”
“Anything for you, Mel,” Jacob says quietly, and he knows he means it.
The two sit in their peace and quiet for quite some time, finishing off their glasses of wine slowly and taking in the serenity of the house. It’s no longer full of Schemmentis, but instead, there’s one Schemmenti, and a Hill, and it... it seems right that the two end the night sitting together. Jacob ends up falling asleep on the couch in an upright position, his head just drooping down to rest gently on Melissa’s shoulder.
“Jake, I think it’s time we hit the hay.”
The man jumps a bit at the disturbance, but his eyes slowly begin to close again.
“Oi, you might be able to sleep on the couch, but I sure as hell can’t,” the second grade teacher grumbles.
Jacob makes no moves, so the redhead gently maneuvers him so that he’s laying down, and then she pulls the afghan from the back of the couch and drapes it over him.
“Merry Christmas, Jake,” the woman sighs softly as she stands up right.
Jacob, mostly asleep at this point, mumbles, “Merry Christmas, Mel. Love you.”
Melissa stops in her tracks, and she turns around slowly to look at her roommate. He’s clearly asleep. That doesn’t stop her from responding back just as quietly, “Yeah, kid. I love you too.” And then she heads up the steps for the night.
It’s then that she realizes that maybe... just maybe, she sees Jacob as more than just a roommate. More than just a friend. Family. Melissa wouldn’t forget about that feeling that struck her deep. Jacob wouldn’t ever forget about the first Schemmenti family dinner he was privy to.
Abbott’s in good graces with the district for the first time in a long time. The school might actually get the funding that they deserve and need.
And then Ava essentially tells the staff that’s come along to the meeting that they can
ask for pretty much anything, and they’ll get it. They’re planning on asking for a billion things. The kids deserve everything and more after years of getting a whole lot of nothing.
“Do you think I could give the presentation for you?” Jacob asks Ava. She allows him to; she’s letting him have face time with the district.
Instead of asking for what they had all agreed on, the middle grades teacher goes and throws a wrench in it all. He asks for a counselor, which is actually a great ask. But they hadn’t spoken about it before, and that’s all he requests. He states that they don’t need anything else.
“Oh no,” Melissa groans as she covers her eyes with her hands. “Ava’s gonna kill him. I can’t look. I can’t look.”
“Oh, you have love for the boy,” Barbara smiles.
The redhead groans. “I have love for the rent he pays me, Barb.”
That’s a lie. Jacob rarely pays rent anymore. Melissa simply doesn’t cash the checks Jacob hands her on the first of the month anymore. And the middle grades teacher is fully aware of this. What Melissa doesn’t know is that Barbara Howard is also aware of this fact.
“Melissa?” Jacob had called down the steps one day.
“What do you want?” the redhead bellowed. “I’m cookin’ us dinner!”
The man made his way down the steps with a confused look on his face. “Did you forget to cash the check I gave you for rent this month? I was checking over my budgeting for this month, and-”
“You paid for groceries a few times,” the second grade teacher half shrugged as she continued to stir the sauce on the stove. “An’ you helped me out when my knee was given’ me trouble. I figured we could call it even.”
“That- that’s not nearly enough,” Jacob stammered out.
Green eyes were rolling at that moment. “I’m tryin’ t’cut you some slack. Take it, Jake.”
Jacob’s lips formed into a tight line, but there was a ghost of a smile there. He knew he was going to struggle that month, but with Melissa’s generosity, he would be okay.
“Thank you,” is all he said.
“Yeah, whatever, kid. Dinner’ll be ready in about twenty, so just... set the table for me?”
That was only the first month the tough woman let his check go uncashed. After the third month of asking why she hadn’t taken his money, and he was given some half-assed excuse, Jacob confided in Janine.
“She- she won’t cash my check!”
“This is the third month in a row,” Jacob had muttered to his colleague. “I- I don’t really know what to do.”
“You take it,” is Janine’s answer. “If she’s feeling generous, do not question it.”
“I guess,” Jacob sighed. “I just... I don’t want her to be strapped for money at my expense.”
“Melissa has ways of making money if she needs to,” the shorter second grade teacher reminded him. “If you buying groceries and helping her out around the house makes it up to her-”
“I’ve been helping her since I found out her knee’s been acting up,” Jacob countered.
“Still,” Janine continued on. “I say take that and run. It’s saving you money, you get great food every night, and Melissa Schemmenti isn’t constantly threatening your ass anymore.”
“She never threatened my ass to begin with.”
“Maybe not to your face.”
With the intel that Janine had, she just so happened to mention it to Barbara when the two were out to lunch one day. It had actually come up naturally. The kindergarten teacher had asked if Jacob had mentioned how it was living with the feisty redhead, and Janine supplied the information.
Barbara kept that information to herself, knowing that Melissa would never want to be approached about actually caring for the boy that she had living with her.
So, when Melissa tells her work wife that she loves the rent Jacob pays her, Barbara doesn’t say a thing. Instead, the kindergarten teacher simply smiles to herself. The camera picks it up. Melissa loves that boy.
When the end of the school year comes, it’s... it’s a nice change of pace. The chaos of having a field trip on one of the last days of the school year always comes with a layer of complexity that makes each teacher question their sanity. The surprise of the eighth grade class writing them a play only added to the insanity. It was a sweet gesture, yes, but it was a lot.
Having to play Jacob was a lot. Melissa has seen sides of him that he shows nobody else. If the redhead were to bet, Jacob wouldn’t even know that he was showing Melissa those sides of himself- she’s picked up on a lot though living with him. Of course, she only plays up the quirky sides of the history teacher, not exposing his other sides.
The last day of school is just as chaotic as ever. Jacob brings doughnuts to work as a sign of appreciation for the staff. Nobody gets a chance to eat them, all of them trying to get their things together and rush out so Summer can start as quickly as possible.
All of the teachers go their separate ways for the summer, but Jacob sits in his classroom and waits for his... Melissa to swing by to let him know they’re about ready to leave. He sits for longer than anticipated. Eventually, he just makes his way down to Melissa’s classroom to wait.
The second grade teacher finds herself being half-pushed into the principal’s office.
“I’m gonna need you to move grades,” Ava tells Melissa.
Melissa furrows a brow, but nods. “Sure. To third grade, so I can loop with these guys, yeah?”
The principal takes a deep breath. “Middle school. Math, specifically.”
“Zero problem whatsoever,” the redhead states confidently. “Bring it on. Those kids are ‘bout to get a lesson in learnin’ lessons, an’ you can quote me on that.”
“Sounds good. You need help, or whatever,” Ava starts as she begins to file her nails. “Ask Gregory, or somethin’.”
Those green eyes are rolled, and Melissa can’t help the chuckle that escapes her lips. “Have a good summer, Ava.”
The now middle grades teacher leaves the office with a grounding breath, and then plasters a smile on her face as she enters her room to gather the last of her things. Jacob is there, sitting on top of one of the student desks, with his things.
“Was beginning to think you forgot about me,” he quips as he continues to scroll through his various social media accounts.
“Like I could forget about you,” Melissa rolls her eyes as she grabs her bag.
The man hops off the desk with a smirk. “You’ve forgotten about me plenty of times before.”
“I was late to work three times just last week because you forgot we carpool.”
“So was our boss. Again, I’ll say: I don’t forget about you when it matters.”
The two roommates spend a lot more time together during Summer break than either had really anticipated. Jacob even went down to Wildwood with Melissa for a weekend to soak up some sun and feel the sand between his feet.
Almost every night without fail, the two would wind down their nights together. Sure, there were a few times where they were just two passing ships in the night, but they finished their days with each other for the most part.
So during development week when it was announced that Melissa was transferring to teach the older students at Abbott, Jacob would be lying if he said he wasn’t hurt about not hearing the information from the redheaded woman herself.
When Melissa states that everybody at Abbott knew everything they would need to know about her, Jacob smiles to himself. He knows everything and more- he lives with her afterall. And when she states that she might smack you in the mouth, again, the history teacher has to smile to himself. Melissa Schemmenti would never smack him in the mouth. If she hadn’t yet, she would never. But then that little cloud looms over his head. Why hadn’t Melissa told him that she was switching from second grade to middle school?
“Middle schoolers, huh?” Jacob tries to approach the elephant in the room casually. “Suprised you didn’t mention it all summer, since, you know, I teach middle school. And well, we live together, so we see each other everyday.”
The redhead just shrugs off his prying and tries to laugh it off.
So when Jacob and Morton begin to test her, the history teacher doesn’t hold back. Maybe he would’ve held back a bit more if his feelings weren’t so hurt. His actions terrify the former second grade teacher. Absolutely terrify her to the point that she finally has to choke down her pride and approach Ava about it.
She doesn’t get out of it. The principal uses her own words against her and tells her there’s no going back.
The two who had heckled Melissa earlier come around to her again, giving her hope that they were just being hard on her, but they only tell her that it might be that rough- even more so. If she’s being honest, she wants to smack Jacob in the mouth. She won’t.
As soon as the bell rings to dismiss the teachers, the two that live in the Schemmenti house climb into the red vehicle that brought them to the school. The car ride home is quiet, both occupants too wrapped up in their own thoughts to converse.
While Melissa and Jacob continue on with their days the way they usually would, it’s stilted. Neither says too much.
“Well,” Jacob sighs once dinner is cleaned up. “I think I’m gonna hit the hay a bit early tonight. You know... first week’s draining and everything.”
Green eyes look at him sadly. “You ain’t gonna have a glass of wine with me like we usually do?”
“I just-” the history teacher can see how badly his roommate wants him to be with her, so he relents. “One glass, and then I really will go to bed. Today was exhausting chasing after Mr. Johnson on that bike.”
Melissa gives a weak smile, one that makes the corners around her eyes wrinkle just slightly. “I believe it.”
The two settle in on the couch with their glasses, but neither really know what to say still. There are so many things they could be talking about, and for the first time in a long time, they don’t know what to say.
It’s Jacob who finally breaks the silence after he downs his first glass and pours a second. He takes a significant sip of that before opening his mouth. “Do you remember when you told me that you don’t forget about me when it matters?”
Melissa turns to look at him with a raised brow. She too downs her glass and reaches for the bottle. If this is how the conversation is going to start, she’s going to need a drink in her system. “And I meant it.”
“So...” Jacob drawls out. “Does that mean that you just... chose to keep the fact that you were switching to middle school from me? O- or did you forget about me?” The man hates the way his voice comes out so small, so... so much like how it used to when he walked on eggshells with his parents.
The redhead inhales deeply, pressing her thumb and forefinger to the bridge of her nose and pinching just slightly. “Jake.”
He doesn’t say anything. Doesn’t look in her direction. His eyes focus on the glass in front of him as he swirls the wine. He doesn’t even notice that she moves closer to him until she’s wrapping an arm around his shoulders.
“I didn’t forget to tell you, and I wasn’t keepin’ it from you to keep it from you,” Melissa sighs softly. “I was keepin’ it to myself because... because I was terrified. Still am, if I’m bein’ honest with you.”
The history teacher finally manages to look at his roommate. “Oh.” Then an immense amount of guilt washes over him as he remembers all of the things he had said and done to scare the redhead. “I- I thought you just forgot about me.”
“Kid, I don’t forget about the ones I love,” Melissa smiles over at him. “And I don’t think I could ever forget about you... no matter how much I might try.” She says that last part with a smirk and a gentle nudge.
“I love you too, Mel,” Jacob smiles.
Green eyes sparkle again. “So, please tell me you and Morton were just bustin’ my balls.”
The man laughs a cynical laugh as he allows himself to relax into Melissa’s arm. “Partly. But also... the kids can be real brutal. Don’t worry though; I’ll never forget about you.”
“I’m holding you to that.”
The two finish their wine together before collectively deciding that they need to get a good night’s sleep if they’re going to survive day two of development week.
Melissa hip checks her roommate as they begin to ascend up the steps.
“Just so you know,” the redhead smiles softly, and she reaches out a hand to squeeze Jacob’s shoulder gently. “I could never forget about you. Don’t want to either.”
The man returns a smile, clearly touched by the sentiment. “I know.”
TAGS: @schemmentis @thesapphictimelady @marvel210 @itisdoctortoyousir @sweetcheeksschemmenti @megamultifandomtrashposts @lemz378 @http-sam @melissaschemmentisbranzino @imaginesmultifandoms @sexysapphicshopowner @lilfartbox1 @maybe-a-humanbean @imlike-so-gaydude @a-queen-and-her-throne @notinmyvocab @melanielaufeyson @dvrkhcld @cosmichymns @sasheemo @m1lflov3rrr @ricejucie @temilyrights @emilynissangtr @squinnchy @emeraldoceansstuff @shinyfaerielights @blkmxrvel @marvelwomenrule @casualfoxwitch @babytakeittothehead @schemmentits @eliscannotdance @m6niacs @fragile-angell @infernumlilith @milfjuulpod @alwaysgoodnight @jeridandridge