S5 Prediction: Mike & Will's 7 Confession + Garage Light Kiss Theory(Long Version)
Byler Nation, I have big news. Im pretty sure I figured out how Mike and Will's confession and first kiss is going to down in S5. Like, i'm unironically convinced that I figured out when, where and what will happen during the scene. Not to be overly confident, but here's you're spoiler warning.
To start off, I think that Mike and Will are going to end up in the upside-down together in S5. The upside-down and Will are connected narratively, seeing as it's literally frozen on the night he went missing.
Obviously there is going to be a reason for that. To bring his story full-circle, it's pretty much inevitable that in the final season Will is going to end up back in the upside-down. Just like it's inevitable that this time Mike will be there with him. Which is why at the end of season 4, they both sit on an upside down couch together.
The next part of this theory has to do with Will having powers. It’s why Will is paralleled to Vecna, Eleven, and Bastian from NeverEnding Story, and could open a portal in s1. It also fits with his overall character arc (becoming a hero after being a victim). I won't make this post a mile long by going through all the evidence (i'll add some proof here, here , here and here), but for now, trust me when I say it's probably going to be revealed that Will can manipulate electricity/time in S5. (Remember, El was originally supposed to die after season one, which makes the notion of Will having powers extremely likely)
Okay? Okay. So here's the theory:
Mike and Will are in the upside-down, which is still stuck on the day he went missing in 1983. In the upside-down, Mike and Will end up at the Wheeler House.
Time is frozen on Nov 6, which is the first episode of season 1. I think that somehow, Mike and Will are going to be able to affect the other-side in season 1 (specifically Nov 6), through the upside-down in season 5.
How though? We know that (as of now) time still flows normally on the other-side, unlike the upside-down. However, it's safe to say that s5 will most likely include some wacky time shenanigans, which will explain how this is possible. For example, what if time were to start moving again in the upside-down? (I'll link s5 time travel proof here, here here, and here). But even just on the surface level, why the hell else would the show's villain thematically be obsessed with the progression of time, be accompanied by the sound of a clock chime, and create visions of grandfather clock? Why else would Hopper's s3 letter talk about "turning back the clock"? Why else would there be so many Back to The Future references?
what if certain moments, like when Ted fiddles with the TV in the background of s1, were actually electrical shortages caused by Will in season 5? anyways, moving on.
This next part of my theory could go two ways: literal voices, or just the parallel/callback.
In the show, people in the upside down can still hear the voices of people on the other side.
Before Will was taken, the upside down looked like a hellscape. If Will is the reason the upside-down resembles Hawkins, than that means his subconscious mind is woven into it's very fabric (it is, proof here). Therefore, Will's memories of that specific day could manifest inside the upside-down (remember this for later).
"Joyce says Time is funny like that. Emotions can make it speed up or slow down."- El
...speed up, slowdown, or stop.
Will's intense emotions in this moment caused time to stop. His powers and his subconscious mind changed the upside-down to look like Hawkins (as opposed to the hellscape).
Okay, back to the kiss scene. Mike and Will seek refuge in Mike’s Basement while they are in the upside-down together. Since time is frozen on November 6, and Will's memories can manifest within the upside-down, then that means they might somehow be able to hear the sound of their childhood voices. They might be able to hear the party playing D&D on November 6.
Mike and Will are nostalgic over this and reminisce together. This is important because Mike's s1-s3 arc involves trying to "grow up" by getting a girlfriend/acting cool (proof here). In the basement, Mike finally admits that he was most happy when he was a kid playing D&D with Will and the Party. Mike doesn't want to "grow up" anymore. However, now it’s too late. The situation seems dire, and they are prepared to take their final stand together becoming “Heroes, just for one day”.
They follow the voices outside to the garage, where they can faintly hear the party saying goodbye.
I'm still on the fence about if they’ll hear their own voices, or what the logistics behind time travel and the upside-down will end up being in s5. Either way, I’m extremely confident this next part will happen. It’s Parallel time b**tches.
In the upside-down, Mike and Will are going to stand in the same spot at the same time as their younger selves on the other side.
The concept of Lies is a HUGE recurring theme in stranger things. One of the very first bits of characterization we learn about Will, is that he doesn't lie to Mike. Even though it was just a white lie. Even though he could have got away with it. Even though it meant he lost. Friends don't LIE. Will waited until the rest of the boys left before letting Mike know the Truth.
From the very start, we are shown that Mike and Will have an honest and different bond than rest of the party. Which is why in season 5, Will remembers his silent vow to Mike and isn’t able to lie to him anymore. (“I, I can remember (I remember) Standing, by the wall (by the wall”)- Bowie
Will is going to parallel his younger self and admit the TRUTH to Mike at the same time his past self does.
and then Mike will kiss him. (“we can be us, just for one day”-Bowie) They don’t think they’ll survive.
Between them, metaphorical electricity FLARES (plus Will’s literal powers), as his brain short-circuits. He’s shocked. As they kiss “Heroes” by David Bowie plays, and the lyrics “the guns, shot above our heads, (over our heads)” narrate as electricity shoots above their heads. The camera then pans up to the garage light over their heads, which flickers.
the audience can feel the electricity between Mike and Will. Just like how Dustin could feel the electricity between Lucas and Max.
As they kiss, “Heroes” by David Bowie continues,
in season one, Mike is still ashamed of his love for Will. Which is why the scene cuts off with the line "shame".
This time when the song plays, it will be different though. This time, the full verse will play as they kiss.
“and we kiss as though nothing could fall and the shame… was on the OTHER SIDE.”
Mike and Will are alone together in the upside-down, and the rest of society is on the other side. Because of this, they are able to finally kiss as if nothing could fall, and forget about how they would be shamed for it on the other side.
Mike and Will are in the upside-down, while their ashamed younger selves are literally on the other side. When they finally kiss as if nothing could fall, they leave their shame on the other side (in the the past).
Here: for the video of my theory!