If you’ve spent the last weekend arguing with people over Baran and Robbie’s confrontation in the final ep of the Pitt I am begging you to read this:
We are, once again, blaming individuals for systemic problems.
Was robby an asshole that entire day? Yes. Literally see my other posts where I’ve said I think the consequences for those actions are going to be a big part of season 3.
So do not get me wrong here. We all have a responsibility for how we move in this world BUT that scene is once again showing us the systematic failures of the world we live in through the lens of the health care system.
Baran strives for equality and equity in her entire career.
Robby as his speeches show, cares for these things too but is hardened and has given up fighting against a system that crushes him daily.
But Robby is right. If Baran showed up as a patient who is a doctor with these symptoms to the ER, THEY WOULD HAVE TO REPORT HER. They have had to do the same for older people doing less! Which we saw in this season and is no accident.
And Baran shared this information because in an equitable society you could share disability information with a coworker and not have to totally lose your job and credibility.
But the Pitt is constantly reminding us we do not live in an equitable society.
If we did, there would be a focus on curing ailments and not profiting on maintaince pharmaceuticals and stopping there.
If we did, we would not have an overly individualized car dependent society that punishes those who cannot drive their own vehicle.
If we did, you could share medical information about yourself without fear of dismal under capitalist standards and ideals.
It’s not that Baran is evil for working. She even said she had been cleared and has her drivers license. She is trying to do everything you’re supposed to be safe and still work. But in the way our healthcare system works (and work cultures at large) a lawsuit is more of a concern than the grey area of this kind of diagnosis. Health is grey and complicated and doesn’t fit in boxes, but we have a “you’re disabled and therefore cannot pass go” kind of system.
She would not be in this situation if working environments were adaptive and if her very existence in that hospital did not pose a threat to her employer.
She would not be in this situation if our federal government spent money on researching all illnesses and ailments instead of following financial directives and health as business.
And in a perfect world she could disclose this information to coworkers, patients, and employers without jeopardizing her lively hood. Which she needs because she we live do live late stage capitalism.
Robby isn’t being an ableist dick any more than the systems we all function under are ableist dicks. We just are so fucking used to and (beaten down under them) that we see them as normal. Robby as an individual isn’t the “issue” here any more than he is for the prison system or homelessness or incels or any other large scale problem patients have represented.
He is a representation of the complexities of health care in this fucked up world. Begging you to see beyond characters as someone you might or might not hang out with. For every bit they are recreations of real people they are also a means for creators to explore themes.
We are falling into what we beg people in the real world to realize. And if we can’t see the bigger picture in a tv show how will we ever see or get others to see it in our real world?