A Lesson in Gift Giving
What would Theodore Nott want for his birthday?
a/n: hi! this isn't the next chapter of my story, but I wanted to take a little break to write a quick oneshot, so here it is! I'm also open to requests for my fics so feel free to ask, enjoy!
word count: 2.4k
Theodore Nott is an enigma. A mystery you're slowly unraveling, and you really mean it when you say slowly. Dating him for the past four months has given you a glimpse into his mind, though it's definitely not enough for you to feel confident in choosing a birthday gift for him on your own. His birthday. You know he's not particularly enthusiastic about celebrations, especially those concerning him. He wouldn't bat an eye if the day passed without a peep from anyone, but you believe he deserves some fuss over his birthday, even if it's just from you. You have four days to think of the perfect gift for the boy who seems perpetually unimpressed by everything. What better way to start than by asking each of his house mates?
You set off, determined, as you approach a chatty Astoria Greengrass who's currently talking the ear off of some poor Hufflepuff girl.Â
"Astoria, I need your help." you say sitting down next to her, the Hufflepuff taking the graciously given opportunity in full as she makes a quick getaway, shooting you a relieved glance.Â
"Sure! What do you need?" she says sweetly, already having forgotten about her previous conversation.Â
"It's Theo. I'm trying to figure out what to get him for his birthday. I want it to be special for him."Â
"Oh, that's sweet! I'm sure he'd like anything from you, but if you need suggestions, how about a personally bound journal with charmed with a spell to keep it away from prying eyes? Can't trust Mattheo not to go snooping." she says with a laugh.Â
"That's actually a really good idea. He does write a lot." you say, glad to start your investigation on such a high note. At this rate, you won't even have to ask any of the others. Thank Merlin there's someone at least partially sane in your house.Â
"Oh, please. He doesn't need another reason to go lock himself away to brood." a sudden, familiar voice comes from behind, startling you out of your thoughts.Â
"You should get him a silver pocket watch. Something traditional and sophisticated to match his aristocratic background."Â
"Daphne, I appreciate your input but I'd rather not remind him of his father on his birthday. Besides, he doesn't care much for flashy things like that." you say, standing up now that the newly arrived Greengrass sister had practically taken over your side of the bench.Â
"Well I can't say I didn't try. Come on Tori, we need to get started on that Binns essay." Daphne tugs on Astoria's arm until she's standing and she gives you a quick, apologetic wave before she's dragged away by her sister.Â
You look down at the mostly empty piece of parchment you had brought with you to keep track of potential gifts. The journal idea is still on the table, but now youâre unsure about it. He does have tons of journals already. You shake it off, deciding to continue your search; you head down a corridor where you eventually come across Blaise Zabini, who's leaning against the wall, arms crossed as he wordlessly judges the students that cross his path now and then.Â
"Zabini, do you have a second?" you ask, approaching him.Â
He looks you up and down before answering. "What is it?"
"Theo's birthday is coming up. I wanted to get a few gift ideas from people, so I'm asking you." you say, slightly self-conscious now.Â
He raises an eyebrow, letting out an amused scoff though you can tell he's thinking about it now. "I'm sure you know Nott isn't interested in any mundane rubbish you might buy from Hogsmeade. Get him some obscure book on ancient runes or theory. The older and more expensive, the better." he says, before straightening up and leaving, abandoning the conversation as soon as it started.Â
"OkayâŠ" you murmur to yourself, now even more discouraged, parchment still painfully blank. You weren't drowning in galleons and any connections you did have weren't anything to write home about, so even if you wanted to, getting a rare book he'd like is completely out of your reach.Â
As you're standing there, dwelling on your shortcomings, a hand slaps you on the back, the sting causing a sudden wave of annoyance to wash away any previous feelings of self pity. You turn around, ready to chew out whoever it is, but they're speaking before you can even open your mouth.Â
"Why the sad face?" Mattheo's voice is obnoxiously loud as he laughs, slapping your back again. Of course, you should've known it was him. Only he'd have enough audacity to do something like that.Â
"Mattheo." you say with a grimace, pushing his hand away.Â
"I've heard about your dilemma and I'm here to help." he says, his smile more unnerving than friendly.Â
"Right, okay. You're close with him, what do you think he'd like?" you say, less hostile now that he's not just here to bother you.Â
"A dagger," he says, his eyes gleaming with amusement. "One with a goblin-wrought silver blade. It's practical and sharp, perfect for him."Â
"You want me to get him a weapon? For his birthday?"Â
"Hey, I'm trying to help you out. Just don't get him anything overly sentimental; he'll end up throwing it out." he says seriously for a second before the smile returns to his face.Â
"Good luck!" he laughs before walking down the hall, his voice echoing off the walls before it fades.Â
That night you go to bed restless, your mind a jumbled mess of almost gifts that still don't seem right. Three more days to figure it out. You still have people to ask and thankfully no one's let it slip to Theo, who's still blissfully unaware of the lengths you're going to for him.Â
You're refreshed and newly inspired the next morning, your qualms from yesterday nowhere to be found. You have Snape first thing that morning, and there's nothing like an early morning Potions class to get your mind going. You sit next to Theo, he'd get suspicious if you didn't, though your thoughts are focused on who you'll ask next after class is over.Â
"Theo, I need to talk with Pansy after class, can I catch up with you later?" you ask, watching him prepare the ingredients for the potion assigned as the task of the day.Â
"Parkinson?" he says, looking up at you now. "Why? Did she say something to you?"
"No, it's nothing like that. She just borrowed my Ancient Runes notes last week and she's 'forgotten' to give them back. It'll be quick, I promise."
You assume it's fine because he just shrugs and goes back to whatever heâs doing, but after class, when you grab your things and make your way over to Pansy out in the hall, you notice he's already there waiting for you.Â
"Theo, you can go ahead, you don't have to wait for me." you say, slightly nervous now as you move to stand in front of him.
"You're acting strange. It'll only take a few minutes right? I can wait." he says, arms crossed now. He's probably noticed the tension in your form and on any other day, his awareness of your habits would make you swoon, but it isn't any other day so it does nothing but make you anxious.Â
"Please? I just want to talk to her, and I can't do that if you're hovering over me." You love him but he really can't take a hint.Â
"âŠFine. I'll be in the common room. Don't be long." he gives in, still wary but you're clearly uncomfortable and he doesn't want to push it.Â
"Thank you." you say giving him a quick kiss on the cheek before shooing him away.Â
Your consultation with Pansy goes about as well as you expect.Â
"Cologne." she says definitively once you ask her. "Something expensive, with cedarwood or amber."Â
"What's wrong with the way he smells now?" you ask, frowning.Â
"It's fine, but it's not impactful," she says, leaning forward and gently poking your chest with a manicured finger. "A proper wizard needs a signature scent. Trust me. Pick up something from that high-end apothecary in Paris. If you give him cedarwood, heâll actually wear it just to keep you happy."
"Besides, every time he puts it on, he'll think of you. Romantic, isn't it?" she says with a satisfied smile. "You'll be thanking me later, I promise."Â
You watch her as she walks off, chewing the inside of your cheek as you give the idea some thought. Another bust. Theo doesn't like attention (nothing screams attention like cologne), and the last thing you'd want to do is give him something that will make him uncomfortable, but that he'll still use out of obligation because you gave it to him.
You decide to retreat back to the common room, running into Draco on your way there. Your interaction with him is so short lived however, youâre not even sure you can call it a conversation.Â
He laughs in your face not even a second after you finish speaking. "If you don't know what to get Nott for his birthday, then you shouldnât be dating him."Â
Jerk. So much for that.Â
You head into the common room, dragging your feet as you practically throw yourself onto the nearest sofa, groaning into a pillow. After staying there for a few seconds, you lift your head, scanning the room. Theo's not there, he must be in his dormitory right now, but there are a few stragglers scattered around. Lorenzo Berkshire, your last hope, is currently laughing at a fifth year who's eyebrows are now singed from a particularly nasty game of exploding snap.Â
"Enzo." your voice carries across the room as you sit up to face him.Â
He looks up at you, his eyes still filled with mirth as he stands up. "Yeah?"
"Quick, come here and keep your voice down." you say waving him over.Â
"Oh, a secret. Okay, I can do that." he's whispering now as he comes to sit beside you.
"It's Theo. What do you think he'd like as a gift?"Â
"Mmm..how about a snake!" He says grinning and you know immediately he won't be of any help. "A pet that'll stay under his bed and guard his books. It'll even keep him company."
"Enzo, I want to give him a nice gift, not a trip to the hospital wing." You say sighing. "Also, I go to his dorm. Why would I want a venomous snake waiting for me?"Â
"Oh right, good point." he smiles sheepishly. "Okay, then get him a bottle of Firewhisky, he looks like he needs it."Â
"Thanks for the suggestions, but I'll just think of something on my own."Â you say, still cringing at the thought of Theo with a snake.
He gives you a shrug before he goes back to his game, already laughing again. Theo comes down now, his eyes searching the room before they land on your figure. A small smile pulls at his mouth as he approaches you.Â
"Hey, you okay? Did you sort things out with Parkinson?" he says in that low, calming tone that makes your heart flutter, and now you can't help but feel bad that you've been tiptoeing around him trying to figure out what his friends think of him when he's right in front of you. What were you thinking? You know him better than anyone else, you're the one constantly around him, so why wouldn't you trust your own judgment?
"Theo, do you want to go to Hogsmeade tomorrow?" you ask softly, your hand finding his as your heart clenches painfully from the overwhelming affection you're constantly feeling for him. The others don't know anything about Theo, your Theo, who stays up until 2:00 AM reading muggle poetry because he finds the structure fascinating, who takes his tea with exactly two sugars but always pretends to drink it black, who secretly keeps dried flowers pressed between the pages of his favorite astronomy books because you had given them to him.
"Yeah, we can go." his fingers intertwine with yours as he watches you carefully. "You sure you're okay?"Â
"I'm fine now. I've fixed my problem."Â
____________________________________________
On the morning of his birthday, you drag him away to a secluded bench in a hidden corner of the courtyard. You're excitedly tugging him along, and he's still half asleep, but he's always willing to entertain you so he goes wherever you take him. You pull him down to sit next to you once you get to the bench, his eyes clear now that he's fully awake.Â
"Close your eyes." you say grinning.
He does without questioning it and you're thankful to him for that. You quickly remove the parcel from the pocket in your robe and you take a deep breath, examining it over once again before speaking.Â
"Okay, you can open them now." you say, and your excitement now turns to anxiety as you wait for his reaction to the gift you had put together the day before.Â
You know he collects the chocolate frog cards so you managed, luckily, to track down a rare, vintage card of an ancient astronomer he's been talking about for a while. It's tucked inside the front page of a classic piece of muggle literature you had found second hand. You had gone through the book, making annotations and leaving notes for him to read. He'd been eyeing it for a few weeks, but he never bought it because he was wary about its muggle origin, so you just got it for him, problem solved. The final gift is a jumper you charmed with a warming spell, folded and placed neatly under the book.Â
He goes through all the items one by one, his lack of response and expression making you unsure about his feelings towards the gift. He looks up at you once he's finished, the intensity of his gaze making you flinch.Â
"When did you even have time to do all this?" he says, and he sounds as breathless as you feel.Â
"I got them when we were at Hogsmeade yesterday and I couldn't really sleep last night anyway so.." you say fiddling with your fingers.Â
He pulls you into a hug so quickly, it knocks the air out of you. You're guessing he likes the gift. You pat his back, laughing softly as his grip on you tightens.Â
"Okay, okay. Seriously, you're crushing me." you say, patting his back harder now.Â
His grip loosens, though he doesn't let you go completely. "Thank you. Really, it's perfect." he sighs into your hair, his voice wavering slightly.Â
You're now immensely grateful you didn't follow any of the silly advice you were given about him. You know now that Theo does like sentimental things as long as they always come from you. Your arms wrap around him now as your head falls onto his shoulder, your voice a content murmur when you speak. "Happy Birthday, Theo."
ââââââââââââââââââââââââ
Tag list:
@st4rsabove
@rafessidemeal
@foolintherainnn
@dayluxe
@slutfordpr











