In the silence I replay all of our conversations. The ones where we laughed until we couldn't breathe, ones where we talked about a future we were working towards, ones filled with love and hope. In the silence I speak, wondering what may have been, asking whatever is listening how this happened.
In the silence your words play on repeat, running through my mind like a song stuck on loop. I am torn, stuck between two paths and unsure which to take. You asked for faith, and I tried to abide. I trusted blindly, bending to your whim until I couldn't recognize the life I had lived. You asked for love, so I provided. Sacrificing everything I could to make sure you were adored just how you wanted and how you demanded. You asked for more, and I gave.
I hurt you, yes. I have done things that have caused you emotional harm, but in the silence now I recognize that it was not me that caused your pain. You asked for faith because you demand subservience under the guise of trust and you ask for love not to return it to me, but so you can slowly withdrawal while I am too preoccupied making you happy to ever notice the damage you inflict on me.
In the silence, I tell myself I did what was best for you. I replay our conversations too, but differently. I remember the moments where you disappointed me, where you failed to be what I needed, where I believe you gave up.
I asked for faith because I needed certainty. I needed to know you wouldn't leave again, wouldn't hurt me the way you did before. Trust is earned, and you broke it — so I took what reassurance I could. If that meant watching more closely, questioning more deeply, holding you tighter, then so be it. Love demands sacrifice, doesn't it? You said you were willing. So I'll tell you that you're quitting as if I wasn't the one that decided the end.
I asked for love, but love must be proven and earned. Words are cheap. Devotion isn't. I needed to know that I mattered more than your independence, more than your habits, more than the parts of you that didn't include me. When you changed for me, I felt strong. When you gave things up, I felt chosen. If you resented that, you should have said so — but I never said I would listen.
You say I withdrew, but you never cared about what you were doing wrong. You never apologized the way I wanted, or tried harder. You were lazy and pathetic, so I reminded you because you told me to hold you accountable. And I did, I just didn't tell you that I was holding you accountable for things that you didn't do, but you don't need to know that.
You say I controlled you. I say I was helping you grow. You say I demanded too much. I say you never gave enough. You say you lost yourself. I say you didn't know the right things in the first place.
In the silence now, I tell myself I was right and that you'll be back any day now. You always come back. I don't have to reach, I just have to wait. I know how you work. After all, I built you that way.