To Justice Moore: why did you feel that it was unnecessary to discuss this idea with anyone? Since you are working under the hand of God, wouldn’t you think that He would give you the ability to persuade them to join you, or persuade them Himself through His own means? I don’t doubt your motives, but it certainly could have gone better for you had you mentioned your plans to someone before you enacted them. The sculpture could even still be there today, and you might have never been suspended. If this is something you truly believed in, you should not have done it so carelessly.
To Moore’s supporters: while half of the Ten Commandments are excellent values by which to live, half of them are also dedicated specifically to one group’s idea of God. While I don’t doubt the existence of God, I have great doubt in the existence of one belief system that works for every one of His children. Shouldn’t there be other displays of scripture, such as at the U.S. Supreme Court, instead of one gigantic 5,200 pound rock displaying only the beliefs of Christians and Jews? The Bible is a wonderful resource to many people of the world, but so are the Koran, the Torah, the Book of Mormon, and an incredible number of other holy texts.
To the civil liberties groups: has any society or civilization ever truly and absolutely separated church and state? The answer is no because that is an impossibility. Every law regarding ethical and moral responsibility either comes from, or has influenced, or at the very least has some relation to some religious belief. The display itself is merely a code of laws by which a certain group of people live. An artistic representation of a code of laws has every right to be in a place where people determine whether or not someone is breaking our code of laws. Is your argument that because this sculpture of laws also happens to have religious connotations, it should not be allowed in a public place where law is practiced? Well then we might as well rewrite our entire code of law also so that it has no religious underpinnings. Good luck with that; I’m moving somewhere where there is actually text in the lawbooks.