Relationships are tricky things. They should be built on mutual love, respect, devotion and acceptance of all the parts of a person that makes them, them. And if they fail, sometimes they can become hateful depending on the people involved. Emotions are unpredictable and often very strong.
But far too often in fictional relationships there is too much focus on one character to the detriment of the other. It goes back to this idea that one partner is the prize and the other the victor (shoutout to @headspacedad for that description) and thus the relationship becomes unbalanced. One partner gets to call all the shots while the other is simply along for the ride - the relationship now feels extremely one-sided, which is not how a relationship should be. It also serves to cheapen the connection between the two characters, since all the âprizeâ is there for is window-dressing for the character that has the most importance in the writerâs eyes. And if required they can be all too easily discarded, the relationship cast aside like it was nothing.
Shadam is a very good example of this - Shiro is obviously the main character here so Adam is merely background noise. They used him to make the point that Shiro is a bad guy for not choosing Adam over his dreams (I very much disliked that scene, honestly); itâs an ultimatum, which are never healthy in relationships. And it feels like everything that follows for Shiro (capture by the Galra, torture, etc) only happens to punish him for making the decision to leave - see, if heâd stayed with Adam on Earth none of that would have happened. Right? He would have just been slaughtered/enslaved along with the rest of humanity when the Galra came to claim the Blue Lion instead but hey, they could have had a bit more time together before the worst happened.Â
I guess what I would have liked is for them to devote a bit more time to the reasons WHY Adam was so adamant that Shiro needed to choose him. Had Shiro been keeping him at armâs length while he worked on himself? Had Shiro been putting too much time into being chosen for the Kerberos mission and neglecting their relationship a bit? Had they been in difficulties for a while because Shiro was a workaholic? Had Adam felt like he was second-place to Shiroâs dreams? We can infer that the answer to all these is yes because of the tiny bit of dialogue during their scene - but it still fell far short of an actual discussion of where they stand and why. There could have been at least one other scene where Shiro and Adam were talking things out (heated or not) prior to Adam walking out on Shiro to give us some insight into how things were between them - gives things a little more depth. Even a time-frame would have been good; how long were they together? Months? Years? What exactly was Adam giving up on? And why should we care, when Shiro is the character we were supposed to be invested in here? He didnât seem to really be that upset when Adam left - why was that? Was it because heâd seen it coming for a long time, or was it because he just didnât care?Â
As a result the confrontation between the pair and Adamâs subsequent death feel cheap, especially given the fact that Shiro only gets a brief moment of screen time to mourn his ex-partner. The EPs can explain in interviews all they want about the fact that Adam and Shiro were planning on getting married, but without showing the depth of their relationship to ground such a declaration it falls flat. Yet another example of things being addressed outside of the series because the story-telling was lacking. If they were planning on getting married, surely showing us the intensity of their emotions towards each other would have been helpful. Shiro is a Japanese man and theyâre (stereotypically) not that open about their feelings, but we donât get more than just a brief hint of how he feels about Adam walking out that door.
I am not a fan of the Shadam pairing particularly but what I donât like about it is that the relationship was used simply as filler to a) show that Shiro is the LGBT+ rep and b) try to get us to believe that Shiro is selfish for leaving Adam behind to go and chase his dreams before his disease rendered him unable to do so.Â
It honestly feels to me as though this relationship and the relationship between Zethrid and Ezor were used solely to point out how progressive the writers/EPs are, and they failed. âBury Your Gaysâ is still alive and well unfortunately and while Shiro is not dead (currently, anyway) the other three are, and their deaths were unceremonious at best and extremely targeted at worst.
I guess Iâm just sick of characters having relationships for the sole purpose of having them torn away to cause maximum pain without any real reason. I get that there can be reasons why relationships fail but if you do choose to go that route, devote some time to explaining why. Donât just tear it apart and expect your audience to swallow it. Examine the difficulties, the pain, the heartbreak, the differences of opinion. Make it emotional. Show the character being devastated or relieved depending on their personality.Â
Make it easy to empathize with your characters.